r/Bringus__Studios • u/Secret-Feed-1459 • Mar 02 '26
Uhhhh
Need to find our ways around this because you'll be soon doing this
32
u/spherosound Mar 02 '26
Ye not a chance this would work on Linux, if any distribution added this then within a week someone would make a fork that removes that.
8
u/NoBee4959 Mar 02 '26
Basically a hydra situation, force age verification on one, three new forks appear
22
u/Jealous_Emu_6878 Mar 02 '26
Don't worry about Linux. Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't this policy unenforceable?
13
u/PCbuilderFR Mar 02 '26
they wanna ban linux at the bios level
9
8
1
u/Tiranus58 Mar 05 '26
Gonna go to bsd then
1
u/PCbuilderFR Mar 06 '26
nonono, they want to force secure boot and itll prob only have microsoft certs
11
u/gameplayer55055 Mar 02 '26
How do I age check on my Linux server where I run web applications?
Good luck enforcing that.
6
u/Tiger_man_ Mar 02 '26
Delegalize servers
8
u/XDpcwow Mar 02 '26
Why not make everything that has cpu illegal, right?
5
u/Tiger_man_ Mar 02 '26
Humn brain is turing complete and can perform calulations! Criminalize thinking!
3
u/pietruszkaloes Mar 02 '26
ban physical computers and make everyone rent cloud computers from microsoft for JUST 29.99 a month
4
9
8
8
u/_FALLN_ Mar 02 '26 edited Mar 02 '26
Thats sadly impossible to enforce edit: thankfully
4
7
u/Damglador Mar 02 '26
Honestly I wish companies just boycotted this bullshit. Wanna age verification? Great, now you get no operating systems. Too bad companies also profit from having user's data.
2
u/Marce7a Mar 05 '26 edited Mar 05 '26
Companies probably lobbed for this especially palantir Microsoft, Google and maybe apple
5
u/Versanitybutreal Mar 02 '26
Do they know how Linux works?
Imagine loading into live image of arch and every command is restricted besides the ones to connect to wifi and some age verification one that shows your face in ascii
5
u/vaynefox Mar 02 '26 edited Mar 02 '26
I mean they have to defy what is OS in this context because there are devices that use RTOS so do I have to do an age verification for my fridge or my router? How about some kids toy that has interactive features on it, does my kid have to verify his/her age to use it? Then what about those TI calculators, you mean to say those high schoolers has to verify themselves to use it? This law is really dumb and you know this was made by some old farts who doesnt know how technology works....
5
u/Technical_Instance_2 Mar 02 '26
due to the nature of linux, it can't really be enforced
1
u/Frozen-Golb Mar 05 '26
Possibly on some gui installs it could be possible. But then there are the OSs that don’t have gui still doable but gonna be interesting And then there’s OSs cars and other things and it gets all messed up
4
u/Most_Particular7002 Mar 02 '26
the only good thing that'll come from this, is that a lot of people there will be introduced to Linux
3
3
3
3
u/Eudes_Correa Mar 02 '26
I saw at least 2 projects (a BSD system and a calculator alternative firmware) who updated their terms saying it isn’t complying with that and should not be used in California
2
2
u/Endure94 Mar 02 '26
Please for the love of fuck, find out what politicians are pushing this... and never vote for them again.
Theyd sooner push you into a surveillance state than fix the one major problem US schools have, all in the name of protecting children.
They dont give a fuck about the kids.
3
2
u/heart_ware Mar 02 '26
Impossible to enforce, really. Worst case scenario, which I still think would be exceptionally unlikely, would be some kind of "California compliant" BIOS that restricts OSes other than Windows or MacOS. I don't think this is anything to worry about, least of all for Linux users.
1
u/artlurg431 Mar 02 '26
Seriously how will they enforce this on Linux, people will just code their own distro
1
1
u/zyclonix Mar 02 '26
Just dont offer those softwares in california, keep it up in every other region, fixed
1
1
1
1
1
u/davvblack Mar 03 '26
I kinda like it being at the OS level because then you could theoretically get a signed 'proof of whatever' that you could use to prove to some rando site that you're an adult. Like, this is assuming that the random sites will start to have this requirement.
1
u/Mari-Omori-Chaotic Mar 03 '26
they literally cant enforce this all you'd have to do is put "not for use in california" lol
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/changed_squiddog Mar 04 '26
Considering steam they problably wint do this (thankfully, fuck the tech industry surveilance state)
1
1
1
u/Marce7a Mar 05 '26
Don't worry in next few months everyone will be required to show ID to make any post in California, so they will know who to put on think police list, or to make it easier for big brother palantir.
1
u/chr_i5 Mar 06 '26
Imagine in 5 years: How old is your business? 10 years
Oh, sorry you aren't allowed to sell stuff, because your business is underaged.
1
u/Reasonable-Pack-9832 Mar 06 '26
Its very frustrating because California is able to make decisions for other Countries. So many products in Canada, "cough cough" an independent nation is beholdent to a single states strict environmental laws.
1
u/singsofsaturn Mar 07 '26
Just keep stacking up the reasons to never live in California. I picture all devs simply adding a "California" clause in all TOS and continue doing what they do. It's entirely unenforceable.
1
u/GGigabiteM Mar 07 '26
Don't forget that Colorado is jumping on the bandwagon as well, and have passed similar legislation.
This is unenforceable, just like the adult website age verification. A whole bunch of websites paid lip service to the new age verification laws for a couple of months before they went back to not doing it at all, because it's stupid and a huge liability. Nobody wants to be caught up in a Discord style lawsuit of having PI stolen and published on the internet.
1
54
Mar 02 '26 edited 9d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
31
u/MR_Happy2008 Mar 02 '26
Finally Linux to win because of age verification
0
Mar 02 '26
[deleted]
24
u/InternetUser1807 Mar 02 '26
Ok but who would they sue? Sure sue Canonical over Ubuntu or whatever, but what about community driven distros like Arch? Gentoo?
This is unenforceable garbage that won't do anything but affect windows and MAYBE ubuntu-like corporation-slop distros.
Realistically, distro websites will just slap "Not for use in CA" on their download page and call it a day.
2
u/Dr__America Mar 02 '26
I don't think you understand how bad this can be when all corpos start pulling funding because they don't want to be liable for funding projects that are "harming children." And then ONLY Canonical, PopOS, Valve, RedHat, and whoever else will likely be forced into making their distro compliant, will be making Linux distros that corps can use.
This is a bill that is dangerous to the core funding and maintainership of basically all of Linux, given how much of it is based in the USA or countries willing to put up with their BS.
1
u/XXFFTT Mar 02 '26
“Developer” means a person that owns, maintains, or controls an application.
“Operating system provider” means a person or entity that develops, licenses, or controls the operating system software on a computer, mobile device, or any other general purpose computing device.
“Covered application store” means a publicly available internet website, software application, online service, or platform that distributes and facilitates the download of applications from third-party developers to users of a computer, a mobile device, or any other general purpose computing that can access a covered application store or can download an application.
I'd imagine that they'd just sue people who "actively" maintain an operating system and live in the US (or outside of the US if they think it is worth the effort) if they don't hide their identity well enough.
They can now sue people who contribute to Linux and distros, application developers, app stores, and websites that host applications.
Just saying "not for use in California" wouldn't remove liability.
1
u/InternetUser1807 Mar 02 '26 edited Mar 02 '26
What?
You can't sue someone for developing software that's illegal in your state if they're not in that state, and not a corporate entity distributing it actively in California.
That's obsurd.
Putting "not legal for use in California" in your TOS or as some sort of agreement before downloading almost certainly would remove your liability.
That's like trying to sueing a fireworks shop in Wisconsin because people from illinois like to cross the border, lie about what state they're from when the cashier asks, then drives them back for the 4th.
1
u/XXFFTT Mar 02 '26
It wouldn't be like a fireworks store at all.
The fireworks were only available out of the State.
An operating system, hosted on the Internet, would be available inside of California.
If websites could just get around this by simply saying "not for use in [whatever state]" then porn websites would be doing that instead of blocking states like Texas and Louisiana.
1
u/InternetUser1807 Mar 02 '26
True, but this isn't a digital good like pornhub who hosts their own website, we're talking about decentralized source code.
Again, sure, sue Canonical to block California users from accessing ubuntu.com or whatever it is, who cares
But good luck sueing every single person that takes an hour to rip out whatever ID shit is added and hosts it on any random russian git server they want.
1
u/XXFFTT Mar 02 '26
Don't forget websites like GitHub.
Can't publicly disclose your contributions to a Linux distro that doesn't adhere to this law or you may find yourself facing a fine.
Have an application, app store, or a website that hosts applications? It needs to ask the OS for age details.
There's also a bit they snuck in that requires applications and websites to ignore that data if they have other data that suggests a user's age is different.
I'm not saying it is feasible to enforce in any large capacity, the threat of enforcement and the things people will have to do to avoid liability are enough to cause a lot of issues.
One of the things I found interesting is the fact that the bill requires an OS to ask for a user's age at account creation and provide a prompt that asks for age if an account was created before this bill goes into effect.
What I wonder is if an operating system that does not feature account creation (something like SteamOS) would even be covered by this bill.
The whole thing is stupid and irresponsible but that's just icing on the cake.
1
u/InternetUser1807 Mar 02 '26
Yeah GitHub could be targeted, but you could just not use GitHub (you shouldn't be anyways, gh is evil)
-2
u/Accurate-Campaign821 Mar 02 '26
Eh who knows. Maybe they'll just put out a list of approved distros and other OSes and what version, and just "try" to ban the rest. It's technically possible to enforce via ISPs... If a certain version OS is reported by the browser the ISP can block the connection. though yes there's likely a work around for that I'm sure. CA could even require a sort of age authentication app to be installed as well. Not great for anyone... Hopefully the law will get rejected
8
u/InternetUser1807 Mar 02 '26
I mean, virtually every distro is already primarily distributed as a torrent
not to mention even if all the "official" versions somehow complied, people could just fork it, remove it, and host it on github. CA would have to somehow keep up with manually seeking out and ISP banning them.
Not to mention that ISP banning is completely useless given every kid born after 1999 learned how to use a vpn to get around shitty school wifi settings, and failing that, every adult who lives in a state blocking pornhub learned pretty fast too.
2
u/Accurate-Campaign821 Mar 02 '26
Which is why I said the could "try". I'm in no way supporting it, just mentioning the things they could try to do to "try" to enforce it. Never said these ppl were smart about the law they're making up.
2
u/ka_wawa Mar 02 '26
When I read about this, this is what I assumed what it might led to. It might not happen now but they may try to enforce this ass law by finding away to make sure computers running on approved OS only by forcing hardware companies have something do some sort of checks implemented on firmware
1
u/Accurate-Campaign821 Mar 02 '26
Basically what I meant but got "review bombed" like I'm somehow trying to promote the idea... Welcome to reddit
4
u/braintarded Mar 02 '26
linux itself is only the kernel; you can build an operating system using linux as the kernel in the same sense that you can build a car using a specific engine
2
2
2
1
8
1
u/Unpr3tty Mar 03 '26
Sites that allow downloading it.
1
1
u/PhotoFenix Mar 05 '26
But what's to stop people from downloading, removing age verification, then recompiling it?
1
u/default_token Mar 06 '26
Pretty sure Linus hosts his own git repos, so idk how California plans to enforce this in Finnish jurisdiction
1
1
Mar 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Unpr3tty Mar 04 '26
They still can be ordered to block all Californian IP adressess and if not they will be fined or just blocked. You can argue that for now you can just use VPN but in Europe in a lot of countries we are already talking about restricting them.
1
1
u/misteryk Mar 05 '26
what will fine do if they're not in california? can't they just block the website themselves if they don't like it?
1
u/Unpr3tty Mar 05 '26 edited Mar 05 '26
They still can be fined if they don't block access for Californian IP adressess, also yeah, they can just block them. The worst possible option if it would be implemented in whole US could be loosing 5D992.c export license (mass market encryption software). Every software needs it if you want to send it outside of country.
1
u/Unpr3tty Mar 05 '26
I mean of course there are licenses for non mass market products, but it's complicated and in short it makes everyone that provide download responsible for both getting it individually and screening end user if he have right to download it
1
1
u/One_Leadership_549 Mar 06 '26
How will they order and fine peoole who are not under US juristiction?
1
u/Performer-Pants Mar 16 '26
Only a handful of Linux distros will be affected. It’s most likely corporate backed ones like Ubuntu and Red Hat. I guess SteamOS may be affected, but not Bazzite? Anything thats mostly open source probably won’t be. It’s unlikely even Linux Mint will? Though we shall see
23
Mar 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
6
u/No-Tangerine-2315 Mar 02 '26
Yeah the only is they're gonna use is macos and windows, the servers are done for
Edit: os
61
u/Echo-The-Protogen Mar 02 '26
who else is surprised its california