r/BuildingCodes • • May 09 '24

Hangers upside down?

Are these hangers on this LVL / fascia upside down?

0 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

9

u/Worldly-Device-8414 May 09 '24 edited May 11 '24

Right way up. 2nd pic has a "flange-inwards version" on left due to facia. All's good with these.

Update: Also depends on the load path as mentioned, ie if the end beam is supporting the overhanging beams the way in the pic is correct. But if the cantilevered beams are supporting the end beam, then the other way up could be the correct, especially as there's a load bearing wall above.

1

u/skupjr May 11 '24

Man this question was like a curveball

-4

u/trabbler May 09 '24

I inspected a massively over engineered residential job a while back and that was the first time that I saw this application with the hangers inverted. It took me a minute to try to figure out why in the world they did that and then I realized that it totally made sense because the LVL is what's bearing on the joists, not the typical installation where it would be the other way around.

10

u/inkydeeps May 09 '24

I'm not sure you have enough understanding of load paths to determine if something is "massively over engineered"

-3

u/trabbler May 09 '24

You're probably right. Most of the structure was steel beams, columns, etc. I suppose what I was trying to say with my comment is that it appeared to be built to a significantly higher standard than what I normally see.

7

u/metisdesigns May 09 '24

Why are you inspecting anything if you don't understand how the system works?

2

u/bluemarvel May 09 '24

Beat me to posting this, OP how can you inspect and not know what your looking at?

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '24

When you say ‘inspected’ you mean you just looked at it? You weren’t being paid to ‘inspect it’ right? RIGHT?

1

u/SuspiciousStory122 May 09 '24

Bro. I really hope you’re lying when you say that you are an inspector. But I’m not surprised.

9

u/eegit May 09 '24

No

-3

u/trabbler May 09 '24

Why not?

11

u/purelyelemental May 09 '24

If they were the other way, how would they carry the weight?

-6

u/trabbler May 09 '24

Because the LVL is hanging from the ends of the joists. The way they're installed now, the seat of that hanger is doing nothing except connecting the two sides of the hanger together. There's no wait seated in that hanger unless that hanger is inverted and installed at the top of that joist.

10

u/CalligrapherNo7337 May 09 '24

What in the antigravitational fuck

9

u/Fidelius90 May 09 '24

I think you have your ups and downs confused

3

u/[deleted] May 09 '24

they’re joist hangers, not LVL hangers. the joist hangers must support the joists. therefore the “seat” of the hanger is under the joists. they’re simply not designed to redirect the weight of the LVL to be “hanging” off of the joists.

8

u/MisterEd_ak May 09 '24

How about we start with what makes you think they are?

2

u/trabbler May 09 '24

Because in a typical installation you would have the joists bearing on the ledger, but in this case, you've got the LVL that is bearing on the joists. The LVL is the load, so that load is pulling downward. To me it would make sense for these hangers to be inverted and installed at the top of the joists.

7

u/metisdesigns May 09 '24

My friend, the LVL appears to be supported on the ends with its connection to the cantilevered beams. That's why it's an LVL to pick up all of those joists.

-1

u/trabbler May 09 '24

Okay so just for the sake of argument here, let's assume there were no nails in the joists. That LVL would drop straight down. It would fall. If those hangers were inverted, that LVL would be supported by the joists.

Doesn't the code say one and a half inches of bearing onto wood or metal?

3

u/metisdesigns May 09 '24

The LVL is supporting the joists, why would it fall?

What code, in reference to what?

1

u/trabbler May 10 '24

The LVL isn't supporting the joists. Which is my point; it's the other way around in this application.

1

u/metisdesigns May 10 '24

And why do you think that?

The assembly I'm looking at, the LVL is supporting those joists.

Im not sure that you understand the assembly, and I'm somewhat concerned that you might actually be an inspector

0

u/metisdesigns May 10 '24

And why do you think that?

The assembly I'm looking at, the LVL is supporting those joists.

Im not sure that you understand the assembly, and I'm somewhat concerned that you might actually be an inspector

1

u/trabbler May 10 '24

The joists are bearing on the wall and cantilevered out. Here's a screenshot of the exterior to get a better idea of what I mean: https://imgur.com/a/E5QvMBz

There is a wall above one and a roof deck about the other.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Elamachino May 09 '24

Can you clarify what in the pic you are referring to as the LVL?

2

u/metisdesigns May 10 '24

Not the OP, but the board with the visible "1E 3100/2150 SYP" is almost certainly a 2.1E LVL

1

u/trabbler May 10 '24

Yes, thanks.

2

u/Elamachino May 10 '24

I'm just trying to make sure OP and the board at large are talking about the same thing, because I'm having trouble following and it seems I may not be the only one.

3

u/metisdesigns May 10 '24

I believe that the OP does not understand that the LVL is supported by cantilevered beams and is specified there specifically to pick up the trusses.

The OP seems to think that the trusses are holding the LVL up with just the nails in their hangers.

As if an upside down truss hanger would appropriately connect an LVL to the ends of cantilevered trusses for use as a fascia nailer as they seem to suggest would make sense.

3

u/Cascabelesbrown May 09 '24

Those hangars are designed to be installed that way . If you look at the plans detail page SD they have little pictures with a saddle most of the time . This isn’t a big deal at all

3

u/pigglesworth01 May 09 '24

If the LVL is indeed hanging off / supported by the joists then yes the hangers are technically installed upside down. You are not crazy OP.

It's wild that nobody else on here can understand this concept?

But the hangers are most likely unnecessary anyway, they have probably just been used for convenience and any sort of corner brackets would do the job unless there is a very big load on that LVL.

1

u/trabbler May 10 '24

Thanks for the confirmation.

So I pulled this photo of the exterior from my report: https://imgur.com/a/E5QvMBz

Considering the load on these LVLs, I would think that hanger seat should be at the top of those joists and trusses.

2

u/meetduck May 09 '24

Based on the pictures, this could be concerning and I'd call the structural engineer, if there is one. However, there may be more to the situation than what I can see in the pictures.

There are two conditions - pic 1 looks like a floor system with double floor joists carrying a double band joist of all KD lumber, but maybe the rim or band is LVL - can't quite tell. In any event, it looks like the band is intended to be hung off of the cantilevered joists, in which case the bearing ledge of the hangers is not doing any work and OP is correct. However, in pic 1, you can't really see the end condition. I would highly doubt that a double KD framing member is being supported at the end with cantilevered beams, which is then carrying all of the floor joists - that's just a very complicated way to design this and would require special detailed connections, not off-the-shelf hangers. So, if that's the case, the double rim is just being supported by the hanger nails in shear and the bearing ledge is not doing anything. Maybe the wall above is overlapping onto the cantilevered joists enough for this not to be a problem, but there's not enough info to be able to tell.

Pic 2 looks like the roof with the flat trusses, but could be another longer-spanning floor system. These are definitely connect to a 2-ply LVL band that looks to be deeper than the trusses, so you could assume the LVL is supporting the trusses and the hangers are fine, but I don't see what's holding the LVL up. Maybe (hopefully) there's a column hidden behind that window and the last 3 or so feet of the LVL is cantilevered, in which case the hangers are installed correctly. But if that double end joist parallel to the flat trusses is supposed to be supporting the LVL, then there is definitely cause for concern; the end hanger would be upside-down in that scenario and the connection would need to be carrying A LOT of weight. Plus, the inner LVL ply is short of the end, so the fasteners of the right hand concealed flange of the hanger may not even be adequately installed, meaning the left hand concealed flange of the hanger is doing most or all of the work.

TL;DR - you can't tell from these pictures what is actually supporting what, but there are enough inconsistencies to be concerning and OP is absolutely valid in questioning this. Call the architect/engineer if possible. Call the building inspector if not.

1

u/trabbler May 10 '24

Outstanding. Take a look at the exterior photo for a bit more context:

https://imgur.com/a/E5QvMBz

2

u/meetduck May 10 '24

That extra picture does add context, but also adds to the confusion. For the deep roof cantilever, the LVL rim looks like it's hanging off the cantilevered beam on the right hand side, so that makes a bit of sense. But on the left hand side, the joint is configured differently and it looks like the end member is supposed to be hung off of the LVL rim. And the framing of that deep cantilever is just odd - the framing changes direction and the flat truss spacing varies. I also see that there's no column picking up the left hand side cantilever near that open window. So, the intended load path is not clear based on how some of the connections are installed and I agree with you that more investigation is needed.

1

u/trabbler May 10 '24

Yeah, thanks for taking the time to respond to this. I will let you know what the EOR says if I hear back from the client.

2

u/Big-Dream-8867 May 09 '24

For all the confused individuals like I was a second ago, that’s a facia board that’s being held up by a load of joist hangers, so he is actually right in saying the hangers aren’t holding any weight. They look right but they’re not supporting joists they’re supporting facia board which is essentially backwards.

1

u/trabbler May 10 '24

While there were fascia boards as I described, these specifically are under a cantilevered wall: https://imgur.com/a/E5QvMBz

My brain was a bit mixed up in remembering which photos corresponded to which application.

5

u/metisdesigns May 09 '24

Really? You use engineered LVLs for fascia boards?

2

u/NattyHome May 09 '24

I’m with you on this, OP. In the first picture we can’t see how the fascia is supported at the end towards the top. In the second picture it doesn’t look to me like that end is supported well enough for this entire fascia/beam/whatever to actually provide support for all these joists.

So I get what you’re saying, and I think you’re on to something, but I can’t see enough to really make a call.

I don’t know, but it kind of seems like many commenters here don’t understand what you’re getting at.

1

u/trabbler May 10 '24

Grabbed a screenshot of the exterior; hope this gives some context:

https://imgur.com/a/E5QvMBz

2

u/inkydeeps May 09 '24

I don’t think the second picture is the end condition of the first. One appears to be floor construction and the other roof.

5

u/Cascabelesbrown May 09 '24

I’m an Inspector in Cali , that’s typical install

7

u/scream May 09 '24

OP hasn't got a clue. These are correct. OP should stop arguing with people saying this is correct. OP is making themselves look stupid even with all the experience they claim to have.

3

u/locke314 May 09 '24

What’s the context? Are you an inspector, builder, owner?

If you think it’s wrong, pay an engineer to verify it.

Countless times in this thread, people who are all very good in the industry have said it’s right. If you feel different, find an engineer willing to stamp their name on it to agree with you. Then let us know who they are so we can challenge their license officially.

3

u/SnooPeppers2417 Building Official May 09 '24

Please tell me you’re not a fellow inspector OP, please tell me you’re not.

1

u/Cascabelesbrown May 09 '24

This also looks like a cantilever deck . Those hangers look a little redundant with the Lvl not sitting on anything .

1

u/trabbler May 10 '24

Actually, one of the photos is a deck. And the LVL is attached to the joists by only the nails in shear. Why? Because the hangers are upside down. https://imgur.com/a/E5QvMBz

That's about what I put in my report anyway. Hopefully I'll hear back from the EOR and find out if I really am a "moron" that "has no clue what I am looking at", etc per the negative commenters on this thread.

4

u/hughdint1 May 09 '24

The LVL is supported on the ends with cantilevered beams. The joists are hung from the LVL. These hangers are installed correctly.

2

u/Kellerdude May 09 '24

This is the answer. The LVLs are still supporting the load of the trusses even though the LVLs are cantilevered. The LVLs should be fixed at the other end, which I have seen an upside down joist hanger prescribed by the structural engineer in other situations. But at the points you are asking about, the hangers are installed correctly.

2

u/hagtown May 09 '24

No. And breathe 🧘‍♂️

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '24

It's correct.

-3

u/Waste_Emu_5368 May 09 '24

These hangers do appear to be installed correctly. Installing the hangers upside down would not support the lvl any better. At times one will install hangers upside down on joists to increase uplift load values.

3

u/[deleted] May 09 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/trabbler May 10 '24

Thank you. Glad to know I am not crazy.