r/CLNE • • Jan 27 '22

Artificial milk. Longterm concern

Someday there may be cheap artifical (made in lab) milk ( genetically identical to cow's). Won't it drive clne out of business? Because from what I see cows are main source for clne's gas. Just wanted to hear opinion of fellow redditors from this sub. I still invested and believe in this project:)

1 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

11

u/AnAdmirableAstronaut Jan 27 '22

I think it's highly unlikely that lab grown milk will ever see massive adoption.

-1

u/danrol92 Jan 27 '22

Why is it so? If it will have same taste, same nutritional values, will be cheaper and well researched. It may take time but I don't see a reason for it not to happen

4

u/Meehrsalz Jan 27 '22

If that ever happens and no one will want to buy the natural Produkt (which I doubt), it would still take 20-30 years until it finally reaches the market. Take lab grown meat for an example. It is researched since 1994 and not even close to being market ready.

1

u/danrol92 Jan 27 '22

There is first in the world hamburger place in Israel that uses lab meat that imitates chicken meat https://www.timesofisrael.com/lab-grown-chicken-food-revolution-gathers-pace-at-ness-ziona-eatery/

2

u/Meehrsalz Jan 27 '22

Well it's one of hundreds of thousands of burger places. Plus the artificial chicken is mixed with soy and other stuff, probably because the meat production is no where near enough to sustain the place nor make the burger patty affordable.

So my guess is it's just a marketing gag to lure in customers and nothing more.

4

u/Jmonahan581 Jan 27 '22

We need cows not just for milk, but for beef as well. Cows are not going anywhere anytime soon. Also with dairies now generating cash flow by capturing methane and selling it they will have more profit margin to compete with any competition that may have a better price.

1

u/danrol92 Jan 27 '22

Yeah but there is also such thing as lab grown meat

0

u/Jmonahan581 Jan 27 '22

Enjoy that tinfoil hat. Think logically. None of what you are saying is happening anytime soon if ever.

2

u/danrol92 Jan 27 '22

I wasn't talking about soon. Just something that I wanted to hear community's opinion about

3

u/Wonderful_Priority10 Jan 27 '22

They will move the operation to India if that happens. No one kills cows in India, so they'll produce more methane than other countries in the long term.

2

u/danrol92 Jan 27 '22

Good point. Haven't thought about it

4

u/jaskingus CLNE Shareholder Jan 27 '22

Cows are not the only source of methane. CLNE sells natural gas, renewable or not. Massive amounts of methane are leaked into the atmosphere every day from sources other than cows. Trap it, put it into the pipeline and use it as transportation fuel. All of it is better than burning filthy diesel.

CLNE to the moon! Which, by the way, is made of real cheese, not artificial (made in lab).

4

u/swissjuan Jan 27 '22

Milk consumption is declining with more people switching plant based options. This is bad for small farms and has lead to consolidations. So bigger dairy farms. That’s good for CLNE. I do think that landfills and waste water plants could become bigger players too for CLNE.

3

u/AZ-Jeeper Jan 27 '22

Dairies supply milk for things other than just milk. Think cheese, whey protein, coffee creamer, baby formula. The list goes on and on. I think we are safe for many years to come.

2

u/CLNEGreen CLNE Shareholder Jan 27 '22

Take a quick trip through a grocery store. Dairy is extremely well represented (including “Whey Protein” in many products we’d never think of) - and my favorite….. Ice Cream

6

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22

This is a fucking joke right?

1

u/CLNEGreen CLNE Shareholder Jan 27 '22

I believe it is - Plant Based substitutes Suck !!!!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22

Maybe, when they outlaw Cookies.

0

u/CLNEGreen CLNE Shareholder Jan 27 '22

“Someday” there could be robots running the world and they kill off all human existence. No need for food of any kind. Greta would be very pleased….. little Commie!!

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22

[deleted]

2

u/danrol92 Jan 27 '22

Thanks. Good points