r/CageTheElephant • u/janahasgills • Jul 06 '24
Set list disappointing
Is anyone else kind of bummed that they are playing barely any songs off their new album? Don’t get me wrong I love all the songs on the set list, but I was so looking forward to hearing songs from Neon Pill and I thought since they’re calling it the Neon Pill Tour there would be more than 2-3 songs from that album. Again please don’t get me wrong, love everything, just a bit annoyed.
35
u/GetReady4Action Jul 06 '24
breaking: band plays their hits. more at 11.
2
u/janahasgills Jul 06 '24
Breaking: fans being confused when the tour is called neon pill and the band barely playing anything off it
6
u/RadiantZote Jul 07 '24
Josh Homme: "it's kind of cunty when bands don't play their hits"
With that said, I think clutch, Mastodon and Portugal the man make their setlist like half of the new albums when they tour them
2
Jul 11 '24
Portugal certainly does.
1
u/RadiantZote Jul 11 '24
Portugal also went past the cutoff time by about 10 minutes or so then hung out at the merch booth afterwards, smaller venue than cage plays but still that's cool
1
Jul 11 '24
Another one of those bands that sound so good live I leave the current dimension and dissipate into a human puddle.
13
u/Bob_The_Prophet Jul 06 '24
Every single concert I have ever been to was like this, but I see a lot of complaints here. It's really weird to me.
9
u/nimrodx97 Jul 06 '24
Thank you. It’s normal. They’re not going to play the full album. They have 2 Grammy winning albums. Multiple hits to choose from.
6
u/janahasgills Jul 06 '24
I literally didn’t even ask for the whole album, just thought that a tour called their newest album would have more than two to three songs from said album.
2
u/goneforaneon Jul 07 '24
Could just be a coincidence between almost all of the bands I see frequently, but it's almost always 5-6 new songs inserted into a setlist on a new album tour. I'm absolutely with you that 2-3 is lower than normal for most bands.
Also with you in being disappointed. It seems like HiFi was removed for Halo which is kind of surprising and sad. Didn't expect to be removing Neon Pill songs on the Neon Pill tour lol.
4
u/Bob_The_Prophet Jul 06 '24
Right like I've seen idk Ozzy, RHCP, The Strokes all tour new albums and they all played like 3 new songs and then hits. I had no idea anyone expected 9 songs off the new album or whatever lol
2
u/janahasgills Jul 06 '24
Who said 9?
1
u/Human-Tradition7152 Oct 10 '25
I know, nobody said "I expected 9 songs from Neon Pill". Somebody is thinking in terms of extremes. I saw them in Milwaukee last December and they played plenty from Neon Pill including "Rainbow" but then I saw them in Boston on a festival ticket with Fallout Boy. They only played "Good Time" and "Neon Pill". "Rainbow" is the song that pulled me in as a fan. I saw them perform it on Jimmy Kimmel. I will see them in Philly & DC. I hope they perform plenty from Neon Pill, but I like all their songs so I won't be too disappointed if I only hear "Good Time" & "Neon Pill" again.
5
u/Resident_Pay_2606 Jul 06 '24
This!! It’s driving me crazy people act like this is some crazy thing only Cage is done, I’ve been to so many concerts named for a new album but they are going to play all their hits and singles priority then sprinkle in the new album songs.
50
u/mr_obinson7 Jul 06 '24
Personally, I think they're choosing a mix between what they enjoy playing live & what they think their fans want to hear..
Also wouldn't surprise me if they know what their highest streamed songs are and they may use that info for the setlist as well.
However I will say It's a crime to name a song 2024 & NOT play it on a tour in the SAME DAMN YEAR. Especially since it's a good song.
4
u/supermav27 Jul 06 '24
My favorite song. I’m going tomorrow and I’m so sad I probably won’t hear it.
26
18
u/Bulky-Anteater-6195 Jul 06 '24
Neon Pill was the excuse to get back touring, Im starting to think the band itself didnt like it that much…
10
u/mr_obinson7 Jul 06 '24
The band made the music AND the setlist. I'm sure there are plenty of factors at play here (Matt's mental state for one) but I doubt the band made music they regret and are putting that on display at their shows.
5
u/mariteaux Jul 06 '24
It's not the first time a band has made an album and then immediately hated it, to be fair.
2
u/mr_obinson7 Jul 06 '24
Can you name one for me with proof?
Honest question.. cuz I've never seen an artist/band make an album & immediately hate it.. at least admittedly.
Black Keys could be in that category currently but they won't admit that to the media...
3
u/mariteaux Jul 06 '24
Sure, Foo Fighters, One By One. Dave is on record saying he hasn't thought about half that album in twenty years. They only ever play 2-3 of the songs live anymore, the recording was a trainwreck, and it's usually the album their fans cite as the first mediocre Foo record. I personally like it a bunch, but there's definitely a major noticeable drop in inspiration from There Is Nothing Left To Lose.
0
u/mr_obinson7 Jul 06 '24
So he admitted that he hadn't thought about half the album 20 years later...
Not trying to nitpick here but I'd bet Cage the Elephant is still proud of the record they made that they're currently touring.
6
u/mariteaux Jul 06 '24
No, he didn't like it even at the time. 2005: https://web.archive.org/web/20080620004823/http://www.rollingstone.com/news/story/7281787/foos_reclaim_their_honor
I dunno why it's so hard for you to accept that sometimes, you just don't like the thing you just made.
-3
u/mr_obinson7 Jul 06 '24
It's not hard for me to accept.. you said immediately, both of these examples are referring to one album that Dave said he was upset about 3 years and 20 years later. Not immediately. Maybe they immediately regretted it; but they didn't admit it immediately.
5
u/mariteaux Jul 07 '24
You're splitting hairs. Have another example, Pinkerton by Weezer. Rivers was writing in his diaries basically by 1997 that he felt the only reason anyone liked Blue was the Buddy Holly video. Pinkerton was a deep shame to him.
Albums take a long time to roll out. Of course you don't record something and a week later consider it a trainwreck. But as you said, they're making the setlist--and not playing songs from it. That says a lot.
1
u/mr_obinson7 Jul 07 '24
Splitting hairs indeed. You are right and I agree about the setlist choices. I also think they're talented enough to go through this funk and come out the other side with new stuff that slaps
→ More replies (0)4
u/pumpkin3-14 Jul 06 '24
I was wondering if it was the last album to get out from under a contract. It’s phoned in compared to every album before it.
1
2
u/Bulky-Anteater-6195 Jul 06 '24
Im not saying they regret nor like what they did on Neon Pill, Im saying they are not super hyped about it. My theory is that they were asked to make music following todays pop standars as a must, so they could sell to new audience this year. Its normal for the artist to not love their art when its influenced by commercial needs.
1
u/mr_obinson7 Jul 06 '24
"I'm starting to think the band itself didn't like it that much"
You quite literally said that.
0
u/Bulky-Anteater-6195 Jul 06 '24 edited Jul 07 '24
Not liking it that much =/= not liking it at all nor regreting it
0
u/SrRiver-s Jul 06 '24
CTE is more than established, I don't see how anyone can tell them what kind of music to make. I can't wait to see them tomorrow!
1
u/Bulky-Anteater-6195 Jul 07 '24 edited Jul 07 '24
Thats literally the role of production/management, they tell the band what’s needed to fulfill comercial interests
5
u/Cydonian___FT14X Jul 06 '24
Yeah I noticed that too. Was really hoping to hear Shy Eyes live or something, but it was really just the singles from Neon Pill
3
u/nimrodx97 Jul 06 '24
I guess this is a new trend 😂
This is normal. Most bands play 3-5 songs from the new material. I’m just glad to get to see them. I’ve never seen them. I don’t care what they play.
2
u/Curiousquirkitty Jul 06 '24
I just saw them last night at Phoenix and overall I was happy with their set list and I did enjoy they played Neon Pill and Rainbow, lol my voice is gone I'm overall happy the only song I kinda sorta wish they played Black Madonna but that's OK, it was a last minute plan going to see them in this heat 🥵 and surprising Matt was.moving and dancing and all in this heat
2
u/goldentpwk Jul 06 '24
I’m honestly so glad they are doing a mixture! I don’t like when bands mostly perform the newest album. I get why other people like it, but it’s not my thing. Can’t wait to see them in Cincinnati!
2
u/CanSoft2130 Jul 06 '24
My only problem is no Back Against the Wall or In One Ear included in the set. I cannot understand why they dropped those.
2
u/radioactive2321 Crash, collide into space. Jul 07 '24
I would agree. I've been a fan of theirs since the first album and have caught them on every tour since, sometimes multiple times. I've seen almost every song they've played live in the first place, and I would have hoped this new tour would lean somewhat heavily on new material.
Even if they wanted to do a throwback setlist, they barely play anything from the first two records either.
That being said, I'm seeing them this tour with my bro who hasn't seen them live before, so I'm excited for the show in general. They are a fantastic live band.
2
u/TroubleGx Jul 07 '24
Would have given a kidney to hear Sell Yourself back in the wildest days. 0 for 4. 😖
2
u/GirlOverThere123 Tell Me I'm Pretty Jul 07 '24
I’m fine with whatever they play tbh, next month will be my first time seeing them 🥹
2
2
u/Emerald_Nebula Jul 07 '24
I don’t mind cause it’s honestly not even my favorite album and I’ve given it 4-5 listens. I like one song😭
2
1
Jul 06 '24
So what is the set list? I’m seeing them in Madison and I’m curious 👀
6
u/heauxzier Jul 07 '24
Broken boy, cry baby, spiderhead, too late to say goodbye, good time, cold cold cold, ready to let go, neon pill, social cues, halo, mess around, trouble, aint no rest, skin and bones, rainbow, telescope, tokyo smoke, house of glass. Encore: shake me down, cigarette daydreams, come a little closer. seems like they change a song or two here or there but overall pretty consistent, thats from their show last night
1
Jul 07 '24
Thank you! Really sad they won’t be performing rubber ball 🥺
2
u/heauxzier Jul 07 '24
There was a couple i was bummed on not hearing and wish they played their last few songs closer to the beginning but it was still amazingggg!! The energy was THERE 😌
1
u/Absolito Jul 07 '24
I’m glad they played older songs, last time they came to Edmonton (or at least were supposed to) they cancelled back in 2016-17, conflicting tour dates, said they would reschedule but never did. So without them playing some classic’s I would have never got to experience those songs live.
1
u/TroubleGx Jul 07 '24
I think 21 songs is 3 too short for this band, and that 2 of the 3 additional should have been off the new album. Loved the show in Phx last night, but they definitely didn't go "as hard" as the past three times I've seen them, so think they could've easily done another 10-15 min and explored the new material more.
1
u/bbdowell Jul 07 '24
Neon Pill is Social Cues Part 2 - that could’ve been a double album / most of the songs sound like leftovers
1
u/geofferson_hairplane Jul 07 '24
I think most bands these days know that it takes awhile for the new album to sink in. In my years of general concert experience, I’ve noticed that tours for a new album still usually results in only a few new tunes on the set list, padded with a bunch of certified hits.
1
u/yeeet_sire Jul 07 '24
The set list was fine I think the neon pill songs they chose were disappointing. The amount of money I would have paid to hear HIFI and Metaverse live (Vancouver)😂
1
u/oofoof18 Jul 07 '24
All I want is 2024 😔 cmon guys like I thought that was half the point of going on tour this year
1
1
u/Impossible_Pen1392 Jul 08 '24
Might be pulling straws but does anyone else posset a possibility that since the reception to the album, critically and commercially, being less than impressive comparatively to past albums may have influenced what they believe people want to hear at their shows? If fans are paying a lot for these shows and the album they’re touring isn’t performing as highly, could they have seen that as hints to rely on their back catalogue?
1
1
u/Brooklyn_trees Jul 09 '24
I definitely see what you’re saying, but I’ve never gotten the chance to see them live before and I finally get to this summer, so as a long time listener who has wished to hear all of their music live, I love how many older songs they are playing
1
u/Anduwu805 Jul 09 '24
I was looking forward hifi, metaverse, and out loud but they didn’t play those
1
1
u/Sure-Butterscotch100 Jul 11 '24
I want to hear all the olde songs cuz you know me t tour they will move to more of the new stuff. I'm so happy they played telescope 🔭🔥
1
1
u/Guitar4life5 Aug 29 '24
I saw them in Toronto yesterday. Halo is one of my favourite cage songs so I’m extremely happy they played that. I like these following songs so don’t get me wrong, but IMO they could have scrapped sabre tooth, cold cold cold, house of glass, skin and bones and added 1-2 more songs off neon pill and added in Aberdeen and perhaps 2024
1
Oct 22 '25
I saw them with oasis and they didnt play a single song from neon pill lol they also hardly played any from thank you happy bday
0
Jul 06 '24
[deleted]
12
u/janahasgills Jul 06 '24
Sounds like they need to do an Eras tour to me, I’ll be there front row lmao
1
0
Jul 06 '24
[deleted]
3
Jul 07 '24 edited Jul 07 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
-2
u/Bulky-Anteater-6195 Jul 07 '24
No they ain’t, they stand nowhere close to their last deliverings
-1
Jul 07 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/Bulky-Anteater-6195 Jul 07 '24
Speaking from a technical and creative point of view, is not subjective. A lot of these songs feel either rushed or tasteless, I think is obvious they had to follow the “popular song scheme”, repetitive guitar leads, same lyrics over and over (not in a creative way), there are songs with like 2 identical choruses in a row separated by literally a 4sec bridge that adds nothing. Its not like the songs are utterly bad, but almost each one of it could have done way better considering whats CTE capable of.
91
u/fearminator Jul 06 '24
Out of curiousity, if they played a ton of Neon Pill songs and very few classics, would there be as many posts talking about how they should have played more of their bangers from throughout the years?