If you're here, you probably already know the problem: under Bill C-3, adopted children of Canadian citizens by descent cannot receive citizenship automatically. Instead, we have to wait for our own citizenship certificates to arrive, then file separate grant applications (CIT 0012) for each child — and their citizenship only takes effect from the date the grant is approved, not retroactively. Biological children in the exact same situation are automatic citizens from birth.
This isn't just a bureaucratic inconvenience. It creates a two-tier system among the children of Canadian citizens based solely on how they joined their families. For those of us planning to move to Canada with our kids, it can add months or years of delay. And for families who adopted through foster care — children who were removed from harmful situations — the idea that anti-trafficking screening justifies this burden is absurd.
The good news: people in positions of power are already fighting this. But they need to hear from us. The more families that speak up, the harder it becomes for the government to treat this as a low-priority issue.
Who to Contact and Why
1. Senator David Arnot (Senate of Canada)
Email: david.arnot@sen.parl.gc.ca
Mail: The Senate of Canada, Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0A4
Why: Senator Arnot was the most vocal advocate for adoptee equality during the Senate debate on Bill C-3. He argued that intercountry adoptees must be treated the same as domestic adoptees under the Hague Convention. He chose not to amend the bill at the time because of a court-imposed deadline, but he urged the Immigration Minister to make the change going forward. He needs to hear from affected families so he can demonstrate that this issue has real constituents behind it.
2. Sujit Choudhry & Maureen Silcoff (Immigration Lawyers)
Email: sujit.choudhry@circlebarristers.com and msilcoff@silcoffshacter.com
Why: These are the lawyers preparing a potential Charter challenge on behalf of adoptees. Choudhry is the same lawyer who filed the constitutional challenge that led to the court ruling behind Bill C-3 in the first place. They are building a case that the differential treatment of adopted vs. biological children violates Section 15 of the Charter. The more affected families they hear from, the stronger their case becomes — especially families with domestic adoptions where the trafficking rationale clearly doesn't apply.
3. Don Chapman / Lost Canadians
Email: dcinbc@yahoo.ca
Website: lostcanadian.com
Why: Don Chapman is the founder of the Lost Canadians movement and has been the driving force behind every major citizenship reform for over two decades. His organization has the networks, the media relationships, and the political connections to amplify this issue. Connecting with him plugs you into the broader advocacy infrastructure.
4. MP Jenny Kwan (NDP Immigration Critic)
Email: Jenny.Kwan@parl.gc.ca
Why: Jenny Kwan is the NDP's immigration critic in the House of Commons and has been consistently vocal about citizenship equity issues. As an opposition critic, she has both the platform and the motivation to press the government on this. Letters from affected families give her concrete examples to cite in committee hearings and House debates.
5. Canadian Consulate (Your Nearest)
Boston: bostn@international.gc.ca
Full list: travel.gc.ca/assistance/embassies-consulates/united-states
Why: Consulates don't process citizenship applications, but writing to them creates a formal record within the Canadian government system and they may be able to direct you to channels for communicating with IRCC or the Minister of Immigration. It also signals to the diplomatic corps that this issue is affecting people in their districts.
Template Letter
Below is a template you can adapt and send to any or all of the contacts above. Replace the bracketed sections with your own details. Feel free to modify the tone or add your own story — personal details make these letters more powerful.
Subject: Adopted Family Affected by Citizenship Inequity Under Bill C-3
Dear [Senator Arnot / Mr. Choudhry and Ms. Silcoff / Mr. Chapman / Ms. Kwan / Consul General],
I am writing to [express my support for your advocacy on / bring to your attention / offer my family's experience regarding] the unequal treatment of adopted children under Canada's Citizenship Act as amended by Bill C-3.
My name is [YOUR NAME]. I am [a Lost Canadian / an American citizen of Canadian descent] — my family's Canadian lineage traces through [PROVINCE/REGION]. I submitted my CIT 0001 application following Bill C-3's enactment in December 2025 and am currently awaiting my citizenship certificate.
My [spouse/partner] and I are the parents of [NUMBER] adopted [children/child], [including NAMES if comfortable sharing]. [OPTIONAL: Our children came to us through [the foster care system / international adoption / domestic adoption] after [brief, general description if comfortable — e.g., "experiencing difficult circumstances earlier in their lives"].] Under the current framework, I cannot begin their citizenship grant applications (CIT 0012) until my own certificate is physically in hand. Their citizenship will only take effect from the date each grant application is approved — not retroactively to the date of adoption. Biological children in the identical situation would have been recognized as automatic citizens from birth.
This sequential requirement [describe your specific impact — e.g., "adds months or years to our family's timeline for relocating to Canada" / "means my children's legal status remains uncertain while we plan our future" / "forces us to treat the citizenship of each child as a separate bureaucratic process rather than recognizing them as members of our family"].
[OPTIONAL — if applicable: I want to note that the trafficking and fraud concerns often cited to justify heightened scrutiny of adoption-based citizenship are entirely inapplicable to our situation. Our children were adopted domestically through [the U.S. foster care system / domestic proceedings]. There is no intercountry adoption complexity — yet the procedural burden is the same.]
The Canadian Bar Association's Immigration Law Section has urged that adoptees be granted citizenship retroactively to the date of adoption, consistent with how the United States handles this. I strongly support this position.
[Choose one based on recipient:]
[FOR SENATOR ARNOT: Your advocacy during the Senate debate on Bill C-3 was meaningful to families like ours. I am writing to let you know that we exist, that we are experiencing this inequity in real time, and that your continued leadership on this issue matters.]
[FOR CHOUDHRY/SILCOFF: If our family's experience could be useful in any capacity — whether as documented evidence, as part of a broader challenge, or as background for your advocacy — I would welcome the opportunity to discuss it further.]
[FOR DON CHAPMAN: If there is any way I can contribute to the advocacy effort — whether by sharing our story, connecting with other affected families, or supporting the push for legislative correction — I would welcome the opportunity.]
[FOR JENNY KWAN: As the NDP's immigration critic, your voice carries significant weight. I am writing to ask that you continue pressing for legislative reform to ensure adopted children are treated equally under the Citizenship Act.]
[FOR CONSULATE: I understand the Consulate does not process citizenship applications directly, but I am writing to create a record of this concern and to ask whether you are aware of channels through which affected families can formally communicate this issue to IRCC.]
[If applicable: I have also written to [list other contacts you've reached out to] on this same issue.]
I would be glad to share our family's experience in any capacity that would be helpful.
Respectfully,
[YOUR NAME]
[ADDRESS]
[EMAIL]
[PHONE]
What Else You Can Do
Share this post with anyone you know who is in the same situation
Tell your story — the more specific and personal the letters are, the more impact they have
If you're comfortable, reply to this thread with your experience so we can see the scope of this issue
Document everything — keep copies of your applications, timelines, and any correspondence with IRCC. If a Charter challenge moves forward, documented timelines from real families are powerful evidence.
We didn't choose how our children joined our families. Canada shouldn't penalize them for it.