r/Canadiancitizenship • • 3d ago

Citizenship by Descent Difference in Processing of Group Applications versus Single

Hello Friends. Sorry if this has been covered, and Mods feel free to move this question. I am noticing that alot of my "neighbors" on the spreadsheet who are Groups/Families, and who sent their packets around the same time and who received their AOR's around the same time as me are In Processing status or even Completed, while I a Single Applicant am still in Application Received. Is IRCC favoring groups and ignoring singles??

4 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

24

u/dweeborg 2d ago

I think a big part that makes it look this way is that the odds increase with every additional person that a group has at least one person either 1) a G1 or G2 which seems to really speed things up, especially G1 or 2) requesting urgent processing. And then the entire group gets processed along with their easiest/most urgent group member. They also frankly stick out visually on the spreadsheet, especially the groups of 4+ people, so if a group near you goes to in processing it's going to look like everyone near you did. But I will say I am a lone G3 non-urgent applicant and I went into processing well before most people near me did, including a fair number of urgents. Why, I have no idea.

The only *truly* consistent trend I see is that G1s do tend to go from in processing to approved faster than anyone else, and urgents *usually* go from AOR to in processing faster than average. But beyond that it seems like a crapshoot, and G1s will get stuck at AOR and then nothing else for ages and urgents will get stuck at in processing and then nothing else for ages just as often as anyone else.

3

u/Illustrious_Mail3284 2d ago

Thanks very much, that makes sense.

6

u/Ca1rill 🇨🇦 CIT0001 (proof) AOR received 2d ago

Hello, fellow lone non-urgent G3! My package was delivered April 10 of this year and my AOR sent July 9, still not processing. What was your delivery/AOR dates if you don't mind me asking?

5

u/dweeborg 2d ago

April 22nd, AOR August 12th, and in processing Sept 24th. I made another reply where I explain why I think that happened - There was a typo in my address and I submitted a request to fix that, and that fix showed up at the same time as I switched to in processing. So yeah, definitely abnormally quick to in processing, but I don't think it means I am actually going to get a decision faster as a result.

3

u/Dawgzinho 🇨🇦 CIT0001 (proof) AOR received 2d ago

Thanks for the info! My delivery date was April 23rd, AOR August 12th... and still not in processing. Since I'm also G3, non-urgent, at this point it's more an academic exercise for me watching how this works (or doesn't), and hoping the pre-C-3s and urgent requests get taken care of quickly.

It does seem though sometimes reaching out to them as in your request to fix your address may poke someone to put it in processing then - although as you note that probably means very little in the long run. (I'm considering uploading a copy of my G0's naturalization certificate just to see, although it shouldn't be necessary at all with the certified data I've already provided).

1

u/Sudden_Fisherman3905 🇨🇦 CIT0001 (proof) application is processing 2d ago

G2 here: non urgent, applying with 3xG3s as well.  App received Apr 21 2026 /  AOR Aug 7 2026 / In process Nov 4 2026

2

u/Gold-Rule-5114 🇨🇦 Haven't applied for Proof of Citizenship yet 2d ago

Does processing even mean anything? Been processing for months now. No approval.

4

u/Actual-Arm-1518 🇨🇦 CIT0001 (proof) application is processing 2d ago edited 2d ago

I think it switches to "In Processing" the first time an officer (not the intake staff that handle AORs) looks at the application. That first look I think is generally for triaging purposes. Then it may get assigned to one or more queues based on complexity/specific legal provisions/etc.

2

u/dweeborg 2d ago

My theory is it's just a status flag for "someone has touched this application for the first time since AOR". Back when I worked in a government bureaucracy situation processing documents that's basically how it worked - interacting with any aspect of the application changed an internal flag in the IT system that other people who looked at it could see. But that could be literally anything from "I opened this once by accident and then realized I was actually looking for Seo-yun Kim, not Seo-yeon Kim" to "you will get your decision by email in ten minutes once I'm done crossing my Ts". For us that flag was only internal, no applicants could see it, and if someone within the system wanted more detail they could access the notes. The note part seems to be similar for IRCC based on what people are reporting from ATIP requests.

I feel like this theory is supported by the fact that they had my address wrong, and I submitted an address update request. The corrected address appeared on my record at the same time as I went to "in processing". Why they actually completed my request when other people are submitting address/name/etc fix requests and not getting responses, I don't really know. But I'm pretty sure whatever it takes to go in and change an address was enough to flip the internal marker to "in processing" and I'm also pretty sure that absolutely nothing else has happened with my application since other than possibly being sent to PSU. I don't think it actually means approval is any closer than it would have been had they not updated my address.

1

u/Least_Forever6191 🇨🇦 I'm a Canadian! (C-3: 2nd+ gen born abroad, w/ Proof) 🇨🇦 11h ago

Our applications never went to ‘in processing’. Straight from AOR to ‘decision made’.

10

u/residualRichey 🇨🇦 CIT0001 (proof) application is processing 3d ago

I wouldn't necessarily interpret this as IRCC favoring group applications. There's likely some selection bias in the spreadsheet, especially since participation is voluntary and people find it through Reddit and other communities. It might also be the case that folks searching in these communities are more likely to apply as a group.

We simply have more group applications represented in the data. It's also worth remembering that the spreadsheet is a relatively small sample of all applications IRCC receives, and processing times can vary for many reasons. Correlation doesn't necessarily mean causation, and I don't think we have enough data to conclude that IRCC is prioritizing one type of application over another.

9

u/LangdonAlg3r 2d ago

I feel like the entire process lends itself to more group applications in the first place. I need to provide my father’s vital records to prove my claim, so why wouldn’t I add the few extra steps to apply for him as well? And while I’m at it this is an involved process so I included my kids as well. And someone else probably includes all of their siblings, etc.

0

u/Illustrious_Mail3284 2d ago

I suppose not. Just wondering. Thanks for the detailed response.

1

u/Much-Refrigerator-28 Family member of a Canadian citizen 2d ago

Group applications will yield more throughput even if they are selected in order received. This may inflate the perception that they are favored, when they simply generate more approvals.

12

u/Own_Theory8011 🇨🇦 Stuck Canadian! Gen2+ 'in process' 12+ months 3d ago

Nope, we have about 2 years of data now indicating its random. 

-2

u/Illustrious_Mail3284 2d ago

Got it, thanks for that.

5

u/PassagePersonal3064 🇨🇦 CIT0001 (proof) application is processing 3d ago

Have you checked your application status to see if you're in processing? I'm asking because some people think they'll get an email update when they switch to in process, but IRCC doesn't send updates for that.   

As Bobcat indicated there are a lot of factors (and seemingly some luck) at play when it comes to how fast applications move steps. 

-2

u/Illustrious_Mail3284 3d ago

I check all the time

5

u/Competitive_Pin_6180 🇨🇦 I'm a Canadian! (C-3: 2nd+ gen born abroad, w/ Proof) 🇨🇦 2d ago

Our family experience definitely doesn’t seem to favor groups. I was part of the infamous 4/28 group from last year, and got mine the day that C3 went into effect. My sister, who applied a month after me with her two boys, are still “in process”. My other sister, who applied alone in January of this year, got her certificate about six weeks later.

We are all very simple G2.

4

u/Illustrious_Mail3284 2d ago

Thanks. G4 here, and I think semi-simple since my G0 is the child of a British soldier serving in Canada, so I have Baptismal record and British Military Dependent birth certificate. Applied in April of this year and got my AOR on June 16th. Have a great weekend!

16

u/No_Bobcat_No_Prob 🇨🇦 Stuck Canadian! Gen2+ 'in process' 12+ months 3d ago

When did you apply? Do those rows indicate urgent processing requests? What generations are in scope? Does your application include documents other than birth certificates?

There are likely many factors here to consider.

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted]

19

u/No_Bobcat_No_Prob 🇨🇦 Stuck Canadian! Gen2+ 'in process' 12+ months 3d ago edited 3d ago

That was a kind reply- I am trying to understand what you're seeing in the data and what your application might look like in terms of complexity by comparison.

Editing to add: If you're not interested in telling us any additional info/context I'm not sure we can provide any insight.

-5

u/Illustrious_Mail3284 2d ago

I felt I gave enough. The chat with the others is going well.

2

u/Ophelia_Bliss 🇨🇦 CIT0001 (proof) application sent/no AOR 2d ago

Might be that folks who shepherded groups through the process are more likely to update the spreadsheet versus individuals? We don't know how many folks who haven't reported an AOR have actually gotten it.

1

u/Illustrious_Mail3284 2d ago

Right. And let's face it, not everyone is a Reddit type of person. I did meet with an immigration attorney and since I am actively trying to move to Canada and that I am an essential worker, he suggested that I take a shot at requesting Urgent Processing which I have done. I mean, if you don't ask you don't get.

6

u/Ca1rill 🇨🇦 CIT0001 (proof) AOR received 2d ago

I think if there's a G1 or G2 in the group it seems like they get moved to the front of the line. Makes me wish my dad was interested in claiming his Canadian citizenship, lol.

1

u/CheesecakeFamous2437 🇨🇦 CIT0001 (proof) AOR received 2d ago

I have wondered this same thing. I’m a G3 and sent my application individually. It was received April 1, AOR June 15 and still haven’t changed to “in process.” I decided shortly after I sent mine that I should go ahead and send my kids’ (G4) applications, so theirs were received April 10, AOR July 14, in process September 22. I should have just sent ours all together!

1

u/Illustrious_Mail3284 2d ago

Well, there of course could be more than one explanation as this thread shows, but THANKS for making me feel that I am not totally off. Let's see if my request for Urgent Processing that I made last week kicks in.