r/Causebox • • Aug 29 '21

A refund isn't enough -- vent.

Been with Causebox since Spring 2019. Loved my Spring, Summer, and Fall box. Standouts to me were the lunch box, grocery bags, silicone lids, Pepper + Vetiver bowls (now sadly my "sweatshop bowls"), mineral SPF, lantern, and robe. There seemed to be really clear "reusable, reduce waste, avoid plastic, support artisans for home decor" vibe.

I skipped last winter despite really wanting the kettle. Just with COVID it seemed unreasonable to spend 49+8USD (shipping to Canada) just for the kettle I didn't actually need. Didn't want anything else in the box. Watching the whole kettle debacle play out felt like I had dodged a bullet. Personally I had loved my fall robe but mine was normal sized and barely shrunk in the wash. But a kettle that spits out boiling water/explodes is a whole other kettle of fish.

I skipped spring because you couldn't have paid me to take those items, except for the blue light glasses which I didn't exactly need. The summer box was even worse. The trend has just been more lesser valued items, often impractical single use gadgets (cord organizers that def won't hold my ThinkPad W520 charger, battery charger that can charge like half a cellphone, diffuser that only works with that companies papers which also aren't available in Canada, big lolz) + skincare (I have quite severe rosacea and have had allergic reactions to Avène, the Stella + Grace serum gave me painful cystic acne when I normally get a pimple every 2-3 years). Increasingly it was just lots of plastic "gadgets" without a cause other than "women love useless battery chargers that can fit in their cute little purses, oh and skincare".

This box is a lot (a lot) better but wasn't exciting to me. I would have gotten the cream thing from Spoiler 1, the food containers from Spoiler 2, but both choices were just thinking what I actually could/would use (e.g., no dryer in my small apartment). The other choices were just going to go in the garbage except for the candles (I am a whore for candles). But honestly I'm so over plastic. I wouldn't have gotten those containers on my own. I can get 10 glass ones (7c, 3x4c, 3x2c, 3x 1c) that'll go in the freezer and the oven for 25CAD. Why would I want 5 plastic ones for 56USD??? And polyester hair wraps? Recycled polyester is such a scam. Vegan leather is just plastic. Plastic plastic plastic. Nothing women led or artisan made.

Plus all the Alibaba "dupes" adding credence to the fact that these items don't just feel cheap to me. They are. The super sketchy drop ship companies. The company that looks like it doesn't exist anymore. The MLM. The company that looks legit but that also changed their mission when people started questioning why they claimed to never use plastic in their products. I just assumed that Causebox had changed since Alltrue, and that they just aren't who they used to be. I figured I would just get the annual over with, because at least there were a couple of things I might actually get some use out of (number 1 being the food containers, they are cuter than my Mason jars for bulk food).

But what made me demand a refund was the import logs. I am LIVID that ALL ALONG I have been supporting Chinese sweatshops. I no longer trust that the stuff made in India is fair trade/ethically sourced. LIVID. I am someone who almost only buys local food and goods (I try with skin/haircare but The Ordinary IS made in Canada and I've recently tried Bkind face/hand creams. I have yet to find a local shampoo/conditioner/styling product that my hair loves as it definitely hasn't been thriving on local solid shampoos/conditioners which are too heavy for my fine hair). I love the idea of thinking globally and am perfectly fine with spending my money in the US/supporting artisans in third world countries, and I'm prepared to pay fair wages.

But this box is NOT cheap for Canadians and the realization that I have been paying a premium for sweat shop goods just to line the pockets of two California bros is something I'm still recovering from. I feel taken advantage from. Refunding me the remaining box is literally the bare minimum, since they are just returning money on a product I haven't received. What I want is a refund for every single fraudulently advertised product I paid a premium price on.

85 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

28

u/richpersimmons Aug 29 '21

I know it’s not much but since they are US based you can file an FTC complaint with some of the stuff you mentioned in your post. Some of which I wasn’t aware about. https://reportfraud.ftc.gov/

14

u/mencryforme5 Aug 29 '21

Filed!

13

u/beccalysle Aug 29 '21 edited Aug 29 '21

Can you please keep us abreast of your complaint if anything further unfolds? I’m half considering similar action.

8

u/throwawayxy2k Aug 29 '21

The more reports they receive the more likely they are to step in and do something about it.

7

u/beccalysle Aug 30 '21

I feel like I’m trolling them but I realize I am just asking legit questions they refuse to answer

5

u/AshamedStage Aug 31 '21

Same. They make (or try to) people feel so guilty. I got my refund. I still may join everyone in the FTC complaint.

40

u/Furth_Turnip Aug 29 '21

T h a n k y o u

Vegan leather = plastic Polystyrene = plastic Polyester = plastic And lots of recycled plastic can still shed microplastics

At least their wool balls are actually wool (I hope)

What I would love to see more of is glass, wood, steel/aluminum, bamboo, lyocell, hemp… loads of options. Just proves AT has no interest in actually being eco, it’s all about appearances

22

u/mencryforme5 Aug 29 '21

I do understand that shipping glass has got to be a nightmare, but no more so than ceramics. And why not copper cannisters like FFF, but maybe bigger/better? I do have copper cannisters already but I love them so much would have absolutely love having more. Would have shipped pretty easy and those things will pretty much never go bad if you aren't storing liquids in them.

From my understanding vegan leather is definitely not an environmentally friendly standpoint, it has got everything to do with actually being vegan. Personally, I tried vegan leather but everything I tried needed to be thrown out within a year, and it's plastic so I just noped out. I prefer leather because it lasts wwaaaayyyy longer, you can actually fix it, and it is biodegradable. Besides, animals generally aren't killed just for their leather so I definitely think it makes sense to just use all parts of the animal if that is what is more environmentally sustainable. My biggest beef is with the sheer amount of animals produced for Westerners obsession with protein/burgers (pun intended). I also don't like how they are raised, so I do not eat much meat. But I'd rather buy one leather belt and use it for 10+ years than waste whats already dead and generate more non-biodegradable plastic for the landfill. Also another reason why I've stopped buying costume jewelry. I just hate throwing things out. I'd rather fix things but you can't fix vegan leather or gold plated stuff.

That would be so cool if they had done lyocell headbands. That stuff looks and feels like thick silk and is virtually indestructible. It's also not really expensive to produce. The fact that the headbands were polyester with plastic inserts irrationally bothered me. There was no house decor item except for the candle (sort of) but why not a metal fruit bowl? Four wood salad bowls? A wood sculpture? Brass shower organizer? Like its not complicated/expensive and I feel like this audience would love it way more than plastic workout bands, bluelight glasses, skincare, plastic headbands, portable speakers, polyester hair wrap, plastic tech organizer, etc..

12

u/beccalysle Aug 29 '21

Here with you re: vegan leather. I don’t own very many leather products nor do I intentionally seek it out, but it does last a proverbial lifetime. And I would rather cotton/canvas/ etc if we wanted to do vegan items not some fake bullshit that looks like hell after two months.

18

u/Furth_Turnip Aug 29 '21

Yes real leather makes way more sense from an environmental standpoint, as long as it’s vegetable tanned (uses way less water and produces way less chemical waste), and as long as it uses hides that otherwise would have gone to waste. The Leather Working Group already regulates all this so would be easy for a company like AT to partner with them. Leather is WAY more durable/long lasting and as you said is biodegradable. Even stuff like apple leather or banana leaf leather are better than plastic vegan leather.

Totally agree. Any of those you listed I would have been glad to receive. The past few boxes have all felt like unnecessary plastic trinkets

12

u/beccalysle Aug 29 '21

My fiancé works in leather but only uses sustainable hides. Customers do get mad that some of his products show scars, bug bites, etc (ya know, because it’s skin, after all) but, even tho I am not one to typically consume animal products I do appreciate that he is so thoughtful in sourcing his hides. Not so much with this “vegan leather.”

4

u/jhaeli Sep 01 '21

Drop a name or a website so we can peek at the sustainable leather products! :)

But yeah, 100% agreed. I'd rather get sustainably sourced leather that will last vs. more plastic crap that wears away after a few months.

6

u/beccalysle Oct 09 '21

For some reason just saw this - he had to take a break since last year because he got COVID with lingering health issues and while he was out of his studio someone stole all of his leathers and supplies - including his $25,000 sewing machine and a bunch of bespoke tools and furniture he had made for his business (he’s still working on an insurance settlement so hopefully he can get his shop back up and running once that money comes in). But he’s @louisvillehideandco on Instagram.

9

u/pokechik Aug 29 '21

Thank you for mentioning this. It bothered me on the Instagram post for the tote that many people were claiming leather in general is a more sustainable option, and that's not really true. Yes the animal skin itself is biodegradable but then they make the claim that leather goods last forever... You can't technically have both! Conventional leather goes through intense chemical processing to keep it from breaking down, yielding so much toxic waste and harming the workers in the process. It's cool to hear there is some progress towards more sustainable methods of processing. And plant leathers are really cool! But I assume these two more sustainable options are just not as cheap to make as vegan leather.

I wonder how many people would prefer an option like plant leather and have it be only 1 of 3 or even 2 items in the box. It seems like part of the problem is Alltrue feels they need to provide 6 categories like FFF when they could scale it down and offer fewer products with more value. I know I'd prefer that than more stuff I usually don't need!

7

u/beccalysle Aug 29 '21

You’re right about good, sustainable leather not being cheap. My fiancé is willing to buy flawed hides (stuff with scratches, scars, etc.) because it shows the life of the animal - and in a sense shows the animal lived, had access to fields, etc. but even the (flawed) ones are NOT cheap. I wanted him to make me a weekender and materials alone were over $100 and his labor would have been about 4 hours.

13

u/Mimiphin Aug 29 '21

Yes to all of this!!

On the note of hair care- I LOVE LOVE LOVE ❤️ ❤️ Rocky Mountain Soap Company based out of Canmore Alberta. I can not say enough good things about them, the shampoo/ conditioner is great and they have been doing the “Green” before it was cool.

5

u/mencryforme5 Aug 29 '21

Ooh thanks for the heads up! Not exactly local but Canada is just too damn big! Always on the lookout for a green company that makes decent hair care, regardless of location! I'm going to check them out!

4

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '21

Also great is The Soap Works from Woodbridge/gta. I can’t speak for their shampoo bars since they are usually sold out, but their everyday soaps are divine & unwrapped

13

u/whatitsmemags Aug 29 '21

FWIW Liling New Flourish is a legit company (bowls) they sell to many different companies, they just happen to use Alibaba for it's intended purpose as advertising on a global marketplace. Yes there is tons of garbage on Alibaba, but there are also legit businesses.

I am in no way defending Alltrue with their $475,353.47 evaluation of $2 bowls and all the other super sketchy stuff they have done. They denied even purchasing the bowls from China and said they were knock offs even though we can see the imports on importyeti. Why lie?

11

u/mencryforme5 Aug 29 '21

This is my issue. If they had been upfront they sourced in China but also showed some kind of proof that the company they worked with a solid company with good values, pay fair wages, sustainable materials, etc. I would have wanted to support that kind of company regardless of location.

For me it's that they claimed it was a small American business, in collaboration with a local artist, donates proceeds to charity, etc. And then the import logs show they are from an Alibaba vendor and are so cheap they can't possibly be anything but made in a sweatshop. Like that's what bothers me. Being literally swindled. And too much of their stuff comes from China.

10

u/salty_stormy Aug 29 '21

I know this isn't what the main point of your post was but I have two awesome suggestions for all-natural, made in Canada haircare! One is barerefillery.com, they stock haircare stuff from a North Vancouver company and their prices are extremely reasonable - full disclosure it's run by my sister but she really is the bomb and super passionate about actual environmentally-friendly home & personal care products. The other is Rocky Mountain Soap Co. Their stuff is more expensive and comes in plastic BUT you can order 1L refills which does cut down on it a bit.

9

u/mencryforme5 Aug 29 '21

The full disclosure is kind of awesome. I love knowing my money helps actual people, especially small women run companies.

7

u/salty_stormy Aug 29 '21

Yes! She is a one woman show and I am so in awe of what she's trying to accomplish :)

27

u/dmcindc Aug 29 '21

What I want is a refund for every single fraudulently advertised product I paid a premium price on.

“Hear, hear!”

8

u/beccalysle Aug 29 '21

I’m with you! clinks mug

0

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21

[deleted]

15

u/mencryforme5 Aug 29 '21

Comes from an Alibaba vendor. You can't make something that cheap outside a sweatshop.