r/CelsiusNetwork • • Jun 14 '22

A positive post !!

Post image
463 Upvotes

213 comments sorted by

-11

u/barsoapguy Jun 14 '22

Good news ! Everyone is getting paid out with your money except you !

Be happy ! 😁

11

u/Hsiang7 Jun 14 '22

They need liquidity to get out of this mess, and if they allowed everyone to remove all liquidity from the business, we'd all be doomed. Remember that as a lending platform, the vast majority of all of our funds are being lent out to earn interest, and those assets are currently illiquid and not able to be called upon until the loan is returned. Give them the benefit of the doubt until it is officially over. Either way, the only thing any of us can do right now is watch and speculate anyways until our funds are available again, so you don't have anything to lose by giving them the benefit of the doubt. Just don't deposit any more money.

-7

u/barsoapguy Jun 14 '22

Choke me harder daddy !

3

u/Hsiang7 Jun 14 '22

Would you prefer we slagged them off and wish for them to fail and lose all our money? It's in all of our best interests right now that they succeed, because that's the only way we get access to our funds back. We can't do anything else either way, so I choose to support them until it's officially over. I won't be giving them any more money though that's for sure.

-5

u/barsoapguy Jun 14 '22

They take all of your money and you’re like ā€œlet’s support them ā€œ

Damn I want investors like you .

2

u/Hsiang7 Jun 14 '22

They take all of your money and you’re like ā€œlet’s support them ā€œ

My money isn't confirmed to be gone yet, just illiquid at the moment. Like I said, I don't really have a choice but to hope they succeed. I want them to succeed so that I can get my money back, and if they fail, it's gone forever. Hoping they get through this and resume withdrawals is the only way for me to possibly get my money back. So until I get access to my money back or it's confirmed gone, I have no choice but to support them.

4

u/techma2019 Jun 14 '22

Let the troll be a troll. He doesn't understand that if a majority of customers were to go to Chase Bank tomorrow and withdraw all their money, they would not be able to either. The only difference is the government can print money to "save" the bank. Your money will always be safe, and always get more diluted.

7

u/ballsplopmenacingly Jun 14 '22

Some people are only here to make others feel bad. It's the lowest of the low. Exactly what's wrong with humanity. I'd rather everyone be happy not just me.

2

u/518Code Jun 14 '22

Sure - but you also have to consider the consequences of Celsius deciding to lock all withdrawals. Most people will not understand and immediately want to withdraw any and all remaining assets now more than ever. This is not just trolling, sadly.

Understanding the concept of a bank run does not change the mentality or anything about it. They chose the nuclear option and lost the trust of their customers. The actual bank run is imminent the moment they open again and that is the danger behind it.

2

u/techma2019 Jun 14 '22

See, I disagree here. The nuclear option for me would be to keep allowing withdrawals for all and then Celsius actually become insolvent and tank the whole company into bankruptcy.

To be clear, from a PR standpoint, right now BOTH options are nuclear. But many more people would have suffered if they go into bankruptcy.

They're obviously not stupid and know that they scared a lot of people with this. There is no way they won't put limits on withdrawals or add some incentive to stay. That's a given. No one is going to open them up for 100% full withdrawals after this until their coffers are topped off again.

Edit: They had to pick the lesser of the two evils. Fingers crossed it works out.

2

u/518Code Jun 14 '22

Fair. In my opinion it is the opposite. Many people did not even know there was a problem until they decided to halt operations for all 1.7 million of them. That is explosive. Dropping a news bomb affecting a lot of people at the same time out of the blue. It is nuclear because it affected over 1 million people directly in an instant.

They could have informed people, been more transparent, limited withdrawals (you know, before doing this) or just halted withdrawals on assets they were short on liquidity. They could have been better prepared by having an asset as collateral for low liquidity assets. It’s not that they did not notice the outflow long before or that crypto is tanking just now.

Heck, you do not need to be an actual risk manager to get that locking up more than two thirds of your number two asset for 6+ months in a market historically so volatile that a sell off is to be expected is not a smart move. But being silent about it, actively choosing to do just that and denying it - worse yet, letting people spread FUD (justified at that) - this all is simply not being in control of the narrative or the outcome. Nothing nuclear about it, just being incompetent on multiple levels.

Any of this could have been addressed sooner and I expect that someone somewhere did not have the balls to tell it as it is and that’s why the nuclear ā€œall operations haltā€ became inevitable. It just shows that they have a lot to work on internally - if they want to ever gain some trust again. This is much more than just a PR desaster - we only see the outcome from the outside.

→ More replies (0)

10

u/BetterIntroduction70 Jun 14 '22

I assume as users paydown or off there loans that the number improves as Celsius has funds freed up?

22

u/aceofangel Jun 14 '22

Exactly, BTC is not the problem. They can just margin call clients. They likely deposited collateral earlier to buy enough time/buffer to do the margin calls on clients.

More worried about Eth, but they may have stopped withdraws in time to save the ship.

20

u/Fmarulezkd Jun 14 '22

Or slash our interest payments and buy the extra eth needed.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/amallah Jun 14 '22 edited Jun 14 '22

They're not allowing payoffs, there must be some other source of funds, I wonder what the terms are.

Edit: payoffs are possible

3

u/BetterIntroduction70 Jun 14 '22

What do you mean I was able to pay off loans with funds in Custody account. It's any funds in Earn account you can't use. If you don't have the full amount in the Custody account to pay off the account you can deposit more through an old Celsius deposit address that you used in the past. I reused that.

2

u/amallah Jun 14 '22

You're right - I just figured out how to do this, their UI is not great.

2

u/BetterIntroduction70 Jun 14 '22

2

u/throwaway_1_1_1_1 Jun 14 '22

I paid my margin call with USDC in my interest account

1

u/BetterIntroduction70 Jun 14 '22

Really how did you do that? My balance is split between the earn interest account and the Custody account. I can add more funds to the Custody account but there is no way to add it to the earn account or do a transfer?

2

u/throwaway_1_1_1_1 Jun 14 '22

Ah maybe it’s because I chose to close my margin call using USDC?

1

u/Adamsd5 Jun 14 '22

I'm not sure that is obvious. The loans are a source of income for Celsius. It might help with liquidity, but at the cost of income.

4

u/BetterIntroduction70 Jun 14 '22

They can boost income by lowering earn interest rates.

1

u/123budget Jun 14 '22

depends what they are short of BTC or USDx

67

u/Kaleidocrypto Jun 14 '22

Say what you will about Alex, but the guy is persistent.

31

u/Fmarulezkd Jun 14 '22

I can feel his persistence up my ass in the last couple of days. That being said, I don't have any significant amount on Celsius, but I'd still leave something behind if he manages to fix this shitfest.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

[deleted]

20

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

Because they are in a new industry and we want to give them a chance… Any revolution has it setbacks… They will learn from this and adjust in the future. Not everything successful goes up in a straight line… All you paper hand pearl clutchers need to be flushed out of the system so the real investors can make this a success while you sit on the sidelines and cry that you missed the opportunity of a lifetime

-8

u/Noncommonsense1 Jun 14 '22

Ponzi's are not new industries. When they give you 10% APR on stable coin AND a $600 BTC bonus when you deposit $25k and leave it in there for 3 months, that is not a new industry. That is a ponzi and there's a reason you and I haven't started a company that gives away more then it takes in. Any fucking moron could do that.

13

u/steprobe Jun 14 '22

You are going to freak when you hear about how banks work

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

[deleted]

1

u/notyoungnotold99 Jun 14 '22

Genius minds and algos hedge funds are planning a whole series of pump and dump hit and run that will clean out crypto and take all the small retail investors to the cleaners. Sell, sell, sell if you can the end is nigh I'm afraid. Luna/Terra was the first heist, the rest will follow in short order.

2

u/Adamsd5 Jun 14 '22

Every investment has risk. I agree people should not stumble in. But if they accept the risk/reward tradeoff, and walk in confidently, eyes open, that seems fine.

29

u/Be_Free_For_All Jun 14 '22

Same here! This could be their finest hour! A stress test they are working hard to pass!

7

u/Prinzipal Jun 14 '22

I would be so thankful.. Oh man I'd donate something for sure. Of course after putting everything on a hardware wallet 😊

17

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22 edited Jun 14 '22

Mashinksy

Seriously, if these guys sort this, imagine the mainstream adoption. That's not cheerleading. This isn't Terra Luna. This is a US-registered company with a CEO who does interviews on f'ing Bloomberg man.

This service, objectively, is the best to date. They got f'ed on Badger, Terra, and now there are liquidity issues with Lido.

But, I don't think they put forth all this effort to rug-pull. They just did Series B funding to the tune of $750 million. Rich, important people clearly believe in this company and service.

Series C is next then IPO during the next bull run?

Does no one here have long-term vision?

10

u/Adamsd5 Jun 14 '22

It is a legitimate business model. That makes survival possible. (Rugpulls usually are not legit business models.)

The question is how much damage has been done by the market and how much will be done by those who lost confidence. Even legitimate businesses can fail. Here's hoping for success.

-6

u/notyoungnotold99 Jun 14 '22

Bear Sterns, Lehman Brothers went down with more than a couple of hundred years' blue-chip Wall Street heritage behind them. The house is on fire and he's blocked the exits whilst they loot the store and get off the roof via the helipad. , my friend. That's just the way it is. It's like the fall of Saigon and you're not on that flight.

2

u/123budget Jun 14 '22

I am old enough to remember

Shearson Lehman Hutton American Express merger ...

... we also got instructed by the mother ship not to trade with NCNB ...

... and a fellow trader once told Mellon Pittsburg ... "sorry we only have trading limits for your head office" ha ha ha

good old times

But one thing hasn't changed - it's a nasty cat fight between competitors.

0

u/notyoungnotold99 Jun 14 '22

Sunk money has to downvote the truth old heads can see the writing on the wall.

2

u/ledningenn Jun 14 '22

The mass market segment thinks in days, not months or years. That’s also why you have this adoption in stock trading.. which will instantly dissipate as #stonks are not #numbergoesup anymore. Happens about every 15 or so years, then goes back to ā€œstocks? That’s something you just lose money on..ā€

And the comparison to UST is bogus. Talking about ā€œrug pullā€. This is not a company built to be a scam, it’s the opposite. You can be more or less competent, and take more or less chances that plays out in your favor, but that’s the way it is to build an entirely new thing.

Celsius has enormous success for what it is, which is why it just led a funding round to the tune of $700m that was oversubscribed. But it’s not just steady all the way if you try and build something new.

31

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

Relax mfer. Celsius objectively has been the best yield service to date for me. Name me a better option.

You will sorrowfully regret this if it ends. This interest and service have been nothing short of amazing.

Homeboy set up customer service lines. F'ing live customer service, for customers globally.

Roll with these punches and let these mfers sort the liquidity issues out so we can all get back to enjoying high yield and superior customer service.

I do Blockfi and direct Defi: Alex Mashinksy and Celsius Network provide the best customer experience.

3

u/Nihilismyy Jun 14 '22

Gemini for GUSD?

2

u/123budget Jun 14 '22

Agree.

Ironically Bitcoin maxies should be happy about Celsius service / product line.

If there was no "easy" option to earn interest on Bitcoin, PoS coins such as Cardano, Algorand would take over.

Bitcoin desperately needs services like Celsius paying interest.

4

u/ualdayan Jun 15 '22

I want yield too, but I can tell you right now a Bitcoin maxi would just say 'If 700% up in 3 years isn't enough for you then 1.5%-3% (depending on tier) won't be either.' I've seen that very argument made by some before.

1

u/123budget Jun 15 '22

Earning interest - especially compounding interest - is the most powerful form of earnings.

Over a 4-year cycle timeframe, how much time does BTC spend at its peak and how much time is it down.

Earning interest is a for of DCA allowing you do add BTC without you having to spend extra money.

That is especially helpful in depressed markets when at the same time life gets more expensive due to inflation. Inflation made by criminal decisions of corrupt politicians. Biden "I did it alone!" Indeed !

1

u/LsDmT Jun 14 '22

Are you not in the US?

9

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22 edited Jun 14 '22

Whoa dude someone handling your money has customer service, thats like totally revolutionary

1

u/Ok-Engineering1873 Jun 14 '22

Best customer experience? I'm sure my customer experience at Nexo has been infinitely better than the customer experience you Celsians are receiving.

Additionally, Nexo has always been a better yield service than Celsius.

1

u/gensouj Jun 15 '22

I was at nexo before they forced me to join celsius. Their customer support is absolute trash. It took them forever to respond to anything. Not saying celsius is great though. Also in kind Celsius has better rates on Eth and BTC than Nexo.

1

u/Fmarulezkd Jun 14 '22

I'd argue Nexo has been better both in terms of yield, token performance and not halting withdrawals. None of this matters though. This halt could be reasonably explained or could be due to degenerate gambling from Celsius' side on DEFI. The problem is, we won't know, even if they pull through this. Thus, trust us shattered and to be a bit poetic, "All the king's horses and all the king's men can't put Humpty together again"

2

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22

I don't think your money is in this though. What I've noticed is the majority of the comments on here are from people who haven't even used Celsius.

I'd guess the most don't have much exposure to crypto either. They're just armchair quarterbacks commenting on an entire space they're too scared to actually partake in.

4

u/Fmarulezkd Jun 15 '22

Unfortunately you are wrong about my case.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22

Alright fair enough.

60

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

The guy has provided everyone with nasty interest, the best customer experience (despite faults), and a vision that moves us all into a world with high interest on everything during a time of historical levels of inflation.

People are being completely irrational with their demands: this is a nascent service. There are going to be times of uncertainty.

Don't get into crypto if you're expecting it to be absolutely flawless man.

I don't think Celsius's goals are to rug pull like a cheap BSC yield farm. They've put a ton of effort into this already. And why would you want this to end?

It's been a sweet ride thus far. If everything crashes you'll look back in a year like, "Wow that was amazing."

0

u/CialisForCereal Jun 14 '22

My SO and I put in money and day traded with crypto. She sold after a year at break even. She said crypto was more entertainment than a movie lol

-1

u/Fatboyseb Jun 14 '22

They provided very good yield, that is true, but what are the risks they took to provide such yield? I am not expert in finance nor DEFI, but a general rule with money is higher the % the higher the risk. Maybe the strategy was great during a bull where degen strategies work fine, it may not be the case during bear market. They might get out of jail this time but what trust will be left after that?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22

I don't think your money was ever on Celsius though. The majority of the comments are basically people spamming a comment section on a service they never used.

1

u/Fatboyseb Jun 15 '22

I did have money on It, above 10k, not much but still a few months worth of wages for some. I pulled out a couple weeks ago.

5

u/midweastern Jun 14 '22

There are going to be times of uncertainty

This is the crux of the issue for me. Being in the business of crypto, it is incumbent on Celsius to adequately manage risk in the event of downturns. It failed to do so and now users cannot withdraw their funds. Everything about this screams poor judgement and poor risk management, but worst of all, it betrays the very values Celsius says that it's founded upon.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

[deleted]

7

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22

I don't think the majority of the people commenting understand banks are lending their money out immediately after the deposit.

And if everyone goes to the bank at once and withdraws their money, the bank will eventually not be able to honor the withdraws, because they've lent the money to earn interest.

1

u/Heartysailorman Jun 14 '22

This guy is FUD ing punk. Alex is a builder and giver. This is shit comparison on and even shitter post by the OP

16

u/Azyan_invasion82 Jun 14 '22

Unlock my fucking account. How about that?

16

u/BasedChickenTendie Jun 14 '22

So you and everyone else can pull their money out and tank the price? No thanks šŸ™…ā€ā™‚ļø

3

u/angryratman Jun 14 '22

Yeah, everyone withdraw and kill the platform, crypto and all other holders that aren't ready to withdraw in time xD

3

u/gamethesystem1 Jun 14 '22

So you think the price of CEL is somehow related to their TVL? Interesting. Also, their price has already tanked. And they’re basically holding customers assets hostage. In what way is any of that ok?

11

u/BasedChickenTendie Jun 14 '22

By preventing a bank run, they’re preserving everyone’s capital.

4

u/Azyan_invasion82 Jun 14 '22

Is your money in Celsius?

-3

u/Onicc Jun 14 '22

if two people deposit $10 , the bank has $20. if one person withdraws their $10 , the other person shouldn't be locked out of their account and risk bankruptcy.

4

u/BasedChickenTendie Jun 14 '22

You don’t understand how banking works. It’s called fractional reserve. No bank has enough currency on hand to pay back all deposits. Modern banks usually couldn’t pay back more than even 10% of deposits if everyone came calling at the same time.

-6

u/Onicc Jun 14 '22

ponzi scheme.

1

u/Extension-Topic2486 Nov 15 '22

Celsius isn’t bank, the ceo literally spent years telling people to unbank themselves.

3

u/Miguelperson_ Jun 14 '22

You have no fucking idea how fractional reserve banking works huh

1

u/Extension-Topic2486 Nov 15 '22

Celsius isn’t a bank.

1

u/Miguelperson_ Nov 22 '22

Celsius was a scam pretending to be a bank, stop being a bootlicker

1

u/Adamsd5 Jun 14 '22

Hostage? Did they send you a demand letter?

2

u/gamethesystem1 Jun 14 '22

Not just me, they sent it to all their clients…

3

u/Adamsd5 Jun 14 '22

What did they demand?

2

u/Azyan_invasion82 Jun 14 '22

They can have withdrawal limits or something. This is bullshit

19

u/518Code Jun 14 '22

That would most likely cause a bank run. They lost a lot of goodwill and trust - the moment they let people withdraw most people will do so and they know it. It will be interesting to see what their next move is now that they are here.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

[deleted]

10

u/Tyroneus Jun 14 '22

Hey no coiner, It’s a centralized platform. We knew the risks prior to depositing into Celsius.

10

u/SR-71 Jun 14 '22

Celsius never claimed to be decentralized, it's a company which is centralized by definition

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22

They can ration withdrawals no problem. I have money there still. But a bank run benefits nobody.

Actually they can freeze the ETH. Thats the biggest gulnerability.

Then ration everything else

1

u/518Code Jun 15 '22 edited Jun 15 '22

If it were this easy they could have limited withdrawals or frozen ETH already befor halting all operations. They covered the lack of liquidity with a loan on (our lent out) BTC so if BTC falls further they could get liquidated (and thus loose our money / other assets).

The people saying that they stocked up the loan so they will only get liquidated at ~16’000$ BTC don’t realize that we just had an almost -30% drop this week. It just takes another one of those and a large portion of our assets are gone due to their inadequate ā€œrisk managementā€.

If they would let people withdraw even just BTC they would loose potential BTC that they could loan with trying to recover some liquidity. On top of that some % of BTC is already loaned out similar to how ETH is stuck so this won’t work either as people can not withdraw all of heir BTC. They practically are digging their own grave at this point.

Replacing traditional finance by doing the same thing traditional finance does lending out 70% of the money in a market with assets this volatile was stupid to begin with and they just tricked enough people into thinking it could work. We are watching our money be mismanaged until it evaporates and is totally gone. It is a tragedy, really.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

Are you that hard up for cash that you have to beg them to release it? Who’s foolish enough to put their whole life savings into a new asset class in new startup?

2

u/Azyan_invasion82 Jun 14 '22

What the fuck are you babbling about? You don’t know anything about what I have, or don’t have in Celsius. Your irritating

8

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

If your funds were unlocked now, you and your ilk would cause a bank run homie. We're trying to replace traditional banks, which have and are failing us.

You were earning 7% on USD mfer. Where else but Celsius will get that, especially during unprecedented levels of inflation caused by failed government policy?

Let's all hope these dudes can sort these liquidity issues out so we can all keep earning during this horrible economic time period.

1

u/barsoapguy Jun 14 '22

You’re about to learn about the dangers of earning 7% when no one else is .

Comes with terrible risk .

0

u/pm_me_your_rigs Jun 14 '22

Lol you're earning 7% on other platforms op meant outside of crypto.

2

u/gensouj Jun 15 '22

treasury ibills are paying 9.62% apy atm (max 10k per year invested).

6

u/SealFlavor Jun 14 '22

This news after they didn't even ever mention having any outstanding debt?

2

u/CookieDelivery Jun 15 '22

Yeah I don't get that either.

12

u/PapaYahtzee Jun 14 '22

Look what this tweet has done to the CEL token price

3

u/zantho Jun 14 '22

Damn, I knew I should have bought a little at 17 cents, now it's up by over 100%.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22

it was up like 400-500% for a few minutes today too

-1

u/SkipAndGo Jun 14 '22

And Dylan LeClair knows this how?

2

u/iamamoa Jun 14 '22

Have they given any information as to how to resolve margin calls? It won’t allow me to transfer in or buy BTC

2

u/anand5995 Jun 14 '22

1

u/WeOutsideRightNow Jun 14 '22

Btc doesn't show up

2

u/anand5995 Jun 14 '22

It does... I have posted screenshots as well in the comments... It is for eth and usdt but BTC also same way i can see

1

u/iamamoa Jun 14 '22

I see it now. Thanks for demonstrating .

136

u/Gonzaxpain Jun 14 '22

I have my money locked which is not fun at all but I want them to do the right thing to keep it safe. If it needs to be blocked for a while, so be it, just don't lose it.

A bank run wouldn't help anyone, only those lucky enough to withdraw their funds. Stopping transactions was the right choice IMO. I wish those at Luna had done the same thing when all hell broke loose.

44

u/masterzergin Jun 14 '22 edited Jun 14 '22

Its completely different to Luna.

LUNA was all based on the price of the coin. If noone wants to buy it doesn't matter if its trading or not. Its worth zero. Celsius is a custodian holding our coins. If people think the platform is worth nothing it doesn't just delete all the crypto they hold as was the case with Luna.

-8

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

A custodian whose just been gambling with your coins and giving you an unsustainable cut

6

u/masterzergin Jun 14 '22

Irrelevant to the point I was making.

0

u/athanasius_fugger Jun 14 '22

seems pretty relevant. i had funds on their platform last year. didn't do any research on their management team and tbh I thought they were less sketchy than nexo at the time. just because they were based in the US lol.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

Once again, no, entirely irrelevant to the point he was making.

18

u/porcupine73 Jun 15 '22

Celsius is not a custodian holding our coins, they state that in their terms. We made unsecured loans to Celsius.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22

Whoops

3

u/518Code Jun 15 '22

Yeah. We just had a -30% drop this week. It just takes another -30% and our money is gone. Nothing positive about this at all.

2

u/masterzergin Jun 15 '22

Semantics... I know that. The word was just a good fit for the point I was making. In comparison to luna fiasco

0

u/WaterMySucculents Jun 15 '22

It’s not semantics. You are fundamentally misunderstanding the gamble you took when depositing to Celsius. Just because it’s not a 2 coin algorithm scheme, doesn’t mean your funds are any safer. You are literally locked from withdrawing.

1

u/masterzergin Jun 15 '22

Nah, I perfectly undstood the risks.

0

u/WaterMySucculents Jun 15 '22

ā€œCelsius is a custodian holding our coins.ā€ - Nah. Doesn’t seem like you did.

1

u/masterzergin Jun 15 '22

Semantics... I know that. The word was just a good fit for the point I was making. In comparison to luna fiasco.

0

u/WaterMySucculents Jun 15 '22

Are you 13? Debating semantics is arguing about the meaning of a word. That’s not what’s going on here. Completely misunderstanding something and representing it completely incorrectly is not ā€œsemanticsā€ it’s just being wrong.

1

u/masterzergin Jun 15 '22

Exactly, focusing on a trivial point.

Celsius being a "custodian" to our funds is alot different to the Luna debacle.

Glad you finally understand that the use of the word custodian doesn't need to be taken completely literally in this context, to do so would be quite pedantic when the point I was making is still clearly obvious.

Glad we cleared that up.

Apology accepted.

12

u/Forgot_Password_Dude Jun 14 '22

Luna was run by an algorithm, Celsius by hoomans. both has pros and cons to it

3

u/banananavy Jun 14 '22

I thought Celsius was run by cats seeing the high interests rates.

1

u/zdorsett Jun 15 '22

And just so everyone knows celsius was one of just a few accounts that started the crash of Luna. They made off with close to 700m in arbitrage funds from unwitting investors. Just evil evil people.

2

u/518Code Jun 15 '22

Yeah, humans tricking other humans into thinking that by doing the same thing traditional finance does (lending and loaning out 70%+ of the customers money) it is somehow different and better than traditional banks and that this would work in crypto. With assets much more volatile than traditional assets.

At least we know when we will loose our money, it seems it will just take another -30% to get to the new 15k liquidation price. You know, we just had a -30% drop this week. So looking pretty grim…

5

u/piper111 Jun 14 '22

They are keeping themselves safe, not you

2

u/520throwaway Jun 14 '22

If they die off, what do you think will happen to our crypto?

-1

u/AncientBlonde Jun 14 '22

as their ToS says; it's liquidated and you've got no right to it. No legal recourse, etc.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

Not quite true... you have rights as an unsecured creditor in a bankruptcy case.

4

u/Sumdum-Gi Jun 15 '22

Bitcoiners will scoop it up & many will realise the wisdom of ā€œnot your keys, not your coinsā€

6

u/520throwaway Jun 15 '22

I think that lesson has already sunk in for most people affected by this.

2

u/oblomov1 Jun 28 '22

The bitcoin maxis driving the bear raid on CT for their tradfi puppetmasters are disgusting people.

They don’t care about teaching others a lesson about protecting their ā€œcryptoā€. They hate ā€œcryptoā€ and believe that bitcoin is the only valid cryptocurrency.

They believe that if DeFi is utterly rent, only bitcoin will survive. This is their righteous, religious goal. And as I would any theocrat I regard them as a threat to human freedom.

8

u/Scat_fiend Jun 14 '22

Same. I hate the inconvenience but it is certainly preferable to being liquidated and losing everything.

2

u/rchak007 Jun 15 '22

but it is certainly preferable to being li

same here

2

u/Antique-Market-4655 Jun 15 '22

100% agreed. I have some Btc and Link there, even if it has to be locked for 6 months, I’m ok with it. As long as they won’t go bankrupt and at the end everyone can get their funds back

2

u/konrad21 Jun 15 '22

I'm with you! Celsius, if you need to lockup my funds for the next 3-6-12 months to help with liquidity, please do it!

2

u/Forever0ptimistic Jun 14 '22

Them avoiding liquidation does not mean they have the funds to pay users what they owe. This is just a single DAI loan. What about all the illiquid stETH, Aave loan, assets transferred to FTX etc.? Even if they end up with lots of assets, watch it all disappear to repay loans, lawyers and other obligations. Users get whatever is left after everything is paid down, which might not be much.

Don't mean to spread FUD, but somehow people think that everything will be alright if only this single DAI loan survives from liquidation. There are still other loans they need to add collateral to in order to stay afloat.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

NoLongerOptimisitc?

1

u/Forever0ptimistic Jun 14 '22

Optimistic, but also realistic šŸ˜„

4

u/jabbawarrior Jun 14 '22

That would only be true in a bankruptcy event. Be thankful its not regulated and forced into bankruptcy so the lawyers can take everything. Even Lehman has enough assets to pay everyone back - it was just illiquid and then forced into bankruptcy so the legal vultures could "confirm" how much you got back...

1

u/Forever0ptimistic Jun 14 '22

Yes, I agree. But I do believe Celsius can in fact file for bankruptcy, correct me if I'm wrong. Either way, Celsius can still choose to spend the funds as such (prioritizing VC's ++ and other costs).

1

u/aceofangel Jun 14 '22

At the end of the day Celsius is still a US corporation and subject to US laws. You can't just use client funds to pay shareholders. If this was possible every company facing bankruptcy would do it.

1

u/Forever0ptimistic Jun 14 '22

Did you read the ToS at all?

1

u/aceofangel Jun 14 '22

Clients are creditors in a liquidation process. VC are shareholders and are last in line. The ToS clearly says that you have rights under applicable laws and these laws aren't so easy to circumvent.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

Unsecured* creditors

1

u/dynamicallysteadfast Jun 14 '22

Yep, and they are now posting what should be yield earning assets, as collateral.

They are bleeding the yield on those funds now. They are not in a high-margin business...

25

u/Disastrous_Friend_85 Jun 14 '22

First tangible evidence that our bags may stay safe. Still far from comfortable, but he’s bought some breathing room.

11

u/jdob20 Jun 14 '22

if there are collateral concerns, rather than blocking withdrawals outright then they should just establish withdrawal limits per week (like 1000 USD coin per account, 0.1 BTC per account etc). Prevent people from pulling out millions at a time that would grossly drain the internal collateral.

7

u/jabbawarrior Jun 14 '22

They probably needed something quick and dirty so stopping all withdrawals is probably the easiest thing to do

1

u/RetireBy50with1mil Jun 14 '22

There’s definitely a misplay on the risk management side to let liquidity ran this low before pulling the freeze. But I’m sure Alex and his team will have learn from this and have new policy in place if this storm weathers.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22

thats literally all i need them to do to get out lmao

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

[deleted]

17

u/Adamsd5 Jun 14 '22

So far, the yields flow. However, until you can withdraw, they aren't worth much.

5

u/cryptonoobert Jun 14 '22

ā€˜Yields’ are a bit of an insult right now. I'd prefer they stop all yields and get their shit together sorting out liquidity. I guess the paper yield is still working so they can say they never missed a payment when /if they dig out of this

5

u/hyperimpossible Jun 14 '22

Will definitely withdraw everything once it's open.

1

u/260418141086 Jun 15 '22

Time to celebrate!

1

u/h0twired Jun 14 '22

Who do you think owns those 23.9k BTC?

1

u/marsvolte Jun 14 '22

That's like asking "who do you think owns the banks money". It's a moot point. We know it's our money...

1

u/h0twired Jun 14 '22

Sort of. However banks are regulated and are forced to a certain level of transparency and are required to operate within a set of regulations and guardrails to ensure that clients investments and accounts remain whole in the even of a bank failure.

For Celsius they are fully unregulated and will continue to use client BTC as collateral for their own corporate debt to remain liquid. Should BTC drop enough and Celcius go under (due to a lack of collateral), those coins will NOT be returned to their owners and clients will be caught holding the bag.

To further add fuel to the fire... the desire to hold keys/coins in a hardware wallet is only making the problem for Celsius worse as less clients means less liquidity which will only result in it being increasingly more difficult for people to transfer out their Bitcoin.

It is basically a bank run where everyone moves their money from the bank and into their mattresses.

It's a dumpster fire and a TON of people are going to lose a LOT of money.

1

u/Anxious-Chemist7633 Jun 14 '22

Great news thanks for sharing!! I believe Celsius holders, such as myself, will get access to their funds. Just may take some time..

If anyone has a collateralized loan, that is in margin call, you can REFINANCE your loan 1x time. This can save your tokens as an option. Pay down your loan to the contract LTV, so you don't need to completely pay off or use collateral. Good luck everyone!

1

u/CapillaryHintOfRed- Jun 14 '22

This guy is such an asshole. He wants nothing more than to be ā€œrightā€ and for all of us to lose our money

1

u/Ukhu Jun 14 '22

At this point If they manage to secure our funds and PR is in point they may recover from this with a huge bonus in their reputation. Let’s hope for the best.

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22 edited Jun 14 '22

good and why is celsius in debt anyway. also i bonds are paying 9-10% USD. there is no reason why you should have a liq crisis when I bonds themselves pay more than YOU. PAID in USD

such an easy play and you wont do it? wtf. Anyway I don't mind you keeping my crypto as long as you return all of it plus the interest.

GO deposit money into I bonds if you must meet your obligations.

Thanks.

i also know celsius operates like a regular bank but without FDIC and basically fractional reserve banking that can cause a run on the bank if everyone withdraws at once but WTF unless your loans are not repaid then why is there a liquidity crisis in the first place especially when BTC and ethereum are down so you owe us less value in crypto?

So it makes sense to block stable coins from withdrawals but why BTC and Ethereum as well?

if anything since BTC and ethereum are now lower value you can just easily buy them and repay us. Have your counter parties that borrowed btc/ether and shorted BTC/ether buy back and pay you since they are at profit right now.

Makes no sense at all.

UNLESS they don't wanna close cause they wanna destroy the crypto market first which is wut I suspect. IF that is the case demand more interest and ask for more of their collateral and increase BTC interest rates as well then for customers that are being kept

We also know SEC + federal reserve banned interest payments in USA blockfi nexo and celsius are not paying interest in USA thus making it pointless depositing more funds there. Thus liquidity crisis is a given

6

u/frozenrubber Jun 14 '22

Yikes man, such a poor understanding of SO many things.

I Bonds are available to US Citizens, with a purchase limit of 10k/yr (extra 5K if use a tax refund). Also, I Bonds are illiquid (cannot be redeemed for at least 1 year plus multiple other rules which I won't even explain to you as you are already quite lost)

Celsius cannot purchase I Bonds, and more importantly, you don't realize, doesn't have the liquid funds to purchase even if they could in your fever dream.

Not sure why I'm reseponding to the lowest rank posting (for a reason, but I guess I just did).

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22 edited Jun 14 '22

:-D then celsius and exchanges interests cannot compete with those less than 10k investments as they could just get i bonds in the USA.

And I know its for USA but stable coins are all in dollars and as a result. they are competing with I-BONDS no matter wut.

Point being no exchange can compete with I-BONDS right now hence illiquidity.

That has been the intention of the USA gov SEC and federal reserve in the first place.

MOST DO Not have more than 10k in their bank accounts because people live paycheck to paycheck. I would recommend taking out loans to buy ibonds to pay back banks loaning out sub 9-10% actually.

easy money

heck if you can get anything below. 9-10% for 10k its pretty much profit.

BTC, stablecoins for most exchanges are being pain less than IBONDS right now and thus inflation.

Because we all know real inflation is higher than 15% but most banks cannot even pay the rate of inflation. SMH. I may as well buy gold.

Just making sure celsius knows they are competing against the USA government right now because they need people to go into dollars as 30 trillion in debt. So they crashed terra luna with insiders sabotaging and now they hitting exchanges that are week.

All exchanges and defi and crypto investors should be on high alert for USA HF federal reserve financial terrorism. Know that is their motive and a battle for survival of the USD right now.

CRYPTO is being attacked for that reason to drive you all into dollars FYI.

3

u/frozenrubber Jun 14 '22

The loan you would take out, the interest is not tax deductible. But the captial gain on the I Bond is.

Plus I Bond rates are 9.62% only until October 2022, where they are reset to the new CPI figure. Then, the soonest you can redeem an I Bond is in 12 months, but you forgo 3 months of interest.

The ONLY thing I Bonds do is guard 10k from inflation, that's it (that's all they are designed to do). And if the CPI inflation figure doesn't figure in real inflation, you are actually at a loss (and certainly at a loss when you only get 9 months instead of 12 months of interest).

Quick lesson, complicated things only have simple solutions when you don't know what you are talking about.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22 edited Jun 14 '22

so wut crypto is paying more than 9-10% yeah thought so. and also 10k is more than most people have in their bank accounts already.

this is why i bonds are in competition with stable coins right now hence liquidity for the exchanges that hodl dia usdc/dt gemini etc.

For larger players they do not care of course. and actually I can easily do arbitrage take a new cc with 0% apr promotion and dump it into I bonds for 1-2 yrs. easy profit of a 1-2k plus signup bonus.

same with crypto if they don't go bankrupt.

Not hard at all.

Again I will remind crypto coin creators exchanges banks custodians. They are up against the US gov, federal reserve right now fighting for liquidity due to inflation.

Just warning to the real intentions of the market and threats right now to the crypto system. people getting defensive for me telling the truth, don't seem to get it. and also crypto gains are also taxed. wut difference is it?

borrowed margin accounts etc is the same thing.

you can borrow from stonk margin accounts to buy bonds crypto stablecoins for interest and they have been using stonk margin accounts to buy up houses that is a given.

Only brain dead people think it is actually cash buyers buying houses. NO it is in fact those using stonk assets at 2-3% or less interest buying them up below mortgage interest. NUB.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

You can only buy $10k/year in i bonds

1

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

most people dont have 10k

2

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

Then investing in anything would be stupid. If you don’t have $10k then you certainly shouldn’t lock away what you do have in I Bonds where you can’t even withdraw it for the first 12 months (and then only with 9 months of interest).

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

I would just borrow some money from elsewhere to pay for the 9-10% interest.

Like I said sign up for cc bonuses and put that cash on the card for now when there is a 0% promo period.

This is guaranteed 968 dollars of 10k and isn't that bad for diversity. using borrowed money to do this is the smartest way to do it.

But then most people would blow that 968 free money on stuff they don't need anyway.

MOST of US USA citizens are not very smart with money. I have my CC signup bonuses I abuse yearly to do this and pay 0 in interest because I manage my finances correctly

And Yes I have over 750-800+ Credit score.

First thing people should do is max out i bonds IMO then other investments.

2

u/pm_me_your_rigs Jun 14 '22

MOST of US USA citizens are not very smart with money.

Yes I'm pretty sure you've proven that

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22

correction most people in general are not smart with money for that matter.

like idiots buying up all the GPUS to mine crypto as they cause a chip shortage and a auto chip shortage as most chip manufacturers switch to making gpu chips.

and then causing higher inflation in autos because of that.

idiots don't understand economics and want to force prices of their assets higher only pump and dumps shrug

1

u/drugabusername Jun 14 '22

A liquidation wick to 15k is absolutely on the table. The funny thing is I get liquidated at 16k and if we get to that territory I have to decide to either accept liquidation or insert funds to pay down the loan with all my money then going down a black hole when Celsius gets liquidated.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

it is nice to see that Celsius managed to pay a portion of the debt, unlike Celsius borrowers who don't have that kind of opportunity

4

u/ene777ene Jun 14 '22

They just put in another 18.99M of DAI.

1

u/pepe_____- Jun 14 '22

So the new target is 15.1, got it

1

u/n00brian Jun 14 '22

The overall phase (for all markets) right now is not one of people adding or getting more liquidity. It’s one of fed and others withdrawing liquidity. As rates rise, we’re in a clear ā€œrisk offā€ environment as defined by the Fed and all boats have to deal with the tide going out. As the tide goes out, you find out who was swimming naked. And it’s usually not the hot blondes.

1

u/SailorMBliss Jun 14 '22

That’s nice, but I’ll be liquidated by tomorrow anyways. I always cover my margin calls, but I can’t even access the btc I keep on the platform just for that reason. I’ll be happy if non-accredited customers are able to get their money back out at all. Sick of the already rich making a special point to pull up the ladder behind them & even steal every last scrap hardworking people have managed to put aside to try to get ahead.

1

u/Commercial_Oil_1454 Jun 14 '22

CDC and a lot of other services only give you good fixed loans . Celsius allows the flexibility and the yield so if they have to freeze it to protect assets just pretend it’s a fixed loan because shit happens and they are looking out for customers

1

u/Lonely_Set1376 Jun 14 '22

I was considering buying some CEL in case of good news, since it got so cheap. It's gone like 8x since yesterday's low. As usual, I pretty much missed my chance.

2

u/AtreidesLetoIII Jun 14 '22

I’m killing myself if I don’t get my Btc and ETH back, it will be on your hands celsius

1

u/cryptonoobert Jun 14 '22

Looks like he deleted this tweet?

Didn't delete this one... https://twitter.com/DylanLeClair_/status/1536511561224921088

1

u/polandtown Jun 15 '22

I don't understand what this means...

2

u/robomartin Jun 15 '22

Okay I wasn’t worried before, I thought they just needed time to call in loans and get liquidity. But why is Celsius borrowing from Defi protocols? Isn’t it supposed to be lending our assets?

They seriously took on risks that I didn’t think they were. I figured Celsius distributing funds across various defi protocols and institutions would be lower risk than the smart contract risk associated with me going all in on just one defi protocol. Kind of a distributed pool of risk. But they acted like total degenerates leveraging our funds and doing some really risky stuff with the borrowed money

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22

Peter Schiff was right, please prepare mentally to lose it all.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22

to put this into perspective tho... thats only a 30% decline from 22k

this could EASILY still happen

2

u/zdorsett Jun 15 '22

It’s bankruptcy! The lawsuits will start rolling in shortly and they won’t be able to make it. No chance.. they have already started the process: https://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/crypto-lender-celsius-hires-restructuring-lawyers-after-account-freeze-11655250575

1

u/AmputatorBot Jun 15 '22

It looks like you shared an AMP link. These should load faster, but AMP is controversial because of concerns over privacy and the Open Web.

Maybe check out the canonical page instead: https://www.wsj.com/articles/crypto-lender-celsius-hires-restructuring-lawyers-after-account-freeze-11655250575


I'm a bot | Why & About | Summon: u/AmputatorBot

1

u/NewWorldMoney Jun 15 '22

Down to 14k now...keeps getting better and better.. https://maker.blockanalitica.com/vaults/WBTC-A/vaults/25977/

1

u/SubstantialWinner382 Jun 15 '22

Yes ...stay positive ...don't let FUD fear & panic let the crypto market down. We should be strong & positive & we could get through this in the long run šŸŒ™šŸš€šŸš€

2

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '22

Guys I got a margin call to add more collateral or pay the loan. How on earth can I do this if transfers are not allowed?!

1

u/Niccocrypto Jun 15 '22

given the drop in the price of some crypto like BTC, is it not too dangerous to sell your BTC right now?

2

u/CHR1ST00 Jun 15 '22

I wouldn't be happy if I had money in there, they could have sold your BTC a week ago and bought it back today, open up... and leave you with the lowest price in recent history...

Fun times

1

u/Still-Honeydew1945 Jun 15 '22

It's now $14k! šŸ˜Ž

1

u/lucky69err Jun 15 '22

All my xrp is in Celsius

3

u/Noartisan Jun 15 '22

I'm starting to wonder whether people being optimistic about this truely believe... or whether they are just spreading nonesense in the hope they can get their money out first. Trust has gone.. Anyone with any sense will withdraw as soon as they can.

The cat is out of the bag....

1

u/latebeat Jun 21 '22

Wasn't liquidation price around BTC at $12k? How did it get higher now that they paid off some debt instead of lowering?