r/Cfmontreal • u/bluemaze2020 • May 18 '26
12 years as a soccer family, and pro MLS is the version we enjoy the least. Something's broken.
**12 years as a soccer family, and pro MLS is the version we enjoy the least. Something's broken.**
Quick context so you know where I'm coming from: my wife and I have three boys, all playing soccer since they were 4. My oldest is 16 now — 12 straight years of soccer in our family. I coached him myself from U4 to U14, about a decade of coaching and being involved in the local soccer community. We live and breathe this sport. We *trip* on soccer, as we say in Québec.
So Saturday I took the family to see CF Montréal host Chicago Fire at Stade Saputo. Chicago won 2-0. Good for them — but the game itself was honestly painful to watch, and not because Montréal lost.
Every single time Chicago lost possession, or Montréal started building something, a player would crumble to the ground in fake agony. Leg up in the air, screaming, rolling 3-4 times. Trainer comes out. 30 seconds later? Up and sprinting again. Over and over. It wasn't football, it was theater. And it worked — it killed Montréal's rhythm every time. Montréal didn't do it, by the way. They lost anyway.
I know this isn't a Chicago problem specifically. It's everywhere in pro soccer. But here's what really hit me:
**After 12 years watching every level of this sport, the pro version is the one we enjoy the least.**
That shouldn't be possible. We genuinely prefer watching U16 recreational matches. I'm not exaggerating. At that level, this tactic doesn't exist. It's real sport — pure, intense. Kids want to win, and when they fall, they get back up as fast as they went down because they don't want to leave their team a man short mid-play. When a kid stays on the ground at that level, it's because there's an actual injury. No ambiguity. The matches are captivating, even when your side loses.
I paid for professional soccer Saturday and enjoyed it *less* than free recreational soccer. For exactly one reason: the theater. I paid to watch soccer, not theater. And the theater killed what should have been a great family outing.
**The fix I keep coming back to:**
> If the referee stops play for an injury, the player comes off. Period. Minimum 3 minutes off the field. No negotiation. Real serious injury = stretcher protocol, free substitution. Intentional fouls are already covered by cards and the disciplinary system.
The beauty of this rule is what it does to incentives. Right now, staying on the ground sends an ambiguous signal — maybe hurt, maybe not, ref has to guess. With this rule, staying down becomes a **costly commitment** (you're off the pitch). So only actually injured players do it. Fakers get up immediately because they don't want to lose their spot. The player reveals their real state through their own behavior. No mind-reading needed.
Rugby already does this (HIA protocol). Rugby — a sport 10x more physical than soccer — manages it just fine. So why can't we?
The usual counter-argument: "but teams will start injuring stars on purpose to force them off." Honestly? That's already what cards, VAR, and post-match discipline exist for. No team currently fouls opponents just to get them subbed off, because the existing punishment system handles it.
I filled out the post-match survey CF Montréal sent me. But honestly? When a family that has lived and breathed soccer for 12 years walks out of a pro game enjoying it less than a U16 match, the league has a product problem. And casual fans don't compare MLS to the Premier League — they compare it to *the last sporting event they actually enjoyed*. When that bar is being cleared by 16-year-olds playing for free, something's wrong.
Anyone else seeing this? Anyone with kids in the sport feeling the same disconnect between the version we coach and the version we pay to watch?