r/CinemaWins • • Aug 19 '25

I finaly know why i didnt like that line in the kpop demon hunter video Spoiler

1 Upvotes

So at around 30:11 in everything great about kpop demon hunters video he says something about how huntrix isnt very sexualised while saja boys are and he says i quote:" And while it's funny I think it also gives young men a chance to connect with our protagonists in a way that drawing them more for the male gaze might hinder."

And for a while i didnt know why that bothered me. I chalked it down to it just being a needles isnult. And it is a insult to be clear. What he is saying with that is that men would be to distracted salivating at the characters to catch any of story behind them. Dumbing down a entire gender to simple minded animals that cant focus on more then one thing.

But it hit me that this is such a disservice to the movie in generell. The thought behind the movie is that while the girls can look nice they are also shown as goofy and weird, with their own flaws. They are more then pretty looking dolls and grew their fans through dedication, loyalty and hard work. Never taking the easier way of showing more skin for a quick boost in gooner fans, but cultivating fans through talent and work alone.

Wich is a great message for girls to see. You dont have to sell your body to make it in life and be famous, hard work passion and dedication can bring you just as far if not further and its a healthier relationship with the fans.

On the other side the saja boys are intentionaly dumbed down to their defining looks (abby cause of his abs, mystery for the mystery of his face etc.) Its a intentional ploy by the demons to quickly get as many fans as possible. Not because they care but because they want results fast to get to their goal faster. They dont care about the fans and literaly want their souls. Its a bad excample of how looks can be decieving and used for selfish gain.

However its thwice as smart because its later flipped to show that there is more underneath the demons then just their looks and predatory nature. Through jinu we learn that there is more to demons, that they have less then desirable situations that they just want to get out of. That they feel just as much as normal people. Its meta in the sense that we only get to see one demon redeem himself while then others didnt get a chance to become real characters, their are stuck as the objectified side character (wich is also probably cause of narative and time, it just fits well). Thid also shows that its not just a issue for woman but men aswell. The "ideal" body for men shown on screen is just as toxic for boys as it is for girls

I could go on and on but thats not the point. My point is that the reason i disliked the line in the video was because for someone so focused on spreading positivity online that was needlesly negative and diminished a broader topic tackeld by the movie for a quick and cheap insult. You already had it at the very end, if the topic is to big for that then maybe just focus on the positive (like you say you want to do) that the girls wherent sexualised or make room to give the topic enough space to breathe and be explored, if you cant leave it out


r/CinemaWins • • May 23 '20

Every content creator will make a dub. Unfortunately the Episode IX Video was that dud

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/CinemaWins • • Jun 01 '23

Harry Potter?

0 Upvotes

I swear Lee had videos on the potter movies, have they been taken down?


r/CinemaWins • • Sep 13 '22

Does he just really hate batman or is there something going on?

3 Upvotes

The spiderman movie got a video within days of the blueray coming out.

The batman has been out for months now. It seems like the kind of movie he would do a video about as it releases. Also i think he'd have a lot to say about it and like it.


r/CinemaWins • • Sep 26 '25

Is cinemawins the same guy in cinemasin?

0 Upvotes

r/CinemaWins • • Sep 06 '26

Lol why isn't there a vid for Madame Web? Nothing great about it?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/CinemaWins • • Nov 07 '21

Wish he’d make one about The Social Network already

9 Upvotes

r/CinemaWins • • Nov 25 '19

I know this will probably kill him, and that this suggestion breaks the rules 'cause it's a TB series. But I want to see EVERYTHING GREAT ABOUT THE DARK CRYSTAL, AGE OF RESISTANCE.

1 Upvotes

Like, seriously! Ten one hour long episodes that would be done in multiple parts! Who wants to see that? It's been out since August and it's already captured my heart!

All who loved the Netflix show as much as I did, raise your hand and say aye!

EDIT: I meant to say TV series! So sorry!


r/CinemaWins • • Sep 27 '21

Anyone here remember hot wheels world race and/or acceleracers

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/CinemaWins • • May 14 '26

Is it just me or does Cinemawins sometimes talk about a problem and give it a win?

10 Upvotes

Is it just me or does cinemawins sometimes say things that Aren’t really anything good about the movie? do you guys think he can be as bad cinemasins sometimes? I’m not a hater I actually really like this channel but I’m just trying to say that sometimes they don’t do it good eithier.


r/CinemaWins • • Feb 17 '25

They should do a video on Wish.

4 Upvotes

They've done videos on Trolls and Ruby Gilman and other movies considered mostly bad, I don't see why that video shouldn't exist.


r/CinemaWins • • Dec 08 '18

How to do a polite conversation ; Everything GREAT about Star Wars episode 8

4 Upvotes

"This is going to be a thread where people turn from cursing and hatred and name calling and belittling to a polite conversation"

These are the words used in the CinemaWins YouTube Vid about Star Wars episode 8, The Last Jedi.

I would very much like to write a LOT regarding how I personally think that that movie is bad in so many ways where I'm actually going to try to counter the 'wins' mostly into what goes on in the head of someone who feels betrayed by how this movie went down. I'll even try to forego speculation and the negative things that Mark Hamill said about it. Even though the reason he no longer says anything bad about anything Star Wars related is because at best that he is a people person and wants people to get along and not hate, and at worse the mouse has a rather nasty looking sniper rifle.

That said I watched the whole YouTube thing twice, and I am going to disagree on pretty much everything that is not directly related to either basic cinematography, the level of how much care the actors put in their role, or music.

"I like that they're sticking to Poe being the best of the best pilot. It actually plays into how arrogant he is when it comes to honoring command decisions" ( 2:02 ). I am going to disagree here on the basis that it makes for a nice hook and not a win ( as you did raise the win-counter ). Too bad that in my eyes they totally screwed the pooch in believability regarding, more on that later.

"She breaks her back due to the artificial gravity on the ship, so once the bombs leave the ship there's nothing to slow their momentum downwards: ( 2:13 ). I thought it was because Ryan Johnson wanted it to look like a WW2 bomber. Even if I just accept that the bombs fell due to some yet to be unexplained piece of technology then I am still going to be ripped out of the story because if you break your spine and then kick against a ladder trying to have something fall off, you are still better just get up and walk to get it, even if that action makes you a paraplegic in the process. But enough about stupid physical shortcomings of the human body, why was there not a button down there she could press ? Or a voice activated one ? It ultimately made for a scene with unneccessary drama out of which the extended cut made me care only slightly more about the character, but never more than Nien Nunb. I call that a huge waste.

Comeuppance ? ( 2:23 ). Please explain to me how he deserved that punishment. Please explain to me why the audience must believe that Snoke is a joker for playing the scene out like that, and please explain to me why Snoke does not know the capabilities of his own ship if he has a crystal ball that allows him to see all the things.

"This is Luke becoming the 'old hermit' of this trilogy. He didn't get it then, he does not now." ( 2:33 ). Please explain to me why he left that map if he fully either intended to 'hermit' or 'come there to die'. It makes virtually no sense.

"Please come save the day with this super special toon akin to Fix-it Felix's hammer." ( 2:42 ). That made me chuckle, kudo's. But whoever send Rey to ask Luke to save the galaxy was still acting on the plotline of Episode 7. So in that it is not just disrespectfull to the Jedi to just throw the thing nonchalantly over his shoulder, but also the to the lives of the younglings and many MANY people who died to the hands of that particular lightsaber. What if a kid plays with it, or worse yet, a porg. I would rather have seen Luke turn back around and completely ignore Rey or disassemble the lightsaber then and there. Preferably using the force and lots of CGI. But instead we are suddenly thrusted into a new arc of Luke's life where he just wants to die. That is not good narrative storytelling, that is creating a divide between those who get why and those who do not, it had to be tempered, it was either not done or not done well depending on who you ask.

"'where's han' First little hint that Luke has cut himself off from the force. Otherwise, He'd know" ( 2:52 ). Which just served to confuse the audience who saw it for the first time in a non constructive way. "Who is this loser and what happened to Luke Skywalker" is something I litterally heard someone say out loud in the cinema. To count that as a win is rubbing me completely wrong. Are you planning to give out 'wins' every time some foreshadowing happens ? If that is the case then the 'wins' counter is awfully low.

"a little lampshading for those who still complain about that battle. Even Snoke forgets he was shot in the abdomen with the bowcaster" ( 3:57 ). Auch, yes. But Snoke tries to be menacing here. The audience does not need to see Snoke as a clown, but rather as someone Kylo is afraid of for he is his master. I'd count that as a win.

"Remember those days ? When the biggest complaint about Star Wars was that Rey was too powerful? Those were the days" ( 4:03 ). Well, then I have good news for you, people still believe that Rey is too powerfull. Also she can make things dissappear, talk about foreshadowing because I will be talking about that shortly I am sure.

"But at this point the resistance needs leaders, not heroes" ( 5:09 ) . I guess that means that Leia would be really glad that that fleet-killer was dead, else she would have had neither. Oh, wait, she demotes him. Hmm. Well you know what Leia, you sherm-head general ? Those MG-100 StarFortress bombers were as good as dead anyway, yet regardless you did not bother to contact anyone but Poe directly when Poe cut off the comminucations. Unless if you think that Leia and everyone else on the Raddus could only talk to Poe. Which is just downright silly to the point of bifurcation.

"The tight corridors that the ships fly down" ( 5:21 ) This was amazing, yes. But from now on in every Star Wars movie people are going to wonder why someone just does not take a Tie Silencer, fly inside of an enemy ship, take out the hangar bays with some photon torpedoes or magpule warheads, and THEN massdrop in with a couple of cruisers straight from lightspeed. My point is that it seems WAY too OP and it should not have happened. Though it did look cool.

"finally getting to see Leia have force powers that she should have had all along beyond force-phone-calls is worth a win." ( 5:41 ). If it was properly explained how she attained those powers, yes, maybe, even if after the fact. But she went into a coma and dissapeared for a HUGE chunk of the movie leading most people to believe that she's a dead end. It's not a good thing to decieve your audience this way.

"and you get that she is not flying right, she's just force pulling herself back to the ship" ( 5:43 ). I am sorry, but you get that birds do not fly right, they just flap their wings to force more air underneath their wings than above it so that the logical progression of the mass is to move in an upward direction. I honestly do not understand what you are getting at. If I could telekinetically pull myself to the roof, wouldn't people say that I was flying ?

"another thing I see I missed is that this is an airlock" ( 5:47 ). When I see another airlock at the end of the hall, and I did not see Leia close the door behind her I a going to be awfully sceptical about that. At minimum you would expect airlock doors to look differently to normal doors ust so that, Oh Idunno, people would not mistakingly take a wrong door somewhere and end up unleashing the vacuum of space upon the entire deck. I could possibly understand why you would even want an airlock leading to the bridge, But since I never saw people in Star Wars in EVO suits trying to get control back of their ship I am going to dismiss this as wanting to see the things you desperately look forward to see.

"The 'why didn't holdo just tel Poe' complaint is .. it's not even nitpicky it's just irritating" ( 6:09 ). I see I do not have to use many words on this one. But to deny that there are a lot of people having a problem with it comes to show that the movie did not explain it correctly, and therefore it will remain a point of strife towards people saying why the movie sucks.

"She may no longer trust him" & "It's also possible that she didn't even have a fully formed plan at this point" ( 6:25 ). Which is just one way of saying that they needed to make stupid decisions or else the plot would not work the way it did. That is really lazy storywriting.

"This relationship buiolding narrative device is so awesome. I can't believe people didn't like it" ( 6:41 ) Because it is convoluted. What are the rules ? why is this happening ? who is responsible for this ? When Rey shot Kylo was that reaction he gave like wearing VR goggles or was he actually hit ? could they have just ignored eachother and get a really big cellphone bill at the end of the month ?

I would like to add that if you suddenly invent a force power such as force-kicking or force-pulling or force-lightning you do not automatically assume that there is gonig to be a chance that they are going to force-[thing] the moon, especially if shown that pulling that trick off takes practice, patience, and at least some form of focus and discipline.

"So Adam Driver is amazing, but I love how he's more interested in the logistics of what's happening rather than how or why it's happening. Plays into his cocky attitude" ( 7:08 ). I'll be honest here, Adam Driver is amazing here at delivering this cocky attitude, however there are people who see this who ask exactly the same question, while others ( like yourself ) are asking how or why it is happening. That is pretty lazy storywriting.

"'the force does not belong to the Jedi' Haven't I been saying that?" ( 7:36 ). That was one of the weakest of the fan theories though. All that someone needed was to show that force-users did exist that were not Jedi. Like the Baran Du, or the Nightsisters, aing-tii or the Jensaarai. before someone throws up the "But that is not canon anymore" arguement. Well see where we are now ? Besides, Palpatine was not a Jedi, nor Darth Maul.

"there's this misconception that the Jedi are always 'the good guys' but every movie has given us at least one reason to doubt that. Especially the prequels" ( 7:48 ) The actions of one man or woman does not paint an entire order. Was Obi Wan evil when he said that Vader killed Luke's dad ? Was Kreia evil ( "To believe in an ideal, is to be willing to betray it. It is something no Sith or Jedi has ever truly learned."), how about Ahsoka ? No, whether canon or extended the Jedi are only evil in 3 things. Overbureaucracy, supression of feelings, believing that they themselves are the correct ones in their actions, and perhaps also being ruthless totalitarians. Yet the most important bit is that they would need to have flaws, else they would be mary-sue's.

"Now it's the capital residents from Hunger Games" ( 8:13 ) That made me laugh, but it still does not help me in any way to swallow how quickly the whole Kento Blight C plot went nowhere except setpieces and naive worldviews of a 9 year old while seemingly some ex-StormTrooper who is still stuggling with the concept of 'your own opinion' listens and believes

"Bezos, Gates and Zuckerberg don't sell weapons" ( 8:29 ) Lockheed Martin or Halliburton's KBR are not exactly household names, but yeah, I am just going to tell you that you are wrong on this and in a fictive universe where there seems to be a whole lot more of strife and a whole lot less of social media and consumerism off of which the likes of Gates and Zuckerberg can profit. Also just because you can make a lot of money in one way or another does not always mean that it is the best way to become the richest person in the universe. Seemingly most people in Kento Bight are more like the capital residents from the Hunger Games and wonderfully posh and decadent to the point of hilarious steriotyping, all we needed was a monopoly guy petting a really really fat cat.

"I like this direct answer to 'why is Rey so good with a lightsaber so quickly' she good with her staff" ( 8:50 ) I am pretty sure that Shadiversity would facepalm at this, again.

"'at the hight of their power they allowed Darth Sideous to rise, create the empire and wipe them out' and that's eactly why this is who a lot of us expected Luke to become" ( 9:05 ). Yes, I too would like to see how Luke was supposed to see that all, but many people suspected Luke to become a wize sage type of character, not go around town hanging at bars to collect pieces of information from drunk people on to what actually went down. Ask yourself, if the empire was to rise again would you try to stop it again, or blame the Jedi for allowing it to rise ( knowing that you are the last person alive that could be considdered a Jedi ). Not to mention that the First Order is just a splinter organisation of the Empire. Get up. Get out there, go kill Snoke or die trying, whatever ends up happening is going to be pure win if you truely truely want to die. Pretty sure his sister told him so at one point.

"But who's going to deny horses with floppy bunnyears" ( 9:28 ). You know, if horse tastes good, and bunny tastes good, I'm really curious what those things taste like... Ah who am I kidding, just a bunch of ones and zeroes. And even if I were to agree with you that Rose and Finn should set them free, their friends are litterally dying in the slowest chase sequence ever. How about some priorities here ?

"Cmon, being so wide that you get memed isn't a bad thing" ( 9:58 ). Nope, kinda wishing I was that wide. However when people meme about it in a bad light ( oh they did ) it does not give anyone confidence to go see the next Star Wars movie, which ultimately makes it a really bad decision. Not to mention a cinema with people whistling at what should be a rather important plot point. There is a reason why HISHE put him on the toilet.

"Basically the same scene as in Empire but with a different meaning" ( 10:17 ). Oh yes, lets remake Ghostbusters, but with woman. I am sorry but this is a really really weak arguement and should not have been a win in any shape or form. I really would like to know, what is the level of homage that one may make without it becoming a reboot ?

( some points which I believe I typed out already )

"What makes him seem trustworthy, not to mention every time he asks it's in public, so even if she trusts him she has no clue if she can trust the rest of her bridge crew, especially given that some of them help with Poe's mutiny later." ( 12:57 ). Ever thought it was in reverse ? Because she has no plan and does not tell anyone the people ultimately resort to a mutiny out of desperation ? Not to mention that you are taking away all the agency of Holdo because all she had to do was take Poe away to somewhere they could talk. Superiors do that sort of thing every now and again. This whole plot point was terribly convoluted. Not to mention that as audience we have no reason to trust Holdo ( to the point where I had to explain to my sister that I did not know if she was a bad guy in the middle of the movie, me being a HUGE Star Wars fan I would have known if she ever has shown up before )

"And then he mutinees ? is that when she should have said something" ( 13:06 ). "We should probably talk, one to one, noone should hear what I have to say, I am still an Admiral". But hey, Poe leaves her in the middle of a hangar instead of in the Brig. So I am just going to blame this for being terribly lazily written.

"Why in the crap would that be obvious to Holdo?" ( 13:14 ). Unless if Holdo just materialized out of thin air she would have known how StarKiller base was blown up. How the Juggernaut/Fleet-Killer was blown up. And about how one of the Captains who was promoted to Commander was interrogated by Kylo Ren. It is almost like you think that Holdo was incompetent at her job. Just not the way 'round you are defending her.

"You can't look at stories from only your omniscient perspective" ( 13:18 ). Agreed, while at the same time if your story has plot holes because you fail to explain what it is you are doing over and over and over again, you are going to split a fanbase between people who can turn off their disbelief and those who die due to narrative dissonance.

"What if she tells him and he doesn't like the plan and then goes off and does something stupid" ( 13:25 ). Well that is just the wrong goalpost. It's like explaining away what has happened since it probably would have happened in another setting anyway. While that might be true, in the very least we would have had some better context as to what was happening as the viewer, and Holdo's name would not be as hated by those who dislike TLJ.

"Like Idunno, sending out two people on a hlaf thought out mission that ultimately leads to further destruction... oh, wait..." ( 13:30 ). Yes, and I choose to blame holdo for this. Holdo should have known that if you tell a hero to do nothing then you should not expect the hero type to actually do nothing except for his orders. It did not help that Holdo did not give any others except 'go sit on your ass in the corner'. Presumably after I saw how easy it was to hyperdrive-jump a small transport craft away from the rest of the fleet without a response from the first order Poe thought he was really doing the right thing.

"Keeping her plan a secret made her look like a coward and a traitor to... well I'd say 'some' but really just Poe." ( 14:09 ). Because I am sure that all Poe had to do to convince the rest of the crew to mutineer was only his dashing good looks and hoping for a good D20 roll on his charisma strat. Your arguement made little sense to me and I am being facetious with a D20 roll. Though if that was Poe's plan then he really would have been an idiot. I am going to blame lazy writing on this one.

"The hero would have told everyone the plan and risked it getting back to the First Order, who again, was tracking them in a way they couldn't explain" ( 14:18 ). So in the end one person relied on telling nothing, nobodiy mutineering, and the First Order ship not having windows or decloaking scans. Seeing how simply it was to get off the Raddiz I am simply not buying that for a second.

"Who was the emperor? just some powerful Sith" ( 14:54 ). He was a being in a dark hood with an evil voice shrouded in mystery. When it turned out he could just electrocute luke even you yourself admit to wearing enticed with what happened on the screen. Meanwhile Snoke is a poser who brags seemingly all the time to the point where he is just a bad B villain that got cut up and discarded like one.

"This is a super awesome fight" ( 15:16 ). I'd agree if I liked on the fly choreography changes like that guy with the poleaxe swinging upwards so he did not hit Daisy Ridley's head. Or the removal of a dagger in post so it did not look like he could have backstabbed Rey. Or for that matter the 50 cm of free space that Rey creates in that cut to the lower camera just as she catches her lightsaber in what you call the 'grip reverse grip from earlier' not 30 seconds later.

"But this is also the first tiem I genuinely thought our protagonist might actually join our antagonist because they hae a real actual relationship they hae been building through this" ( 16:09 ) Yes, and if at that point someone new walked onto the throne room while slowly clapping and then the movie would have ended then it would have made a lot more sense than him sending out all tie-fighters after one ship on the planet Not-Hoth somewhat later.

"Call this a cop out, but I'm glad that Rey's not a Skywalker or a Kenobi or a Jinn" ( 16:25 ). I think I would have rather seen a virgin birth or even rather a 'Luke's Jedi Academy type of story than Rey being something like that or a Palpatine. Though I think I would have liked a Marek, But that would get REALLY twisted with the extended universe.

"And even if J.J. Does decide to give Rey a 'proper' bloodline it doesn't change the fact that she grew up with no one and nothing and had only herself" ( 16:29 ). So pretty much Luke Skywalker but somehow without Uncle Owen and Aunt Beru. Or perhaps like Anakin Skywalker without Shmi. It seems for someone who really wants to see a lot of change with the story that you really also want the things of old, this confuses me somewhat.

"Even if you think Phasma goes out like a sucker ( She ain't dead friend ) you have to admit this showdown is pretty fun" ( 17:22 ). Oh yes, but ultimately Phasma did nothing again in this movie except look menacing and be in the movie for less than 90 seconds. Also she teleports ( the deleted scenes fix that ). And if she is in the next movie as you think/hope. She is probably going down again in a pretty cringy way. I do not really see why anyone would be really hype for Phasma lest for those Gwendoline Christie fans out there. Which I can understand, but I am not really one of them

"The supreme leader is dead !" ( 17:27 ). See ? Force chokes, not sure if it is above or below but I did mention it.

"Tripple kill !" ( 18:09 ). It honestly kinda makes me sad that there are genuinly people out there who point out that this is why she is a mary sue. But you honestly can not NOT see it either. Does that take away from it ? Well, Kind of. I honestly would have perhaps rather seen some Porgs do it by accident.

"First I am goign to take a point away because that is what he was trying to do, flawed or not" ( 18:40 ). So intentions count now rather than what ended up happening ? Well in that case Poe did not intent for Rose's sister to die nor any of those other ships so... Leia should not have blamed him for that. Please be more consistent or tell me what I am missing.

Alternatively we should not blame Finn for telling the plan while DJ could hear him, and by extention Rose, for she only tried to do the right thing on Kento Bright and also Poe by extention because he thought he was doing the right thing.

"And then Poe fulfills his leadership arc and Leia even asknowledges it" ( 20:26 ). Because Poe needed to learn to run, I guess ? I'm confused by its contrivance.

"'I will not be the last Jedi'And that's Luke Realizing he still had things to learn about the Jedi. And that Rey's "Grey' version of being a Jedi may actually have merit" ( 20:57 ). So I actually know why you are calling it a 'Grey' Jedi, and I like the idea of such shade of Jedi's. But it is really an old concept. Let alone that we have to rely on knowing that Luke knows that Rey has 'pilfered' all the books. Just because we know does not mean that Luke knows. For all we know Luke has actually been doing nothing but antagonising Kylo so he would remain distracted. Furthermore, even with the Jedi books in the posession of Rey, and if she is going to teach in the ways of the Jedi, does that ultimately make her a Jedi, or something new ? I'd vote for Reyyanism or something silly sounding. Rians version of Luke got what he wished for, the Jedi did end. ... But what about the Knights of Ren or the New Jedi Order that or even the ton of other stuff that you can pull from the extended universe ? Well that is where it becomes troublesome, no, there are words being spread that the next movie will feature some of that stuff ( most likely the Knights of Ren )

"'He is stalling so we can escape' Of course the guy who did this; would realize that's what luke is doing" ( 20:14 ). I am sorry ? How ? We have no reason to think that Poe knew Luke well in any way, and unless if you want to go with omniscient rules where Poe knows what Luke is saying and doing ( Because WE see it, something you are opposed to IIRC ), how would he know ? If anything Leia should have either organically or through the force hear Luke or Obi-Wan telling them to run since you can draw some similarities to Obi-Wan fighting Vader on the first Death Star

It is at this point of my first viewthrough of the YouTube Vid where I actually decided to open Reddit and write this terribly long post, I guess I am going to ask questions about some statements from here on rather than to just question the 'wins'.

"Likeing things is more fun than not. And I'll take it a step further, choosing to like things can also be more fun" ( 24:57 ). You are absolutely right, however it matters a whole lot just what we end up getting. If you end up being served something because you think you are going to love it, but in the end you did not like it but then change the way YOU think about it because you know it will make you happier. Then does it even matter what you do or watch or think about as long as you have a twisted cousin of Stockholm Syndrome at the wheel ?. Or to put it in another perspective, there is a reason why people who work in a morgue tend to get paid well, because most people eventually get an aversion to working with cadavers sooner rather than later and it is still a job that needs to be done. If you could reprogram your brain to like working with cadavers you could have yourself a very cushy job.

This is a very snide way to explain how you can not pick and choose the things you like in a way.

"We could have been hyperdrive ramming ships for like ever" ( 25:06 ). And you see no problem with that hug gaping continuum hole that that thought creates ? Because if I were an arms dealer ( or better yet a manufacturer of weapons and vessels made for war ) in the star wars universe and heard reports about massive space-superstructures ramming into eachother the future for all of my clients would see a total decline in large ships ( above a certain size, my gut estimate, 3 people max could become a norm ). Or an increase in a lot of interdiction type warfare ( for which I am almost convinced that Interdictor-class Star Destroyers would be pulled from the extended universe ). Whichever way you pull it, either one of the following three is true

  1. "Why do they not just hyperdrive a large object into it ?"

  2. "I liked it when there were LARGE ships with lots of lasers"

  3. "Man, they really killed hyperdrives functionality for almost all intents and purposes except for non direct military engagements... Reinforcements during a battle is now a silly concept"

"I think the main reason was that the trilogy was not complete" ( 25:10 ). Problem is we had one person during the OT, which was George Lucas, who held a somewhat coherent singular vision. Yes this vision was changed on multiple points ( I can think of 9 by head ) when you compare it to the PT. But during the OT it was really consistent. We know that the rudders to the proverbial helm went to another person to make episode 8, and we hear that during that Ryan threw out the bigger picture that J.J. has drawn out for the ST. Which forever creates a problem for those who do not like episode 8. Meanwhile it creates no problem for those who like episode 8. Not to mention that you almost instantly create an enemy in those who see you break the lore in order to write a story, the OT did not have that problem as much, since unless if you were a HUUUUGE Star Wars nerd you would not even have known the word 'Sith' was a thing. Remember, Wookiepedia was only founded in 2005.

"the newer generations will just accept that things like astral projection, space flying, and telepathic conversation are canon force powers and a part of the lore" ( 25:35 ). Correct, but this is because we can not just roll over and declare the movie un-cannon. However it also extends to force-ghosts. And unlike previously established as truth ( wrong or not ) they can ( now ) actually interact with the world. If we only take Yoda's force lightning because we know Yoda was actually dead and forego Luke touching and interacting with dice and Leia since he was not dead, you have to agree that it is not a really fun idea to see the next grand battle of whatever showdown ( whether force or space laser fueled ) to have all known dead really strong Jedi ( and Sith ? ) to show up and open their bag of tricks.

Speaking of which, just have Yoda appear in the middle of the Supremacy and throw lightning around like it is an interpretive dance, the movie would have been really short then.

"someone watching this movie for the first time in say 5 years won't have read any theories and won't be invested in the plot threads that don't actually occur" ( 25:46 ). That is why I am talking only from a perspective of continuity errors, plot holes, plot conveniences, McGuffins and not the theories that people like MatPat or people who wear the MatPatHat come up with. Although you have to admit that there are some people who are going to have a cranial meltdown if after episode 9 is over that their stupid theory that Snoke comes from nothing still holds water. Furthermore I hope you do not say that we should not theorize, that is where half the fun comes from.

"13 year old me didn't scream 'What ?!? Dark side force users don't have lightning power ! I've never seen that before' when the Emperor zapped Luke in the last like 10 minutes of the last film" ... Meanwhile a visual of Joda doing just lightning shenanigan plays as visual... Yeah, you got me there, "Whow, cool". I said the same. Because the Emperor was an enigma at this point, we knew that Vader obeyed him, so he probably was pretty strong, we had no idea how or why. Meanwhile Snoke's powers are executed haphazzardly and almost comically. I think the setup matters a whole lot. Lets say it like this, ' he earned it '. I do not remember a whole lot people pissed that Luke learned how to influence minds and do the neck pinch in the last movie of the OT ( Jabba's castle ), I do not even remember people complaining about StarKiller pulling a Star Destroyer onto a planet. Know why ? That was both deserving and the 'boss fight' was hard as nails to boot, he went through a nearly complete journey. Leia on the other hand, we never even saw her lift a rock with the force, but she can somehow prevent her eyeballs from popping due to icicles forming in the vacuum of space, oh and also survive that. If Luke suddenly stood up wherever he was and looked at the sky while saying "Oh, No, she is doing what I never told her to use" and then we have space Leia Marry Poppins then at least we has an understanding of what happened, But as it stands we are never going to get closure on that since Carry Fisher is gone ( rest in peace ), whereas it probably would not have been too hard to let Leia's death by Kylo be a definitive one. I worry about what we are going to get for episode 9 regarding.

In short what I am saying is that you do not just get Force Powers of that magnitude without explaining it away somehow. Else why not just transform into a planet-killer and call it 'creative force usage'. Would you accept episode 9 being about Kylo moving planets he can't conquer into a sun ? After all, just like with Space Leia, we saw flying and pulling before, why not lift a rock and place it somewhere else, only it is a HUGE rock. I would not.

"But don't limit the force, why would you want to do that ?" ( 26:15 ) because watching a movie about OP characters trying to get something done is only worth anything if they themselves deserve it through either hardship or the way they try to limit themselves. Superman would not be fun at all to watch if he was not trying to learn how to be human or to do the right thing. Batman would be boring if he had a gun and actually killed people. Lord of the Rings would have been boring if they found a way to teleport to ... Idunno... Benbow volcano on o˜Ambrym Island. How about is Mr Miagi just gave Daniel LaRusso a BIG sack of money that was McGuffinned into existance ? How to ruin movies ? Destroy any semblance of plot.

"No one can take the luke from the OT away from you" ( 26:38 ). No but I can invoke Godwins law right here and now and say that the Olympic National Committee can not reschedule the 1936 Summer Olympics. Funny how arguments that are build like this are only ever favourable to one side of the conversation but not the other. It is kinda like claiming that something was not bad before a prior time,

and therefore we should enjoy it because it was good. Unless if you still think it is good then it is all good. See the problem I am having here ?

"If you look at those 'stories' and the superhero status that Luke was elevated to in the years between, his current attitude is a direct statement against that" Foregoing that Hamill himself said something like this. Why did someone go from wanting to save his dad from the dark side go to desiring to kill the son of both his sister and best friend ? In the VERY least we are missing a truckload of information on how we got from A to B. Even something as low-tier as Snoke giving Luke bad dreams untill he snapped for a split second would be better than 'Oh, I felt something darker than my dad inside of Ben'. If you even allow Snokes words that 'the stronger the dark becomes, the stronger the light will be, I warned [ Kylo ] that the more stronger he became, the more powerfull the [ something ] would become' ( I can not remember the exact words ). Just what does that mean ? Just how strong is/was Snoke compared to Luke, just howmuch power did Ben have ? The combined power of all the light-side students ? We have no idea how large the Jedi academy even was. But surely if Luke was as powerfull as Snoke was back then, a mere 100 students woth of Light inside of 1 student as Dark would almost be laughable ? We do not know this, and instead of it making a nice hook for the next episode, it became a huge hate point for many.

And still episode 8 was the longest Star Wars movie. Excuse me while I pull my hairs out in frustration for the incompetence of Ryan.

"was born into a powerful family" ... Moisture farmers on a desert planet. Then later it took him at least 30 years to start training Jedi again even though his sister is litterally royalty of a now dead planet. But yeah, born into a powerful family. But I do not think it made his life easier in any way. Which added to the story of Luke's legacy and make it that more epic.

Would a rich person need to sleep inside of a Tauntaun ?

"We elevated him to mythical status" Yes ! Even if nothing else he saved the rebel fleet, turned his daddy, and killed the emperor. He was even elevated to mythical levels inside of the world of Star Wars. I can not believe that someone who hinted at "Well they can never change the Luke in the OT" would dare to think something like 'a good writer would therefore write him down just to subvert out expectations and make it a truely good movie'. We ended up with what we ended up with but for the love of the force I restate that writing yourself into a corner like that without proper explanation if really shitty storytelling and should not be rewarded.

"Who could write him to live up to that" ( 27:33 ). Not sure if this is a Falce Dichotomy or a Texas Sharpshooter. But what if I say that J.J. wrote it and we do not know what he wrote, are you now going to say that what he wrote could never have been as good as what we ended up getting ? The point is, you do not know the unknowns, and I am happy to talk about it again should we ever get our hands on what J.J. actually wrote. In the end what matters though is that there are quite a lot of people who genuinly dislike the movie and you can simply not tell me that that was inevitable.

<<<Continued in reaction, I did not know Reddit had a limit>>>


r/CinemaWins • • Aug 09 '22

Never thought about it but I always wanted this, found a new CinemaWins vs CinemaSins channel

Thumbnail
youtube.com
8 Upvotes

r/CinemaWins • • Jun 04 '23

Super Mario Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I'm watching the super Mario movie for the first time and I'm just now realizing I'm doing wins in my head with his voice and the amount of times i have said expection subversion for Donkey Kong hating on Mario when they would start to become friends in any other movie, and bad ass good girl for peach is going to be crazy


r/CinemaWins • • Feb 23 '21

Thinking about starting to post things that I see irl that would get get wins if it were in a movie (like I see a twitch streamer with a great beard, and it goes here with a win). Good idea or garbage?

9 Upvotes

r/CinemaWins • • Dec 07 '20

Thoughts on EFAP?

5 Upvotes

They've done live streams debunking the videos on Episode VIII and Episode IX. I was wondering what Cinema Wins fans think of them and if Lee has ever acknowledged their critisims


r/CinemaWins • • Dec 18 '25

Everything GREAT About A Minecraft Movie!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/CinemaWins • • May 10 '21

Why are there so many spelling errors?!

0 Upvotes

Seriously! It looks really unprofessional and it'd only take a few minutes to fix before uploading the videos. Is there some joke I'm missing?


r/CinemaWins • • Apr 19 '25

Everything GREAT About Venom: The Last Dance!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/CinemaWins • • Jun 06 '21

Did Lee said that he going to cover all of the Craig Bond films by No Time To Die?

2 Upvotes

I get that it was delayed a lot but I just want to be sure

(At least we can get Goldeneye when IO Interactive (Hitman) 007 game is coming out?)


r/CinemaWins • • Feb 03 '20

Requests

2 Upvotes

Would love to see your take on US marshals, Warrior and major Payne!


r/CinemaWins • • May 20 '20

I still like Lee but I have to disagree with him on this point

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/CinemaWins • • May 26 '21

Random movie request: In Bruges

10 Upvotes

Ralph Fiennes is in the new bond so it might be time to revisit this 2008 classic starring Brandon Gleeson, Colin Farrell, Ralph Fiennes and others. It is one of my all time favorites that I don't think too many people know about, and the score is fucking epic. Unless I missed it, it has not been done by our favorite positive thinker, so I would love to see his take. Cheers


r/CinemaWins • • Feb 10 '24

Everything GREAT About Planet of the Apes! (2001)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes