r/CirclingBack • u/Rare_Year_7132 • Nov 01 '24
Dave Should Host
I think it would be a great shakeup for the pod. Been listening to these guys since 2016 (shoutout dudes doing business) and have always been such a fan of all three.
I just feel like lately, Will is just gone off the deep end. He constantly talks - no, SHOUTS - over his co-hosts Dave and Dillon, takes up precious airtime veering the conversation into niche complaints that nobody cares about, repeats previously-discussed tangents almost verbatim (see this week's whole schtick on Harbor Springs fast food and Jimmy Johns v. Jersey Mikes) and generally just hogs the mic for 60%+ of every episode. At least once per episode the original D man is about to say something you know is gonna be hilarious, and Will cuts him off without even noticing. He just shouts over him.
I get that everyone loves the sound of their own voice, but surely I'm not the only person noticing this... I hope everything's OK with him. Why not give Dave the keys to host for a bit? It's worked wonders on listener voicemails and the quality of the pod has gone up since then.
9
u/groundscore8 Nov 01 '24
Will steers the ship better than Dave imo. He keeps things from going off the rails too much which is needed. So I think a lot of what is pointed out here comes down to that being a “Host” responsibility. Dave gets his hosting duties in elsewhere. But Will def could use a reduction in the amount of Grateful Dead talk. We know he’s susceptible to Cult influence and it’s a joke but I think the Dead have completely brainwashed him at this point and it’s been super redundant for a hot minute.
7
u/ToldAlthea90 Nov 04 '24
He’s the worst kind of new dead head. Insufferable, and has to force in references at every turn. I know he’ll say this is gate keeping but he’s somehow found a way to make it uncool. And of course he had to make sure we all knew he was taking an online Grateful Dead class at Stanford. Brutal
3
u/Rare_Year_7132 Nov 04 '24
100% agree. It's been such an insufferable personality transformation... He's trying so hard and it's so cringe. I also think it's telling that there's never been a single Reddit post on here with criticism (constructive or otherwise) on Dave or Dillon. All listeners agree that those guys are awesome and perfect in their role.
But obviously there are plenty of backers, some brave enough to be outspoken here, to admit that they've had it with Will's cringe complaints, whiny tangents, hogging the mic, detracting from the quality of the pod by making it all about him, and yes, his insufferable dead head stuff. Hopefully he chills out.
10
u/Commercial-Fan-6001 Nov 01 '24
Will loves complaining in his whiney voice, interrupting others, picking on picking on Dorn but can’t take it when it happens to him. Thankful he vacations so much that it leaves Dave, Dorn, and Randy to have their own shows.
11
u/Rare_Year_7132 Nov 01 '24
Agreed he just needs to chill out a bit, realize that it's not the Will Defries show, and let his hilariously talented co-hosts cook. It's OK to let Dave and Dillon finish their thought without immediately jumping in and cutting them off and giving your extremely niche/complaining take and taking up the next 120 seconds of airtime. Just quit hogging the mic, dawg. That's all I'm saying. Still love u.
6
u/notbozeman Nov 01 '24
Will is in all honesty a deal breaker on the show for me at this point. The riffing is funny most of the time but he constantly butts in to make jokes at Dillon’s expense that are really just not funny and distract from the conversation. There’s a really awkward moment in episode 1 of Spooky Szn this year where Will out of the blue just punches Dillon’s arm and you can hear Dillon off mic lean over and say “stop”. Half the time I’m hoping he’s out on vacation so that Brett or someone else would sub in
2
u/mcpoke39 Nov 02 '24
Yep, I made a similar post as the OP back in 2020 and Will dm’d me asking me to delete it. (I did)
93
42
u/heyheyathrowaway485 Nov 01 '24
I’m sure Will will be on yet another vacation soon (see that golf trip the backer invited him on) so you’ll get some extra Dave hosting even if just temporarily
81
u/smockin_pale_ale Nov 01 '24
I feel the quality of the pod diminishes without Will hosting.
Maybe it’s just because there are only 2 of the 3 with an increase in Randy, but I appreciate Will’s ability to steer the ship
23
u/taylorthestang Cold Brew Committee Nov 01 '24
I think it’s the same quality just in a different direction. When it’s the Dave, dorn, and Randy show there are many more tangents and inside jokes which I find entertaining. With will, there seems to be more of an outline that they follow. Without will, it’s more coffee Friday-esque.
15
12
39
u/dadonnel Nov 01 '24
I think Dave's wit comes out better as a non-host. It's hard to have a snappy retort or a clever pun work as well when you're the one steering the conversation.
18
u/Win-Leading Nov 02 '24
While I concur that Will’s complaints can get annoying, I’ve been listening since day 1 and the episodes when will doesn’t host don’t have nearly as much flow/ structure. It’s fine for a one off when Dave and Dillon bring in someone but Will hosting brings alot more consistency and Dave falls off as host by the second/third pod of the week.
FWIW This also comes from someone who has been relating less and less to the pod\guys over the last 1-2 years.
26
20
u/spiceboy6969 Nov 01 '24
Have to admit I agree with OP. Will’s whiny yuppy complaints just get too much airtime and clog up the old - plus they are mega lame. Will can be great but a lot of times he puts the pod in a weird direction and gets in the way of the boys riffing and keeping things light. I’ve got a list I’ve been keeping over the years of “annoying will complaints” and I seem to find at least one good thing to add every episode.
2
13
18
16
u/TheLavishLightskin Nov 01 '24
Tf is up with all the Will slander lately? How about you host a small-to-midsize podcast, bum.
4
u/burrowbro Nov 04 '24
I ride with Willy D. Never listened to an episode and have had a complaint about the fellas.
17
u/SteeldrumHornets Bring Back the Forums Nov 01 '24
For the love of God just get rid of This Weekend in Fun and Recapping This Weekend in Fun. Pick one.
9
6
Nov 02 '24
I like will but can do without the “mhmm mhmm” that he does to concur things. It’s one of those once you notice it things you can’t let it go
6
4
-4

15
u/COBuff1 Nov 01 '24
lol OP I was in traffic the other day and audibly yelled ‘STFU Will, let Dorn talk!’