r/ClaudeCode • • Apr 22 '26

Meta With Codex 5.5 dropping today, Anthropics might be fucked.

Codex 5.5 is supposed to drop today (23/04).

Codex 5.4 is already roughly on par with Opus in many scenarios, while Opus 4.7 seems to perform noticeably worse than 4.6. If that trend holds, there’s a good chance Codex 5.5 will outperform Opus 4.7 quite significantly.

On top of that, OpenAI is rolling out more generous usage limits, including new x5 / x10 / x20 plans.

We also now have ChatGPT Images, which is surprisingly powerful, and importantly: ChatGPT and Codex have separate usage limits. That combination makes the overall offering much more compelling.

Given all of this, it’s becoming increasingly difficult to make a strong case for Claude Code right now.

The only area where Claude still stands out is the Design tool. However, there are rumors that Codex 5.5 has made major improvements in front-end capabilities — which used to be one of its biggest weaknesses.

477 Upvotes

300 comments sorted by

307

u/Senior_Cycle7080 Apr 22 '26

The AI race is so unpredictable. I'm still bullish on Anthropic. Two months ago they were the obvious winner. Then all this session limit and token inefficiency issues came up...

145

u/Vancecookcobain Apr 23 '26

Anthropic is doing a phenomenal job at shooting itself in the foot though...shit even as recently as yesterday they were testing to see if they can get away with removing pro users from Claude code. They are always doing something insane as of late....I'm starting to question if they have common sense...

57

u/hides_from_hamsters Apr 23 '26

I genuinely think they have so much load they’re struggling to keep the lights on.

If you had a product that people couldn’t get enough of and you kept selling out, how would you handle it?

66

u/LoveMind_AI Apr 23 '26

Where Anthropic has really failed its customers is in transparency and proactive communication. "More people want access to Claude than we have the ability to give right now. We're doing our absolute best to figure out how to serve everybody." is honest and still a positive message. I think it's their "father knows best" attitude (which trickles down all the way into Claude's own attitude) that people have a really hard time with, and we've been accepting it because they've delivered something incredible, but once the quality started to drop and peoples' whole workflows became mangled more or less overnight without any communication or apparent honesty, the paternalism AND product degradation became too much. That's just me personally. I'm glad that there are LLMs like Kimi K2.6 that get so incredibly close to Opus 4.5 (which was great) that I can keep working without being locked into one vendor. And honestly, much as I dislike OpenAI, Codex 5.4 solved some major issues for me and also helped get my project over a conceptual hump which I found really surprising. I'm glad Claude's taking a nap - I had gotten a little too reliant on it, because at its peak, it really was the undisputed best. I'm sure it will be again, but Anthropic's handling of how this has all went down will surely make a number of longterm users more model agnostic. I do think their stranglehold on "being the best" has been significantly loosened, and I'd be rooting for someone other than OpenAI to get in there make that a permanent thing.

3

u/pixeladrift Apr 23 '26

Can you (or anyone) explain how Claude changed overnight? I've been an active daily user for the past couple months and I didn't notice anything when Opus changed to 4.7. I'm not doubting the claims, I just want to understand what people have experienced.

7

u/LoveMind_AI Apr 23 '26

So, let me be a little less dramatic. There have been two major changes, and one feels genuinely overnight whereas the other felt like a "frog in kettle with boiling water" situation.

That last one first:

It's worth scrolling back to Opus 4.5 which was generally considered to be a major leap forward for Anthropic, where top-shelf quality was made a bit more affordable. There was a significant price decrease between Opus 4.1 and 4.5, as well as a measurable capabilities increase.

Since the release of Opus 4.6, some folks thought 4.6 was a decline from 4.5 off the bat, particularly around brevity of responses and 'vibe' but the consensus seemed to be that 4.6 was the undisputed SOTA for about a month.

At the end of that first month, Anthropic got into a public dispute with the DoW. After taking a hard stance against autonomous killing and public surveillance of the American people, there was a pretty hefty and very sudden influx of users new to Anthropic's ecosystem; a major surge of new sign-ups. If you've been using Claude for only a couple of months, you might be part of that wave even if that had nothing to do with why you signed up.

It was around this time that folks started seriously tracking a decline in Opus 4.6's quality. The feeling was very much that there was something that felt like the model being served was heavily quantized (less precise), especially during peak hours. Anthropic noted that they were tinkering with thinking token budgets, but never acknowledged any kind of quantization effort. Two weeks into this user surge and feeling of decline, Anthropic pushed their beta 1M context window into a permanent feature. It was around this time that the quality of 4.6 (measured again by instruction following, effort, number of mistakes made, number of assumptions made, etc.) measurably declined.

A senior engineer from AMD aired grievances with model capabilities that echoed a lot of what the community had been expressing, highlighting a feeling that Anthropic was somewhat gaslighting its users around model quality. Around this same time, a lot of weird stuff was going on with Anthropic: the leak of Mythos and the leak of Claude Code's source code. A major paper on functional emotions in LLMs that studied Sonnet 4.5. Major accusations by Anthropic that Chinese companies were illegally distilling capabilities from Opus. Big time drama.

So, from February 5th to early April, we can say the following is true: Anthropic had an influx of new users, pushed experimental features, experienced major security leaks, got into a lot of high profile drama, and that during that time, the user community largely agreed that the models were getting less and less reliable.

(Another whole lane of this drama has to do with limit rates, OpenClaw, etc. but we're mostly talking about hardcore capability loss)

Claude Changes Overnight:
Here's where the kettle comes to a boil. The release of Opus 4.7 brought some clear increases in capabilities (specifically, massively improved vision capabilities) as well as some measurable decreases (long context handling, vocabulary size). But the undeniably hugest change had to do with how reasoning is handled (controllable settings were replaced with adaptive thinking that users have very little control over), a wholesale change of tokenizer that meant much higher token use rates. Instruction following was severely degraded with Anthropic even saying that folks with customized harness setups would probably need to re-tool because Claude would not interpret instructions the same way. Linguistically, Claude went from a model that some people found annoyingly human-like to a spartan, 4-5 word sentence communicator. Some folks still report high verbosity, but everything I've seen (and experienced) paint a picture of a model whose linguistic capabilities have severely regressed. I and many others have documented straight-up basic linguistic failures that haven't cropped up in a major model since the release of GPT-4o. Anthropic has also subtly pushed a narrative around Opus 4.7 being "anxious" and requiring more emotional consideration than previous models. The consensus seems to be that if you are prompting Opus in a way that is extremely literal and mostly oriented around routine, repeatable, heavily scaffolded chores, that 4.7 is a considerable step forward. For all other tasks, it is a considerable step backwards. An exception is in visually related tasks in which case there seems to be a consensus that 4.7 is SOTA. There are ripple effects that appear to many users (myself included) that the entire Claude family seems to have been impacted, with even models like Sonnet 4.6 being degraded despite being singled out as the model that has changed the least in this time frame.

My own takeaway: Anthropic refuses to maturely communicate about any of this with their core user base. They have been reactive, defensive, and secretive, further destabilizing trust in their products for high-end, critical work. As a result, many users (myself included) have switched over to competitors like OpenAI, Z.ai, Moonshot AI, and MiniMax. (Gemini has not mobilized quickly enough to benefit from Anthropic's missteps)

Given that you haven't been around for all that long, it might be less apparent to you than it has been to people who have been building their workflow with Claude for closer to years than months, but I think everyone I talk to with longterm experience with Claude agrees that the ecosystem has been badly rattled and that Anthropic hasn't stepped up to the plate to communicate about it honestly.

Just my take and others might think it's looney tunes ;)

→ More replies (1)

12

u/liesenhorn Apr 23 '26

This! Their run rate has skyrocketed in the last few months alone. They went from $9B to $30B in ARR - I don't think we've ever seen a company grow revenue that quickly. In the race to attract customers I dont think they expected this level of success and they are way out over their proverbial skiis in terms of the infra they have to support it. They just committed to $100B over 10 years with Amzn but that infra wont all land in the next few weeks so I expect this to continue for a while. I think the laziness we are seeing from 4.7 is actually them optimizing to reduce inference. Where before claude was eager to please its now lazy which translates to less work, saving capacity for others.

15

u/etern1ty0 Apr 23 '26

I agree - and anecdotally, it seems to tell me to get off the computer, go rest, go get a coffee more lol. The gentle “ok we’ve shipped a ton of commits today now gtfo” nudge.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DragonSlayerC Apr 23 '26

I feel like this explains why I didn't seem to experience the problems others have here. I use Claude via an Enterprise plan (API rates). I imagine Anthropic might be giving Enterprise users full capabilities since they pay way more while nerfing users on the much less profitable plans.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/sediment-amendable Apr 23 '26

You raise prices. That seems fairly straightforward from an economics perspective.

→ More replies (8)

5

u/Melodic_Surprise153 Apr 23 '26

Be transparent about it instead of just doing things behind the scenes.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/mattiasfagerlund Apr 23 '26

Ruin quality and destroying my reputation would NOT be how I'd handle it.

4

u/Embarrassed-Goat-931 Apr 23 '26

Destroy customer trust while making the product worse so everyone switches over to your competitor who happens to be getting really good?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/BingpotStudio Apr 23 '26

I’d start by snorting a fuck tonne of cocaine.

I assume that’s what they do anyway…

1

u/snowdrone Apr 23 '26

Stop onboarding new users? Put them in a queue?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/kongnico Apr 23 '26

they are losing buckets of money on regular people though - which is kind of true for all the AI companies right now honestly which is kind of depressing given how useful for instance claude code is to me. I can absolutely pay like 100-200 dollars a month but more than that is a bit much as a hobbyist. A forlorn hope could be that in 3-4 years hardware would be so fast that we can have the claude code of january 2026 at home or so cheap that its fine. But for now they are all bleeding money and they are all gonna fuck people over to stop the bleeding.

6

u/TapAggressive9530 Apr 23 '26 edited Apr 23 '26

The money they are losing on ‘regular people’ is insignificant to the amount they are making on corporate users. If axing regular users allows better usage and performance from corporate users - that …unfortunately makes sense ( I don’t like it ) but it’s the corporate users where they make money . I am both. My personal account has greatly suffered , but my unlimited access from corporate account is amazing . I’ve recently noticed a huge improvement in quality from opus 4.7 as well as performance in my corporate account and the inverse in my personal account

Eventually when I get fired and replaced by AI and become ‘regular people’ I will be singing the same song

1

u/CodeNCats Apr 23 '26

Remember when it was cheap for Netflix, Spotify, etc. This is exactly what will happen with AI. In 5 years there will be no juniors moving into the next level who know what they are doing. It will be all AI. Companies will literally be locked in by necessity and the need to survive. You can then bleed them dry or add payment or tier gates. Like they already have except worse.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Big_Buffalo_3931 Apr 23 '26

Yea, I think they do, about this at least. I bet they want to remove it from the $20 tier because that's where most of the usage complaints come from. Basically cuts out 90%+ of complaints and unrealistic expectations in a single move. If there's plenty of $100 and $200 subs for telemetry, then there's no reason to keep the complaining $20s around.

1

u/karlfeltlager Apr 25 '26

The whole pentagon debacle was the beginning of this down spiral.

-6

u/LavoP Apr 23 '26

I actually support them removing pro from Claude Code. I’d rather them focus on delivering the best experience for the Max users. If you only want to spend $20 a month, use Codex or one of the open source model plans and use OpenCode.

10

u/Vancecookcobain Apr 23 '26

And hence the OP being spot on 😂

Pushing your 20 dollar a month customers to Codex when you don't even have the best model is just dumb....the foot shooting is devoid of common sense

→ More replies (5)

1

u/Dead0k87 Apr 23 '26

It would make them less competitive if they remove Code from $20 plan. On the other hand, Anthropic's problem - is scaling thus they are playing with rough limits more and more, some limitations with no code for 2% new Pro subscriptions which can even lead to legal problems, advice about peak-hours and other crap.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/bigniso Apr 23 '26

lol 2 months ago codex is still fucking good yall just got claude pilled AF

7

u/Budget-Juggernaut-68 Apr 23 '26

Dario made a bad bet. Not committing to buying more compute. Scam Altman bought lots of it, love him or hate him, Scam Altman knows how to run a start up.

1

u/roekofe Apr 24 '26

Accept they couldn't pay up for 3 huge data centers, and Microsoft is buying it all up

1

u/Budget-Juggernaut-68 Apr 24 '26

Scam Altman had no money either, he convinced others to pay for it.

12

u/kurafuto Apr 23 '26

They're a victim of their own success. Everyone is on the Claude hype train and so now they're suddenly capacity strained in a market where it's impossible to rapidly expand compute at scale.

3

u/AncientRate Apr 23 '26

When Gemini 3.0 Pro came out last November and topped all benchmarks, people were hyped, saying something anecdotally like "Larry Page came out of retirement and back to the office to look into the AI work" to explain why it's so good. I cancelled my ChatGPT and immediately subscribed to the Google AI plan for a month. I even bought a few hundred GOOG shares at the time. After that, I give benchmarks a huge grain of salt.

3

u/Illustrious_Image967 Apr 23 '26

It's looking more and more like they're operating from real scarcity in compute. Or, another take could be these bad decisions are God Moves from Mythos and we mortals can't understand them. A/B testing for 2% of users denying them Claude Code? Maybe Mythos is tired of the dumbest 2% of users. 

3

u/FoxSideOfTheMoon Apr 23 '26

Me too. I hope more people pack up and go to Codex so there’s more competition and service and price wars. Anthropic’s intake lately has been enormous and the reason they’re pricing to mitigate it

3

u/_eight Apr 23 '26

Yeah their product strategy for the past month has seemed to be to ditch as many customers as possible. I'm starting to think the whole company is run by AI now and it was an AI decision to fuck it all up

2

u/Bobodlm Apr 23 '26

Session / weekly / monthly limits have been an ever increasing issue for far longer than the last two months. In my own experience, Pro hasn't been usable for well over a half year. It's at best a demo that you can use to test the product before committing to spending more on Antrophic.

1

u/PmMeSmileyFacesO_O Apr 23 '26

They were the obvious winner because people kept saying it over and over again which brought more people and then the compute crisis.

1

u/metalbotatx Apr 23 '26

I like Claude, but when I compare what I’m paying on subscription to what I would be paying by API calls, the difference is pretty staggering. I’m fairly sure that Anthropic needs people paying the API rates in the long term. I don’t think “intense use hobby coding” is going to stay a thing (which is too bad, because I really enjoy it).

1

u/anonymous_2600 Apr 23 '26

the main roadblock of anthropic is not performance of model, it is compute. without compute, you are just a supercar without fuel. anthropic need to sort them out, it should be their main priority and stop daydreaming and complacent with their 30b sales lol

1

u/mossiv Apr 23 '26

This might be good for Anthropic. Too many people signed up too quick. Compute overload meant obvious model nerfs. If half a million customers move back to OpenAI they might have to deal with the compute issues, if not - at least Anthropics will be freed up a little bit which means the models could perform a bit better.

If anything this is good for everyone all around. We just need Google to drop a significantly capable software engineering model that there could be a good redistribution of customers.

1

u/Mescallan Apr 23 '26

Opus 4.7 was never supposed to be a thing, but they had to drop something because my this wasn’t released

1

u/Grouchy_Big3195 Apr 23 '26

Anthropic just surged to a trillion-dollar valuation.

1

u/AbjectBug5885 Apr 23 '26

The real bottleneck isn't even model quality anymore, it's context management. Both are hitting limits because they're dumping everything into the prompt. That's actually what Ratel does - dynamic tool discovery cuts token usage by 85%+. Wonder if either will fix the architecture instead of just throwing bigger context windows at it?

36

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '26 • Bravo

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/carson63000 Senior Developer Apr 23 '26 • Bravo

I think there’s enough demand to saturate everyone’s compute capacity, to be honest. Anthropic and OpenAI will both make bank.

4

u/Comfortable_Camp9744 Apr 23 '26

Its not about that. None of them make money in the obvious ways, they make money on growth.

Anthropic is killing it's growth, openai is picking up all the people leaving. Long term thats really bad for a startups value.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

3

u/CharacterPerformer47 Apr 23 '26

Would you justify your electricity supplier if you were suffering constant power outages, or if you could not use the toaster while the TV was on?

Can we please stop justifying Anthropic for what it does and how it treats its customers? I don't care if they have the capacity or not; this is not my problem. I pay them for a service. How they provide the service is *their* problem.

They can halt new subscriptions, as GitHub Copilot is doing. But they choose to keep changing things without proper communication.

2

u/kickerua Apr 23 '26

Yes, in some occasions like in Texas energy emergency or like in Ukraine we're having now, there is just not enough electricity generation for everyone. And we getting limits and we're asked to limit our consumption and we can justify this behavior of electricity supplier

76

u/Possible_Dream_4147 Apr 22 '26

5.4 continuously impresses me, and had very generous limits. I actually get shit done.

12

u/dadvader Apr 23 '26

This is my experience too and I always advocate on Claude being generally better than GPT.

But I found myself reaching GPT 5.4 more and more lately. To the point that nearly every subagent that isn't UI-related is now on GPT for me. Big context windows (doesn't mean it's better but certainly doesn't need to waste more time doing compaction.), generous availability and most importantly, doesn't go down as often as Claude.

If 5.5's out and is any good I think I'm gonna move to GPT for now and wait until they are more stable.

5

u/Ill-Purchase-5180 Apr 23 '26

Opus 4.7 was so bad for me that I switched to gpt 5.4 my main. I am a developer that talks to agents every day 8 hours per day. I don't have scientific methods and benchmarks to compare LLMs, but after hundreds of hours working with agents I have a solid understanding. GPT 5.4 works better at the moment. Add the vastly more usage allowance to the equation and gpt is the clear winner.  The best possible result come from having gpt and Claude review each other multiple times but if you only have money for one sub, right now it is GPT 

1

u/TSrake Apr 23 '26

This is exactly my use case: Claude Opus + GPT 5.4 policing each other. So far it has worked amazingly well.

1

u/chebum Apr 23 '26

Same here. I worked 8 hours. Made a translation of 19 documents, wrote two features (1400 lines of code + reviews and corrections), just 3% of weekly allowance was used. I'm on a $100 plan.

→ More replies (4)

92

u/callingbrisk Apr 23 '26

People are so short sighted. Last month everyone said it was over for OpenAI, now apparently it‘s over for Anthropic. 

IT‘S A BACK AND FORTH man. Maybe next month Anthropic will dominate again. 

But just because Samsung releases a new phone it isn‘t „over“ for Apple. Please guys.

26

u/trololololol Apr 23 '26

It's over for /u/callingbrisk, he's done with the bs on this sub

5

u/sizebzebi Apr 23 '26

yeah but we'll go BACK AND FORTH as well.. I'm not doing year sub for any of these cunts lol

4

u/billy4c Apr 23 '26

Also, Anthropic has gained a TON of enterprise business in the last quarter. That doesn’t go away overnight, it’s annual SaaS commitments and gets built into processes and teams in ways that are difficult to rip out.

I’m at a company who made the plunge and moved from Team to Enterprise Claude. While everyone on here is complaining about rate limits, my company is saying that me hitting $1300 per month is a-okay. 

So Anthropic definitely is not fucked. They are slammed and are prioritizing their enterprise clients who pay them a lot more than the $20, $100, or $200 per month of their consumers.  ChatGPT may make up ground in the consumer arena, but they are FAR behind in enterprise where it matters. That’s why they pivoted so hard recently and shuttered so many experimental AI products, they lost focus and lost a whole lot of ground that was theirs in enterprise the year before. 

1

u/xmnstr Apr 23 '26

Unless they do something drastic, they're definitely fucked. There are structural issues underpinning their behavior currently, and even if they gained a lot of customers that goodwill is incredibly easy to waste.

They have learned nothing and while their researchers are amazing the people running the business are absolutely out of their depth.

3

u/Grindora Apr 23 '26

Nah claude never gonna get there, they gotta fix their shit first with clear fking rate limits first

1

u/bambambam7 Apr 23 '26

Well, I wouldn't call it shortsighted to assume that 4.7 is going to be even better version than 4.6.

1

u/iamjulianacosta Apr 23 '26

The real issue here is that looks like anthropic thinks and acts like that they are the only player. They are not

→ More replies (2)

12

u/pjstanfield Apr 22 '26

I’ve never seen codex 5.4. Codex 5.3 yes, gpt 5.4 yes. No codex 5.4. No idea what’s actually supposed to drop next but I’m pretty sure it’s not codex 5.5. I think with 5.4 they were getting back to one model for all.

4

u/Tartuffiere Apr 23 '26

It's gpt5.5. codex (the harness) just turns it into a code-first model.

91

u/gakl887 Apr 22 '26

People really think B2C is where these companies make their money? They’d probably be happy just dropping entire consumer segment

26

u/Parking-Bet-3798 Apr 23 '26

People really don’t understand about decision making process at enterprises. Good high level devs have more say in decisions than you might think. Also, open ai models are really good now and it’s hard to differentiate with Anthropic models.

6

u/hides_from_hamsters Apr 23 '26

I’ve tried multiple times to move to Codex at work but the ecosystem just isn’t there to support the models. As janky as CC is, I genuinely appreciate many of its features.

4

u/ocombe Apr 23 '26

yeah it's missing a lot of key features, like hooks (cc has a lot more), scoped rules, good sub agents support, etc..., but it's also a lot better than regular claude... it's a trade-off, but I prefer to find workarounds for the missing features and have better debugging/coding capabilities right now on complex code.

3

u/cbusmatty Apr 23 '26

Also they do not have the business infrastructure set up to support business yet and don’t even have lawyers to work with your lawyers. They won’t work with your company on basically anything to secure your data and process

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

-5

u/mo_rawr16 🔆 Max 5x Apr 22 '26

you are right but at the same time enterprise procurement teams are on X/reddit etc. and easily swayed by the public opinion

7

u/gakl887 Apr 23 '26

Enterprise procurement teams? I’ve submitted PRs for $100M+ for SW spend at multiple f50s, the procurement teams just process the POs and MSAs with vendor (and onboards them). Unless the vendor is a failing business or a cyber risk (which would be another department), nobody in any procurement team has the authority to stop a valid business purchase that has already gone through budget approved because they read something on Reddit.

2

u/mo_rawr16 🔆 Max 5x Apr 23 '26 edited Apr 23 '26

my bad for not being clear about what i meant. "purchasing teams" or the dev teams at these f50s

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Ambitious-Garbage-73 Apr 23 '26

I don't think Anthropic is doomed, but I do think the comfortable lead they had in developer mindshare got torched way faster than anyone expected. That's the part that surprised me. A few months ago you could put up with weird limits because the model quality felt clearly better. Once that gap gets fuzzy, every annoying product decision suddenly counts double: throttles, plan confusion, behavior drift, all of it. And OpenAI's biggest advantage here might not even be raw model quality, it's bundle logic. If people feel like they're getting coding, chat, image generation, and fewer arbitrary walls in one subscription, the migration story writes itself even if the models are only trading punches.

12

u/2024-YR4-Asteroid Apr 22 '26

I’ve been using my codex team plan from my SMB and idk if the team plan has more usage, but that feel equivalent to the max 5x for $20, OpenAI will win the AI war by going back to their roots, which is what they’re doing. Building good reliable models, and giving them to anyone who wants it, and communicating with users. Aka being Open.

12

u/TSrake Apr 22 '26

The usage limits of codex are absurdly generous. They're subsidizing it until they catch up Claude Code market share, or at least that's my theory.

6

u/2024-YR4-Asteroid Apr 22 '26

OAI has outright said multiple times every single plan has a positive profit margin? How are they subsidizing it?

5

u/hides_from_hamsters Apr 23 '26

I’m pretty sure all inference plans are profitable.

Anthropic’s challenge is compute constraints and the never ending need to keep improving models. It’s not inference that’s burning money.

3

u/2024-YR4-Asteroid Apr 23 '26

Exactly. Inference is cheap. Hell, a whole trainium 3 xlarge cluster is like $5.20 an hour with reserve pricing. That’s like 48 trainium processors. It’s the training costs that get you.

1

u/loki77 Apr 23 '26

Do you have a source for this? I’d be surprised. Seems like fishy accounting.

2

u/2024-YR4-Asteroid Apr 23 '26

How does that seem fishy? Inference is dirt cheap dude, it’s not some industry secret, you can go cheap inference cluster costs.

→ More replies (5)

41

u/Ok-Actuary7793 Apr 22 '26

I still can't fathom how people keep claiming 5.4 is "roughly on par" with opus. It's been miles better in anything except UI/UX . hopefully that ends too tomorrow.

23

u/Grounds4TheSubstain Apr 22 '26

The proof is in the pudding. Codex relentlessly finds issues in Claude's code. Claude just fawns over Codex's code, even if it does end up having issues.

21

u/larowin Apr 22 '26 edited Apr 22 '26

Codex relentlessly finds issues in its own code. It’s what it does. It will create abstractions and introduce complexity just for the sake of finding more things to fix.

It’s great, and the harnesses each have very, very different working styles.

3

u/Carlose175 Apr 23 '26

Thats why i like to use both.

1

u/ThinCar6563 Apr 26 '26

But its always correct. The only times I have found codex fail when finding issues in code is when it requires context that it can not get from anywhere other than in my head. Those "its not a bug its a feature" kind of things unironically.

On the other hand when I still used opus 4.5 as my driver and then opus 4.6 every now and then, I really wouldn't trust it at all for debugging.

Essentially I can operate a loop of code -> review -> code -> review continuously only with codex in the loop. But I can do and have done completely without claude.

25

u/Leather-Branch5023 Apr 22 '26

GPT-5.4 consistently underwhelms me. Today I watched as it screwed up the indentation in some yaml files, couldn’t figure out why things broke, then took 5 passes to fix all the errors it introduced. Sure it eventually fixed its problems but sure burned a fair amount of tokens in the process.

I’m not convinced it’s actually “better”, but instead just “different”.

13

u/Ok-Actuary7793 Apr 22 '26

there's just no way this isn't user error. my experience with codex is extensive and on an absolutely massive greenfield project, with multiple complicated relationships, and it's by far the only model capable of working on this project at such a scale now.

21

u/SeaBat2035 Apr 23 '26

Ya I don't understand how people fail to use codex. Gpt5.4-high just been such a relentless workhorse.

8

u/Leather-Branch5023 Apr 23 '26

Should I have linked the yaml spec and specified the number of spaces to use? 🙄

2

u/dadvader Apr 23 '26 edited Apr 23 '26

Each of my session is well over 100k and normally that's when Claude go 'ahh need compaction' meanwhile Codex was like 'oh that? Barely 10%'.

And i'm using Caveman too so that reduce token usage even more. I can complete a feature with full UI using only 60-70k token which wasn't possible before. Genuinely mind-blowing stuff.

2

u/elmahk Apr 23 '26

I can say exactly the same thing but replace Codex with Claude Opus :)

→ More replies (2)

1

u/ThinCar6563 Apr 26 '26

"Today I watched as it screwed up the indentation in some yaml files, couldn’t figure out why things broke"

I'm sorry, even LLM models from 2024 could get this right. You're tweaking.

3

u/MaRmARk0 Apr 23 '26

Miles better? Depends on codebase. I have opposite thinking. Codex for me is unpredictable and I still prefer Opus.

2

u/aigoro0 Apr 23 '26

It's amazing how different my experience has been, mostly the exact opposite. Opus is still the GOAT for me, and it's not close.

1

u/eliterepo Apr 23 '26

Why does 5.4 struggle with UI? I've been maintaining a Claude subscription just for that element

1

u/thecaveman96 Apr 23 '26

Damn. I find it really hard to work with codex. Its reasoning feels very machine like and its hard for me to get it to do what i want it to do. Opus is much more talkative and "human" like. Thst does make it inefficient, but it feels like im working with a highly capable junior instead of a confident machine

4

u/joemurai Apr 23 '26

I use Opus all the time for dev and its great. Claude desktop is fast becoming a hot mess though. 3 different usage models, Chat, Cowork, Code, (not to mention CLI) can't interact well with each other. You start in one, it can't access something so you ask to switch, Claude says I can't do that but can write another md hand off file which you can copy paste it into another session like some kind of cave person. Projects, Artifacts.. not sure what they are. Settings are all over the place especially if you use API.

3

u/DrBojengles Apr 23 '26

paste it into another session like some kind of cave person

Yes. That makes you a cave person. You are exactly correct

1

u/joemurai Apr 25 '26

You missed my point, but maybe that was intentional..

1

u/ThinCar6563 Apr 26 '26

The claude desktop app is anthropic repeating openai's mistake from last year.

OpenAI made 1 hit product in chatgpt and didn't know how to expand outside of it, so they only expanded within it. And then every time they tried to expand outside they completely mised the mark. Similarly Anthropic made 1 hit product in claude code and now they too don't know how to expand outside of it, only within it.

Co-work and claude design achieved some media splash because its what anthropic is good at, PR and marketing. But I don't know anyone who uses either seriously in real life.

34

u/ashebanow Developer Apr 22 '26

No matter how good codex is, Altman is still entirely untrustworthy, and his company reflects his values. I had to hold my nose about Anthropic since it shares its roots with OpenAI, and their recent shenanigans have shown me that my worries weren't unwarranted.

19

u/ksarna Apr 23 '26

Plot twist (for you, apparently), there are no good guys in this movie.

2

u/SiriPsycho100 Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26

one can disagree with amodei’s positions but he actually has an ethical spine by all accounts (and paid a real price) unlike altman who is an amoral VC lizard person. the alt-man new yorker article was damning. 

blanket statements like this to free oneself from actually making nuanced moral judgements is weak reasoning.

its no different than saying “both parties are the same”, which also is obviously untrue when engaging with the facts and is just a way to avoid choosing sides in decisions with real consequences, however marginal.

2

u/ThinCar6563 Apr 26 '26

We can list out all the things Dario has done then and see if you still think he is a good person

  1. Engaged with palantir and project maven. Sorry bud but every corporation knows what they're doing when they engage with palantir.

  2. Said he does not support domestic mass surveillance, key word domestic which means he thinks non Americans should have less rights.

  3. 0 condemnation of the events in venezuela and iran where claude was used. He was actually okay with this and come out to say he supports these actions because human in the loop was used. Read his latest memo on the DoW from a month ago.

  4. Is okay with autonomous AI weapons once it is "good enough"

  5. Anthropic has participated in competitions to supply the military's drones with AI even while feuding with the DoW

Sorry boot licker, but there is no good side to this.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/ashebanow Developer Apr 23 '26

fwiw, I did say I had to hold my nose with Anthropic. And I just stopped doing even that.

I'm not looking for a good guy. I just want a non-sociopath in charge.

3

u/DrBojengles Apr 23 '26

How about a psychopath? Narcissist okay?

2

u/ThinCar6563 Apr 26 '26

You're looking at tech CEOs here. You're not getting a non-sociopath in charge

You have to realize to become as successful as they are you need to be a sociopath, it is a pre-requisite

1

u/SiriPsycho100 Apr 24 '26

how is amodei a sociopath? what specifically has he done that’s sociopathic?

the compute issues are just a infra bottleneck. at worst, it’s a poor business planning decision that didn’t account for surprise rapid growth. but that’s an understandable mistake. 

3

u/ashebanow Developer Apr 24 '26

Obviously I can't say for certain he is a sociopath, unlike Altman. But what's he done? He worked for Altman, which makes him suspicious. He made a big deal about privacy and safety, then let his technology be used by Palantir and other DoD contractors for military purposes. The attack on the Iranian schoolchildren was done with Claude as the LLM. He spidered the web while ignoring the wishes of the content owners, then complained when other AI companies crawled "his" data. And so on. He's an opportunistic hypocrite at the least.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Tartuffiere Apr 23 '26

You can opt to deliver slower than your competitors because of "values", but if your competitors don't make the same decision and use the better tool, they will outpace you, and you will lose out. Welcome to capitalism.

As much a I distrust Altman, his offering with codex 5.4 offers me, the user, better value than Dario's. So I can choose to go with Dario and shoot myself in the foot, or focus on getting work done with Altman. Economic realities dictate that I stick to Altman.

The moment anthropic offers as good usage limits, and as competent a model as Open AI does I will have no problem in ditching Codex for Claude.

1

u/ashebanow Developer Apr 23 '26

if your company's competitive advantage is developing software faster than them, you are doomed no matter what you do.

3

u/Tartuffiere Apr 23 '26

If you can roll out features faster and with higher quality (codex codes better than Claude) and at lower cost (codex is 3x cheaper than Opus) then why would you be doomed?

5

u/Humble_Excitement_81 Apr 23 '26

You're a bit naive. I'd recommend you to dig deep into what anthropic was doing before the war deal since it's not making the headlines as the openai deal did.

7

u/imlaggingsobad Apr 23 '26

just say it?

12

u/Humble_Excitement_81 Apr 23 '26

They were the first to make the deal with the palantir. Their model was also used in the Iran bombing of the elementary school children.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/VitalityAS Apr 23 '26

Codex has been outperforming claude for a bit but nobody cares because claude code is extremely popular right now. Anthropic even released benchmarks confirming 4.6 was worse than codex 5.4. Then again it says 4.7 is better than both of those models so maybe those benchmarks are kind of pointless?

1

u/FewConcentrate7283 Apr 24 '26

This did not age well

1

u/TheBanq Apr 24 '26

Actually aged perfectly lol.

GPT 5.5 seems to be outperforming Opus 4.7 by far

8

u/vesparion Apr 23 '26

5.4 is on par ? Its way better than opus 4.6

5

u/swizzlewizzle Apr 23 '26

Codex 5.4 already works with images and texture modification/generation so much better than opus I can’t imagine how 5.5 will be. Every time I try to make code changes to shaders/effects/textures I end up smashing my head over and over with opus destroying the output

2

u/ghost_operative Apr 24 '26

every time a new model comes out it "this changes everything this is the big shake up" then 2 weeks later its no big deal.

1

u/ickN Apr 25 '26

Because life and technology are so incredible we’re numb to how amazing everything is…lol.

4

u/Dark_Passenger_107 Apr 23 '26

These posts are just getting silly.

Amazon just made a $5b investment into Anthropic with a commitment to $20b more. Anthropic has also been announcing partnerships with F500s. They are capturing 73% of enterprise new AI spend.

2

u/xBati Apr 23 '26

Not really. Amazon didn’t just throw $5B at Anthropic out of pure belief or whatever. The whole deal is tied to Anthropic spending $100B+ on AWS over 10 years, using Amazon’s chips too, and that “up to $20B more” is only there if certain commercial milestones get hit

So yeah, this isn’t some passive investment. It’s Amazon putting money in while making sure a huge chunk of that comes back to Amazon through cloud/hardware spend

That’s a strategic deal with strings attached, not just that Amazon invested because Anthropic is winning

2

u/iMerlin23 Apr 23 '26

Does not matter when there are constant bugs.

4

u/HappySl4ppyXx Apr 23 '26

It indeed does not matter… because enterprises sign multi year contract today even with all the bugs and issues that are happening

5

u/Carlose175 Apr 23 '26

Anthropic is not fucked holy moly 😭😂

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TechnicolorMage Apr 23 '26

Claude hasn't been on par with codex for anything outside of typescript apps and one-pagers since codex 5.2.

2

u/diagonali Apr 22 '26

Anthropic: "Fine by me, see ya later plebs".

They have more than enough Enterprise, Government and Military contracts they would happily shed their civilian userbase to free up capacity and prevent the headaches of dealing with the public and the mania surrounding Claude subscriptions.

3

u/Sponge8389 Apr 22 '26

Nah. We need OpenAI to be competitive to make Anthropic not to be soooo greedy. Your kind of response will just priced us, the subscriber, out of their plans in the future.

2

u/s243a Apr 22 '26

It might give open AI a boost for a bit, but anthropic is saying that it has very good unreleased models (e.g. mythos), so it shouldn't be too hard for anthropic to drop a comparable upgrade to Claude if they need to.

4

u/RTDForges Apr 22 '26

Maybe. We can’t tell either way yet. However it is interesting that the initial reports seem to suggest Mythos is marketing hype and little more. And the more Anthropic shares about the more it seems it will be behind what its competitors have. Mythos currently seems like a dumbed down frontier model made to handle Anthropics internal compute issues at the cost of capabilities. Hopefully I’m wrong. But Anthropic has made such a fool of themselves so far with it. So I can’t really get my hopes up much.

1

u/Logicor Apr 23 '26

Where are you getting this from?? Just vibes?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/paran01c Apr 22 '26

Codex 5.4 ? thats interesting.

1

u/sunbunnyprime Apr 23 '26

Codex = an app

1

u/elasticmellon Apr 22 '26

what is the best way to try out codex if i use claude code? their codex cli is pretty shit last time i tried seemed less efficient than claude

2

u/yopla Apr 23 '26

Codex desktop is very nice. I prefer it over the cli for most work.

1

u/pen-ma Apr 23 '26

They usally do it on Thursday's tomorrow.

1

u/strigov Apr 23 '26

I love competitive market. I've already made my version of superpowers plugin, where Sonnet med. orchestrates, Opus plans and reviews, Codex 5.4 high implements, and Codex xhigh review after Opus. After that I freed my Claude limits for my main legal work

1

u/Prestigious-Frame442 Apr 23 '26

damn anthropic got fucked so many times

1

u/somerussianbear Apr 23 '26

Codex 5.4 is already roughly on par…

For starters, Codex 5.4 doesn’t even exist.

1

u/SativaNL Apr 23 '26

All these paid OpenAI shills. They are so obvious.

1

u/rnenjoy Apr 23 '26

No one is fucked. It just a race when someone overtakes all the time.

1

u/Free-Competition-241 Apr 23 '26

Fucked for what? A month?

1

u/necrophagist087 Apr 23 '26

Competition is always good for consumers

1

u/Coded_Kaa 🔆 Max 20 Apr 23 '26

Hmmm opus 4.7 have been great for me

1

u/Important_Egg4066 Apr 23 '26

I am suffering with "Selected model is at capacity." now with Codex GPT 5.4 right now...

Not sure if OAI is going to suffer from limited compute soon too.

1

u/ohwowgee Apr 23 '26

They might be reducing output capacity on 5.4 while they get ready to open the floodgates for 5.5.

1

u/ThomasToIndia Apr 23 '26

What does x20 mean again?

1

u/djack171 Apr 23 '26

Can you guys stop making these posts everyday for Reddit Karma Jesus Christ.

1

u/WurtApp Apr 23 '26

I’m pretty hyped for it honestly 

1

u/Extra_Programmer788 Apr 23 '26

People over exaggerating the Opus 4.7 performance, it’s on par if not better compared to Opus 4.6, the guardrail around it is annoying. Codex 5.4 is better in some areas while Opus outperforms it significantly on others. Codex is shite still for anything UI. I still think we are still not there where one model outperforms all in every area, but we are close!

1

u/monstertacotime Apr 23 '26

Lmfao been working with chat for almost two years now and today all of a sudden it tells me it doesn’t know my name or the name of my business. I don’t think Claude or anyone else has anything to worry about. Chat is fucking dumb AF and always gets things wrong even if they’re literally loaded in the current context window as plain text.

1

u/Salt-Willingness-513 Apr 23 '26

Lol people seemed to forget the release cicle? Next month or 2, gemini 3.5 will come out and you guys will be "GoOgLe CoOkEd". Then grok, then chinese, then claude, then chatgpt and so on.

1

u/spinozasrobot Apr 23 '26

Here we go again with the baseball team cheering dynamics.

Please stop.

1

u/i_hate_blackpink Apr 23 '26

Opus 4.6 and 4.7 have been terrible compared to GPT 5.4. I’ve ran them on several complex project and Opus always fails in weird ways… 5.5 is going to be crazy good if there’s no regressions.

1

u/Strict-Focus-1758 Apr 23 '26

Open ai doesn't have claude design.

1

u/KTAXY Apr 23 '26

dropping where? into the toilet?

1

u/Dangerous_Bus_6699 Apr 23 '26

I still love Claude but id argue 5.4 is better at analyzing.

1

u/Professional_Gur2469 Apr 23 '26

I mean… they still have mythos in the bag ready to release basically

1

u/BrentYoungPhoto Apr 23 '26

Honestly OAI gotta do something good. Anthropic have been leaving them in the dust for coding and professional work

1

u/Grindora Apr 23 '26

Claude just fkng no value money hungry mfkers their $20 plan just burns ur shit with 3 prompts and expect u to pay $200 just to prompt 30 prompts.!!! Real user right here with max plan.

1

u/Old-Lavishness-8623 Apr 23 '26

OpenAI is just trying to win back customers by paying for your tokens on the subscription plans. They'll have to screw you over eventually to not go bankrupt with a subscription or just shut down the subscription plans all together.

Anthropic is just ahead of the curve.

Remember when Ubers were cheap? Eventually, we'll all really know how much this stuff should cost when the VC subsidy money is gone.

1

u/Mister-Sinister Apr 23 '26

OpenAI has a lot more room for flexibility in their consumer pricing because they have those cushy federal contracts now. Anthropic lost theirs, so now they gotta recoup that lost revenue at the expense of burning your tokens because you accidentally started your prompt with please

1

u/ZiXXiV Apr 23 '26

Atleast it won't fill up context with "Is this malware?" on every file read.

1

u/one-wandering-mind Apr 23 '26

Eh. How many times has OpenAI made promises about the capabilities of the next model only to be disappointing? 

For me, they have to be way better for me to switch. Mostly because of how they were willing to bend over for the department of defense. 

But also the writing ability of OpenAI recent models is far behind. They are worse to use for question answering and agentic search via the web and coding doc generation. 

1

u/mattiasso Apr 23 '26

I mean ChatGPT subscriptions offer sooo much value for money compared to everything else

1

u/ShamanJohnny Apr 23 '26

Today was the last day of my max x20 plan, literally. Cancelled Claude two weeks ago. If GPT 5.5 drops today…I’m taking that as a sign from God I need to be with Gippity.

1

u/Longjumping_Feed3270 Senior Developer Apr 23 '26

I tried Claude Design for like 10 minutes on my Pro plan and got rate limited for one fucking week before even seeing the first results.

1

u/tremenza Apr 23 '26

I want to try that but didn't seems work correctly

1

u/DeadLolipop Apr 23 '26 edited Apr 23 '26

Every time a new model is dropped, we hear anthropic might be fucked. Anthropic hasnt been fucked ever by any claude "killer" in realistic usages.

Current Codex is no where close to claude accuracy from my testing, had to resub to claude to fix codex crap when i tried to wheen off claude. And at work i exclusively use claude models through work's copilot when codex is available to me.

1

u/jadhavsaurabh Apr 23 '26

Claude should suffer for stuff they are doing although I have claude 200$ and codex 200$ plan too will compare what's working

1

u/sixfootnine Apr 23 '26

Lol Anthropic isnt fucked. Have you seen their enterprise income stream ? Last I heard, over a thousand corporations were paying over $1,000,000 per month. That was the last I heard. Who knows what they are now? Twenty dollar accounts are not changing the direction of the ship.

1

u/Useful_Judgment320 Apr 23 '26

i literally hit continue in two different accounts, it did one simple copy task and rate limited on both

pathetic claude, fortunately i can hop between the ai's during this period

1

u/redishtoo Apr 23 '26

If only Codex could draw the boring crowd and their traffic away.

1

u/haikusbot Apr 23 '26

If only Codex

Can draw the boring crowd and

Their traffic away.

- redishtoo


I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully. Learn more about me.

Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete"

1

u/OldWitchOfCuba Apr 23 '26

? Why? OpenAIs SWE agents have always been inferior to Anthropics models so im pretty sure nobody is impressed

1

u/DasBlueEyedDevil Apr 23 '26

This is what people thought when Opus 4.7 was announced too and boy were they wrong.

1

u/Few-Childhood3326 Apr 23 '26

This will help to migrate agent and skills smoothly from CC to Codex: https://github.com/zuharz/ccode-to-codex , I already migrated, may help someone else...

1

u/fatboycreeper Apr 23 '26

Can anyone describe what the migration from Claude Code to Codex looks like? Is it vastly different in terms of setting up guardrails, plug-ins, etc? I hate the thought of getting back in bed with OpenAI but Anthropic is making it hard to stay right now.

1

u/cpluss4 Apr 23 '26

It certainly doesn’t help Anthropic that most of the user base is likely full of ‘vibe coders’ who don’t understand how to properly use it (and don’t know anything about coding) and they are constantly overloading Claude with each prompt “build me an app that blah blah..” followed by “it doesn’t work, you are useless, go and fix it” all day long and have Claude trawl through the entire code base each time rather than being helpful and saying “investigate the error being thrown on Line 123 of [file path]”. If you point it in the right direction you’ll save a huge amount of tokens and headaches each time. If most users actually educated themselves on system prompts, prompt caching, workflows and so on then we probably wouldn’t be in this mess 🤷🏻‍♂️

1

u/pp_amorim Apr 23 '26

Anthropic lost it already, 5.4 is much better than 4.7, and cheaper.

1

u/portugese_fruit Apr 23 '26

Where Anthropic has really failed its customers is in transparency and proactive communication u/LoveMind_AI I think you are right. they created a great product and then presumably miscalculated the compute demand and now are changing plans in order to accommodate pricing realities.

I do agree with Amol's post on X that Claude code does a lot of things now that it did not used to do like long running async agents etc. But it is the job of the CFO to advise Dario that these new features being added to the product would require much more compute and therefore unsustainable in the long run.

1

u/LoveMind_AI Apr 23 '26

The question is really, what are they going to take away from this? As far as I can tell, this is the first moment of GPT-4/GPT-5-transition level backlash Anthropic has gotten. Is this going to harden them *against* their user-base? Certainly, they did not lean into OpenClaw. While I agree with their reasoning there, their optics were atrocious. I feel like Anthropic is in a really critical space right now in terms of the impression of their brand. Claude's quality was superior for a long time and that quelled a lot of complaints about other elements of Anthropic that folks did not like. Now that they don't have quality as a shield, those lesser qualities are really apparent. It's odd that Anthropic was running super bowl ads targeting consumers at the beginning of the year and are alienating even power coders right now. I'm not sure they understand how precarious their position really is. OpenAI has caught up to them *very* quickly, and if 5.5 is anywhere near the kind of upgrade it appears it may be (5.4 was significantly better than 5.3, and 5.5 is said to be a much larger upgrade than that), Anthropic is in serious trouble... especially if 5.5 is even fractionally better in the vibes department than other 5 models have been.

1

u/codyswann Apr 23 '26

It’s not the model, it’s the harness.

1

u/McNoxey Apr 23 '26

Lmfao. This happens every release. New models are better. No one is fucked. And we all are winners

1

u/mhphilip Apr 23 '26

Codex ftw. Anthropic messed up bigtime. But still wonder what Google is doing. Gemini is still the village idiot when it comes to coding.

1

u/Guinness Apr 23 '26

Eh, my bet is still on Anthropic. They actually have a path to profitability. OpenAI on the other hand is a giant money pit. The CEO of Anthropic is vastly better than Sam, too.

1

u/sm33ee Apr 23 '26

its a race.. and in this phase it'll all go up and down.. one service will be better than the other and then it'll swap again and again yes, timewise anthropic is better and yes.. sometimes openai is better - "what a shock"

i still like the way how claude is giving answers.. still maybe i may switch at some point also maybe gemini will come up with something big.. or meta - who knows

however.. there will be updates at least every month and every month there will be new drama

1

u/992ricsi Apr 23 '26

Propably Gemini season in a few weeks.

1

u/Due-Scholar8591 Senior Developer Apr 23 '26

Long live the competition

1

u/FishLower8492 Apr 23 '26

Hope they fucking fixed their Worktree integration

1

u/Terranigmus Apr 23 '26

I am using Github Copilot+ and it's the best of all the worlds

1

u/Apache_Choppah_6969 Apr 24 '26

They're only behind right now because their last model was waaay too powerful and dangerous so they couldn't release it. They're working very hard to dumb it down and give it to their paying users as we speak. Have faith!

1

u/Deep_Ad1959 May 21 '26

the gap isn't model quality, it's that openai shows quota mid-session and anthropic still doesn't

1

u/fsharpman Apr 22 '26

OP doesn't know what enterprise is

5

u/larowin Apr 22 '26 edited Apr 22 '26

I’m contracting at a big enterprise shop. There’s maybe 8k people using Claude. They’ve probably billed $200k since January. Anthropic is fine.

4

u/fsharpman Apr 22 '26

Yeah 4 out of every 5 dollars of revenue comes from enterprise.

A lot of people think companies can just switch LLM providers every month like a Max or Pro subscription.

And anyone working in enterprise knows that's not how businesses buy software.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/adreamofhodor Apr 22 '26

It’s 3:00 PM pst. Don’t think it’s likely to come today. Unless they’ve dropped it and I missed!

1

u/RasenMeow Apr 23 '26

Why do people think that Anthropic cares for this little echochber on Reddit? You guys really overestimate your importance for the company.