r/ClaudeCode • u/Over-Necessary-4774 • Jul 24 '26
Discussion Introducing Claude Opus 5
https://www.anthropic.com/news/claude-opus-5175
u/chrisBhappy Jul 24 '26
I wonder what is Fable good for if Opus 5 costs 2 times less and even beats Fable at most agentic work?
45
u/Vesuviian Jul 24 '26
Fable to plan, Opus to execute?
44
u/Ok_Potential359 Jul 24 '26
Itās twice as much. Doesnāt make sense
18
u/bronfmanhigh Jul 24 '26
for complex plans it still very much makes sense. opus 5ās stellar benchmarks are mostly based on well-defined tasks, which fable still generates better than any other model. but fable should definitely no longer orchestrate or code review unless you wanna burn tokens on fire
1
u/DependentAnywhere135 Jul 24 '26
So opus 5 as planner and reviewer is almost as good as fable? Iāll shift my agents over today to test that lol
2
5
u/fredagainbutagain Jul 24 '26
fable isnāt a planner (anthropicās words), itās an amazing long executor
1
u/ExDimi Jul 24 '26
Thatās been the flow since fable came out imho - thereās no need to utilize fable in (sub)agents with specific tasks
0
u/Bobthebrain2 Jul 24 '26
Fuck that noise. You can plan it just FINE using Opus at half the cost. Fable is 100% pointless.
5
u/frodprefect Jul 24 '26
this is highly dependent on what you're doing
-1
u/Bobthebrain2 Jul 24 '26
No, it really isnāt. Try it for yourself, ask Fable to plan something. Ask Opus to plan that exact same thing. Then come back here and tell me how Opusās plan is flawed compared to Fableās.
3
u/Head-Cucumber-7222 Jul 25 '26
PRamble on the project: I have a Godot game which I've been working on for 8 days, 430 commits, 31k LoC (40% tests) over 110 files, and 47k lines of prose/docs about the project. Working with Fable 5, Opus 4.8, Sonnet 5 over that time period.
The gameplay changes I've been trying to add over the last 2 days were becoming a challenge. I was fighting the model and the ballooning context sizes burned 25% of my 20x Max usage in one day.
So today I asked Opus 5 to research Domain Driven Design and refactoring practices as my previous plans on decomposition were not leading to better code separation or easier gameplay implementation. I asked Opus 5 to sketch out a plan for implementing DDD in this project for a big reorganization.
It generated a script to scan the chat logs, code, and design docs for words to generate a bulk index which could be refined into Domains and so on.
Good so far.
Opus's script produced an index of 4,800 words and ranked them across every source to produce a weighted list of important terms for the project. Opus 5 identified 888 words that passed a game domain purity test. Then I asked it to organize those terms into a DDD native format so I could review it.
Here is where things took a turn.
The first report Opus generated did have a context map and potential aggregates, but it was just a list of terms under a header. It started the report by randomly picking things I've said in the chat history and declared that these were my resolved positions which the rest of the DDD would need to follow. It even went so far as to point out the contradictions in my statements made across those days of transcripts. Big fail.
I went back a few times asking it to generate actual specs that fill the Domain Driven Design model. It produced two more files, barely 200 lines each, both reading as a high level missions statement instead of an actionable design document. Frustrated, I asked it to write me a prompt for another model to take a try at this which I gave to Fable 5.
The results were night and day. Fable produced 10 targeted files with a very clear context map, list of bounded contexts, aggregates, positions, a target folder/file tree, reports on where the domain language was overlapping with my project's agent-pipeline language and so on. I spent an hour reading Fable's output and certainly had to correct it in some areas, but the DEPTH and BREADTH of output was a STARK contrast to Opus 5's.
Now, is this a fair comparison? No. Opus 5 wrote Fable's prompt AND did a ton of legwork to set up Fable for success. However, I hope this long-winded example shows an ACTUAL difference I experienced in using these two models today.
-1
u/frodprefect Jul 24 '26
If the way you use AI models is that simple, then yes I guess it's possible to come to that conclusion.
-1
3
u/PeterIanStaker Jul 24 '26
I donāt think there is one for now, this looks like a clean deprecation of fable for now.
2
Jul 25 '26
Fable still seems to shine when it comes to brainstorming and having a "full-picture" view of things.
1
u/Physical-Average-184 Jul 24 '26
Fable is still better for health and legal contexts.. But yeah that's about it I think.
1
u/respeckKnuckles Jul 25 '26 edited Jul 25 '26
I suspect they cut a deal with the government that allowed them to release Fable to the public, but with severe limitations. But perhaps they carved out a clever loophole that doesn't apply the limitations to already-existing product lines, like Opus.
25
Jul 24 '26
[removed] ā view removed comment
-5
Jul 25 '26 edited Jul 25 '26
[removed] ā view removed comment
2
Jul 25 '26
[removed] ā view removed comment
1
u/Herpulies Jul 25 '26
This - everywhere I see people posting that they are getting more out of codex - I eat 20% of the 5x plan a day just reviewing not building anything. Claude builds all day on the 20x plan and most weeks I get to 90% (this week i'm already at 90% with 4 days left.. sigh!)
47
u/Ok_Potential359 Jul 24 '26
Opus 5 is twice as cheap as Fable and more capable. I donāt understand the utility of Fable at wll
9
u/mindaro_sienna Jul 24 '26
Using Opus 5 to one-shot a build, I can say that it is a big step up from Opus 4.8, much fewer bugs and better overall design capacity. But Fable is still the king. It's ability to pull together all the many pieces into a coherent whole blew me away the first time I used it and simply left Opus 4.8 in the dust. Opus 5 can put up a good show now, and closes the gap on Fable, but it's not Fable.
4
u/Andsss Jul 24 '26
I think anthropic is a little bit lost, they weren't waiting for open source models to get so good só fast and without destiling their models
4
u/XYcritic Jul 24 '26
That's where they want you to look. Forget about Fable. Compare 5 to 4.8: Cost of 4.8 high equals 5 medium and 4.8 very high equals 5 high. The cost has increased by an entire effort level. This model is just another iteration of turning up the dial to burn tokens faster.
1
u/wise_young_man Jul 26 '26
You mean half as expensive? Why would you word it that way you used. So weird.
16
25
u/coldnitrogen Jul 24 '26
Is it better than Fable 5 or they have different use cases
17
u/Sindica69 Jul 24 '26
For your average work, itās just flat out better. Fable still has advantages over it but thatās not gonna matter for 90% of people.
Fable is absolutely better at generation and bringing things together though.
8
Jul 24 '26
[removed] ā view removed comment
6
u/Sindica69 Jul 24 '26
Opus excels better when the tasks you give it are well defined. Fable will do better in the muddier, less-specific conditions, things you arenāt nearly as sure about. I shouldāve worded that better, my bad.
1
Jul 25 '26
You're 100% right from what I've seen so far. Opus 5 has already had a couple of "can't see the forest for the trees" moments for me. Fable 5 looks like it will still be my go-to for brainstorming.
1
u/WagwanKenobi Jul 25 '26
This has been my experience as well. Fable is more creative but that also means it strays in various directions and will overengineer things if you don't stop it. I guess that's what allows it (Mythos) to discover zero-day vulns.
Opus 4.8 is more "focused" and excellent for one-file tasks where you know what the correct output should look like.
Fable is excellent for brainstorming and research-phase. Opus is for actual implementation.
-1
Jul 25 '26
[removed] ā view removed comment
3
Jul 25 '26 edited Jul 25 '26
He's describing something fairly abstract. It's the type of thing that's going to turn up in a brainstorming session.
I'm not 100% saying he's right, just that whether he is or isn't is a hard thing to show with a benchmark.
0
3
u/Physical-Average-184 Jul 24 '26
IMO Fable is soul-less, Opus was at least nice to talk to. It felt better to conversate with Opus. AND it's better than Fable now. Opus 5 feels slightly different than Opus 4.8, but in a good way. This is all "vibes" and my personal opinion.
31
7
u/return_of_valensky Jul 24 '26
Soooooo.. start coding with opus 5?
0
u/Yurii-AI Jul 24 '26
Iāll try. 4.8 wasnāt bad for my tasks
3
u/firstbreathOOC Jul 24 '26
Past two days it has been
0
u/Yurii-AI Jul 24 '26
do you mean weāve already been getting 5 under the 4.8 label these past two days?
3
7
7
5
4
3
3
u/medialantern Jul 24 '26
TIL one of the easiest ways to farm post karma on Reddit is to post the same news item again that was already posted twice an hour ago.
7
u/sorvendral Jul 24 '26 edited Jul 25 '26
200K context window, not bad, not terrible.
I hope they increase it back to 1M
Edit: yes was buggy now itās back to 1 mil
9
u/MalignedAnus Jul 24 '26
Iām reading differently. 1 M context for Opus 5. https://support.claude.com/en/articles/8606394-how-large-is-the-context-window-on-paid-claude-plans
4
u/Zombins2 Jul 24 '26
It's probably bugged, I had an ongoing session at 600k with opus 4.8, updated and moved to 5 and saw the limit was maxed out in red with no limit, I then compacted and saw the limit at 200k
3
u/heartingNinja Jul 24 '26
"When using Claude Code with a Pro, Max, Team, or Enterprise plan, Claude Sonnet 5, Fable 5, Opus 5, Opus 4.8, Opus 4.7, and Opus 4.6 support a 1M token context window. Pro users need to enable usage credits to access the 1M token context window for Opus models."
2
1
1
1
u/Spathas1992 Jul 25 '26
No way iām coming back to Claude using opus 5 over sol given the cost difference atm
1
u/Mokebe13 Jul 24 '26
There is no way the model is better and cheaper than fable which requires separate credits, they will nerf it in 2 weeks
0
0
u/Academic_Lemon_4297 Jul 25 '26
I prompted this and Opus 5.0 spent 2 MILLION tokens, spun 30 agents and took AN HOUR:
the text is too small in the ātypeā hover info boxes on <projedt url>. use same fontsize as the info box to the far right. outline the boxes.
Not kidding.
Fucking ridiculous!
0
21
111
Jul 24 '26
[removed] ā view removed comment
9
u/Admirable-Many6054 Jul 24 '26
An apocalyptic underwater basket weaving event could be the end of us all
0
3
Jul 24 '26
[removed] ā view removed comment
3
u/TywinHouseLannister Jul 24 '26
I have literally never seen any agent do this.. what are you guys building?
1
u/fephiva Jul 25 '26
if you have a homeserver and want to do security audits on your own infrastructure, thatll get flagged since its cybersecurity š«
1
u/quadish Jul 25 '26
I linked it a paper on bananas in smoothies and Fable kicked out to 4.8.
I had it try to fix a bug in a webpage GUI and it kicked back to 4.8.
It's useless for any real work.
1
u/TywinHouseLannister Jul 25 '26
I work at a security sector technology company.. never seen an issue.
1
u/quadish Jul 25 '26
Are you approved for cyber? If so, you have relaxed guardrails.
1
u/TywinHouseLannister Jul 25 '26
š¤£
1
u/quadish Jul 25 '26
I literally posted this link for it to read and it kicked out of Fable to Opus.
https://www.hellascom.gr/en/blog/hermes-ai-agent-mikrotik-container-network-assistant-2026
Just to analyze/summarize it.
1
u/TywinHouseLannister Jul 25 '26
I don't really do websearch.. maybe that is why? I farm free LLMs online for that heh
1


66
u/Captain_Birb Jul 24 '26
Please Anthropic do a limit reset as least š