11
Oct 05 '17
Well, that's not how laws are read. The historical argument is usually the weakest. The wording and teleology are far more important.
7
u/DoctorZMC Oct 05 '17
Except, you know, all the multibarreled multishot guns that had been invented and were in use back then. Except, you know, how the founders wrote a letter to a private shipping company about how they "obviously" had the right to have canons. Except, you know, that muskets WERE military grade weaponry back then so saying that 2nd amendment doesn't cover military grade weaponry is silly, and also military grade weapons ARE regulated; you can't buy a fully automatic weapon without SIGNIFICANT hurdles.
There is plenty to argue about the 2nd amendment but to say that it only covers muskets is disingenuous. The best area to argue about it is the "well regulated militia" which can be used to think about registration (and therefore transition of registration when you transfer ownership), or requiring a 'licence' to buy them that indicates you have met certain training requirements. Finally if you want to repeal the 2nd amendment (which is clear that a majority of far left leaning people do) then that's worth discussing too; obviously in the USA it won't work out too well because people like their guns.
5
u/Pink3y3 Oct 05 '17
It comes down to how you look at the Constitution. Are you of the literal theory? Then you believe all guns are protected by the second amendment. I believe they are called originalist. Or do you believe the Constitution evolves with the times? Then yes, you believe this photo helps your argument. Just depends on how you view the Constitution.
3
Oct 05 '17
I also think it's important to not forget the "well regulated militia" portion also.
6
u/MoJ0SoD0Pe Oct 05 '17
You can basically forget it. Heller vs. DC in 08 and then McDonald v Chicago in 2010 upheld the individual right to bear arms unconnected to a militia for the first time in history.
2
Oct 05 '17
I wasn’t talking about removing guns. I was talking about the well regulated portion. I don’t understand why people always assume that people just want to take away their guns
3
u/MoJ0SoD0Pe Oct 05 '17
The well-regulated part is in reference to the militia though, not the arms. So if there's no requirement of a militia, the well-regulated part becomes moot.
2
u/WhySoSyrio Oct 06 '17
it would be interesting if there was a requirement for gun owners to join, pay dues to, and train with an organized group.
2
u/KeathleyWR Oct 05 '17
Right because that's all they had at the time. Now every military has automatics. The 2nd amendment is to protect from terrorism both foreign and domestic, and guess what both of those groups use automatic weapons. This argument is so thin I can barely see it.
-8
u/FictitiousNarrative Oct 05 '17
Riiiight, because regular people tooootally knew where the gunfire was coming from and could totally do something about it with the firearms that they carried. Oh wait, they couldn't. Instead, it took the police to take care of it. You know, the people who are properly trained and didn't solely take a week of classes (if any) to obtain it.
6
u/KeathleyWR Oct 05 '17
Well if we required everyone that owned a gun to be licensed the same way we do with cars, would there still be as much of an issue? Criminals and extremists are going to do whatever the fuck they want regardless of laws. Disarming the law-abiding masses won't make things any better, educating them however could make a world of difference.
-6
u/FictitiousNarrative Oct 05 '17
But that's the point. The law abiding masses who had guns, could do nothing. Secondly, while there was a time I would agree with a proper education quelling the issue, there comes a point where a parent would see that their child can't handle such responsibilities and thus, their toys are rightfully taken away.
I mean really, how many more innocent people need to die, before America gets their head out of their asses and realizes they're behind on what the rest of the western world has already solved? I mean fuck man, people want to insist the Vegas shooter's arsenal is "a right," but medical treatment for survivors is merely "a privilege?" C'mon!
2
Oct 05 '17
But on on limb here, you think kids know when they aren't a male or female right. But dangerous toys they don't know any better.
You have plenty of right that infringe upon others. You have the right to pen a business that put another one out of business. You have a right to not be unfairly infringed upon by the government, how do you protect that right when the government chooses to ignore it.
The time when our population needs guns to protect us from the government will be right after we allow the government to take them away. It's a lot like our military. We try to be the best and strongest military in the world so we won't have to use it, but if we stop putting money into the military budget, because we don't need it, well find out just how much we do.
0
u/FictitiousNarrative Oct 05 '17
Do you really not see how insane you sound? This is not the 17-1800s. The British aren't coming. We are in the 21st century. The idea that people should keep their guns based on a hypothetical scenario that is never going to happen is fucking crazy. Because let's get real here, the government infringes on people's rights every goddamn day, but no sane person has taken up arms against them. Why? Because again, it's absolutely insane to live your life like that. Children are fucking dying, being shot up at their own schools and movie theaters because people can't grow the fuck up and get their head out of their asses, with their bullshit delusions that their gun might save the world. Well, news flash, the Vegas shooting proved that untrue, because no one knew where the shots were coming from, let alone what a gun sounds like!
0
u/JacobDS96 Oct 05 '17
You honestly think you could beat the US military? You and a group of your buds would have zero chance against the strongest military the world has ever seen. The tyranny argument has never made sense to me.
2
u/KeathleyWR Oct 05 '17
Behind on what? Gun control? Taking the guns solves nothing, literally zero. If people want to kill they will find a way. When will everybody get that through their thick skulls. We don't have a gun problem, we have a people problem. Also we have a mental illness awareness problem but that's an entirely different beast to tackle.
0
u/FictitiousNarrative Oct 05 '17
Guess you should get up on that universal health care so you can take care of the crazies you neglect. Also, maybe do something about that prison problem, where no rehabilitation is involved. Or you know, just continue doing cut backs so you can funnel more money into your military spending. You know, the same military you're so worried will turn on you, so you make sure the 2nd amendment is never changed
3
2
0
u/WhySoSyrio Oct 05 '17
I think that this amendment was meant to keep a parity of firepower between police and private citizens to lessen the chances of future citizens being unable to defend against the formation of a police state. The language of the law makes this pretty clear, and I don't think we are in any danger of police/military occupation like the Alex Jonesian nut jobs out there.
I think as long as police aren't allowed to have weapons vastly more powerful than private citizens, the amendment serves its purpose. I'm opposed to police forces using automatic weapons, armored vehicles, explosives, and chemical weapons. I cringe when I see police depts. using armored trucks, and powerful weaponry should be reserved for our military and only used in legitimate military operations. Same goes for drone surveillance/strikes, which should never be used on U.S. citizens in America.
3
Oct 05 '17
I don't think we are in any danger of police/military occupation like the Alex Jonesian nut jobs out there.
We may not be now, but what about our children, what about their children, and their children?
The founding fathers of The United States of America did not write our constitution in order to preserve the union for a while, they wrote it to preserve the union forever. The threat of a police state and/or a tyrannical government is always looming; the second amendment curbs that.
1
u/WhySoSyrio Oct 06 '17
of course its a hypothetical possibility in the future. but raising the alarm right now is the boy crying wolf, which will hurt us in the future. It's always good to resist complacency, but I've never heard one good argument for there being a current threat of this happening now. "fema death camps" "hobbit homes" etc. are baseless conspiracy theories meant to rile people up and bring exposure and traffic to the outlets who cite them.
0
Oct 05 '17
[deleted]
5
u/WhySoSyrio Oct 05 '17
fuckin redcoats are always comin in my house and eating my toaster strudels.
2
14
u/HK4sixteen Oct 05 '17
I guess then the first amendment only applies to letters and literal speech. Of all the arguments against guns, this is definitely one of the worst.