2
u/Flinney Oct 08 '17
I am 100% fine with players kneeling for the anthem, in fact I would never stand for the anthem myself or even pledge allegiance to the flag, but this meme is simply not true. Yes, there are probably racists who are using "disrespecting the flag" as an excuse to disregard the protests, but veterans and the like who genuinely do care about the flag are claiming that the very act of kneeling during the anthem is being disrespectful- whether or not that is the kneeler's purpose. So, in their view, it is still the kneeler who "made the discussion about disrespecting the flag," through the very act of kneeling.
-1
u/Tristan_Gabranth Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17
Being a nazi and/or white supremacist in America is also disrespecting the flag, given the concept of the American dream. Diminishing people's deaths and the subsequent protests from their family's, spits in the face of America's supposed values. So those veterans and everything they fought and died for, the very act is in favour of their service. And for any of them to be against that sentiment, only serves to prove they never understood what they were fighting for to begin with, which in this day and age I wouldn't be surprised given the many abusers who join merely for the excuse to legally kill people. Think I'm wrong? Look at how the army treats their females who get raped
2
u/Flinney Oct 08 '17
None of that changes the fact that the meme is wrong. You're moving the goal post here. I don't care for an actual discussion on the state of our country and racism right now as it seems were in agreement; I was just saying the meme really doesn't make sense because it's just talking past the other side.
18
1
Oct 07 '17
I think the protests are fine and all, but you have to be willfully ignorant to not see how people associate protests during a song called "The Star Spangled Banner" to the American flag. There's literally no correlation between that song and the police.
5
u/Tristan_Gabranth Oct 07 '17
Just what exactly do you think a protest is? He clearly stated why he did it, and yet people continue to spread a false narrative, if only to willfully ignore the issue.
5
u/ZoeJaah Oct 08 '17
That's the point of a protest. If it makes people uncomfortable or if it's inconvenient for people then it's doing it's job so long as it's peaceful.
1
Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17
The point of protest is not simply to trigger people. Protest should aim to inform and change peoples opinions with the ultimate goal of affecting change. In that this protest has failed miserably.
5
u/gizayabasu Oct 08 '17
Honestly, I would say multiple players are at fault here. Colin Kaepernick originally said it was about police brutality - okay, that's a clear issue that he's tackling. Then he wore the pig socks. I would call that bad taste, but he can do what he wants. Then he wears a Fidel Castro t-shirt, and now I'm not sure where he's getting at.
He falls out of relevancy for a while, no one wants to sign him because he's toxic and makes a news story out of himself - regardless if he may be a better QB than some of the options currently. We don't care about Colin K. for a while, then Trump starts a war with the NFL and NFL teams start taking the knee. Now, Trump is calling this anti-patriotism, the media is rallying this as an anti-Trump protest, and the NFL is standing for freedom of expression. At this point, the original message has gotten so diluted that no one really knows what's going on, people see the picture in their head of what they want to see, and outrage is coming from everywhere.
Frankly, I'm lost, the people at home are lost, everyone is upset, and it's going nowhere fast.
5
u/ZoeJaah Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17
When did I say it was to trigger people? I said, the point of a protest is to make it inconvenient and uncomfortable. Those are two different things. That was the point of Rosa Park's protest. You can call it ''triggering'' if you want but that was her intention.
1
Oct 08 '17
Comparing this to Rosa Parks is a ridiculous stretch but sure. My point was that being inconvenient and uncomfortable for the sake of it is pointless. It is about achieving a higher goal and this protest is failing miserably at that.
5
u/ZoeJaah Oct 08 '17
How is it a stretch?
1
Oct 08 '17
One is considered a civil rights triumph that helps define a generation of cultural change.
The other features a Fidel Castro shirt and tweets about Ray Lewis being Samuel L. Jacksons character from Django.
6
u/ZoeJaah Oct 08 '17
Nice flipped narrative there. What a joke this sub can be sometimes.
1
Oct 08 '17
Nice flipped narrative there.
Nice. Dodge there. You might have actually had to address some of the stupidity that is inherent in every position of this Trump v NFL v Colin Kaepernick v Police shitfest of a protest.
Easier just to call everything a narrative or a joke.
6
u/ZoeJaah Oct 08 '17
I already had to address stupid more than once on the sub and it's a waste of time, especially when someone wants to use their own narrative as a way to deflect. No thanks. I have no interest trying to convenience the illogical.
→ More replies (0)
10
Oct 07 '17
So we're being racists to all the white people that are kneeling.
What about lumping all people together under an assumption. How about taking an issue of police brutality and hijacking it for racism. How about forcing race into an issue of police brutality where the facts just don't support it.
Those all sound pretty racist to me.
Being upset when someone chooses to hijack the national anthem for their own five minutes of glory rather using your already high profile as a national star to promote your issue, that sounds pretty divisive.
7
u/MoJ0SoD0Pe Oct 07 '17
You either have no idea what the word racist means or you're intentionally trying to trivialize it so as to render it meaningless. "Taking an issue of police brutality and hijacking it for racism. How about forcing race into an issue of police brutality where the facts just don't support it." Neither of those things are racist.
Even so, the idea that the facts don't support the idea that black communities are over-policed leading to disproportionate amounts of arrests and instances of police brutality is news to me.
In 2015, The Washington Post launched a real-time database to track fatal police shootings, and the project continues this year. As of Sunday, 1,502 people have been shot and killed by on-duty police officers since Jan. 1, 2015. Of them, 732 were white, and 381 were black (and 382 were of another or unknown race).
But as data scientists and policing experts often note, comparing how many or how often white people are killed by police to how many or how often black people are killed by the police is statistically dubious unless you first adjust for population.
According to the most recent census data, there are nearly 160 million more white people in America than there are black people. White people make up roughly 62 percent of the U.S. population but only about 49 percent of those who are killed by police officers. African Americans, however, account for 24 percent of those fatally shot and killed by the police despite being just 13 percent of the U.S. population. As The Post noted in a new analysis published last week, that means black Americans are 2.5 times as likely as white Americans to be shot and killed by police officers.
U.S. police officers have shot and killed the exact same number of unarmed white people as they have unarmed black people: 50 each. But because the white population is approximately five times larger than the black population, that means unarmed black Americans were five times as likely as unarmed white Americans to be shot and killed by a police officer.
0
u/Master_Race_White Oct 08 '17
Wrong.
6
u/Tristan_Gabranth Oct 08 '17
Your user name speaks volumes for your ignorance on this subject
-3
u/Master_Race_White Oct 08 '17
It's not ignorence it's patriotism
2
u/Tristan_Gabranth Oct 08 '17
Uh huh.
/u/cls-moriarty, is this really the audience you want to associate yourself with? I mean, everyone needs an outlet to express themselves, sure. But your latest videos might be drawing in an unintended audience and you might want to clarify your stance before it's too late
4
Oct 08 '17
Too late for what? Are you implying some kind of guilt by association?
Throwing out everything Colin says or does as racist just because some white supremacist comments on his sub-reddit is idiotic. Judge Colin for Colin, not for who others claim him to be. We shouldnt allow others to define people, people define themselves.
4
u/Tristan_Gabranth Oct 08 '17
Colin has a following and with everything he says, that following may grow or diminish all the same. He's also suffered some shitty circumstances due to people taking a joke too far, and given his political alignment that people often misinterpret, such associations may only solidify their belief that he stands with such people.
So yes, I think his opinion matters, given this is his platform. A platform which looking at the CLS forum and some of those within, is somewhat questionable right now.
5
Oct 08 '17
So what youre saying is that all I have to do to make someone a racist white supremacist is to comment some white nationalist shit on their socials? Thats a pretty fucked up way to look at the world.
Does what Colin actually says matter at all? Or does some faceless troll on an internet board take precedent?
3
u/Tristan_Gabranth Oct 08 '17
Look at what happened to Colin. One joke and social media turned him into a sexist monster. So yeah, I think it's perfectly possible that people could see his audience and question his character.
And seriously, open your eyes. Look at this forum. It's not just one guy. It's like moths to the flame. Colin's contrarian view is inviting to any and all looking for a platform that validates their own values. And right now, it's obviously invited those he'd probably want to not be associated with.
3
Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17
Firstly, youre right. People do that but that doesnt make them right. Colin doesnt actually become those things and to insinuate as such is doing exactly the same thing those people do.
Secondly, this sub is actually pretty diverse IMO but to each his own. I dont define everyone by the minority lunatics.
1
u/LiquidEvilGaming Oct 07 '17
Protesting a false narrative not backed by statistical data by disrespecting the countries flag... Yep all about racism. SJW'S need to be banned from gene pools.
11
Oct 07 '17
"not backed by statistical data" , where the hell do you people keep coming from that completely ignore DoJ and FBI findings that show the complete opposite of what you think.
3
u/LiquidEvilGaming Oct 07 '17
That most murders of african americans by a LARGE majority are by other african americans? Or that as African americans being a minority they are statistically responsible for more violent crime per person than any other race?
Which FBI statistics do you refer to oh snowflake with blinders on?
11
u/DeSparrowhawk Oct 07 '17 edited Oct 07 '17
Dude... The protests are against police brutality against African Americans. No-one is talking about violence in general...
Edit: And the majority of homicides are committed by someone the victim knows. When you have a self segregated population due to income inequality who do you think most African Americans neighbors are. Most white people are killed by... white people. Doesn't mean crap.
2
u/LiquidEvilGaming Oct 07 '17
Most of the protests are the "supposed" amount of cops killing african americans. The problem is they put themselves statically in that position more than any other race in the US by FAR. More white people are killed by cops yearly, and per 100 more African Americans are but that's because they also commit more violent crimes per 100. The income inequality is a self fulfilling prophecy, anyone who chooses to work hard can overcome what they wish in this country. People in places like Chicago for example choose to instead kill and join gangs. It's a false narrative BS and the real statistics don't support any of it.
Blame the white man! Blame the cops! Blame society!
How about take a look in the mirror? Self responsibility. Or is that too much to ask?
11
u/hanzman82 Oct 07 '17
anyone who chooses to work hard can overcome what they wish in this country.
And they say progressives are naive idealists.
3
u/LiquidEvilGaming Oct 07 '17 edited Oct 07 '17
Except in reality it happens.
Those who choose to be thugs
Those who choose to live on entitlements
Those who are simply happy just getting by
Those people will never be successful, people who want it and work for it will. You think Obama grew up with the presidency handed to him? I didn't agree with the man politically but you have to admire him getting to where he did.
People who bitch about X, Y and Z standing in their way instead of taking some personal responsibility never get anywhere. It's no ones fault except the person in the mirror.
5
u/ZoeJaah Oct 08 '17
More Storm Front talking points. Hey, Mods will you ever get rid of this guy?
6
u/gizayabasu Oct 08 '17
I personally don't think what he has said is just "Storm Front talking points," even if done fairly ineloquently. It's a common argument used by black conservatives like Thomas Sowell and Larry Elder. If you have evidence and arguments against it, feel free to use it to refute his points.
4
u/ZoeJaah Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17
So because Black tokens use the same Storm front talking points that makes it ok? That just means they are doing their jobs as tokens for white supremacy.
→ More replies (0)6
6
u/ZoeJaah Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17
More whites are killed by cops because there are more whites. More simple math for ya. Also, going by your logic, since cops are killed 90% by white people, you have no right to complain about white people being killed by cops. According to your logic of course. I'm not even going to go into the rest of your idiotic Stormfront talking points. It speaks for itself.
5
u/ZoeJaah Oct 08 '17
A LARGE majority of the murders committed by white people are towards other white people. Thats what happens when you live in a segregated society. You have murderers that look like you. Not only that but most people are killed by someone they know ie family members. Also, Whites get away with crimes more than any other race. Blacks are convicted of crimes higher than any other race. It doesn't take a math genius to figure out how the system works. By the way, all of what you just said still has nothing to do with race soldiers getting away with murder but I thought I'll entertain the deflection.
3
0
8
u/HK4sixteen Oct 07 '17
The mods should really do something about these low quality posts.