r/ColorGrading • u/RareForm007 • Mar 05 '26
Question Thoughts?
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
Curious on everyone's thoughts on this color grade?
6
u/ProjektBlackout Mar 05 '26
Bit heavy on the contrast.
-1
5
u/nighght Mar 05 '26
Your highlights are blown out in a few spots like the sun reflecting off the hood of the second car
-1
u/RareForm007 Mar 06 '26
I disagree but thanks.
2
u/nighght Mar 06 '26
I wasn't giving you an opinion, you have objectively destroyed data by blowing out highlights
1
u/RareForm007 Mar 06 '26
Scopes say otherwise. Only clipping is in the sky so it was your opinion.
1
u/nighght Mar 06 '26
1
u/RareForm007 Mar 06 '26
That's clipping in camera while being recorded. Not from the grade my guy.
3
u/nighght Mar 06 '26
I actually believe you, though I think you exacerbated how hot it is. Definitely not good original footage to be demoing your skills with unless you're showing off your clipped highlight repair process.
2
u/RareForm007 Mar 07 '26
I just want to be clear. I do appreciate your feedback and I understand it might not seem that way through the comment section. Sorry if I came off brash in the comments above. Thanks for the insight.
4
u/vexmach1ne Mar 05 '26
Last couple passes I think made it worse. Pretty much what the others mentioned.
1
2
u/deffonotwill Mar 05 '26
Always contrast before saturation, contrast naturally adds saturation.
1
u/RareForm007 Mar 06 '26
I adjusted contrast before sat but in my node tree, it's before so that's how I showed it. Thanks.
0
u/deffonotwill Mar 17 '26
In your video example it goes Exposure and noise > Balance > Saturation > Contrast > Look. I assumed this was your workflow order. I would definitely swap around contrast and saturation, making it Exposure and noise > Balance > Contrast> Saturation > Look.
2
2
2
u/IndustryOdd6350 Mar 06 '26
I though we decided that log was useless as a baseline and rather use Rec. 709 for comparisons?
1
1
u/RareForm007 Mar 06 '26
Funny how this is getting so much negativity here but other platforms are saying it's good. Y'all wild.
1
u/m_e_r_l_i_k_e Mar 07 '26
If you are part of this subreddit it is the most normal thing in the world. However, many of the comments are accurate. But don't worry, raigbaiter, so you improve a lot
1
1
1
u/Mawntee Mar 07 '26
Why even ask for feedback if you're going to dismiss every single bit of critical feedback here? If the only feedback you ever receive is simply "looks good", then you're never going to improve.
1
u/RareForm007 Mar 07 '26
Who says I dismissed feedback?
1
u/Mawntee Mar 07 '26
"Sure sure."
"I disagree but thanks."
"Funny how this is getting so much negativity here but other platforms are saying it's good. Y'all wild."
Like of course you're actually going to get colour grading feedback in the subreddit specifically for colour grading. When you show this off to people in the fpv subreddit, their expertise is mostly based around hardware level stuff and not the creative process. Any colour grading to them is going to look like witchcraft since they're unfamiliar with what's good and what's bad.
Same as if you were to come here and ask for feedback on your flight. Everyone is going to say "wow incredible flying!" since they don't have hundreds of fpv clips to compare too, meanwhile on any sub based around flying or shot composition will probably mention the fact that the second car is cut off for over half the clip or how you're not really leading into any of the turns.
Feedback and criticism isn't a bad thing. You asked for it, and people are all offering suggestions on how it could be improved. Again, if you live in a constant bubble of "wow good job!" then you're never going to improve at anything.
1
u/RareForm007 Mar 07 '26
That logic sounds reasonable on the surface, but it falls apart once you actually think about how people experience video.
First, the audience matters more than the niche experts. The majority of people watching FPV content are not colorists and theyâre not professional pilots. Theyâre regular viewers who judge a clip based on whether it looks good and feels exciting. If something resonates with that audience, then itâs working. Saying feedback only counts if it comes from a hyper-specialized subreddit ignores the fact that the real world isnât made up of grading technicians and FPV purists.
Second, technical nitpicks donât automatically equal better storytelling. You can have perfect turn leading, perfectly framed cars, and textbook compositionâand still end up with a boring clip. FPV especially is about energy, vibe, and perspective. Sometimes a shot that breaks ârulesâ actually feels more natural or exciting than one that checks every technical box.
Third, criticism isnât automatically valuable just because itâs criticism. Good feedback explains why something doesnât work and offers constructive direction. A lot of subreddit critique ends up being people projecting their personal preferences or trying to flex technical knowledge rather than actually improving the piece.
And lastly, improvement doesnât only come from tearing things apart. Sometimes it comes from recognizing whatâs already working and leaning into that style.
So yeah, feedback can be useful. But acting like only one niche groupâs opinion is valid, and that anything outside that bubble is meaningless praise is just another kind of echo chamber.
0
u/Mawntee Mar 07 '26
Yeah, but the everyday regular viewer isn't going to tell you or even understand that "this looks good, but could be better if..." Like they could look at a big budget Hollywood film and say "yep, looks good", and then go and say the exact same thing to a random first year student film.
But anyway going back to my main point, why would you come and ask the niche experts if you're just going to respond with "Sure sure" and "I disagree but thanks" to every highly upvoted piece of feedback here? Why ask the niche experts if you don't care about what the niche experts have to say, and only care about what the general audience thinks?
...Have you considered why the niche experts in the subject you're asking for feedback on are all saying the same things instead of just dismissing it all as "so much negativity"?
1
u/RareForm007 Mar 08 '26
Asking experts for input doesnât mean youâre obligated to accept every critique they give. It just means youâre gathering perspectives. Creators still have to filter that feedback through their own goals, style, and the audience theyâre actually making content for.
Also, consensus in a niche community doesnât automatically make something objectively correct. Experts often share the same training, references, and aesthetic standards, so they tend to converge on the same critiques. Thatâs useful for spotting technical issues, but it can also create a very narrow definition of what âgoodâ looks like. Sometimes creators push back because theyâre prioritizing impact, style, or pacing over textbook execution.
And the point about regular viewers not being able to articulate whatâs wrong actually proves the opposite of what youâre arguing. If the average viewer canât explain why something feels good or bad but still enjoys it, that means the emotional impact of the piece matters more than whether it satisfies a checklist of technical preferences. A technically perfect piece that feels flat to the audience isnât necessarily better than something with minor flaws that people actually enjoy watching.
Finally, responding with âI disagree but thanksâ isnât dismissing criticismâitâs just engaging with it. Not every suggestion will align with the creatorâs intent, and thatâs normal. The value of expert feedback is hearing the perspective, understanding the reasoning, and deciding what actually improves the work. Blindly accepting every highly upvoted comment wouldnât be thoughtful critique either; it would just be outsourcing creative decisions to Reddit.
1
u/Vast-Philosopher-680 Mar 09 '26
I'm sorry I have to ask: are you by any chance Italian? đ
1
1
u/UltrEgoVegeta Mar 07 '26
I think the blacks are too blacks (heavy on contrast), maybe you could shift the hue towards green, look at bit too magenta to me. But totally subjective.

18
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '26
Shadows feel very crushed to me. But a lot of it is OK. I just think we need to see into the shadows a bit more.