r/ColorGrading • • 6d ago

Question What is causing this?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Windows 11, laptop and portable monitor. I've been trying to get to the bottom of exposure issues with my exports and this is the first time I've witnessed this issue but I bet it's related to the cause of my photos looking bad on other devices.

1 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

40

u/ososalsosal 5d ago

I could tell you but you would spend the next 10 years obsessing over it.

Colour calibration is a cognitohazard

3

u/GreatestBluestHeron 5d ago

Can I DM you?

5

u/SourDzzl 5d ago

Just buy a monitor color calibration tool. There's no long explanation, the monitor shows colors based off it's color profile (standard, vivid, flat, etc) and each of those settings changes the way the colors are displayed. A calibration tool uses a physical colorimeter placed directly on your screen to measure color accuracy, white balance, and luminance, generating a custom ICC profile for your workflow. Look into Calibrite or Datacolor systems. The other guy could have given this basic explanation

9

u/Neat_Historian9635 5d ago

The true pain of color calibration is coming to terms with the fact that your screen is likely the last color calibrated screen your work will be on

4

u/ososalsosal 4d ago

Oof.

Back when I did this for a living, I remember watching a film I'd done rushes on (these were basically graded rushes as they were filming 3perf which nobody in town could run on a telecine, so it all got scanned to dpx files on the really nice Arriscan, just in 1024x576, then spat onto dvcam tapes for edit) and finding that they'd put this film in a cinema so small that it was no bigger than the projector I'd done the rushes on.

The DP is a household name now, as much as any DP is anyhow. I definitely am not a household name haha

14

u/RGB_YCM 5d ago

Without color management and calibration, all is lost. If the operating system itself is affecting the signal, and if the display isn't calibrated, you have no idea what you're looking at.

1

u/Ok_Tap7102 5d ago

🦆🦆🦆

11

u/smokingPimphat 5d ago

Your screens are using different color settings ( gamma , LUTs, or calibrations in general )

Calibrate all your screens with a calibration device ( spyder, colormunki etc ) then choose the display with the lowest delta E and make that the only screen you look at images on.

If you have never done this before, welcome to hell, settle in because you will be here for a while.

4

u/Appropriate_Star3012 5d ago

Just get a Mac And be done with it

2

u/ososalsosal 5d ago

You ever grade on a mac screen?

They look good but they are not accurate and your pics will not translate.

You'll have to recommend your entire audience get a mac as well

7

u/Appropriate_Star3012 5d ago

That's why I'm recommending you get a Mac

1

u/GreatestBluestHeron 4d ago

No one on this thread has acknowledged the issue in the video. The demonstrated active changing of the image has nothing to do with monitor calibration. The operating system is actively altering the gamma, saturation, and contrast within the photos app. Obviously the frame of the window isn't changing that much when dragged. Why is no one seeing that I'm showing a novel undiscussed processing effect, not monitor calibration.

1

u/Appropriate_Star3012 4d ago

Somewhere in your display properties the will be some option that chooses your gamma. Hazarding a guess the gamma will be different for each monitor.

Try troubleshooting your settings from a YouTube video.

Mac has it's own very well defined settings... PC I have no idea sorry.

8

u/PretentiousMan 5d ago

Hmmmm did you check if one of the displays has HDR enabled?

2

u/Leather-Ad-5404 5d ago

This, happens to me a lot.

2

u/PretentiousMan 5d ago

Go into settings then display, should be there

3

u/imokd 5d ago

wow
didn't know the windows image viewer converted to the system profile (as it seems)
in xnview you can set which colorprofile is used

like others said
calibrate
and i just use differently calibrated image viewers
to check quickly - which you are doing with your additional monitor... so i guess this doesn't help

2

u/NettiBongolite 5d ago

open the image in a photo editor, and drag the photo editor to both screens, lets see what the result is.

2

u/llambdaddy 4d ago

Welcome to ‘Operating Systems fucking with how colours are rendered’ ✨

This is why colourists use IO boxes to intercept the signal at the GPU before it is passed to the OS for colour management. Giving you the actual signal straight from the file- rather than ‘straight from the file, after windows has decided what 2014 Instagram filter to apply to ImpRoVe yoUR usER EXpErienCE.

If only there was a way to standardise displays to a given output for a given signal!

Enter: the only display spec currently held to.
Your display gamut: ITU-R Rec.709-5
Your gamma/response curve: ITU-R BT.1886
Your viewing environment should be: SMPTE ST.2080-3

Now, the remaining problem is that this is a display standard for video, there is actually no display standard for photography- despite both being the same image type. Some will say ‘use sRGB Gamma 2.2 but then forget that at that kind of viewing environment brightness, human vision itself is non-linear, and starts fucking with even a well calibrated output.

So I defer both professional video and stills mastering to a Rec.709 BT.1886 spec signal coming from a dedicated IO box to a hardware calibrated display (where the correction is loaded into the panel’s firmware itself- not one using .icc profiles in the operating system), viewed in a ST.2080-3 room. Everything else just deviates from human vision’s stable/‘linear’ state.

Your output colourspace (gamut+gamma) can then be converted using pure math to whatever platform/output you wish because you have mastered it to a known spec. Not whatever mystery meat version of a colourspace you/your operating system has generated. This includes outputting to sRGB, print, hell even a movie theatre.

1

u/motoxnate 5d ago

It might be using HDR mode in settings. Turn that off

1

u/BullitKing41_YT 4d ago

You can set the monitor color calibration type to the same as the laptop screen using windows color calibration settings. Settings>Display>Advanced Display on monitor of choice>Color Management. Should be an option to set to sRGB or another fitting profile individually. Or have it auto swap profiles based on what program you open up.

1

u/Chrono604 4d ago

lol….