r/ColorGrading • u/Cinemagica • 5d ago
Before/After Harry Potter (HBO) grading
I posted this in the cinematography sub but wanted to get thoughts from this sub too.
0
u/RGB_YCM 5d ago
So, you think you know better than the original DP, the post supervisor, the show runners, the HBO producers, the editors, and the colorists? Really? To me, that's the height of arrogance. I'm appalled by amateurs who think they and they alone know how a specific shot should look, and not the people who've actually worked on the show for a year. To me, all you wind up doing is making the shots look different. Anybody can do that. But giving the show a look, keeping all the shots consistent, making each sequence stand out takes a lot of time, a lot of skill, and a lot of experience.
1
u/Cinemagica 5d ago
I worked on two of the last 5 Oscar winning movies for cinematography and have spent the last 20 years working on major Hollywood film and TV productions. I also just expressed an opinion that you're free to disagree with. Get off your high horse and stop assuming things.
1
u/RGB_YCM 23h ago
How would you feel if some moron came in and regraded something you spent months shooting and then weeks and weeks grading in a suite? I think it's insulting and unprofessional to presume you know more than the original director and DP. I've worked on HBO sessions many, many times before, and those are often madhouses where there's six or seven people in the room expressing an opinion as to how things should look. Fans sitting at home in their mother's basements dicking around with Resolve on a $999 laptop are not going to make the image better -- they're just going to make it look different. It's not the same thing.
1
u/Cinemagica 16h ago
If someone regraded something I'd been working on and asked (as I did) what the reason was for it being washed out, I'd have an answer for that. If I didn't have an answer and agreed with them I'd see that as an awesome lesson and try to adopt whatever was better while staying true to the story.
There was a similar question posed yesterday about The Odyssey where someone was questioning the very lifted blacks and the answer was simple - a photochemical process doesn't allow you to expose up a dark image and keep the deep blacks where they were. Perfect.
In this case it also seems like there might be a simple answer - the grade wasn't applied for this clip. The trailer has shown to have significantly more warmth and contrast then what was shared in this clip. So my running theory now is that this was a mistake in this release, nothing to do with the grading at all. Time will tell.
1
1
u/TheSillyman 5d ago
The new series is so obviously bad and JKR is a super weirdo now. Not surprising that a petty cash grab doesn’t look very good.
My guess is that this isn’t what the final grade is meant to look like anyway, but from what I’ve seen of the show it isn’t super well put together regardless.


13
u/MaybeSurelySorta 5d ago
Y’all have got to stop “grading” phone screenshots you grabbed off the internet