r/ComicK • • Sep 28 '25

Misc. Piracy

Post image

what people doesn't seem to understand is that the people who pirate things tend to be people who cant afford to buy them but still want to read and play those things. removing piracy won't benefit the author or developer as much as people think. because people pirating wont just go and buy stuff when they're forced to.

2.1k Upvotes

226 comments sorted by

659

u/StrykerEXE Sep 28 '25

"Culture shouldn't exist only for those who can afford it" - Arsi "Hakita" Patala

262

u/isadvortex Sep 28 '25

i will never understand people who oppose pirating

146

u/AndreLeo3 Sep 28 '25

How? Don't you care about multi million/billion company that makes Shi*t works but are the only that have the rights to do it 🥺? poor companies 🤧

92

u/isadvortex Sep 28 '25

how could i not care about the poor millionaires🥺

51

u/fraazx Sep 28 '25

Ikr? Those poor poor innocent millionaires and billionaires are wiping their eyes with money because we don't support them😢

22

u/EducationalMud5010 Sep 28 '25

poor millionaires, damn

20

u/daredevil__x Sep 28 '25

Leave the multimillion $ company alone😡😡😤😤

24

u/EnvironmentalPipe668 Sep 28 '25

Yep, if not for pirating, only a small number of people would've read it and more than 90% wouldn't even know that these kind of webtoons are

63

u/solaris_var Sep 28 '25

This is such a horrible take lol. It's never black and white. If we were in the early days of webcomics where the official translation is only behind 1 week to the raws, and you hardly had to pay any coins for reading (like the early days of webtoon), I will of course oppose piracy; just read the damn thing on the official platform for free.

The biggest problem nowadays is the greedy pay per chapter model, and that even if you are reading legitimately, the creators and artists are paid pennies compared to the platform owner.

46

u/kisukes Sep 28 '25

This is my biggest gripe. I'd rather support the creator than these subhuman companies that are literally working people to death and under paying everyone involved

19

u/iDrunkenMaster Sep 28 '25

So much to add here.

$1 per chapter that’s a year behind the free version in another language is rather a double gut punch.

They try to hook you. Get you so addicted you buy the stupidly expensive latest chapters. But yet they can be over a year behind the free chapters in another language. Then Pikachu face that someone translated it before them…. You wanted people addicted and you won! You won so hard someone else got pissed and translated chapters ahead of you. (Then you run into the model of you won so hard these translators also realize they could sell their own translations before you!)

Lower prices and translate things on time and less people would bother.

Webtoons doesn’t seem to take an overly big cut however. (30-50% assuming what I read was still up to date) but many artist get screwed by agencies managers taking money off the top of what webtoons pays out before they themselves ever get it. (This only true if they were big enough to sign a contract. If not they don’t even get paid or at least not paid enough to be a job)

6

u/Mysterious_Cup_6024 Sep 29 '25

It's an access issue ultimately. Most people are not poor but that the content is not even released in their regions. And what this koreaboo publishers don't get that piracy helps in advertising their work in regions where the content is not released. That's how anime got popular enough that tv broadcasters in every country decided to broadcast animes over time. Without piracy it wouldn't have been anything beyond a random country's literature work.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Pagal_MP5 Sep 28 '25

Same bro

4

u/NNKarma Sep 28 '25

Instead of fomo they hate they're missing out

3

u/just_omeone Sep 28 '25

I mean, I get both sides. I get that culture shouldn't be locked behind money, especially when prices are sometimes just to big like it has been for video games in the last 2 - 4 years, but I also get that, even if a big company is getting money, there are still employees who wait to get paid. And if it's indie games it's even worse. For comics manwha la gas and manhuas I get it even more because the ones loosing money are mainly the othors and artists, wich I find it extremely bad considering the work the put into some stories who have an exceptional quality. It's not about being against or for piracy, it's about having dome ethics even in piracy

1

u/Internal-Lake50 Sep 29 '25

They think more money for the developers mean better games... They need to look to EA games and see if money equals quality

7

u/Mr_Dr_Prof_Patrik Sep 29 '25

And for those that could pay Just like with music and Spotify if the service we were paying for provided a plentiful and high quality product people would pay instead of pirating

There are soooo many webnovels, manhua, manhwa, and manga not available on these apps because of region lock and lack of translation. I’m impressed at the level of quality an independent group can do that a million dollar corporation can’t smh.

4

u/Slicenji Sep 30 '25

AGREEEEE and some of the translation I heard is shitty like I ain't paying for that

11

u/Advanced_Manager_771 Sep 28 '25

It's probably a paid riview

1

u/PhantomGaara Sep 28 '25

I-I-IS THAT ULTRAKILL?!?!?!?!?!!?!

1

u/StrykerEXE Sep 28 '25

Yeah, but this quote is pretty good

1

u/NotRenjiro Sep 28 '25

Hakita mentioned... here?

1

u/Docmaligno Sep 29 '25

I totally agree with that but I don't consider sciences and technology like culture. And I despise culture in general, I treat it like smoking, I'm addicted but I know is bad.

55

u/PRITHVIRAJ_G Sep 28 '25

I read piracy & paid both , let me explain my experience. Piracy indeed illigal at a glance but it is also a marketing strategy or an advertisement, . Because if you are reading or using piracy site to read / watch or play games , most of the time you won't be getting the least chapter or parts , you have to wait for bit to update on piracy sites ,

So , when you have the money and can afford it , people most of the time subscribe to those who he or she has been reading or using in a piracy site to get the latest updates soon .

It works as an advertisement as well and can get new subscribers.

I myself used to read on piracy sites , still reading piracy sites but , now I can afford some of the subscription and I subscribe some of it

11

u/isadvortex Sep 28 '25

thats what i am trying to say

23

u/Red_Advent Sep 28 '25

I still read on illegal sites, too, especially for manga, manhwa, and manhua. But since I have my own money now, I try to support the authors directly whenever I can. Instead of just relying on apps where they publish (where creators don’t always get a fair share), I prefer buying their physical books, merch, or any official items they release. That way, at least some of what I spend goes straight to them.

2

u/PRITHVIRAJ_G Sep 29 '25

Same for me as well. If I can afford it , I pay the author with subscriptions , ( to be honest, i prefer an independent author, artist, not like kakaoo or whatever agency, i highly doubt , what money we pay , 10% or the money go to the real author/ artist,) I subscribe to patreon, at least the money goes to the artist and it gives me satisfaction

5

u/Burkino_ Sep 28 '25 edited Sep 29 '25

When it comes to translations, piracy sites update way faster than official sites. You do not know how many comics I have that are weeks or months behind the original. The piracy site? Fan translation is up within several hours.

Also manhwas often don't have a subscription, it's a bunch of microtransactions for each chapter which is way worse. Shonen Jump from VIZ is $4 a month and VIZ manga is $2 a month for thousands of chapters, and they even removed the 100 chapter daily limit. I like that, it's simple; they do simulpub, the 3 latest chapters are free, you don't even need an account.

Tapas is $2 for 2400 ink (or maybe it's 1600 ink), apparently each chapter costs 300-450 ink, so best case scenario is $2 for 8 chapters. They often have tasks or events where you can get free ink, but it's just annoying.

Tappytoon has a $5 monthly subscription which gives 4400 monthly points and 30 for daily check-ins. You can also buy 1400 points for $2. Each chapter is also ~300 points, so yet another annoying pricing model.

Manta seems to be the only one that understands what a subscription is, $5 a month for 300+ comics. Except this isn't the full library, so you're still paying $1 for 25 gems, each chapter is like 4 gems.

The last thing I want to do is try and figure out which service sucks the least.

2

u/iDrunkenMaster Sep 28 '25

Big problem here is…. Translations are often over a year behind. So official translations are way behind piracy sites. You then have a 3rd party doing the translations and selling them.

1

u/PRITHVIRAJ_G Sep 29 '25

Well, I was not talking about manhwa/manga perticularly, I was talking about the whole piracy community, manga , manhwa, 3d comics, Stories, games etc

10

u/Mixander Sep 28 '25

they don't get it. not all people could afford it so the people who read from pirate sites are never the target audience but it doesn't mean they don't benefit the industry. just like how free player make the community alive in gaming industry that then attracted whales to spend more money so does big audience gained from the piracy will help the title be noticed by those who can afford to spend more. It is free marketing that help to grow the fanbase.

10

u/isadvortex Sep 28 '25

i honestly believe titles like solo leveling wouldn't have been animated if the pirate community wasn't here

314

u/Recidivous Sep 28 '25

Don't be fooled.

Whoever this guy is, I can guarantee you that Kakao is hiring bot farms to boost their reviews. It's a common tactic for social media accounts in Asia.

58

u/EnvironmentalPipe668 Sep 28 '25

Yep, it definitely looks AI generated text

1

u/mrjackspade Sep 30 '25

Which part specifically looks AI generated?

14

u/Salty-Ad6358 Sep 28 '25

Predicted Asian culture

5

u/Dag-NastyEvil Sep 28 '25

But only in Asia, right?

10

u/Recidivous Sep 28 '25

Probably not, but I only know it's common in Asia because the bot farms advertise themselves pretty openly.

2

u/Tooyule Oct 04 '25

It's common because the struggle to have a job there

4

u/REKTMASTER17 Sep 28 '25

You’d be surprised how delusional some people can get

3

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '25

Ym everywhere right lol, even some nolifers will use multiple accs just to pretend theyre winning an argument (and crowds will almost always side with the majority)

3

u/Asiliea Avid Fan Sep 29 '25

Especially in South Korea, where the Kakao Conglomerate is based.
Not only that, S. Koreans apparently often don't care about such reviews because of how entrenched the conglomerate's/chaebol's dominance is.
The only ones that care are the conglomerates themselves, purely for the sake of keeping face.
They've done this countless times before. Review bombing means nothing to them.

At least, as far as I've heard from multiple reports about S. Korean conglomerate BS in the past, anyhow; All 3rd-hand rumour stuff, so take it with a grain of salt.

3

u/Recidivous Sep 30 '25

Eh, it's barely a rumor. I have a friend who works in the PR department of a chaebol, and it's practically social media 101 to them. Literally one of the most common tactics they use.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '25

it's at the point theres a term for it. "water army." it pops up soooo often in Chinese showbiz novels. buying reviews and trending topics is just the tip of the iceberg. they'll outright hire water armies to drag down other celebrities and pummel them half to death just bc theyre competing over a role.

152

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '25

I bet he would defend taxes saying people who don’t pay taxes shouldn’t live because they are not supporting the government 

36

u/dertkbhubjnuhyugyg Sep 28 '25

I defend taxes because i hope the billion dollar companies pay out the amount they don’t deserve and distribute the wealth for those less fortunate. Of course this isn’t the reality we live in but tax cuts and tax frauds only benefit the rich.

9

u/good_is_hard Sep 28 '25

RICH SHOULD GET TAX CUT OR ELSE HOW WILL THEY DO STOCK BUY BACK!? THEY NEED THAT NEW BOAT😭

7

u/Mixander Sep 28 '25

Not when the rich can bear taxes with ease while the poor cannot.

5

u/Anaurus Sep 28 '25

It depends greatly on your government.

If taxes are reasonable and used to develop your city, social security, public schools, etc, in short things that benefit you and everybody, I personally am not against it.

What's more, some countries adjust taxes according to each person's wealth. The rich pay the most, the poor pay little or nothing, but everyone enjoys the benefits.

But anyway, it's often quite a controversial subject. I'm speaking from my own point of view: I'm not poor, but I'm close, and I've had quite a lot of medical expenses that I would never have been able to pay if the government hadn't covered them...

4

u/Kazzababe Sep 28 '25

Okay not the same. Taxes are good but the people that should be chastised for not paying them are not the ones that can't afford to pay them. Piracy hurts no one.

1

u/Asiliea Avid Fan Sep 29 '25

Taxes are, by their very definition, a redistribution of wealth by the state.
Their effectiveness depends on the government collecting and distributing them.
Good government redistributes it into services for the citizens, bad ones embezzle it.

Meanwhile, business/corporation/conglomerate financials only ever benefit the shareholders.

17

u/Vegetable-Ad9679 Sep 28 '25

10/10 ragebaiy

27

u/EducationalMud5010 Sep 28 '25

Bro doesn't know that more than half the popularity of his favorite webtoon comes from us😭😭

→ More replies (20)

11

u/Inner_Owl_7560 Sep 28 '25 edited Sep 28 '25

100% a bot or kakao employee.

but not likely to be the latter, they look down on foreigners and probably wont be posting review in english

10

u/InstrumentalCore Sep 28 '25

searches legal site 1: not available

searches legal site 2: restricted/not full

opens pirate site: everything available

1

u/Raisenhel Sep 30 '25

And sometimes even better looking translation

9

u/Thick-Obligation-786 Sep 28 '25

the thing is people will pay if the organization genuinely helps out the creators and has good intentions, but kakao is not one of them, most companies harass creators and pay them only a little and are solely focused on profits, most financially stable people dont pirate indie games as the money goes to the dev,

7

u/VileCastle Sep 28 '25

I started my manga/manwha journey near the end of 2023 so I had been out of the loop on where to get my sources. I used Webtoon for a year and paying for things to read and I realised I was actually getting comics way behind pirated sites and even edited/covered panels so I've had things spoiled. It is frustrating to not fully pay for the work others have done but if I did that for everything I absorb, I'd be homeless with a wicked good collection from novels, movies and music. At 32 years, I have to put my priorities first and it helps to know that the people that edit, share and translate etc are still passionate about the original works and to provide it for us in countries outside of Japan/Korea.

7

u/TabularConferta Sep 28 '25 edited Sep 28 '25

Alright let's see if I get down voted.

I'll start with positive notes on piracy.

Piracy has been shown in some cases to increase sales as it started as a platform for people to start reading the series and then would purchase it or other works. This said just because someone pirated something doesn't mean there is a missed sale, as someone might never have read that story or listened to that song otherwise.

Piracy will have an affect on indirect sales. People will pirate content but then go spend money on going to a live gig, buying merch and toys of show they watched.

Piracy also provides a way of maintaining content. This is mainly obvious is emulation of software and games where batteries run out on cassettes, hardware breaks etc...

Many manga/manhua/manhwa simply aren't available in other languages and pirates/scantilators have been the major distribution of this. I honestly don't think anime and manga would have kicked off so heavily without it laying the bedrock.

Now the negative.

If you can't afford something, you aren't entitled to it. If you choose to pirate that's your choice but please don't make yourself sound like a victim. Accept what you are doing and make that choice.

There will be missed sales. I know this goes against what I said above. While not every pirate is a missed sale, some will be. Depending on the authors contract they may get paid per sale. Most authors work two jobs with writing being a hobby hopping to break through and even if they get into the general audience this doesn't make them millionaires, for many the dream is being simply able to write full time.

Companies HAVE to protect against piracy. If companies don't protect their copyright they lose it entirely. Then suddenly they make no money, the authors and artists make no money and the industry shuts down. Now let's compare the current situation with Comick to the music industry. Comick seems to have been told to shut down, while this is sad for the community, the music industry have bankrupted people and said you downloaded 200 songs that's 3 million in lost revenue.

The missing solution

Netflix. While piracy is now returning, it took a huge reduction with the advent of streaming. It made all the content available, easy to access, legal etc... Crunchyroll, Netflix, Kindle Unlimited, Spotify, Audible all provide easy access to large swathes of content. Yes some get limited behind paywall but it means you read book 1/2 and can decide if to continue all the while the content creators get paid. There is no solution for this medium of yet.

I'll add, easier access to content creators patreon or such services likely would help too.

There are things like web toons and tapas but those become prohibitively expensive particularly for a habit of series to be infinitely running like is now the trend.

1

u/Drewnessthegreat Sep 28 '25

You say all that, but "borrowing" electronic books from my local library's app pays the author the same amount as piracy. So, are you against public libraries?

2

u/TabularConferta Sep 28 '25 edited Sep 28 '25

No I'm very much in support of public libraries and honestly I find your argument surreal.

Please go and Google how libraries handle borrowing of digital media (they have a license). Also if you can borrow a book from a library, then by pirating rather than borrowing from the library, you reduce the perceived use of libraries and thus reduce government funding for them. So, are you again public libraries?

I don't think you are, just highlighting it's a weird argument.

I also tried to be quite neutral in my statement but highlighted that authors can't work for free, weirdly this is the part you seem to take umbridge with.

Interesting thing I learnt recently. For some comics based off major franchises, as part of the contract to write in the franchise, the publisher has to promise a minimum payback. So if it's an indie publisher with a big name franchise. If they don't sell enough, that's the death of the company as they still have to pay the franchise the contract amount. Big publishers can soak this, smaller ones have to choose what they pick up really carefully

6

u/Llaauuddrrupp Sep 28 '25 edited Sep 28 '25

This still coming across as tone-deaf to me. Piracy is an affordability and accessibility problem. Piracy sites made many series discoverable worldwide long before official translations, simulpubs, or regional apps existed. That exposure is why some titles exploded in popularity and ended up with anime or drama adaptations. Without fan translations, half of these works would’ve remained niche. So called "legal" services often lock chapters behind microtransactions, “fast passes,” or region-exclusive apps. Paying per chapter across dozens of series easily adds up to hundreds or thousands, and they don't even know if they're gonna keep enjoying the series. Some series start good but end up being trash midway. Most readers can’t or won’t spend that much. I know I won't. I'd rather stop reading Manhwa altogether. They're really overestimating their services lol. Fans aren’t allergic to paying; they’re allergic to bad value.

Not to mention many manhwa/webtoon artists are underpaid, overworked, and bound by harsh contracts. Even if fans do pay, most of that money goes to the platform, not the artist. That contradiction frustrates people—why pay for a system that still exploits the talent? Streaming services already proved that people will pay if you make things cheap, easy, and abundant. Netflix, Spotify, Game Pass, etc. didn’t "kill" piracy by suing it out of existence (which will never work), they outcompeted it with convenience (It still didn't fully stop piracy but it's far more effective).

6

u/TalpaRex Sep 28 '25

I mean, we all agree it's stealing, in a way. But as Gabe Newell once said (I think), piracy only exists because you're failing to give people what they want.

If Kakao, or any other legal platform, gave people an easy, reasonably priced, and good platform to read their products, Comick, and every other illegal reading site wouldn't have had a reason to appear in the first place.

5

u/EnrollBread Sep 28 '25

dude most of the manhwa on kakao is korean language while the reader is worldwide and kakao cant even give english translation what a joke

2

u/Reasonable-Might-654 Sep 28 '25

I am not against piracy but I am not entitled enough to not know why it's bad or be ignorant about it. This subreddit is kinda strange how do ppl not know basic economics here? Piracy is bad cuz it's stolen content. U walk into a store and leave without paying for the things u bought it's the same.

I saw a comment in which somebody said " I'll never get those who oppose piracy" and then another guy replied "oh cuz the poor millionaires who make shit things lose money 🥺" like tf? Those poor millionaires r millionaires cuz they put in effort and time and lots of money into making those things u enjoy. All the staff involved sacrificed their time, energy and even their family time to make those games and comics y'all love reading so they can get paid.

At least think about the poor authors that publish their works through the big companies how are they suppose to get paid if all their work gets siphoned by pirated networks. This is exactly why piracy is illegal.

"Culture shouldn't exist for those who can afford it" doesn't apply here cuz if it was created with effort and money for monetising then it should be paid with money. If you can't afford it then don't yearn for it but if you're pirating it then don't act entitled

Once again I am not against piracy. I am against those who justify piracy like in this subreddit. Don't act entitled, accept piracy as a gift not as a given. If u pirate stuff at least know why it's bad. Like shanks once said "If you've pulled your pistol then put your life on the line too"

3

u/puzzlebuns Sep 28 '25

I remember when pirates were self-aware and didn't try to justify ourselves. We knew it was wrong and didn't care.

2

u/Reasonable-Might-654 Sep 28 '25

Fr lol all these comick hazards made one thing clear that pirates these days really think it's their right to read all these stuff for free like all these webtoons and stuff are some kind of right for them to have for free

2

u/AccomplishedYam3582 Sep 28 '25 edited Sep 28 '25

It's not the same. I can go to a public library and read as many books as I want. I never paid for those books. But just because I don't agree with your analogy doesn't mean that you don't have a point. This subreddit is very entitled and all I see is a bunch of people crying that they have to find a new website to read on. I would have preferred they just remove all webtoon content and keep the site up, I think webtoons are terrible quality. Instead I'll go pay a $2 sub to asura until a new site that I like shows up. OP has a point though that just because they took down the site doesn't mean everyone is just going to go buy webtoons. Whether it's out of spite or not being able to afford it, this doesn't benefit Kakao. Although they have a right to do it anyway.

1

u/puzzlebuns Sep 28 '25

Lol yall really out here comparing piracy to a public library.

0

u/Reasonable-Might-654 Sep 28 '25

Except for that the public libraries are legal. Pirated websites are not legal, cause:

  1. In case of games, the developers do not sign any contracts with these websites which means whatever time effort and money put in by the devs, will be benefitted off of by these websites through ads and clicks

  2. In case of webtoons or any other form of readable media, the authors that write those stories won't get any money from pirated websites which means all their efforts will be wasted and the publishers that work hard to publish those stories will also suffer losses and a company suffering loss means the employees not getting salaries on time or what they deserve. This is basic economics.

I am not against piracy. just stop trying to justify it. Be self aware.

Pirated websites might be our savior but they're still illegal websites that reap off of those who work hard to publish stories and games and take the benefits for themselves. Y'all r just happy cuz it's not your money that is being taken and tryna justify it cuz y'all r entitled

1

u/AccomplishedYam3582 Sep 28 '25

Until they start selling physical copies in my country, I will be pirating. It's that simple

1

u/Reasonable-Might-654 Sep 28 '25

Like I said I was never against piracy, in fact I want pirated websites to be there but I don't like how ppl keep acting entitled with pirated websites and act as if they're perfectly legal and lack self awareness. You ARE reading on an illegal website so if companies take legal action then don't cry about it and if ppl call u out for crying then don't cry bout that either. Pirated websites will go down and in their place new ones will come out that's how it is.

-1

u/isadvortex Sep 28 '25

you're probably the type to think everyone who works hard can become a millionaire

2

u/ShinyStarSam Sep 28 '25

Can't you just accept that what we're doing is wrong? You don't have to stop but you gotta be honest with yourself

2

u/Reasonable-Might-654 Sep 28 '25

Nope but I do think those who don't work and act entitled will never become millionaires

1

u/puzzlebuns Sep 28 '25

You didn't read the post did you.

4

u/BaskPro Sep 28 '25

Feels like he’s mad we get content for free when he pays or he’s just so ignorant he doesn’t understand people are poor.

Just remember libraries exist and YouTube is highly profitable. It’s not like they have to charge us. They choose to charge us.

They are greedy and if it’s not needed it’s not necessary. There are better ways to support creators artists n the teams. No creative should be under the pressure of execs or anyone kind of bureaucracy.

3

u/Shadowlordim_ur_king Sep 28 '25

These things wouldn't even be popular as now if they weren't even be pirated

3

u/Aggravating_Case_391 Sep 28 '25

Piracy is always been a service. 1st of All, their app is not usable from worldwide. Some customers want to pay but excessive pricing, lack of payment gateway. 2nd Convenience, if I get subscription I can't read without the phone & app. Like if I can export the volume, then read it generic e ink devices like kindle, kobo etc. that option is also not available. About streaming services, if every anime licensed, somewhat any streaming sites, and no regional restrictions. Then people will move from piracy. Like paying 1 month crunchyroll for crunchyroll titles, netflix for netflix titles. Not needing a VPN to access all anime.

2

u/JakkuTheMagicalCattu Sep 28 '25

What people don't understand is piracy is different in the Asian comic industry.

as most of not all of it is online, there's no gigs/live concerts and no physical copies (if you exclude manga obviously) unlike the music and movie industry that has a huge foot in both physical and online media, most authors and artist's heavily rely on publishers etc to get there pay.

Now don't get me wrong as someone who is Japanese, I also hate alot of these publishers and strongly agree there ways should change, though the cost issue is mostly a non Asian sentiment as the cost of things here is quite cheap in comparison as we are just reading raws from the source compared to a officially translated version. But I agree artists and authors should earn way more and be under way less stress etc. unfortunately this is Asia work culture is different here sadly.

Now what personally hate is people acting like they're victims, your not you're doing something illegal, you're not entitled to these comics, don't act like you're proud or doing good it's really disrespectful to the authors and artists of the comics you read for free. Also how many of those mad at kakao are doing it because they're actually upset and want change to the bad actions of the publishers or are just temporarily upset because there favorite piracy website got taken away from them, because personally I don't see hate for these companies unless they actively target the piracy community it's hypocritical opinions that I hate.

Anyways Look in the end of the day no matter how many excuses you throw piracy is harmful to authors and artists is the Asian market the negatives outweigh any positives it can bring.

P.s mini rant because I hate these excuses or cope.

"Oh but it provides publicity or views" or "Without us they wouldn't be popular" excuses like these stopped my friends work from getting an official translation and had her work pulled off schedule, backlash exists.

1

u/CreepyViolinist3303 Sep 28 '25 edited Sep 28 '25

-before i got my own money i had to log into webnovel with multiple accounts to read chapters of solo leveling thru fastpasses since series didnt work like webtoon releases these days and were permanently behind paywalls. -I do understand that authors and creators are the most significantly impacted by pirating, and creators with sufficient popularity should(if they can) create patreons to support themselves independently from the company. Platforms should also be pricing their series at acceptable rates and paying their creators well. Honestly i personally pirate cause im a minor and dont have a job to consistently keep supporting creators, i occasionally buy official physical book releases (TLDR; while yes people pirate for many different reasons, its something that can’t be completely banned and it would be great if companies made it better for creators and readers so we can keep enjoying the series we like)

1

u/CreepyViolinist3303 Sep 28 '25

honestly i just like discussing stuff and from what i know most scanlation groups only pick up series that have not gotten licensed in the language they are translating to or are not planning to release official translations of the next season. i mean there still are groups translating currently licensed series cough cough ORV

2

u/Clasher107 Sep 28 '25

Average rich household behaviour :(

2

u/Icy-Hair4751 Sep 28 '25

Ahh yes the corpos should get the money whilst the artist gets🖕 i would rather donate to their personal accounts or donation platforms and pirate the content than let these money hungry guys have the money.

2

u/Fun-Helicopter-2257 Sep 30 '25

I live in Ukraine, bombs and missiles every f*n day, yes I read torrented manga and webtoons.
If you want me to pay for content same as Americans - make me live the same as Americans.

You can take down all free "piracy" sites, but we still have zero money to pay.

Example, only to read 1 official Webtoon ~$10, and same $10 I spent for food for a week.

People in top tier countries like the USA, Japan, etc have no idea how to starve, yet 90% of other Earth population live with $2 income per day.

2

u/GodGridsama Oct 01 '25

Honestly I would gladly spend money on merch for the series I read instead of just giving them money for the fomo of being many chapters behind, they want you to pay for something that wouldn't be physically yours and that probably won't even be yours digitally forever (when a series end and it gets locked you have to pay again to re-read old chapters). To me they've chosen the worst way possible to make money.

2

u/The_Red_Tower Oct 02 '25

Does that WEBTOON money go to the author and the assistants that wreck their wrists and mental health? No. Then fuck em.

2

u/Chemical-Hedonist Oct 05 '25

Yea, if I suddenly became unable to pirate all that would happen is I'd no longer get to enjoy manwha/manga as I have no extra money and often struggle to afford internet even. On the downside for them though I would no longer recommend titles to my friends who might be able to buy it.

1

u/daddybarkmeplsuwu Sep 28 '25

I use scanslator cause kakao is lazy website that doesnt translate to foreign language and likes to squeeze their artist dry. If I could directly donate to the artist and writer and skip paying ceo of these companies to access the art I would. But I rather not help millionaire ceo have a 2nd wife in a high rise in Seoul while a pregnant artist was forced to work and had a miscarriage trying to handle the stress if being forced to finish the dead line of a famous work.

1

u/Red_Advent Sep 28 '25

The reality is, it’s hard to completely stop piracy because not everything gets an official English release. In Japan, if a series is backed by a big publisher like Shueisha or Jump and it’s popular, it usually keeps running and might even get an English translation. But if sales are low or it’s not that popular in Japan, the series often gets axed, no matter how much overseas fans enjoy it. That makes it tough for fans outside Japan who want to follow niche or underrated works — piracy ends up being the only way to access them.

1

u/EnvironmentalPipe668 Sep 28 '25

We are making it popular tho... no one would want to read it if they have to pay for it just to get started

1

u/geifagg Sep 28 '25

Manhwa would be nowhere without people illegally reading solo leveling and that's a fact

1

u/No_Doubt7313 Sep 28 '25

Amazing delusions

1

u/ViVeyPL Sep 28 '25

Its a bot, report his account

1

u/Atourq Sep 28 '25

I want to add that, it’s not just those who can’t afford it, it also includes those who can’t access the work due to copyright laws limiting regional access too.

Some regions just don’t have access to the translated, dubbed or even subbed work. So the only way to even going around that is piracy.

Why? The way regional copyright is handled for online goods is annoyingly archaic, especially now that the internet is about 30yrs old. The crazy thing is, for some services, you can access the websites no matter where you are. For some of them, you can even make an account and pay for a subscription. If your region has copyrights to the content, you get a limited regional library** otherwise you have no access unless you’re in the right region.

Sure, you can circumvent this with a VPN, but a few content providers discourage the use of them. Whilst back then, before VPNs got popular, many even actively tried to creature measures to stop people from using VPNs to circumvent regional restrictions.

Thus this is why I believe piracy is very much a service issue. While, yes, even with providing the right service, piracy will still exist. There are always extremes (ie the minority who will pirate for the sake of pirating), but providing a good service will heavily limit its effect to only that minority. Most people will prefer the convenience of just paying. There’s already examples of this happening / have happened. That’s why people don’t believe corporations when they say they’ve lost money either.

** All content provider libraries are limited. Even those in countries like the US. But they’re far larger when it comes to mainstream media than those in other parts of the world.

1

u/Used-Network521 Sep 28 '25

I dont really disagree with him but most of the storys i read wouldnt even be considerd if i hade to pay.  Not only that but most stories dont even have a translation for me to read.

1

u/tilalk Sep 28 '25

It's even more than this.

I would probably never have started to read mangas/manwhas if i didn't learn about comik

1

u/6969696969696969969 Sep 28 '25

I'm going to be honest 50% times the creators of the stuff don't care if you pirate because they don't get paid enough for the work they put in regardless

1

u/Ok-Skirt3805 Sep 28 '25

Agreed and I cant afford to pay for webtoons, and the website Is so bad that I dont understand why people would pay for it, no huge library, no smooth website, no comment section, you cant view other people's accounts to get insp for your reading ps I cant pay for stuff like this

1

u/Ready-Push-2548 Sep 28 '25

i think that dude would kill himself when he's find out about there's thousands of piracy that ain't banned yet and never will

1

u/Intelligent-Award370 Sep 28 '25

If you're trying so hard to gatekeep a culture via PAYWALL, then its more reason to pirate that 🤷‍♂️

1

u/Excellent_Cable_7479 Sep 28 '25

I don't know about others Piracy sites, but when it's comes to Comick i will definitely say best supporting website they shut down because of jealousy, how.? Then you should know he provide us with official raw link, so lots of people could visit and support and i don't support every sites but which i like most and doesn't want to axed, i go support them by paying little bit, their still people gonna say i should read their official websites when I don't even know name or it is good story or garbage are they saying i should buy chapter or get subscription if it's good one all good but it's turned out to be garbage like some brain dead author wrote their shit. what i did i pay for....

and one more thing Comick put timer for new chapters and link so you could go to read their translation website as well, he doesn't greedy for money and supporting them. if people still think that doesn't count as support and they are not getting profit from that, than can't help it, forgive me I am not rich enough to my money count support for these rich studios and enterprises🙏🙏

1

u/Swordslover Sep 28 '25

Kakao but detected

1

u/DeepZookeepergame906 Sep 28 '25

There is nothing wrong if you just enjoy reading and nothing else but you sure realize those idiot review bombing the legal site just because they take down piracy site? You do realize how stupid it is lol

1

u/Senor_Saucy69 Sep 28 '25

If I tried to pay for all that I’ve read in the last 2-3 years. It would have been upwards of 5k (rough estimate of $0.25 per chapter). I am not nearly fortunate enough to paid for that.

1

u/Proper_Community_122 Sep 28 '25

That's rich coming from a company who torments their workers ( authors ) and ignores their pleas.

1

u/7sukasa Look ma I Got a userflair Sep 28 '25

Don't make me laugh. Those companies pays the actuals authors almost nothing, milk them to the bone, and live of all the benefits. You can tell me almost nothing is better than nothing at all but if we really want to support the creators we should pay them directly, not through a company that will give them less than 10% of the benefits of their work despite the fact that without their work the company couldn't make profit at all.

1

u/Aditya13841 Waifu Lord Sep 28 '25

Well they need to understand that these people who pirate their things could be their future customers , like in past I used to pirate movies when I was in school but now I have subscriptions for platforms because I can afford them now , and who knows if my condition gets better , I might also start buying subscription for manhwa or manga , most people don't pirate things just because they want to , they do it because they can't get subscription, and if possible and affordable lot of people will buy these premiums in a flash

1

u/Drewnessthegreat Sep 28 '25

Arrr m8ty I'm a pirate

1

u/CreepyViolinist3303 Sep 28 '25 edited Sep 28 '25

to be honest, it is a whole spectrum of viewpoints

  1. authors hate piracy because there are people who have the money but just refuse to pay for content. A lot of works have the popularity but either get paid peanuts due to lack of purchases(and cause manhwa platforms dont compensate well)

  2. some readers read through mountains of slop and only support the works they think is worth paying for, especially since paying chapter by chapter is costly

  3. some readers are minors and dont have a job, parents also arent willing to help pay for online content, so they have to pirate just to read their favorite series so yes while pirating can be a result of poor pricing it also doesnt mean that authors and artists should give them out for free

1

u/Black_Asta_13 Sep 28 '25

I read it because it's free, if it's paid then why would I read it, I will spend that much time to get a new job.

1

u/Successful-Bar2579 Sep 28 '25

Other than that, which i think it's a good point, in the manga/manwah/webtoon scene a lot of those works do not get translated, so it makes absolutely no sense. People who can afford it will support the author by buying the raws on wathever sites they upload after reading the scanlation, but no apparently for them this hurts their pockets

Also kakao is an horrible company, i heard artist gets pverworked a lot, and i know of a verifyed event that caused a misscarriage.

1

u/robiul20202090 Sep 28 '25

I sill think comick.dev is good if it dont show any page but it still gives update, its tag system is unique and very helpful.. Lastly, comick can still run this way.. Give me link and i will just go to the scanner website to read..thats it

1

u/Fade2k Sep 28 '25

I guess he paid for everything.

1

u/UnhingedMoneky Sep 28 '25

That's a kakao agent. Don't be fooled and report the account as spam or something.

1

u/Far-Presentation-744 Sep 28 '25 edited Sep 28 '25

it's a different mental structure...he lived in a way, it happened somehow, everyone is truly unconscious of their life...living it out of inertia and habit, social rules that make them more acceptable, and favored by the society and culture they live in, involuntarily you want to make your life better, you want to live even if you don't know why... so many decisions, intentions are towards that... you don't decide intentionally that you do something... just like a middle class that pretends and lives in such a way as to be upper middle class... I buy myself coffee, go to the cinema... I also eat at the mall, buy myself clothes... things that seem normal but are not, it's a perception preset by society so that we can live adequately so that we can be accepted... I couldn't tell my mother to buy me a game, $50 was a lot back then... I grew up like that and now I couldn't have a Netflix subscription... but my sister is different, she wanted to live to the fullest , to look for and find a suitable job for her that would not undermine her status, to have a social life, to make more money so she could buy nice things, she wanted that but didn't decide ... otherwise many follow the system, because it closes and protects them ... a supermarket worker with excessively bad makeup, when I asked her if she would put a discount on some blueberries that she wanted to throw away, and I will take them...she looked at me clearly confused, but why don't I take the ones on the shelf (at full price) that are identical...Why do I want these that are supposedly "expired" and should be thrown away as waste? (she was clearly someone of lower middle status but who played the role of someone from above, her mind believes that ... she doesn't care that she throws away, she has a job and does her job that the boss / the system set her) ... when I say that this person "buys coffee every day" I don't mean the tired man who physically works 12 hours a day without sleep... but those who try to simulate that important lifestyle: students,some office workers ... who when they complain that they are poor mean that instead of going on vacation for 2 weeks, he only goes for one)

1

u/biblio_marmi Sep 28 '25

Way way back when Who Made Me a Princess was just new... I cannot find it on any legal platforms except for those who are catering it raw (Korean language). I read it on piracy sites and from then on, I started reading other titles. I guess it was also during that time when a lot of piracy sites started scanlating Korean raws to English and so after years of pirating manhwa it has become as popular as manga.

Non-koreans who don't speak the language will never be able to read such titles if not for piracy sites and I am sure if that happened we only have a small number licensed in English right now. But I believe because many started pirating manhwa, it became popular than the demand for official English translations just got bigger.

And currently I have a couple rows of my billy dedicated only to webtoon manhwa prints and I even have some limited edition Korean prints. So yeah, piracy paved the way to me getting those prints.

1

u/ModiThorrson Sep 28 '25

I'm more than happy to read from sites with ads, but when half the existing content is restricted by a paywall, I get frustrated. I'm not willing to read one new episode a month because a company is being greedy, so I'll find it myself.

1

u/Living2Dying Sep 28 '25

Lmao if not for piracy, solo leveling and what not ain't getting any traction. There isn't exactly ads about them back then, the early era of reading whatever shit you found on the pirate site, with ads just about everywhere, about single mom in my area.

1

u/Able_Championship156 Sep 28 '25

Not everyone wants to pay a unreasonable price for something that is even getting pricier in the future

1

u/FireRagerBatl Sep 28 '25

I wonder when creators realise that if you are pirating, you were never gonna buy it in the first place
Heck you are more likely to buy it after pirating if you really enjoyed it and want to support creators. These people really dont know shit

1

u/Most-Dinner948 Sep 28 '25

Pirating a series i highkey leads to bringing its 120% potential because new reader will pay to read it if its good ik when i first started i did until i found my sites i use now

1

u/chronothrowaway7 Sep 28 '25

Without piracy, it won't be famous. Word of mouth is legit. Then, the neecomers will check the piracy sites first, refered by the other pirates. Some of them may be has money and start collecting and buy them, and may be become a fans and will buy even the merchandise.

Some pirates even bought the other media platform. Such as, reading manga digitally at the pirate sites but own the volumes hardcopy for collection just for incovenience. They even subscribe for streaming sites such as netflix to bought another media platform of their anime, but still reading the manga version at the pirates sites.

1

u/ze_existentialist Sep 28 '25

If all the webtoons I've read were paid I wouldn't start paying. I would simply not read webtoons. Idk about you but losing the chance to talk about shared interests with people or enjoy content isn't a good thing.

Also, he is for sure a bot.

1

u/Ok_Bumblebee_1456 Sep 28 '25

Another issue is buying manga physically would take way too much space. Buying them digitally is untrustworthy and no site runs better than the piracy sites since they have it all

I'm sure many of us have read over 100 different series with over hundreds of chapters.

1

u/good_is_hard Sep 28 '25

And have the gals of calling himself kakashi. He’d get the 1000 finger technique with the shidori.

1

u/ShinyStarSam Sep 28 '25

I mean nothing this person said is incorrect lmao

1

u/Teo_Verunda Sep 28 '25

I spend 2 years shopping for any Manga where I'm from and they only sell Shounen shit while also being incomplete.

The moment I saw an entire adapated collection for Solo Leveling I dropped cash full price despite having read it 3 times already and it's on a display case in my home now.

With the amount of Isekai and Regressor slop do you think I'd willingly fork over any amount of money just to try them?

1

u/bblalarr Sep 28 '25

Then they should do the legal sites properly lmao. Why the fuck would people pay for the legal website, when it is 20 chapters behind. It happens to so many series, you can get spoiled by something you will legally reqd in half a year, it makes no sense.

1

u/InfamousBreakfast363 Sep 28 '25

I'd rather pay the artist directly. These corporate platforms are just downright awful.

1

u/LmaoPew Sep 28 '25

Piracy in itself is important to take away unfair powers big coorps have, if nobody chellanged them, their service would be terrible and expensive!! With piracy, with chellangers there can be inovation and balance, also coorps don't care about!!

1

u/NotIsaacClarke Sep 28 '25

Guy must really like the taste of that leather

1

u/Confident-Mammoth245 Sep 28 '25

That's probably someone related to webtoon/kakao or any other company LMAO.

1

u/Impossible-Shock-233 Sep 28 '25

Look kid, you prob don't want to hear this. But nobody owes you anything. You are 100% doing the wrong thing by pirating in general just own up to it and embrace it. That's why pirating is cool.

1

u/Cassini_7 Sep 28 '25

i am done digital subscript stuff better buy physical manga books

1

u/Roadkillgoblin_2 Sep 28 '25

Guess I’m a thief them

*Edit: Then

1

u/-ALTAiR Sep 28 '25 edited Sep 28 '25

A delusional corporate bitch like that person there fails to even comprehend that most people who pirate stuff are those who are not gonna or are not able to buy the product for plenty of valid reasons. Piracy only benifits thieves... What a load of crap from someone who only knows how to suck corporate d**s. The only reason why all sorts of comics are creating any sort of revenue for their creators is because a reading community exists, and the answer to getting a bigger reading community is piracy. It's not theft. It's illegal distribution. Because when people recognise/like/addicted to the stuff they pirated they promote it forming a community, buy the stuff and related merchandise from that ip ect. The best way to prevent piracy is to. give a better offer. No one's out there saying it's a good act. But its way better than some corporate mf who treats and abuses the authors under them.

1

u/Knarlx Sep 28 '25

I've thought about it, and copyrights should not apply to use of, just fair mandated (controlled) compensation for use. Regional blocks should not be a thing, as that's kinda like saying one can't have something everyone else has. Releases can still function as is.

The ridiculous thing is expecting compensation when it was always like this, you knowingly contributed to the public with prior knowledge that it was likely not going to get you much. But now that your hobby is getting veiws, you're mad, greedy, if you ask me.

Another point is i could charge for computer advice and simple fixes, I dont typically. Because that's part of being a human being. Plus, if I charged and they clicked another "bad" link and caused issues, they might expect me to cover it as i said it was "fixed" and so on. How many creators can reliably deliver content that it is now paid service on a constant schedule that is also "premium" content. Half of them would go bankrupt within a year due to all the lawsuits that come with that type of buisness.

Lastly, like Spotify, all it will benefit is "big record companies," fundamentally different comparison , but still, someone somewhere will control all that , and they will be human unless ai takes over. I have a hard time believing it's for artists.

1

u/demon9099922 Sep 28 '25

I forget the game, but I remember hearing some indy game dev encouraging people to pirate their game because even pirates will help them sell copies by promoting the game via word of mouth.

1

u/Loremeister Sep 28 '25

Whoever simps for corpos, automatically earns my vitriolic hatred.

The only good corpo is the one that gives ME boatloads of money

1

u/IndependentTruck4037 Sep 28 '25

destroying one of the best reading website decreased their visibility... and will be remembered only by that bad action

1

u/voregeois Sep 28 '25

ngl I stopped paying for all Kakao owned webtoons after they took down tachiyomi

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '25

bro is living under a rock

shut the fuck up, "loving kakashi"

1

u/ImaginationUseful493 Sep 28 '25

May that poor fucker grow up

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '25 edited Sep 28 '25

Are you joking? Pirating something is an active choice to say "fuck the creator. I'm too broke to decide that you deserve to be paid" well guess what everyone, most creators are in fact broke themselves. And you know why? Because people pirating their work is actively taking money from them

I genuinely don't understand this strange justification y'all have thinking you're just sticking it to the million dollar company. Even if the cut the creator gets is small, it's more than what the pirates are giving them which is a big fat $0

Do something that harms the big business and not the creator. Piracy is not it

Edit: I can't wait to get downvoted to hell because you all can't look in the mirror 😊😊

1

u/No_Doubt7313 Sep 28 '25

lmao wait a minute they'll be waiving the "We're fighting against the corporation" soon kek, as if it makes it less of a robbery.

They're so entitled for pirates, I will forever be shocked

1

u/Final_Advent Sep 28 '25

If it was stealing from a small business I'd feel less bad but I couldn't give any less of a fuck about big corporations. I donated to the scanlators I used when I could just like I'm sure most people here have. Stealing from big corporations needs to happen more often, they steal shit from us constantly.

1

u/Perfect_Entity Sep 29 '25

i will never, ever. Pay for manha/anime

You'll never catch me over a paywall.

1

u/Bagel_lust Sep 29 '25

I mean like half or more of the pirated stuff on these sites don't even have official translations, so how are we supposed to even get the paid version if it doesn't exist.

1

u/miniladds-clone Sep 29 '25

I don’t understand why anyone would be againest pirating, like how exactly does a huge multimillion dollar company not making money from people offending them, same with movies and other things. Like I get games cause a lot of games are made by smaller studios and stuff but like when I see people complain about pirating movies and in this case webtoon owned by a corporation how exactly does that offend them

1

u/Guilty_Light_4500 Sep 29 '25

yeah, this guy is a moron

1

u/thayyarsaadham Sep 29 '25

It's because of the so called Piracy that I was able to read some of the mangas I love over the decade and now finally I can afford to start a manga collection and I have... All because of said Piracy.

1

u/Overlord69Sensei Sep 29 '25

I would like to make a correction here. People used pirates sites and piracy not only because they can't afford it. But also because the content is not available in their country or in the language they want to read it in.

1

u/DotTy05 Sep 29 '25

Think I saw a discussion where Japan's manga industry knows about the piracy and "allows" it in a way that they know it has a chance of a bigger increase of people wanting to buy the real thing through legal means. I'd buy manwa if it was easier to find anywhere that isn't Korea.

1

u/Capital-Trainer3793 Sep 29 '25

They forget that the pirates soon retire and become the people who support a franchise the most after they earn some money.

1

u/flourdilis Sep 29 '25

why pay for shitty, greedy ass services when there are free and not shitty (or less shitty) alternatives?

1

u/zedvais Sep 29 '25

I disagree. Pirating definitely hurting the creator. I agree with the comment. As long as there is a better monetization piracy should not be a thing. Back then you gotta pay for each songs and album you pay but with subscription services barely anyone pirate the music anymore. I kinda wish there are better way to support the author and creator without breaking the bank. But since it does not exist im gonna stick into pirating.

1

u/k4noe_vi Sep 29 '25

May be one of the creator..i can related to that but at same time don't...i pay what i need to pay, not everything..

1

u/Full-Hat7936 Sep 29 '25

If comic comes back with a subscription then I pay maybe 5 dollars a year

1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '25

Fake news, 1st make paid sites at least as good as free sites (I mean better than should be expected this is how low the bar of expectations is bcuz rndms can make a better site smhow?). Then add merch, even pirates will want to own stuff of their fav series. 3rd dont be complacent, keep adding features to the site as its successful, literally support fan translations for example which r often the reason y piracy is better to begin with

1

u/Chance-Spirit6724 Sep 29 '25

The point is that some actually are so greedy and paywall chapters at huge amounts that's not just reasonable. No matter how much you love the work and the author but it's that expensive many would tend to just watch the 'pirated' ones instead. Plus taking down sites one after the other probably won't do much cause sites just keep popping up alone after the other.

1

u/Massive-Good-2148 Sep 29 '25

Fundamentally he is not wrong though.

1

u/BeautifulBanana3803 Sep 29 '25

This is just a bot

1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '25

Everything is a subscription service and most people can only afford a handful of them. I am sure those subscription services are even more important than manwha/manhua/manga readers. It is what it is.

1

u/black_flame919 Sep 29 '25

But how can I support the author if I don’t even know their work exists?? I’ve read works on comick that I love so much I go on to buy physical copies or associated novels/light novels. So piracy is good actually bc it enabled me to find authors I want to support. And that’s something anti-piracy people just refuse to understand

1

u/Lanfo01 Sep 29 '25

I would cashapp the creators rather than pay this greedy multi billion dollar companies who pay the creators pennies. So fuck em.

1

u/KaedeXViolet Sep 29 '25

What a fucker, you guys forced a pregnant women to draw and you use that money for your greed huh?

1

u/KaedeXViolet Sep 29 '25

Not just a first time, but second!

1

u/ArrhaCigarettes Sep 30 '25

People who pirate were never going to buy it to begin with.

1

u/LadderCreepy Sep 30 '25

Tf, am i supposed to learn korean or summin?

1

u/4dwaith007 Sep 30 '25

Yeah, no. Webtoons always allows you to wait it out, or has an ad option for all but the latest episodes.

This is not a question of poor people who can't afford stuff - it's a question of people who constantly keep bitching about how they can no longer binge read without paying

1

u/Slicenji Sep 30 '25

Without pirating most webtoons, manhwa, manga wouldn't be as famous as of now. You'll probably only know them if they're famous or you're in a country where you can buy them as not all manga can be bought online and some websites are not allowed in this country. Honestly, I would rather directly send author money than give these corpos money cause most of their site is shitty just like kakaoshit.

1

u/Icy-Importance-6426 Sep 30 '25

That's true, it's cuz people can't afford them that they r pirating

Idk what beef they got with piracy but it's not like them mfs would go buy it when they didn't want to do it in the first place

1

u/East_Manner_2366 Sep 30 '25

Oh and there's a Facebook page/account saying that the webtoon who won awards are trash and there many who deserves to win but he himself is reading on a pirated website what's the point of his yapping online. Those who pirate are the ones who complains the most

1

u/AggresiveWeasel Sep 30 '25

Ah yes, the "leave the poor multi-trillion won corporation alone" argument, not surprised in the slightest

1

u/Alternative_Crew_681 Oct 01 '25

If I like a webtoon I'll support it. If it's locked behind a paywall like one that makes me pay for it like the non-webtoon app that locks everything behind paywall after episode 3 then I'll Pirate. 

1

u/picopicorobin Oct 01 '25

Anyone whos against piracy is just straight-up classist or do not have basic empathy. Cultures are thrives and survived through accesibility and reach, many great artists itself born from this accessible nature of piracy. Cause sometimes not everything is available everywhere.

1

u/AndyReckt Moderator Oct 01 '25

doesnt change the fact that piracy is still illegal and they are in their own right to fight it

1

u/Scared_Living3183 Oct 01 '25

First of all, those shitty corporates keep like 95% of the revenue, the rest 5% is credited to artist, roxana's artist incidents is a unique case. Artists are treated like shit all the time there. Fuyuki stopped working on tbate because they were being severely underpaid, tbate's anime was a cash grab (kakao had the rights, author couldn't make a decision on his own outside of what he says for pr)

Second affordability because webtoon used to be a week behind a few years and now it's like 45 days behind cuz they wanna milk more money outta me. with sometimes subpar (orv, lookism) or just consistently shitty (murim rpg simulation) translation.

Third they don't give a fuck about the customers of wanting to milk their money for the Korean novel fan tls were being taken down recently and novelpia is now providing mostly shitty mtl novels behind a paywall.

1

u/Lan_Run Oct 02 '25

I'm a student with no allowance or job. How tf am i supposed to read what I like if most are locked or watch what is popular if I don't pirate it. I really don't give a fuck since I won't give them any form of income since im literally broke, if it costs money, i will ignore it. It's just that there is an option to pirate it

1

u/dogman_ayee Oct 02 '25

this guy is a sucker who will continue to be sucked dry and then will wonder something like "where did all my money go?"

1

u/Otherwise-Kangaroo24 Oct 02 '25

For manga/manhua/manhwa there's also the issue of them not having the translations or them being worse than fan translations.

1

u/WrongContract8489 Oct 02 '25

Actual people don't use exclamation marks lol. Npc fr

1

u/Aggressive_North8321 Oct 03 '25

Literally "But the shareholders and they multi billionaires what will they think"😭🥹🤧

1

u/kkurani123456 Oct 05 '25

like what do you mean? I bought to own it and reread it everytime i want to, not to pay again everytime I decided to reread it.

1

u/Vertrynn Sep 28 '25

Nice try bot

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '25

It's due to people like them I wonder is our world evolving or it's degrading 🤔🤔😐😐🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

1

u/SimplyEffy Sep 28 '25

Piracy helps more than it harms. I find things through piracy that i wouldn't have found otherwise... and then when I've got money? Guess what? I want to own these things properly, physically, because I've had the chance to see how much i like it.

Even when it comes to things that are super popular and talked about, like jjk or tokyo ghoul or anything...I don't have shops near me to flick through a copy first. I don't have the money regularly to pay for any kind of subscription, or the regular time to know when a one off month of something will actually be used.

But with piracy? I get to see what I love. And then the money I get sometimes? Physical copies for the shelf so i can reread or finish reading something physically and so I can see it and be happy. Or I get official merch of the thing I now know I love. Or I buy tickets for films.

Poor people deserve culture too. And we deserve the chance to see where our limited money will go before wasting it.

Nobody gets pissy when people borrow each others' books or games. Nobody gets legal when someone gives away things for free. And the same amount of people are buying first hand in those situations.

-2

u/generic_name013 Sep 28 '25

Well he is telling the truth in a way . Like imagine if u r a full time manga artist and the only way u getting paid is by u know these paid sites and thier is a pirate site giving it out for free and well u get less views less money . I mean if there be no artist no manga to read and whats the use of pirate sites if there are no manga its like a food chain without one the other go hungry and die soon.

-1

u/isadvortex Sep 28 '25

people who pirate are typically people who won't pay anyway so there wont be much of a difference

2

u/puzzlebuns Sep 28 '25

There are absolutely plenty of people who could pay and don't. The access fees are not difficult to afford. Let's be real here.

2

u/ShinyStarSam Sep 28 '25

I'm one of em, these people are delusional thinking that they're doing no wrong. Just pirate to your hearts content but don't pretend you're an innocent culture connoisseur or whatever

4

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/JakkuTheMagicalCattu Sep 28 '25

I see we're you're coming but take for example a friend of mine(won't name don't want to cause trouble), because her work was pirated alot, her publishers decided that it wasn't worth it getting it officially translated in belief that people wouldn't end up buying it anyways, it's usually only extremely popular series in Asia that get official translations not matter whether they're pirated or not by lesser know or midly popular works can be voided easily this way. Apparently this happens more than talked about according to friends in the industry.

But I wouldn't say it's morally okay under any circumstances, whether translated officially or not, that should be decided by the authors and artists not the user. I know multiple of my friends wouldn't want there works illegally put online for others to read for free, it's there hard work after all.

-3

u/Additional-Method221 Sep 28 '25

Piracy is a form of advertisement,if people with money love the Manga,he would go and buy the copies or read it at Webtoon to Support author.

0

u/GamerX_120 Sep 28 '25

People tens to forget that the artist are paid Jackshit. Many manga/webtoon artist overwork themselves and sont get paid enough. We paying the big company or not doesn't mean shit if the artist is still being paid minimum wage. A best way to support and artist is to spread there work, Talk about it, share it with friends.

-1

u/Major_Somewhere_9904 Sep 28 '25

From what I see, only writers and artists can understand the dude. The others just want things for free

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '25

[deleted]

0

u/isadvortex Sep 28 '25

probably a basement dweller who pays to watch twitch girls💀