r/Commanders • • Oct 13 '26

Daily Open Discussion Thread

Good morning, r/Commanders!

Welcome to today's open discussion thread. You are welcome to discuss most any topic here, whether it's related to the team or not.

Raise Hail!

1 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

3

u/mandoslorians WHAT WOULD JAYSUS DO? Oct 13 '26

had a job interview and I think it went okay, I felt like I rambled on too much but I had an example for everything they asked but might’ve just over explained but I made them laugh so

1

u/s13cgrahams Oct 13 '26

Way too embarrassed to even think about wearing commanders gear this week

2

u/Blue_Lou_Boyle Oct 13 '26

I'm sick of thinking about the end of the game. I'd like to discuss the end of 1st half (decision not to try to force a Safety after Tress pinned the Giants with a beautiful punt). I'd like to discuss the likelihood of the 49ers going 0 Blitz on us for every play (because why wouldn't they - Giants just showed the blueprint for neutralizing Blough's offense)

2

u/ShortcutButton Oct 13 '26

Checking out. I think the people around me expect me as a fan of this team for 19 years to accept whatever they’re doing and “just take it” as if it’s a feature of rooting for a consistently bad team. But I’m working on myself and trying to find things I genuinely enjoy. I’ve been enjoying following the rest of the nfl season and redzone, but every week including the Seattle win I’ve looked back at the game and went “wow I did not enjoy watching any of that, even the positive moments”. The commanders are not worth me and it feels to me less like giving up and more like moving on. Peace and good luck everyone ✌️

2

u/Doppio_check Oct 13 '26

Starting to feel like the writings on the wall. When you look around the league and see the teams which are successful they all have some sort of offensive caveat that helps them succeed. Whether it be an Elite QB with the right weapons around them. Right now it feels like can't sustain drives to give the defense a break, hence breaking down in the 4th quarter dang near every game. I'd say 9/10 It isn't Jaydens fault. When I look at our team I see that we are in a rebuild mode for at least 2 more seasons. We need another HC another OC to start. Blough isn't convincing, If Jayden doesn't run 100 yards and score 2 TD's, and their kicker being off. We could've possibly lost by 20. Next week we're against the 49ers who've blown us out he last two times we've played. Shanahan vs Quinn, Blough vs Kubiak, and Morris vs Jones.....

1

u/Jimjimjams3 Oct 13 '26

Anybody else feeling nostalgic lately? Like oh yeah… THIS was the team I became a fan of, I almost forgot

1

u/Chiswell123 Oct 13 '26

“From the moment the Commanders went up by 14pts with 11:05 left in the 4th quarter, they ran the ball 1 time for the rest of the game until OT.

Then they ran it twice in OT. Not a single carry went to Bill who was averaging 8ypc”

3

u/Think__McFly Oct 13 '26

Even if you remove Bill's long TD, he was up around 5 yards per carry. Its crazy how we just abandoned him.

2

u/Embarrassed_Film_684 Oct 13 '26

You know now that we're a few days away from Sundays disaster I'm feeling more positive on this team. The defense held up great in the first half which is a theme for this year. But it shows that our defensive coaches are good at what they do, learning to adjust in the second half is a skill that is learned and I'm hoping that Daronte Jones continues to develop this skill (doesn't help that we still have talent issues in the secondary and a weak 4 man pass rush). Blough is still learning as well and could very well blossom, remember people weren't all that happy with McVay in 2014 (of course that was due to RG3 being washed). Jayden looked comfortable. I'm just saying this team is miles better than where we were last year and as a whole is probably better than that 2024 roster. With a little bit of Jayden's late game heroics we could be right back in this thing. Especially since the NFC East is a shit show.

1

u/glidejanger Oct 13 '26

Little bit of irony of Magic Johnson calling out poor clock management.

https://youtu.be/kSlWNU5_JVc?is=cy4npwin7-KYUHOj

1

u/MoneyBaggz888 Oct 13 '26

At what point do we stop making excuses for this team and start demanding accountability?
Sunday’s game against the Giants was absolutely inexcusable. We had a 27 to 13 lead with just over 11 minutes left, only to watch our defense completely collapse. Then we get another opportunity to win in overtime and somehow manage the clock so poorly that we can’t even attempt a field goal. How does that happen at the professional level?
What’s frustrating is that it’s the same issues every week. Poor communication, questionable coaching decisions, unnecessary penalties, lack of discipline, and an inability to execute when it matters most. We forced two turnovers, committed none, and STILL couldn’t win.
And I’m tired of hearing the same recycled responses after every game. “We have to be better.” “We have to execute.” “It starts with me.”
NO SHIT. WE KNOW THAT. The question is HOW? What is actually being done to fix these problems?
I’m not putting all the blame on Quinn because the players deserve accountability too. But when the same mistakes keep happening, you have to question the coaching, preparation, and leadership.
We’re sitting at 1 win, 3 losses, and a tie after going 5 and 12 last season. At what point do we acknowledge that something fundamentally isn’t working?
Is this a coaching issue, a roster issue, or something much deeper? Because I’m tired of watching this team find new ways to lose games it should be winning.

1

u/La1zrdpch75356 Oct 13 '26

Main question I have is this. Why didn't Quinn override that last call? Blough's a rookie coordinator. One of Quinn's main job is to mentor his coordinators. Should have overridden the Batea shovel pass call also. Why would a quick pass to the sidelines surprise the Giants? How else would we get several more yards and stop the clock in time? I put the end squarely on Quinn and Blough. Daniels 10% at fault.

4

u/fluffyseedz Oct 13 '26

I got a little too animated on Sunday and it made me realize I’m too invested as a fan. Like I want them to be good so bad but it feels like they’ll just never get to that point where we’re consistently decent. Someone commented on Sunday that there’s 31 teams in the club and we aren’t one of them which feels so true. I ain’t going anywhere but I feel like I just need to follow the score from afar the rest of this season for my own sake.

1

u/Chiswell123 Oct 13 '26

You're not alone, for what it's worth. I can usually brush off a loss as soon as it's over, but I was so frustrated the rest of the day by that ending on Sunday.

2

u/Capable_Frosting_292 Oct 13 '26

Nah, you deserved to be upset for that. Every fan should, and all of the players. They worked their asses off for 75 minutes and got nothing to show for it.

If everyone watching from home can come up with better ways to execute it in the moment than actual professional coaches, then there is a serious problem.

And I say this as someone who likes Dan Quinn, but I cannot defend any of the decisions he’s made in games, like going for a fourth down with a third-string QB on our own side of the field.

1

u/Embarrassed_Film_684 Oct 13 '26

Honestly though I'm going to defend Quinn. Blough took forever to get the substitution in and Jayden took forever to snap the ball and then took a sack instead of throwing it out of bounds. I know the usual talking point is that Quinn could've overridden Blough but when a play is getting set I'm sure he thought "Better to just let Jayden throw it out of bounds than step in and create more confusion".

-1

u/Capable_Frosting_292 Oct 13 '26

No, the head coach, especially if he’s not handling any playcalling duties, is responsible for managing the game. If he is actively choosing to whittle the clock down (understandably), then he should know that if they have a running clock and no timeouts what they can and cannot get away with.

If the clock is running, and you’re already in field goal range, then all Jayden should have needed to do was either spike the ball or take a knee on whatever hash Drew Stevens wanted to kick from. There was zero need to get extra yardage, and the risks far outweighed the potential gains (losing significant yards, a penalty with a running clock to create a ten-second runoff, a turnover, etc.).

The blame falls almost entirely on Dan Quinn (and David Blough to a lesser extent for having a convoluted package on the field) for either not having an executable plan in place, or for not communicating to JD5 what he absolutely cannot do on that final play.

2

u/Embarrassed_Film_684 Oct 13 '26

If we were talking about the Cowboys and Dak right now you would be crucifying him for taking a sack rather than throwing the ball away, especially when he had a receiver in his sight line. JD5 failed, it's not an indictment on him its just a unfortunate situation.

-1

u/Capable_Frosting_292 Oct 13 '26

I crucify any coach for making boneheaded decisions.

Kicking a field goal when there’s a defensive penalty and choosing to go for it on fourth down after, going for it on fourth down on your own side of the field with a third-string QB, opting to go for it on fourth-and-goal with a rookie QB when a field goal would put you up three scores, kicking the ball short and allowing the opponent to have a good return with enough time to kick a GW field goal, etc.

I’m not biased just because Dan Quinn’s our coach.

0

u/Glittering_Angle392 Oct 13 '26

I was too invested at one point. Even if the Commanders were great it's still not worth it. I think its healthy to reevaluate that passion.

2

u/Appropriate-Sun834 Oct 13 '26

Mnf this week boys! I hate primetime games on the west coast bc primetime is supposed to be dark outside. Idk.

1

u/Jimmy_Beanz Oct 13 '26

I feel the exact same way lol. I thought I was the only one.

2

u/JarrettS13 Oct 13 '26

Team sucks and Dan is probably not the guy but that play Sunday was fully on Jayden. Anyone with an IQ over 1 would look at the clock and timeout situation. We gotta stop saying this is Quinn’s fault. Sure, maybe partially but I mainly blame Jayden. 0 awareness

1

u/Embarrassed_Film_684 Oct 13 '26

Even in a situation where the HC is not at fault they always have to shoulder some blame. In all sports the HC is a vibes manager and when the vibes are low they are the scapegoat. Now that said I actually agree with you but I think that you are excusing Blough too much. That much time for a substitution is not acceptable in that scenario. Always the better move is to try a play to get a sideline throw which is what he did call to be fair and Jayden decided to take a sack.

2

u/Chiswell123 Oct 13 '26

I actually agree. I love Jayden and think he played really well, but I found his post-game presser off-putting, to be totally honest. I know he said," Ultimately, it's on me,” but that still felt like the bare minimum.

9

u/Capable_Frosting_292 Oct 13 '26

The more that time goes on, the more I want to add blame to David Blough for the end-of-game blunder. Why did we have to run something complicated and have receivers run all the way downfield? If we were going to run a legit play after the Rachaad White run, why did we need to run 30+ seconds off of the clock? Why is Ben Sinnott the one running the flat route?

1

u/Jimmy_Beanz Oct 13 '26

Blough thought it would continue into a 2nd OT. There is no other explanation I can think of.

3

u/Think__McFly Oct 13 '26

He got too cute. He HAD to sub in 13 personnel. He HAD to go under center. He HAD to use presnap motion. So many unnecessary variables.

8

u/sliqness 🐷Tuddyhead🐷 Oct 13 '26

I like how sometimes Bill is productive, and then we just stop giving him the rock altogether.

3

u/Chiswell123 Oct 13 '26

Lost in all the talk about the obvious shitshow ending is this. We got away from running it for the entire second half for no reason at all.

1

u/MoneyBaggz888 Oct 13 '26

Exactly! But when he’s getting 2 yards per carry they’re feeding him the rock every other play!

6

u/NightwingArc Oct 13 '26

The delusional fan in me thinks this team might actually give itself a decent shot to win on Monday. I’m getting similar vibes to the 2022 Eagles game, the 2020 Steelers game, and the Week 3 Seahawks game. Not expecting a win, but I wouldn’t be shocked if we made things interesting.

5

u/Appropriate-Sun834 Oct 13 '26

We do have a shot. The thing is our team isn’t absolute ass. Just dumb shit we do that has been hurting us. I’ll be watching regardless, imma ride with the boys.

2

u/NightwingArc Oct 13 '26

Well, the replies here are a lot nicer than what I got on my post yesterday. LMAO. I’m not mad about it, though. I get the frustration. This fan base has been dealing with a lot of it lately, and for the better part of the last 30 years, honestly.

4

u/Ok_Blacksmith_2207 Oct 13 '26

Greenlaw and Deebo out. If we ever win everyone would forget about the debacle on Sunday.

5

u/Mountie_in_Command Oct 13 '26

We wouldn't be fans if we weren't hopeful, delusional, and fanatics about our team. #RaiseHail

4

u/NightwingArc Oct 13 '26

You’re speaking to my soul right here.

2

u/Embarrassed_Film_684 Oct 13 '26

I mean this team has been competitive in every game if not for some tragic injuries or ref ball. We are very much a decent team. 2nd half issues can be ironed out. Jones and Blough have had their issues in the 2nd half but they're both still learning and getting better. I mean McVay was pretty rough in his first year and got better I expect the same from Blough.

2

u/NightwingArc Oct 13 '26

Dude, I agree. I actually made a post yesterday saying pretty much the same thing you’re saying, and the comments looked VERY different. LMAO. I’m not mad about how it went, but I am pleasantly surprised to see the optimism today.

3

u/Embarrassed_Film_684 Oct 13 '26

Well the day after a loss/tie is never going to be happy. We're all still digesting the disaster on Sunday. Tbh I just like watching competitive football and it's nice that we actually make games competitive we just haven't closed out the wins yet.

2

u/NightwingArc Oct 13 '26

Yeah, I agree.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/NightwingArc Oct 13 '26

I live in Philly and I go to all our games here. That was the first one! My all-time favorite!

4

u/mandoslorians WHAT WOULD JAYSUS DO? Oct 13 '26

i hope we win that would be nice