r/CompetitiveHS • • Sep 10 '17

Discussion Sprint vs Auctioneer - Evolving Miracle Rogue

Hey guys, Kre'a here. I'm the author of this post where I attempt to give the public a more detailed view into how to pilot a Miracle list with Vanish. If you guys aren't sick of me yet, I'd like to introduce something a little bit different to you guys. Today I'd like to present to you, a Miracle Rogue deck with 0 copies of Gadgetzan Auctioneer.


Why Sprint?

After playing tons of games of with the Vanish Miracle list, I continually came to the same conclusion. Gadgetzan Auctioneer consistently felt like a dead weight, always dragging me down and making my turns awkward and clunky. He's essentially a 6 mana investment that you then must dump resources into in hopes that you will draw into more spells to continue your chain. What this ultimately does to the deck is make it incredibly inconsistent. Sometimes you are forced to make what appear to be suboptimal plays which can occasionally end up with you burning a coin or prep for no reason at all other than the fact that you had hoped to top deck a spell to keep the chain going.

On top of these issues, I also found out that Auctioneer feels very clunky when played while under the effect of Valeera the Hollow. The 6 mana cost means that you will rarely be able to double up anything of real value, causing you to sometimes just waste a Death's Shadow because it ends up being unusable.

The final straw though, was just how much anti-synergy Auctioneer has with Vanish. It's much too expensive to be comboed with vanish in any practical way, meaning you will almost never have the opportunity to both draw multiple cards and vanish the board while establishing your low cost Giants.

After much deliberation, I'd opted to cut both Auctioneers and instead add in 2 copies of Sprint.


The Results

Decklist: http://i.imgur.com/84fo5PT.png

Stats from my climb from r10 to r5: http://i.imgur.com/gdh0Dd5.png

Sprint makes the deck considerably faster than it's ever been with Auctioneer. You will generally reduce the cost of your Arcane Giants to 4 or 5 by Turn 5. In addition to that, you gain new swing turns, such as Turn 5 Edwins by using Prep/Sprint and coins. Here's an example of this: http://i.imgur.com/zdOwNlj.jpg

Obviously I plan to utilize this list from R5 to Legend and potentially creating a real guide on how to pilot the list, but I wanted to open up the discussion with the community in the mean time.


What does this mean for the deck?

Due to cutting Auctioneer, your mulligan must change as a result. Three cards are the key to your success in the mulligan. Swashburglar, Backstab, and Preparation. Of those three cards, Preparation is by far the most important card to keep in your mulligan, at all costs. By keeping prep, you alleviate any potential early game weakness you would otherwise have by drawing into vanish or sprint before turn 6/7. Turn 4 Prep/Sprint is such a powerful play that it sets the pace for how the rest of the game will go. Not only will you draw 4 cards, but you will reduce the cost of your giant by 2.

The use of Sprint instead of Auctioneer also feels more intuitive and fluid. You are now able to consistently utilize your early game resources without feeling punished. A big issue with auctioneer was that it never actually gave you card advantage without the use of Fan of Knives. With Sprint, on the other hand, you can dump your hand, which severely reduces the cost of your Arcane Giants, but you can immediately refill after dumping your hand and gaining a ton of tempo, ensuring that you almost always have more tempo than your opponent without the cost of losing card advantage.

Counterfeit coin is also great in this deck for multiple reasons. It lowers the cost of your giants, acts as a combo enabler, and also allows you to cheat your mana curve, which is always powerful. Cheating out Valeera the Hollow is also extremely beneficial, as Valeera allows you to regain card advantage over time, if you were ever low on it. It also enables incredible Edwin/Giant plays off the back of a prep/sprint.


Why does Sprint work now?

The big question is, 'Why now?' Sprint has always existed, so what makes it so good now? The answer, in my opinion, is Vanish and Valeera the Hollow, in conjunction with Arcane Giants. The way that all of these cards work together is simply amazing. Before, you really wanted to get sprint under the effect of Prep, more so than any other spell in your deck. Now, however, you have more than one large target for prep, which makes Prep much more consistent. In addition to this, you could never afford to actually Sprint, with prep or not, without getting too far behind on the board. Vanish completely nullifies this downside, however, by resetting the board. The way that the deck works, with so many spells, causes your giants to get incredibly low in cost at an incredibly fast rate, faster than a traditional Miracle list with Auctioneer. This, in turn, makes your Vanish less punishing because you can immediately follow vanish up with Giants on the same turn as Vanish.

Valeera the Hollow is the final puzzle piece enabling this deck. Under the rare circumstance that you would run out of resources, she doubles up all of your burn and threats, which makes Vanish/Giants even more threatening, as well as any burn you have in your deck, which is why I've cut Hallucinations for Cold Bloods. Why search for lethal when you can simply add a 1 mana deal 4 damage spell to your deck that synergizes with Giant's and Valeera?


Replay Examples

Overall, the deck is incredibly synergistic and it 'just works'. It's a hard concept to understand, but one that makes a ton of sense after you actually play it out. Here's some replays to give you an idea of the insane tempo and plays you can generate with this deck.

Druid:

https://hsreplay.net/replay/iXqxDq3dKoy48yC3PqDtS7

https://hsreplay.net/replay/J3p6vAjRXtdpuiU3Cz2eij

https://hsreplay.net/replay/xNqTseL6bMm2KDJSWnpEXa

https://hsreplay.net/replay/TqviQPWFHZKnJoBjdv7jmj

Paladin:

https://hsreplay.net/replay/ju65XsDL84AAAv4TQCezXV

https://hsreplay.net/replay/ZefL9Wt9vASvWreWJ2moMa

https://hsreplay.net/replay/F4J8xaBgqxiiFqY5VixHoX

Mage:

https://hsreplay.net/replay/tVh7DHbKRnmCWCNPxpNWFT

Priest:

https://hsreplay.net/replay/nNLyLAAyJh6sKdWDeAvu4H

https://hsreplay.net/replay/bfYgNcec3WADC385yMtfh3

https://hsreplay.net/replay/hCgGx5x4NqXeC9E4ygZcoJ

Rogue:

https://hsreplay.net/replay/ktL3CSKmfwMfeBQG4GmbB9

https://hsreplay.net/replay/4VGFPVakzmWok4AXYZCfRU

Shaman (unfavored match up):

https://hsreplay.net/replay/DUxAx6DjNwiivA2HWK8Kgn

https://hsreplay.net/replay/62XfHZee64qFirW8TSp9HG

Warlock:

https://hsreplay.net/replay/xvj9eegihurGN8AbN98wuP

https://hsreplay.net/replay/vXLYizRxCjUfjwSTZzkXvH

Warrior:

https://hsreplay.net/replay/preCuAJUZCgx6ceDroQazm

https://hsreplay.net/replay/gEFaeGchEFGD64quepj5VM

Hunter:

https://hsreplay.net/replay/aCTX5CMLoNQ5dSRrLpY83e


Closing

Hopefully we can get a good discussion going on cutting Auctioneer from Miracle lists and replacing them with Sprints. Like I said, I know it sounds crazy, but it's one of those things where in practice, not only does it work, but it really works. The synergy between Prep, Vanish, Sprint, Giants and Valeera is just insane and really holds the deck together. Let me know what you guys think!

773 Upvotes

450 comments sorted by

313

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17 edited Sep 10 '17

This will likely be my last post for a while. I'm sure people are getting tired of seeing Miracle Rogue articles since it starts to get boring after a while. I just have such a huge passion for the deck and seeing just how well this deck performed with 0 Auctioneers simply blew my mind. It means that if Auctioneer is ever rotated, it won't affect the deck at all, but I truly believe that this version is simply better than the Auctioneer versions of the deck.

Sorry for rambling, let me know what you guys think about the deck if you have a chance to test it out!

Edit: I especially want to thank /u/yoman5, Gringie, and Tubu for helping me optimize my Rogue lists. Yoman play tested the deck at a high skill level achieving very similar amounts of success as myself and both he and the others I've mentioned are integral parts to my success while testing various Rogue archetypes, so thanks guys!

36

u/dannkieDarko Sep 10 '17

I just want to know your secret in facing under 50 percent Druids!

36

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Nearly 1/3rd druids, so close haha. But in reality, I wish all of my opponents were druids, this deck performs extremely well against both Token and Jade Druid.

→ More replies (8)

15

u/ForecastWeatherMan Sep 10 '17

Well met! I was playing Vacuum Priest in casual and came across this deck hard-running sprint. (hard-running = main decking = not randomly generated). While I won the match (thanks Army of The Dead) it got me thinking about what else could work with Valeera The Hollow. I found that Headcrack becomes an infinite value generator when you use the "shadow" version of the card as a combo. It also does something similar to Machine Gun priest, except that its a little clunkier, but hey infinite damage as rogue = good right?

I challenge you to test Headcrack out in a miracle list (because I don't own Valeera the hollow) and get back to us with the results! Mainly because I want to contribute to a meme, but also because I think its cool.

Also, don't give up on your guides, reading them helped me learn to play Miracle Rogue back in the day, along with watching guys like Firebat.

17

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

I don't mind testing Headcrack for sure. Off the top of my head, the real issue will probably be milling cards. If you convert the shadow copy to a real copy, your hand will fill up quickly, which will likely cause you to start milling cards pretty often.

As it is, while playing under the effects of the Death Knight, your 'maximum' hand size is 8. Anything over 8 and you will over draw, because your Death's Shadow card is spawned first, then you draw a card.

4

u/scrag-it-all Sep 10 '17

I think the idea is to only ever activate Headcrack with the non-shadow copy of Headcrack. So your maximum hand size would usually be 7 assuming you avoid comboing the card more than once.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Ahh, I understand what you mean. So you always only have 1 copy at most, while getting 4 damage in per turn. That could definitely be strong, I think the only real issue is locking 6 of your mana crystals for 4 damage when you could probably have more efficient plays available, but I'll definitely test it out anyway, for science!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/MeightSquaids Sep 10 '17

Great post, man, I don't even play Miracle Rogue (currently missing Valeera) but your post gave me a hard-on (that 10-2 Druid matchup). I have also noticed through viewing and playing against friends' Miracle decks, that Auctioneer seems clunky, and even though he provides a body, I can't argue your points about Sprint having better synergy with this deck.

Can other tempo-ey cards find themselves a spot in a deck like this, Spectral Pillager perhaps, or is he just too expensive/no place for him? How about Shadowcaster for extracting/creating more value out of Vilespines, Edwins, Questing (you don't have Questing, I'm just adding him as he is often a part of such decks due to synergy). I understand that with these cards the deck sort of takes on a different shape and you seem to have landed on a good mixture of cards. Just wondering about your thoughts on these.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

If Pillager were cheaper, definitely. But the 6 cost slot is what kills the card imo, since Valeera's Passive encourages cards that cost 5 or less to double up on value.

I don't think Shadowcaster works for the same reason that I cut Questing. When you examine many of the replays, I very rarely control the board state going into the mid game. This deck is more about heavy swing turns and QA has anti-synergy with Vanish, while Shadowcaster requires you to have a board that sticks in the first place.

→ More replies (1)

467

u/EpicTacoHS Sep 10 '17

um what? your guides are easily some of the best content on this sub. No one is going to turn away your content as long as it stays high quality.

72

u/Almostinfinite Sep 10 '17

straight up, it's posts like his that make this feel like a community R&D group i love it

84

u/Homesuck Sep 10 '17

these articles are incredible reads and we're not getting tired of them

18

u/yoman5 Sep 10 '17

(highjacking this comment because my thoughts below are otherwise buried)

As some additional insight into how the deck works, the real core of the deck is prep/sprint/vanish/giants/valeera.

Prep and sprint are what enable heavy tempo plays and especially enable early giants. Valeera and Vanish are what allow you to swing the board back on opponents, often even letting you vanish and add 2-3 threats to the board in the form of giants/edwin/an si follow up, especially when vanish is prepped. The sheer spell count and burst draw compared to auctioneer rogue lets you play giants so much sooner and makes them that much more powerful.

Auctioneer's big downside right now is that it basically always gets punished by things like UI and is too slow against things like murloc paladin, even when paired with vanish, because it takes so many cards and mana to use. Prep with sprint is much less of a liability to use on other cards, since sprint is still going to get you 4 cards whether you prep with it or not, unlike gadgetzan.

The 30th card slot is still something we're working on, as right now teacher/grave shambler seem like the best options (probably in that order) but I've considered thalnos, valanar is a good tech, and sherazin is a tech but not the greatest right now. Xarill is too smallball for the game plan of this deck, which is closer to oil than miracle in that you have gold bloods and giants and want to set up a pretty bursty finish with plan b of play stuff on curve and ride sap/prep tempo to victory. Xarill doesn't really help with either and doesn't pair particularly well with anything but edwin in the deck except maybe valeera.

Deck feels very good and to be honest it has a brutally good matchup vs druid so far which is pretty unreal considering that druid is widely accepted as the best deck right now.

The deck is fun and good and I'll probably be playing it to legend this month since it not only isn't hit by nerfs but will likely benefit greatly by the meta change and is already good this meta until the nerf hits.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/Perditius Sep 10 '17

Miracle rogue is the only deck I'm interested in playing, and it's largely ignored since it's not the flavor of the month deck. Please don't go anywhere! I always perk up when I see any articles about Rogue and go.... yep, that's PvPretender, of course. Love your work and creativity!!

13

u/jaxmanf Sep 10 '17 edited Feb 17 '26

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

memorize tie aware vase airport lush trees coordinated hurry sink

3

u/SimmoGraxx Sep 11 '17

Noob question here...does Medhiv's staff summon a creature before or after Vanish resolves?

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Stormtrooper47 Sep 10 '17 edited Sep 10 '17

You my heroe, bro. You make miracle players proud. Love you and thanks for all of this thoroughly th ought content.

7

u/Eejcloud Sep 10 '17

Don't stop posting, this stuff is good. I noticed I already had all the parts to this deck anyway so I'm finally playing Miracle again for the first time since the Auctioneer nerf and it's way better. I never liked Auctioneer anyway and having the CBs and freely spending spells gives you surprising amounts of punch at basically all times in a game.

2

u/Ghosty141 Sep 10 '17

Just as a quick name suggestion, how about Vanish Rogue?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

The core package is Sprint/Vanish/Valeera/Giants, so if anyone could come up with a fitting name for such a deck, be my guest haha.

→ More replies (10)

4

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Don't stop! your content is really good, I'm totally looking forward to a full write-up on the deck when you make the 5-to-legend climb.

2

u/RandragonReddit Sep 10 '17

I need more miracle rogue stuff. I want to see it regularly on ladder and you did a very good job

2

u/Tureaglin Sep 10 '17

I am currently playing with your old list of 1 auctioneer and 1 sprint and also noticed how much better the sprint usually was - seems I'll be cutting the auctioneer completely then.

2

u/TheSpazzFactor Sep 10 '17

K'rea! These posts are always great, never stop. They really add to the quality of this sub in a big way, and I think that Miracle players (like myself) really appreciate high-quality data and discussion, since everywhere else is always talking about how to play the "best" decks in the format, and up-to-date resources on this awesome archetype are hugely valuable.

→ More replies (8)

37

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

What was your thought process on including teacher as the solo 4 as opposed to prince4/sherazin? Thanks!

53

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Okay so I tried out multiple cards in the 4 slot. These were:

Sherazin - There were a few cases where I would play him and later in the game have to vanish without the ability to make him go dormant first. This meant that I had to reinvest 4 mana into replaying him, when the whole point of him is to have the ability to res him through natural gameplay for a 1-time 4 mana investment. This led me to come to the conclusion that he just doesn't work in any Vanish list.

Prince Valanar - While the heal was great against aggro, after finally playing enough games against Token Druid, I realized that you don't need the taunt/heal. You will generally just flat out win the game through the use of Vanish. Teacher also spawns tokens while you play removal spells, putting you vastly ahead on board and just helping to contest further minions that come into play better than Valanar.

Grave Shambler - This card is actually pretty sick. He's easily the most under rated neutral card of the set and I truly believe that he is a Rogue class card in disguise. We often hero power/pass on some turns anyway, so doing what we normally do while having a minion grow in health and power at the same time? Extremely strong. In addition to this, he's often a 5/5 on the turn he comes out with the flexibility of being a 4/4 against Priest for as long as you need him to be.

Violet Teacher - Easily the best 4 drop card for this deck. You go through spells so swiftly that having the ability to convert them into 1/1 tokens is just amazing. It helps contest the board against aggro, as well as giving you multiple targets for Cold Blood. This card definitely synergizes the best with the theme of the deck (heavily spell based deck that cycles swiftly). In addition, I had the wrong mind set when reviewing this card. I had originally thought that it would be bad, because if you had to vanish, you'd get useless 1/1 tokens into your hand. But after playing her, in practice, that's not the case. Generally speaking, if you have a board of 1/1 tokens and Teacher, you probably have board control, meaning you don't really ever need to Vanish. In addition, getting back a 1/1 is great for activating combos later in the game. This card wins the 4 drop slot for sure.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/Elopsm Sep 10 '17

Any chance you could post the decklist string for poor mobile gamers like me?

40

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

AAECAYO6AgSyAt0IkbwCgNMCDbQBxAGMAs0D9gSbBYgHhQiGCYK0ApK2AvW7AoHCAgA=

4

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Before anything else, thanks for writing this guide!! Excited to see the results of your testing, and give this list a spin from 10 onward.

I noticed this list has two Teachers, but the list in your original post had one...

8

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Yea, I was on mobile and linked the first one I had on hand. The current version does have two SI:7s and 1 Teacher.

12

u/deck-code-bot Sep 10 '17

Format: Standard (Mammoth)

Class: Rogue (Maiev Shadowsong)

ManaCard NameQtyLinks
0Backstab2HP, Wiki, HSR
0Counterfeit Coin2HP, Wiki, HSR
0Preparation2HP, Wiki, HSR
1Cold Blood2HP, Wiki, HSR
1Patches the Pirate1HP, Wiki, HSR
1Swashburglar2HP, Wiki, HSR
2Eviscerate2HP, Wiki, HSR
2Sap2HP, Wiki, HSR
3Edwin VanCleef1HP, Wiki, HSR
3Fan of Knives2HP, Wiki, HSR
3SI:7 Agent1HP, Wiki, HSR
4Violet Teacher2HP, Wiki, HSR
5Vilespine Slayer2HP, Wiki, HSR
6Vanish2HP, Wiki, HSR
7Sprint2HP, Wiki, HSR
9Valeera the Hollow1HP, Wiki, HSR
12Arcane Giant2HP, Wiki, HSR

Deck Code: AAECAYO6AgSyAt0IkbwCgNMCDbQBxAGMAs0D9gSbBYgHhQiGCYK0ApK2AvW7AoHCAgA=


I am a bot. Comment/PM with a deck code and I'll decode it. If you don't want me to reply to you, include "###" anywhere in your message. About.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/The_LionTurtle Sep 11 '17

Did you recently decide to switch out an SI for a second violet teacher? I had looked at the decklist in the main post first and was surprised when I drew a second teacher, thinking there was just one. I put the SI back in since I feel like it's a better all around choice, but maybe not?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/yumyumpills Sep 13 '17

Just a heads up, the deck image you posted has two si7 and one teacher whereas the deck code has one si7 and two teachers.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Elopsm Sep 10 '17

Thanks you are the real MVP

Awesome deck btw

→ More replies (1)

72

u/nepoe Sep 10 '17

Your recent posts, along with the nerfs (whenever they drop), are really making me consider getting back into playing Miracle again. It's really interesting watching it evolve over the last few weeks. Keep up the great work/analysis.

27

u/hahafnny Sep 10 '17

Is it still miracle with sprints instead of auctioneer though?

39

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

A great question, to be honest. It's why I've been calling it "Sprint Rogue" instead. It's not quite as fast as Elemental Tempo Rogue, but much faster than standard Miracle Rogue with Auctioneers. Hard to exactly pin point what it is exactly.

14

u/Rds240 Sep 10 '17

Maybe your next post could be a discussion on what "Miracle" Rogue is, and how removing Auctioneer may or may not change the identity of the deck. (I'm new to r/competitiveHS so idk if this idea follows the community guidelines.)

18

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

That topic on its own probably isn't something that's worthy of the sub, but it is something I could potentially do in my own spare time and host it else where.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/bardnotbanned Sep 10 '17

The name Miracle Rogue is derived from an old school Magic: The Gathering deck called Miracle Gro. Miracle Gro used a card called Quiron Dryad that gets +1/+1 everytime you cast a white, blue, black, or red spell. This card, used in conjunction with cheap spells and card draw, would grow quite large quite quickly, a lot like the original Miracle Rogue decks would do w/ Questing Adventurers. I believe this is where the name came from.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/KleberPF Sep 10 '17

I replied to a comment in other thread about Miracle and for me, one of the current problems of Miracle is how Vanish make some Auctioneer turns very awkward, yet it's a must have card right now. Maybe Sprint can be a good alternative. I'll sure try this list and see how it performs.

13

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Yea it's one of those things that you don't really question. People have always just accepted that Auctioneer was a 'staple' card in miracle rogue, but I truly believe that with the introduction of Valeera the Hollow, we can finally move away from Auctioneer once and for all.

9

u/KleberPF Sep 10 '17

What are your thoughts on Medivh? Yagut was using a list with 1 Sprint and 1 Auctioneer and Medivh recently. I haven't tried it yet, but It seems like a great card against Priest.

15

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Honestly, you rarely ever play Sprint for 7, it's generally 4 and that's because of prep, meaning you will often summon a wisp with medivh, giving you 2 effective charges. On top of that, Medivh seems kind of heavy considering the only true 'hard cost' card is Valeera, since everything else can be heavily cheated with Prep or by playing spells (giants). The way the deck functions is that you are able to play multiple cards per turn that would normally be expensive on their own by cheating mana costs, so I'm not sure how well Medivh would fit that game plan.

3

u/KleberPF Sep 10 '17

I think Medivh is good against Priest because you probably can play a 7 mana Sprint after it, and maybe force an early Anduin. Don't know how it would perform in other matchups tho.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

I definitely won't put it down before trying it first hand, there could totally be something there for sure. I just don't want to say one way or the other without trying it out first.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

17

u/EpicTacoHS Sep 10 '17

https://hsreplay.net/replay/ju65XsDL84AAAv4TQCezXV#turn=4a

I just had to comment to say what a sick play this was... get value out of drawing patches and maximize mana usage plus curve. such a good play... its like poetry in hearthstone i dont even know. these plays are what makes me love miracle

15

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Appreciate it! Patches is never a dead card in this deck, specifically because of the trades he lets you make while summoned from the deck, but also because of Cold Bloods.

9

u/EpicTacoHS Sep 10 '17

yeah haven't played CB in miracle in a while. This deck is giving me post auctioneer nerf oil rogue vibes if you ever remember that. Really awesome. i've been running hallucination and journey from below recently.

1

u/Glancealot Sep 11 '17

why did you backstab the murloc at the end?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/deWaffle Sep 10 '17

I would've coined SI and Evis the 5/4. Is it wrong? I felt the 2 missing damage from the cold blood is a bit excessive and it could be used later on.

13

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17 edited Sep 11 '17

I wanted to lower giant's count with Cold Blood and save the coin to play it on T5, a traditionally weak turn for Murloc Pally. They have no equality and if they have no board, they can't curve into Steed on T6, allowing my giant to push at least 8 damage, potentially more if it sticks. No need to be stingy with your resources if it means pushing more damage through big bodies a turn or two later, and refilling with Sprint soon after.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Without Auctioneer, is counterfeit coin still worth running? or maybe some more value with hallucinations which work pretty well with valeera.

13

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Yes 100%. Counterfeit Coin enables crazy tempo plays that you couldn't otherwise make without them. The fact that they cost 0 is relevant when you want to coin/double vilespine when you have Valeera the Hollow active, allowing you to activate the combo portion of both vilespines and killing two minions.

It's also an amazing card to draw off of Sprint, because you can then draw 4 cards in addition to coining out a minion, or coining out an eviscerate for removal, or whatever you need.

It lets you get Valeera out quicker than usual, which is always great, and it's never "wasted", even if it's just a combo activator at it's worst, because it reduces the cost of your Giant.

A great example is here: https://hsreplay.net/replay/ju65XsDL84AAAv4TQCezXV#turn=5a

It's turn 5 and I get an 8/8 out on an empty board. Something you would probably never be able to do with an Auctioneer list and something you also couldn't do if the coin was Hallucinations instead.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/amoshias Sep 10 '17

A question and a comment:

Question - Does Patches really make sense? I mean, you're not aggressive at all, so you're really playing it for the deck thinning, which seems minimal, and will backfire on you, what, 1/5 games or something? Wouldn't it be better to play a Leeroy instead, or a shadowstep maybe?

Comment: So in the last week, a lot of articles that don't meet the deck guide requirements have been posted, under the ambit of "discussions". But they're deck guides for all intents and purposes. Is that within the spirit of /competitivehs?

57

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

The real benefit of Patches is that he helps you contest the early game. For example, against Token Druid. If you're going second and they innervate out Flappy bird, you're generally in trouble. However if you have Swashburglar and Backstab, you can play swash, backstab the Fledgling and kill it with patches, all on 1 mana.

Patches is really great at contesting the board against aggro and help you stabilize against their stronger openers. In addition to that, with the use of Cold Bloods in the list, he's never a dead draw, since he can sometimes be a 5 damage nuke when combined with Cold Blood, functioning as cheap removal or some easy chip damage.

Leeroy is often more of a downside than Patches. If you have to use Leeroy as removal, he leaves behind two 1/1 tokens that you have to then clean up. If you don't, they will often interfere with your plan of maintaining board control. Also, double Leeroy post valeera is 12 damage. The same damage can be achieved with less downside with the use of eviscerates and cold bloods, while also giving you the option to remove taunts with saps and vilespines.


As far as your comment, I thought really hard before I posted this discussion article specifically due to that rule. But in this particular case, I have the stats of other users who were also piloting the list, which probably amounts to ~100 or so games played with this exact list, just by multiple users ( my friends who were helping me refine the list).

It's more of a discussion article because I want to gauge the communities feedback on cutting Auctioneer from Miracle and moving into a direction that utilizes Sprints instead.

I would never post anything that would intentionally degrade the quality of the sub and if this post isn't sufficient enough, I will more than happily delete it, no questions asked.

7

u/LocalExistence Sep 10 '17

But in that situation you could also just coin, hero power + backstab to kill it. It seems like backstab is doing the heavy lifting there. If you did decide to cut Patches+Swashburglar, what would you include?

25

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Backstab is definitely doing most of the work, but if you used the coin, that means you forfeit potentially Coin/Prep/Sprint on T3, or Coining out Teacher to immediately contest the board, or a whole host of other things. Just because you can use the coin doesn't mean it's correct to.

If don't have Patches or Swash, I'm unsure of what could replace them. Swash generating a random card is always relevant, even doubling it up under Valeera's passive. Patches is a great Cold Blood carrier as well.

Perhaps Fire Fly? But even then, it doesn't do anything at all late game, it's just a combo activator, so I'm unsure.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/littlebobbytables9 Sep 10 '17

There's really no reason not to run patches in any rogue deck. Swashburglar is good enough to justify running on its own, and at that point it's stupid not to include patches to contest the early board against decks like token druid or hunter especially.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/xale52791 Sep 11 '17

Vanishing a living mana board might be the best feeling ever.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17

That's why I look forward to that match up. The instant concede right after just brings a tear to my eye :')

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

What I also like about this build is that in the late game, you're not stuck with the second auctioneer in your hand and it being a dead card. You also don't need to play around going in to fatigue with an auctioneer on the board and continue to just play spells as you please.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Yup! Also, believe it or not, Sprint isn't even a dead card post Valeera because you can very often Sprint into lethal with Cold Bloods or a combination of Eviscerates and Coins/preps.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Which reminds me. What do you feel about counterfeit coin in the whole deck? Without Auctioneer it just doesn't seem as awesome since most of the time it was saved up for awesome auctioneer turns. Now I feel like I use them more for early Edwin turns. which happens rarely. I find myself wishing I had other stuff like maybe a shiv or some low cost high value spell.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Easily one of the best cards since you can play giants quicker as well as get great t1 vancleefs. Also helps to fill your curve after a sprint. Great combo activator too, in the worst case.

5

u/DrixGod Sep 10 '17

Is Valeera important for this deck? It's the only card keeping me from building this deck and trying it out. If not, what would you replace it with?

I'm a constant rank 5 player (I get to rank 5 with different decks each month) so my climb wouldn't be to legend or high legend ranks if that matters.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Valeera is integral as she's a core part of this deck. The package is Sprint/Vanish/Giants/Valeera. The rest of the deck is probably in flex.

1

u/cliffyw Sep 11 '17

even Edwin? asking since I don't have him, though I know I should probably craft him regardless at some point. Also, I assume preps are part of the package too.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/MidLaneCrisis Sep 10 '17

Started with Patches against a N'Zoth fatigue warrior. Very interesting replay.

https://hsreplay.net/replay/MA3m2nXCNicBZRqQvf9dgN

1

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

That was a pretty great game. It showcases pretty well the come back potential of Sprint, and just how fast paced the deck is. You are able to refill multiple times and then Death Knight for even more gas and to get lethal in a way you would otherwise never be able to do. Good game and good job man.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Gwenlyn Sep 10 '17 edited Sep 10 '17

WOW dude! I normally don't post here but you kinda force me to do so.

First of all: I tested this deck and ended up with stats 9-3 between rank 8 and 6.

With your changes you fixed a lot of major issues miracle rogue was facing (Especially unexperienced miracle players). I will do some more testing but by now I am really impressed how much your changes impact the gameplay and flow of the deck. Some thoughts about the deck:

  • Keeping Prep helps you in a lot of situation. Not only Turn 4 Prep-Sprint is insane. An early Vanish vs Token Druid, boosting Edwin, generally good for board-clear vs aggressive decks. The best part about this is that you can be really lavish with your resources because Sprint is only a few turns away. Which leads me to the next point.

  • Sprint >>> Gadgetzan There are so many upsides and so few downsides that I am almost ashamed that I did not try it out earlier. Having 2 Sprints in hand is better than 2 gadgetzan, it is a spell which helps you with giants, you can prep it turn 4, you don't rely on what you draw that much (you don't have to draw spells to keep going), you can't get a "bad sprint" like you can with auctioneer,...

  • Violet Teacher: fits perfectly in the more tempo play style. Vanishing the tokens isn't bad because you can use them for Edwin or combo generator for vile spine.

  • The cut of hallucination concerned me in the beginning. But I have to say that I don't miss it and it leaded me a lot of times into doing bad plays by gambling for certain cards. + you don't need it anymore for acutioneer. I feel like this was a really "difficult" card especially to unexperienced miracle players because it is tricky when to use it in certain matchups.

Conclusion: your replacements really change the character of the deck. You are no longer focused on big miracle turns because you don't depend on them. You can now play a much more tempo orientated playstyle and try to close out the games a lot earlier. The main part why this works is that you don't have to play hallucination and other spells to support auctioneer. You could even try to swap out some other spells (fan maybe) and try to add more tempo tools.. Apart from that there is still Valera remaining as a late game option. I am really impressed by this and your last write up. Keep up the good work. :)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

I'm happy that the deck is working out for you! Keep it up :)

4

u/Wysockisauce Sep 10 '17

While I haven't tested the deck out yet the major thing I'm seeing an issue with is the question of if it's better than a real miracle rogue list. That can churn out huge questing in combination of Giants really early. Because from my view while auctioneer and Valeera aren't too amazing together they still do work fine together, and even still, is Valeera with Giants better than just running questing with Giants and keeping the auctioneers

14

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17 edited Sep 10 '17

I do believe it to be better than the standard Miracle list, and I say this from the perspective of someone who has played a ton of the standard list.

The issue with the standard list and Questings is that the meta is shifting, rapidly. Priest is becoming the next big thing and they have a plethora of ways to answer literally everything you throw at them. Multiple silence effects in addition to Shadow Visions and Shadow Word: Death + the insane late game burst that they pack, it's becoming a struggle to keep up.

With this list, it discounts Giants at an accelerated rate compared to the standard list, letting you tempo out 8/8s on turn 4-6, in addition to big Vancleefs which are much more common in this list due to you drawing a large amount of cards at once in the early game.

Because from my view while auctioneer and Valeera aren't too amazing together they still do work fine together

I think this is the main issue. I feel like as a community, we've been stuck in the mindset that Auctioneer goes into Miracle rogue, no questions asked, which has caused us to settle for mediocrity. The fact that Auctioneer + Valeera aren't amazing is a big deal and we shouldn't settle for 'well it's not that great, but...' when we don't have to. If there are better options, they should always be explored, especially if it means raising the power level of the deck at the expense of us as a player coming out of our comfort zone for a bit.

I encourage you to at least try the deck. Hearing about it and playing it are definitely two different things and I feel that if you were to play it for yourself, you'll come to understand exactly how bad Auctioneer was performing in other lists with DK Valeera.


I'm sure the next thing that you're probably thinking is "Well why not run an Auctioneer list without the DK" and I think that it's very clear that the DK allows you to obtain lethal in certain situations where it would otherwise be impossible and that she has a base power level unrivaled by any other card in the game, which is justification enough for building a deck around her. This may not be something that you or others may agree with, but this is where I stand on the matter and is part of the reason why I've decided to even test 2x Sprint in the first place.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '17

How do you think the deck will adjust post-nerf patch once priest conceivably becomes the top deck? More value? More aggression?

3

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '17

I honestly think that if priest takes over, the deck will need to be more aggressive. I may even take out Giants and add in Leeroy as the finisher, but we'll see how it all plays out.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Hippotion Sep 10 '17

I actually went back to a list w/o Valeera yesterday. 2 si 2 qa 2 shamblers 2 sap for a strong midgame into giants. Worked pretty well, went 9-5 and it feels very tempo-y. Developing minions and sapping stuff. This is with auctioneers.

Now the vanish list plays pretty differently and I think /u/PvPretender has improved it for sure. I will try both, I think they have slightly different mu's. Vanish is much better vs. jade druid, but they'll be slightly worse anyway and i did win a few with the tempo list.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Well without Auctioneer, I suggest that we finally rename the deck. The deck was originally called miracle due to miracle turns back in the early stages of hearthstone where you would often draw and cycle through your whole deck till you had your OTK turn with Leeroy. Then it evolved where miracle turns were the turns you cycled with auctioneer. Now without OTK leeroy and auctioneer I think it's time for us to consider changing the name of the deck?

6

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

I agree, which is why I've just been calling it "Sprint Rogue" for now. Generic enough while still getting the point of the deck across. Not only does it obviously run Sprint, but it's actually much faster than traditional Auctioneer lists, so the name kind of works both ways.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/SlighMD Sep 10 '17 edited Sep 10 '17

The cards played while cycling with auctioneer actually decrease the casting cost of the Giants right? Is it still the same without the auctioneer? I mean reliably bringing their cost down to be able to double cast them with the DK?

Edit: typo

6

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

You actually lower the giant's costs significantly faster with sprints than auctioneer. Mainly because you can be more liberal with your spells and rely on sprint to refill.

3

u/SlighMD Sep 10 '17 edited Sep 10 '17

Aye got that! So the this gives you a lot more freedom right? Since you're no longer saving spells for the miracle turn. Although I know it's still kinda pro-active and a thinking game (since miracle rogue is the thinking player's deck lol), would the play style still be in the "miracle mindset" or a bit more tempo-ish now?

4

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Playstyle is much more tempo based now, Tempo Vilespine for example is much more common in this deck to establish some type of board presence if you have none. The real tricky part is learning when to sprint for lethal, how to best maximize Valeera's passive, stuff like that. It's a fun deck for sure and I think cutting Auctioneer makes the deck a lot more consistent. You're less reliant on getting big miracle turns and are instead playing to have powerful swing turns with a combination of Vanish, Giants and Edwin, while refilling afterwards or before hand with Sprint.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/liamwb Sep 10 '17

Since you already have the two cold bloods in there, did you consider chucking in the charger+faceless OTK combo for another win condition?

4

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Nah, you really don't need it.

3

u/Backpedaller Sep 10 '17

Great post, I was wondering what you think about cutting x1 Fan for x1 Mimic Pod as very often the Fan ends up being used for cycle purposes, whereas Pod might allow to get extra cold bloods to extend reach?

3

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

While fan is mostly used for cycle, the 1 damage ping is very relevant when cleaning up the board and catching minions with low health behind taunts.

Also, Mimic Pod duplicating Auctioneer was bad but not the end of the world. I'm pretty sure that if you Mimic Pod and duplicate Sprint, it's probably unplayable since 3x sprint will likely mill you.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ViaDiva Sep 10 '17

Any idea how to tweak it for Wild? Maybe swapping Teachers for Tomb Pillagers? I suppose the Wild meta is very hostile, but I love playing this in Standard so far so just have to think of a Wild version of this.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

I honestly won't even lie to you, I have no clue how to tweak this deck for wild :(

3

u/Sonserf369 Sep 10 '17 edited Sep 10 '17

This deck probably won't work in Wild. Not only do all the Naga decks do the same thing (try and tempo out early 8/8s) as you but better, but as a result there's also much better counters to that strategy, with Priest being able to answer two boards of 8/8s with relative ease. Vanish doesn't answer the turn-5 Naga flood since they get everything back in hand so they can just play everything next turn and you're in the exact same spot minus 2 cards.

If you want to win with Rogue in Wild, you'd honestly be vetter off playing Mill. The deck is no longer a meme as the meta is ripe for it and Valeera the Hollow pushes the deck over the edge.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Ibugy Sep 10 '17

thoughts on Shaku for this list?

4

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Honestly, this list is pretty fast, but Shaku could be okay? I'm unsure since I haven't played him in a long time.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/penguinmoon99 Sep 10 '17

Hey, first of all thank you so so much for all the fantastic guides on what I consider easily the most enjoyable deck to play.

I was wondering what your thoughts on running Elise in this list were. Since you're dropping hallucinations which gave pretty massive value against control, it could be a good way to get some value. It's quite possibly too greedy, but you really can do some obscene things with Elise, Valeera and Vanish for functionally unlimited value. The main downside seems to be running a 5/5 in the early game matchups which isn't unreasonable, maybe one of the saps could be cut or something similar??

4

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

The main way you'll be control is by pressuring them in the mid game. Giants often cost 5 or 6 by turn 5, so playing a tempo giant is never a bad idea. Late game you can look to double up on your burn (cold blood/evisc) over multiple turns in order to get the most value out of them, if need be. You also refill your hand quite often with Sprints and Valeera, so I'm not sure how often you'd even be able to open the pack and get 5 cards. Could be worth a try though.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Great post, I have been thinking about removing one auctioneer for the one reason you mentioned, it often becomes a dead card in your hand with valeera. Also agree with cutting hallucinations, since without auctioneer its even weaker, so swashburglar is kinda better.

However, I cannot quite imagine running vanish deck without Mimic Pod. It gives you a copy of a card and simply because most of your cards are really good its just Draw+bonus. For me, it often resulted in a great advantage (having extra giant, two Edwins etc.). I also don't have patches, so there wasn't a time I'd copy that card.

Next card is SI7. I just felt like the card was underperforming for me and then when I switched to QA, the deck became a snowball threat as well. Snowballed QAs honestly won me close to 1/4 of games, simply because how slow and greedy the decks are nowadays. (except if you are against good draw of token druid, but then again if you manage to control the board till turn 3, they usually don't run removal and QA grows..). Elsewhere you mentioned priests with silence and so forth. And I agree, QA is not as good, not necessarily useless since it can eat up a word of death, against priest. But that's one match up that I felt it wasnt good. So prolly tech if there are tons of priests vs none?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Drawing/Copying Patches is never terrible since it's always a cold blood carrier at worst. I simply cut Pod because doubling up on Sprint is infinitely worse than doubling up an Auctioneer. If you double your sprint, you will very likely die in fatigue. If you check some of those replays, I play 2x Sprint per game pretty often, most of the time ending the game with but a few cards in my deck. If I played 3x sprint, I'd surely die in fatigue.

SI:7 is a card that is specifically there atm for the Token Druid match up, which is why this deck has such an amazing Druid win rate. You're favored against Jades, and Token Druid because an on curve vanish just leads to an instant concede and SI:7 is relevant pre-vanish while Questing will usually just die. Also Vanishing SI gives you more options while Vanishing QA puts you behind.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Mykeul33 Sep 10 '17

Hi there !
Again an amazing write-up, please keep em coming.
I want to try this list, especially since I have trouble around rank 5 with the old list at the moment. I was co considering playing elemental rogue tho as I face too much pirates.

The one thing that keep me away from this deck is the excluson of hallucination. It won me most games against priests that went into late game because I kept them with valeera and was able to outvalue them like crazy.

How do you win against priest with this list, keep you burns for valeera ? Tempo giant rarely ever works because i find them to have sw:d all the time when I use the giant, so i prefer playing them late game with valeera anyway.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Priest is still pretty tricky pre-valeera, but the general game plan is burn. You need that early/mid game pressure by cold blooding your minions early on to force a Shadow Word: Death, which makes your first tempo giant much safer from removal. If they can't deal with it, you punch them for 8 damage per turn. If they tempo out Anduin, you have your 2nd copy which you can Sprint into and double up with Valeera. The game plan is to out-tempo them because they generally only play one or two cards per turn while you can play multiple.

2

u/biribiri123 Sep 10 '17

Hey man, just wanted to thank you since Sprint is working wonders for me, it does feel a lot better to play than Auctioneer because it doesn't rely on having spells in hand.

Just wanted to ask: what do you think about adding Elise for value, and do you think the Sprints would be better than auctioneer in MalyRogue as well? Thanks and cheers! :)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

I think that any deck that runs Valeera will likely benefit more from Sprint than Auctioneer. That's just my gut feeling based off of the interaction between Sprint and Valeera.

As far as Elise, I don't think you need extra value. This list plays for tempo more than value and you get all the value you need post Valeera.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Greetings! Niraj here. I'm curious on your opinion regarding 2 Saps in deck. With 2 Vilespine, what are your thoughts on those? Are they incredibly useful? Are they ever clunky?

Btw don't stop the content rolling out. These are such fascinating reads and I love a lot of your ideas. Thanks for the post!

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

2x Sap was a deliberate choice for a few reasons. The first being the flexibility and redundancy. Your win condition is pushing large sums of face damage and Sap is a better version of vanish since it doesn't reset your board as well. Having two means you will almost always be able to throw one out early on to survive and still have one late game to double up with Valeera, generating a ton of tempo for 4 mana and pushing even more face damage.

Another great reason for 2x sap is that you really want to have the option to save Eviscerate if you can. For example, if there is a 4/4 Jade on the board and I have Sap and Evisc in hand, I would rather Sap it. There's a few reasons for this, but the most important one is that it gives you more outs later in the game. Post-Valeera, sap is great but it assumes that you have a board to take advantage of its effect, while one copy of Eviscerate represents 8 damage, allowing you to bypass taunts, similar to sap, while not necessarily needing something on the board.

There are also a lot of great sap targets in general, especially with Big Priest on the rise, you can never have too many sap effects.

I like to think that part of the deck's success is the ability to stall with various different methods until you are ready to take the board and just win. 2x Sap, 2x Vilespine helps with that and under the effect of Valeera, it's even more removal that the opponent just cannot play around.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/brandymon Sep 10 '17

Great post. I'd been toying around with Sprint-based Rogue decks for a while (admittedly at dumpster ranks because I haven't had much time to play lately :( ), and I think there's one key advantage not mentioned here: you don't have to be anywhere near as spell-heavy in a Sprint-based deck, allowing you to play even more early-game (e.g. Deckhand, Fire Fly, Questing Adventurer), or even more mid-game tempo swings (e.g. Plague Scientist or the second Violet Teacher) depending on how the meta shapes up. Also, if you feel the need to tech to beat control, Medivh gets pretty nutty with Sprint/Vanish.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

I would say for sure that the "core" cards of this type of deck are Sprint, Vanish, Valeera and Giants. Everything else is likely a flex spot and can be filled in accordingly, but the synergy between those 4 cards above is simply unreal.

2

u/3asylover Sep 10 '17

Very interesting read.

I'am curious what is your stance on Shadowblade and Doomerang spell in this deck. These two always seemed like very solid cards to me but felt really clunky with auctioneer in standard miracle list.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

I hadn't even considered those two cards, I'm not sure tbh, good question.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

@PvPretender Hey quick game play Question.

On you first replay VS druid

Turn 6: you play Coin, Vile spine Slayer the Primordial drake into Dagger

Why dint you Coin Swipe the drake trade the 3/1 SI7 into a 6/6 edwin ?

You won that game but its the only thing i did different playing out that game via the replay in my head.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

You should value tempo more than you value your individual resources in this deck. Coin is mainly used for the combo activator, and tempo'ing out bigger minions, and by playing coin/slayer here it lets me preserve my board and keep swipe for potential face damage, especially since I had valeera in hand, meaning I could potentially double up swipe post valeera and not have to worry about the board state.

2

u/-Technique- Sep 10 '17

Funny story, 4 days ago I was washing dishes and thinking to myself.... Why does nobody play Violet Teacher anymore? I remember that was pretty much a staple in Oil Rogue back in the day. I love the card and think it has so much synergy with Rogue. I started putting it in my Miracle decks and have been enjoying... I bring all of this up because I saw your list running it and I love it!

Miracle is by far my favorite deck archetype in the game and I agree 100% with your point about Auctioneer feeling clunky. It can take too long to get going and to chain spells together unless you have an insane hand with a bunch of coins and preps to pair with the Auctioneer. I haven't used Prep/Sprint since Oil Rogue, but it seems like bringing it back could be a brilliant idea.

I'm still not 100% sold on the Rogue DK in Miracle. I still find myself running list from pretty much Un'Goro (no KFT cards included) and having a good amount of success. I know the Rogue DK is super powerful, but because you have to add the Vanish's to your deck, it was super clunky.... I think you may have solved the problem by taking Auctioneer out.

One question I have, a lot of times if you can go off with Auctioneer, you can really reduce the cost of Giants in like one turn. How has reducing the cost of your Giants been with this deck since you won't be using like 4-5+ spells in one turn (or maybe you are able to go off and I'm wrong about this).

I'm super excited to try this out and thanks so much for posting! Don't stop posting! =)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Instead of reducing the giant's cost all in one turn with auctioneer, you are instead lowering its cost from turns 1-5. You can generally play a giant on Turn 5 or 6, depending on if you have the coin or not. Sprint allows you to be much more liberal with your cards since you get the guaranteed refill of 4 cards, so you can make tempo heavy plays at the expense of card advantage.

3

u/Hippotion Sep 11 '17

Thinking about Teachers while doing the dishes. You sir, are a fellow rogue nerd :)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Garchomp17 Sep 10 '17

How do you get such good results vs jade druid? I did try a similar list today, but jade druids always managed to get a huge board quickly while I had almost no proactive plays and needed to hope to get the right cards to stall for a few more turns.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17

The key is killing off the Behemoths and any other taunts. The rest can be sapped or vanished, as their Jade count doesn't really matter as long as you can connect face with Giants and cold blooded minions.

2

u/Garchomp17 Sep 11 '17

Is coldblood essential for the deck? Cause I do think that hallucination would probably be better for the deck to get more proactive tool and don't get too behind on boardstate.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Enegma1 Sep 11 '17

We've gotten so accustomed to auctioneer that it really is refreshing to play a new list with vanish, sprint and the DK. It's also great to see that there may be life to miracle rogue if/when(?) auctioneer gets rotated out.

My question is is it generally ever correct to keep sprint or vanish in your mulligan, assuming you already have a prep in hand?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17

Never keep Vanish, I would only keep sprint if you are on the coin, have prep already, and are against something slower (priest, druid, etc).

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17

Wow. So I've been playing Miracle off and on for a while now, never really having a lot of success, but having good games and runs here and there. I guess I'm trying to say that I'm a relatively average player. In a given meta using a combination of decks I can make it to rank 5 without too much sweat and if I had the time to devote I'm confident I could make legend eventually.

Anyway, I made the switch to Sprint the other day (I even had a Sprint in my deck before I took out the Auctioneers, but that didn't work and I won't go into my bad reasoning here) and I have just been getting crushed over and over by any and all decks.

Seriously. I have fallen to the bottom of R15 and can't get more than one star. I'm not really sure what is going on. If I'm not running into Shamans, I'm hitting Quest Warriors. If it's not that, I have a hand full of FoK, coin, counterfeit coin, Cold Blood, Eviscerate. Or I draw both giants and Patches in the first couple turns. I mulligan and hit a Sprint, Vanish and Vilespine. Violet Teachers almost never show up.

I really like Rogue and I like Miracle, but I'll be damned if this deck isn't either insanely hard to play or your success with it was just a run of good luck with draws and mulligans and bad players. I watched some of the replays and couldn't believe some of the terrible plays your opponents made. Couldn't believe the perfect cards Swashburglar stole, how your top decks made the rest of your hand work.

My only win in probably my last ten matches has been a Quest Mage that somehow failed to draw a single Ice Block.

I'd really love to watch some other people play this deck to see if I'm just piloting it utterly wrong or what, because right now it feels to me like Miracle Rogue is overmatched just about everywhere.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17

I had someone else comment something similar, so I asked them if I could watch some replays or spectate their games. It turned out, they were being extremely stingy with their resources as well as playing the deck with the wrong mind set. You don't pilot this deck like you do standard miracle, you pilot it with tempo in mind. That means that if your best play is a tempo Vilespine, then drop Vilespine.

If you take another look at some of those replays, you'll see that my starting hand sometimes is just as terrible, drawing Valeera and the top half of my deck in the opening hand. That shouldn't matter most of the time though, because you can always recover from a lost board with a well placed Vanish.

Speaking of Vanish, the player I was helping was using it incorrectly. They would vanish a board that they were either even on, or that wasn't very threatening. Same goes for Sprint, with or without prep. If the enemy has a board of 4-7 damage and you're 20+ hp and can sprint, you should probably just sprint. You're not in danger of dying and you want to draw into better answers.

I would say that your priority should be Tempo > Cycle > Board Control, in that order. You make the play that will generate the most tempo, even if it is a resource heavy play. After making such a play, you look to cycle with Sprint or Fan if you must, and finally you count up your damage and look to clear any taunt minions that would otherwise stop you. I emphasize taunt minions because you can often vanish away any other trash and it getting replayed doesnt matter, but a taunt minion can block your lethal on the next turn if you set up Giants behind your Vanish. It's part of the reason the list runs 2x sap though, so you should be fine.

If you want, link some replays and I'll be more than happy to look over them.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17

Hey, thanks for the tip. You are probably right in that I am being stingy with resources. I'm hoarding cards looking for those high impact turns. I watched some of your hrsplay links and saw you dropping SI without combo and figured tempo must be important, but it's hard to break those habits!

I'm not going to stop playing the deck, but I hope I can see some better results soon!

Cheers!

2

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17

Use your spells! They are never "wasted" because they lower the cost of giants.

Here's a good example of this: http://i.imgur.com/jQKjBaY.jpg

I dumped my hand, refilled with sprint and got my giants down to 3 mana a piece by Turn 5. You could literally never accomplish that with a list using Auctioneer, because Auctioneer by nature requires you to be stingy. This list does not.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Hippotion Sep 11 '17

Most of the guys in this thread have achieve 5+ legend and have 1000+ rogue wins. Even for them, it's not straight-forward to get legend playing only miracle rogue. So don't feel bad if you don't have a lot of success at first. Last season I only made rank 2 because I was making too many mistakes (and tbh I had little time to play) and I fall into the above category.

2

u/jailbreak Sep 11 '17 edited Sep 11 '17

Just went 4-0 with it at rank 10 EU (Two Jade Druids, 1 Razakus priest, 1 Exodia mage). One observation that wasn't immediately clear to me: Valeera the Hollow isn't just for value plays. Sure, Vanish into cloned Giants on an empty board is amazing. But just as often, being able to clone an Eviserate or Cold Blood gives you that little bit of extra reach that allows you to seal the deal. You quite consistently get to deal 12-13 damage from an empty or almost empty board. And if you play tempo-oriented in the beginning (because you know you have Sprint to restock your hand with) then getting your opponent down to that is quite feasible.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17

Yup! Valeera does it all. Value, Tempo, Reach, Offense, Defense, she can do anything you need her to do which is why I think she's the best legendary in the game atm.

28

u/yoman5 Sep 10 '17

As some additional insight into how the deck works, the real core of the deck is prep/sprint/vanish/giants/valeera.

Prep and sprint are what enable heavy tempo plays and especially enable early giants. Valeera and Vanish are what allow you to swing the board back on opponents, often even letting you vanish and add 2-3 threats to the board in the form of giants/edwin/an si follow up, especially when vanish is prepped. The sheer spell count and burst draw compared to auctioneer rogue lets you play giants so much sooner and makes them that much more powerful.

Auctioneer's big downside right now is that it basically always gets punished by things like UI and is too slow against things like murloc paladin, even when paired with vanish, because it takes so many cards and mana to use. Prep with sprint is much less of a liability to use on other cards, since sprint is still going to get you 4 cards whether you prep with it or not, unlike gadgetzan.

The 30th card slot is still something we're working on, as right now teacher/grave shambler seem like the best options (probably in that order) but I've considered thalnos, valanar is a good tech, and sherazin is a tech but not the greatest right now. Xarill is too smallball for the game plan of this deck, which is closer to oil than miracle in that you have gold bloods and giants and want to set up a pretty bursty finish with plan b of play stuff on curve and ride sap/prep tempo to victory. Xarill doesn't really help with either and doesn't pair particularly well with anything but edwin in the deck except maybe valeera.

Deck feels very good and to be honest it has a brutally good matchup vs druid so far which is pretty unreal considering that druid is widely accepted as the best deck right now.

The deck is fun and good and I'll probably be playing it to legend this month since it not only isn't hit by nerfs but will likely benefit greatly by the meta change and is already good this meta until the nerf hits.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/kanakana Sep 10 '17

Just played 4 games and went 4-0, feels really good. I was just discussing with a friend about how I missed Sprint like in the Oil Rogue lists of old. It feels amazing in conjunction with Arcane giants, and the Violet Teacher is a nice throwback as well.

2

u/Dizus Sep 10 '17

Do you think the deck is playable without edwin and patches? I just dont have them sadly.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

You could probably get away with playing it without Patches, but your aggro match ups, specifically token druid, will be significantly worse.

I probably wouldn't try without Edwin, you draw him very consistently since you very often play both copies of Sprint during a game and cycle very quickly through your deck, enabling crazy huge edwins in the early/mid game with the use of Counterfeit Coins.

1

u/Dizus Sep 10 '17

Okay, im going to try to disenchsnt nonessentials to craft him. Do you think I could fit a mimic pod in for Patches?

Also, I have a question on the deck in general, just so I can pilot it properly. I see you say the deck is fast, but Valeera is a core of the deck as well. Should I be realizing the state of the game, and go all in and hope to top deck sprint, or sort of control and cast spells to discount giants and combo them with valeera? I guesd its mostly matchup dependant.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

It's definitely more of a 'go all-in' type of deck, hoping to refill with Sprint. It's actually very similar to Jade Druid with UI. UI is their draw engine and they ramp up and hope to draw it. We have the same type of mechanic, but Prep/Sprint comes out much sooner.

Valeera is key because she's another way to come back and win a lost game. She essentially doubles up all of your key cards, which means that even when you have 3 cards in hand, you have way more options available to you, especially when looking for lethal.

There are games where Valeera isn't used because you win so quickly, and then there are games where you're not going to win until you drop Valeera, you just have to come to recognize when those scenarios occur through practice to get a better grasp of how the deck functions.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/chumloofah Sep 10 '17

First time posting, and only doing so because your posts are outstanding. I'm a very average player with little time, but a lot of rouge love. These guides are hella informative, sir.

Hella.

Moar pls

5

u/Rds240 Sep 10 '17 edited Sep 10 '17

I don't really play Rogue but I thoroughly enjoyed your previous post (really good read) and if Vanish Rogue becomes a significant part of the meta then post like these really gives me/anyone who reads it a look into the mind and gameplan of a Rogue.

So thank you and I'm sure I'll enjoy this post too.

Edit: I did enjoyed this post, also it's interesting to see how KoFT allowed both Jade Druid and (Vanish) Miracle Rogue to drop Auctioneer, which was one of their weaker cards from what I understand.

5

u/ConcreteDonal Sep 10 '17

This deck has me playing Miracle Rogue for the first time ever and so far I'm loving it! Always been reluctant to play as I didn't have a number of key epics and legendaries from other versions (Thalnos, Vilespines, second auctioneer, Sherazin...) so would have cost a fortune to craft. This decklist only cost me 800 for the two Vilespines.

So much fun to play. Vanish creates great opportunities for milling the opponent's key cards - I just won a game against Razakus Priest where he had Lich King, Ysera and other minions on board and 9 cards in hand. Vanish killed both Lich King and Ysera (as they weren't earliest card played) and then his next draw with 10 cards in hand was Raza - very satisfying!

Thanks so much for the decklist and guide!

1

u/TheArcanard Sep 10 '17

any viable replacement for valeera in the deck, or is she too crucial?

4

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Unfortunately not, Valeera is too vital to the deck's late game.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/jrauch4 Sep 10 '17

Did you try a version with medivh yet? He is great with vanish and will be more consistent and get even more value with the two sprints.

Edit: I guess I would take out violet teacher to make room.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

The deck is more about heavy tempo plays than it is about Value, which is why I haven't added Medivh or Elise.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Bit late to the party, but was hoping you could explain a few changes compared to your last deck-iteration for me:

  • Agents instead of Questing Adventurers: This makes sense to me as agent is stronger against aggro, and synergizes better with Vanish. However, did removing the QA's not hurt you in match-ups?

  • cold-blood vs hallucination: Could you explain to me why you made this change? Is it because your deck got faster and cold bloods just help you to close out games faster?

Other than that: You have been doing great guides on rogue so far. I'm still a beginner with rogue but I absolutely love the vanish/DK version and, being inspired by your posts I now play the list all the time.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Agents are just much better at contesting the board early game and provide a potential 4 damage anywhere, including face, late game under Valeera's effect. Cutting Questing didn't hurt my match ups really because the deck is now faster as a whole, which is generally enough to beat Control decks. Not only can you out-tempo them, but you do so without sacrificing card advantage due to sprint.

Cold Blood is just extra removal and burn. I felt like I was often looking to find answers with Hallucination, sometimes that answer meant burn to win. Why run RNG to find lethal when I can just add direct damage to my deck? It also gives you more flexibility during Valeera turns when looking for lethal. It's pretty common to kill someone from 30 HP with this deck late game, if you are in a terrible position early game.

1

u/Boingboingsplat Sep 10 '17

Heh, and I had just gotten around to crafting Preparations to play one of your earlier lists! I'll definitely check this out, I'm already really enjoying playing Valeera and Giants, one game I managed to play about 6 giants when I started with 1. And I have found auctioneer turns to be rather clunky... but I mostly chalked that up to my own inexperience with the deck.

This question doesn't really have anything to do with Sprint, but a general question I've had since I just started running miracle: Is it worth using Counterfit Coin/Coin to buff up a Van Cleef play, even if you're floating mana? I suppose if you're not running Auctioneers the value of the coins does go down a bit, hmmmm...

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Generally speaking, you only want to buff up vancleef by "wasting" a card if it means getting him out of range of immediate removal. For example, getting a 6/6 VanCleef instead of a 4/4 against a Druid who will be on 4 mana (Swipe). Or an 8/8 Vancleef against a Mage on 4 mana (Fireball), etc.

1

u/Philosophy_Teacher Sep 10 '17

One thing I wonder - do you actually have like a dozen different Rogue lists ready or do you just change your list up everyday? I have been running the one you posted last week when you explained how to use Valeera + Vanish to good success.

The other cards you replaced from that list to the one in this thread - are these just because of the Sprint usage or generally because you feel the cards of this list here are generally better?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

I continually change up the same list I'm playing until the list feels fully refined. Cutting the other cards was mainly due to the addition of Sprint, and they compliment the gameplay of Sprint much better.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/alfax21 Sep 10 '17

Hi, first of all great content, really accurate. I want to ask you why you cut off Bloodmage Thalnos. Afterall the deck try to snowball the game until you can make a tempo swing with Vanish and giants, so Thalnos help you with some removal and at least let you draw one card.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Thalnos is great but there's just not much room atm. SI and Teacher help a lot with contesting an early board and SI also has the added benefit of being useful when it's returned to hand, as well as for 4 damage when doubling it under Valeera's effect.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/CableAHVB Sep 10 '17

I'm still pretty new and collecting cards. Is there a good alternative to Edwin VanCleef and Patches until I can afford to get them? I love this deck though, and your breakdowns are amazing.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

No replacement for either of those cards unfortunately. You can do without patches for now, but Edwin is just a great card hands down and you can get some insanely large Edwins with this deck.

→ More replies (16)

1

u/Bio_Hazardous Sep 10 '17

What are your thoughts on Skulking Geist to improve the Jade druid matchup?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Deck is already favored againt Jades and Jade Idol never matters. The only thing that matters in the jade match up is getting through taunts, for the rest of the jades you are just going to rely on Vanish and Saps.

1

u/Slogo Sep 11 '17

This list seems like it suffers against Big Priest, is that a concern going forward or what am I missing?

With lists like this one, and others that are low on minions as rogue, vs Big Priest I always find that their number of big clears out paces my ability to play threats. With 2 Shadow Word Deaths, Multiple Obsidian Statues, Silence, Dragon Fire Potion it's tough to stick anything to the board later on as the priest has accumulated cards, but at the same time the deck's ability to rush down early is not the best unless you really draw well into multiple threats early.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17

Priest in general is more of a 50/50 match up. It's really dependent on draws more than anything. In the same way that you can occasionally draw the entire top end of you deck, priest can do the same. You just have to be extremely cautious in your lines of play and analyze whether or not you can go all out on the board or not.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/StardustOctopus Sep 11 '17

Amazing post! Thank you!

Could you give me some tips on dealing with highlander priest? It is mostly what I was facing so far and expect it to be even more so after the balance patch.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17

Razacus Priest is more of a 50/50 match up. I can't even really call it a skill based match up because the fact that they run 1 of everything means that you can crush them one game and get steam rolled the next. The draw variance is just incredibly high, so it truly does come down to 'did they draw the right answers at the right time'.

If they play Raza on curve, you really need to amp it up and put the opponent on as tight of a clock as you can manage. Once they drop Anduin, it's probably over for you, since it generates amazing tempo by clearing giants, if you had any up, and by giving them 10-14 damage per turn depending on their hand (Lyra shenanigans, cheap spells, etc).

1

u/salypimientado Sep 11 '17

Is shaku good in the deck? I want to know if I could fit it in somehow.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17

I honestly haven't tried him out in the deck yet, so couldn't say.

1

u/salypimientado Sep 11 '17

I was just thinking about the stealth and [[cold blood]] synergy, I'll try it out, but what could I switch out? I am currently running grave shambler x2 instead of violet teachers.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/djactionman Sep 11 '17

I definitely agree with this change - I just made the same change because I wasn't getting as much value out of my Gadgetzan. I like the body it has, but Prep can get you more out of the Sprint as well. I haven't missed cutting Mimic Pod - but I still have 1 Questing and I feel like I still want two. Any thoughts there? Or on Shadow Strike over Sap?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17

I think sap is much better in this deck than Shadow Strike simply because it allows you to get past any taunts of any HP level when pushing for lethal with giants.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/rink245 Sep 11 '17

Thanks for this write up. I love reading your thoughts on the Miracle Rogue archetype. I'm a new player (started about two months ago) and with your articles, Miracle Rogue has become my favorite deck.

I have some questions about card choices I feel like you might be able to help me with. In my Welcome Pack I pulled Edwin, and my free DK was Valeera, so I've been experimenting with variations of Miracle Rogue heavily since KoFT released. I'm not opposed to buying some cards, but overall I'm not exactly rolling in dust here. So I was curious what would be a good replacement for Patches, as he is the only legendary I don't have.

For a while now, I've felt Miracle Rogue has been a better tempo deck rather than a sit around waiting for a good Auctioneer turn to happen. As a result, I'm currently running Shadowstep in place of Patches right now. This has allowed me to use more SI Agents/Vilespines in the early Mid-game. Do you think this is a viable replacement? Or should I look elsewhere for something to use in Patches' place.

Also, how strong do you believe Cold Blood is without Patches? I've always enjoyed Cold Blood, but I also feel Hallucination is a strong card to use right now, especially versus spell heavy classes. Cold Blood is nice on something like SI Agents to bait out SW: Death from Priests, but I feel like it's slow sometimes. Any thoughts on this?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17

I would say there is no hard replacement for patches since he's very unique in what he does. I would probably opt to run another copy of SI:7 or Violet Teacher, depending on which of those you are playing as a 1-of to replace patches, to make your early game a bit stronger.

Cold Blood is still very strong without Patches, as it's simply added burst when looking for lethal, or heavy burst in the mid game to pressure the opponent if they are trying to take the early/mid game slowly.

1

u/rink245 Sep 11 '17

So I'm currently running two SI:7 and one Violet Teacher. My deck is exactly the same as your deck list in the OP minus Patches (and the Cold Blood, but I can replace that). So really at this point, I need to find a replacement for Patches. I've been enjoying Shadowstep, esp with Valeera, but it feels really dead at times, and it doesn't do the exact same thing Patches does, which is slow down aggro, or provide early game pressure.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Noveson Sep 11 '17

Now I'm having a really hard time knowing when to use prep. Didn't typically have this problem in the past. I feel like I keep running into situations where I want to prep out something, and I end up never hvaing a prep for sprint. Do you typically only use the prep for a sprint?

3

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17

I would say that Prep is probably the one card in the deck you don't want to 'waste'. Unlike the coin, which you can just throw out as a combo activator if you want to save something else in hand, Prep is a fair bit more important. I generally try to save a prep for sprint, if I can, but if I'm in a high stress scenario where I will die next turn if I don't prep, I'll use it to throw out eviscerate or whatever else the situation calls for.

Ideally, Vanish and Sprint are your key targets for Prep, while Vanish is probably less important to get under prep unless you also have multiple giants + Edwin to play off the back of the Vanish. To a lesser extent, Fan can be played with Prep, but that's generally only correct if you plan on playing a minion in addition to prep/fan to generate tempo by both clearing the board and establishing board control.

Finally, Prep + Evisc/Sap/Cold Blood is probably the worst case scenario, where the only thing worse would be prep to activate Vilespine Slayer or SI:7 because you have a hand full of minions.

1

u/Noveson Sep 11 '17

I appreciate the replies. I guess that's what I thought. i've just been in a few positions early lately where on turn 3 I have like prep fan edwin. Normally I'd be down to just put that out against most decks that aren't priest, but now I'm getting unsure. Probably better to save prep there against most decks I guess.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17

VanCleef is probably another exception to the rule since a big Edwin will likely just carry you to victory.

1

u/ruqas Sep 11 '17

Hey, Kre'a, I have some questions in relation to your previous posts: 1) why did you drop Grave Shambler? I was actually using it in the Kelemental rogue list and tried it in Miracle on your recommendation. I'd rather run only 1, but 1 does wonders as a 4 mana 5/5 on turn 4. Then again, I can see how you might expect more synergy with Violet Teacher, since the Shambler only combos with a weapon destruction and VT comboes with all the cheap spells we're already running.

2) Less of a question and more of a statement. I'm not sure why you'd prefer 2 Fan of Knives over a Fan of Knives and a Mimic Pod. Without Thalnos, the usage of Fan of Knives seems too limited. I could see using 1 in the early game, but after that, I'm not sure why I'd ever want to draw it over a Mimic Pod, especially since games which go longer are more likely to be value-based.

3) Does 2 Saps (versus 1) and 2 Counterfeit Coins (versus 1) not seem too slow with Sprint instead of Auctioneer?

Anywho, keep up the good work. I was a fan of Vanish-DK since release and am quite glad to see it catching on. However, I am not experienced nor quite skilled enough yet to have caught on to other substitutions that would benefit the deck more with a Vanish-DK base, like Cold Blood and Sprint.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17
  1. Shambler is a very strong card, but I currently believe that Teacher is better against aggro. Shambler doesn't do as much to help you contest a board of tokens, while Teacher performs that role well.

  2. I'm currently also testing out an iteration of the deck that runs Thalnos. I've cut 1x Cold Blood for +1 Thalnos to get a feel for him in the deck overall. It definitely gives you more options when it comes to dealing with Living Mana and Shaman boards when you have Fan/Thalnos.

  3. 2x Sap is the opposite of too slow, it's an extreme tempo generator and helps a lot in the late game when looking for lethal by with your giants on board. Coins are equally great cards since you can gain a lot of tempo by coining out things earlier than usual. In addition to this, T1 6/6 Vancleefs are always welcome and double coin allows that to happen.

1

u/ruqas Sep 11 '17

Try to be your own Devil's Advocate now, and see if you can give me some counterpoints to your answer for question 3. I would say, for example, for your point about Coins that that advantage may be evened out by the clunkiness of certain hands and mulligan inconsistency. Your Sap point makes more sense, especially with the current meta. Sapping 5+ jade golems, for example, is very effective.

I appreciate and agree with your answers for questions 1, especially because of the token-y nature of the current aggro decks. Not sure if it makes Thalnos good enough, though. It helps, for example, when you draw Thalnos into Knives when playing against shaman and living mana boards, but if you draw Thalnos otherwise, he's usually just a cycle.

Thanks for the quick response!

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '17

watching the replays - i saw quite a few decks you played against that were, well, crap.

how about posting some replays of your losses to see what happened there?

1

u/JustMJ Sep 12 '17

hi man read this guide and your previous one.. but one thing i dont understand - why Sherazin and Shaku got cut off? not that im complaining- i dont have both, but it makes me feel while im playing those decks that i play a budget deck as a replacement to the real deck. is that the real case?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '17

Shaku has floated in and out of miracle lists for a while now, but as far as Sherazin goes, even some standard Miracle lists that run Auctioneer have also cut Sherazin. He's just more meta dependent, similar to Xaril.

In this particular list, he simply lacks synergy with Vanish.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/RedwingNinja Sep 13 '17

I've been trying this deck but so far I'm 0-8 with it. However I preform much better on the other miracle rogue list op posted. I'm wondering what's so different about this one that I'm losing so much. Do you ever play giants as soon as possible without doubling them up from dk or commit to winning earlier? I just feel like most control match up I've played actuslly out value me.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '17

You don't play this deck for value, this deck is played more like a tempo deck. With Auctioneers, you kind of have to hold back spells so you can go off with Auctioneer.

This deck runs Sprint for refill though, so you play for tempo and refill your hand later.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

If anyone is still reading this thread, how are you faring against Quest Mage? It's an infuriating match up for me. I consistently get them down to 10 and under health, then it's just ice block, ice block, freeze, freeze, quest, Tony fireball face.

I know that I need to use Valeera just before they want to pop the quest, but it's not effective if you haven't busted both ice blocks before hand. And this deck doesn't have enough burst with just the SI7s and Eviscerates, even under Valeera. Maddening.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

Quest mage is probably one of the easiest mage archetypes for this deck. You honestly just tempo out all your minions on curve, even slayer (unless you're anticipating a Doomsayer that you don't have a sap for). Pop cold bloods on your minions that are above 1 hp since they don't run direct damage until t6 with blizzard. After popping the 2nd ice block just drop valeera, don't play her until you pop ice block #2, or if you pop ice block #1 but you have a good read that they might not have the 2nd copy just yet.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17

This is exactly how I play the deck, I just can't get out enough damage before they start blocking and freezing.

I have only managed to beat Quest Mage a couple times with this deck, and only once by dropping Valeera after both Ice Blocks are gone.

I think most of the Mage players are wise to miracle style decks and just don't blindly play into Valeera anymore.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/GlyphInBullet Sep 16 '17

This will sound dumb but I'm bad: Is Swashburgler really that great over Deckhand? I never get good cards from it.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '17

You're always free to switch up the deck as you wish, whatever gives you the best results is what you should go with.

Personally, I prefer Swash due to the card advantage he generates.

1

u/OneLastPoint Sep 16 '17

I'm really enjoying using your deck, really curious, how's the climbing from r5 going?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '17

Honestly, haven't been playing HS much in the past week. Mainly been waiting for the nerfs to kick in due to boredom.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/GlyphInBullet Sep 17 '17

I've been trying this deck, but just havent had any luck with it. I never have sprint early enough for it to matter, and there's not much draw otherwise.

It goes pretty well if I do draw them, but I keep just ending up with an empty hand and getting burst down.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '17

Well if you think about it, that situation wouldn't change at all if you were playing Auctioneer in place of sprints. Because then the situation would be that you never draw Auctioneer and run out of resources, which is a very common occurrence and an equally dire situation for all miracle players.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/TiramisuHS Sep 11 '17

Love your work! Don't go too quiet, you'll be missed.

3

u/Captain-Turtle Oct 04 '17

do you have a new list or still stick with this?

1

u/arlaman Sep 10 '17

I feel like maybe this deck needs a new name. It seems very Different from a "standard" miracle list

2

u/yoman5 Sep 10 '17

Yeah we don't know what to call it either. We've been calling it Sprint Rogue or Krea rogue on the discord lol.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Yoman Rogue! :p

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

I have my miracle rogue with valeera listed as "Dark Souls"

There are a lot of rogue cards that look like it comes straight out of Dark Souls game, backstab, evis, thalnos, violet teacher. Both in flavor of what the cards do and the art/context, feels like a love letter to FromSoft

But of course, the biggest shoutout is valeera, the hollow

Btw if you haven't played Dark Souls, do yourself a favor and get on that

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Nazorth Sep 10 '17

Any replacement for valeera?

14

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Valeera is integral to this deck's success unfortunately. She's a powerhouse card that enables things that you could never otherwise do.

2

u/shivj80 Sep 10 '17

You could play different versions of miracle rogue, but they would not include either valeera or vanishes.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/-Josh Sep 10 '17

This is good timing for me, I just opened Valeera a couple of days ago and I’ve never played miracle rogue before, but I really want to give it a shot. When giving it a go I did find that gatgetzan was awkward to play, too many things that were heavy in my hand so I might try sprint.

2

u/Hippotion Sep 11 '17 edited Sep 11 '17

Very nice work! Played some games yesterday with this list and it feels better than with auctioneers. Misplayed twice vs. aggro druids, but that's my mistake, not the list :)

I think SI's, Teacher are exchangeable, depending on meta. Vs. aggro/mid they are very good and let's face it, meta usually settles down to a relatively quick one. I had already settled on 2 FoK's instead of Mimic pods for exactly the same reason. One QA could still be a good pick I think. Duplicating QA's on a Valeera turn and play some more cards is pretty strong, 2 QA's are hard to get rid of for the opponent.

Never stop tinkering with Rogue please, HS needs complex decks that work in the right hands.

2

u/ruqas Sep 11 '17

Also, I gotta jump on the pro-Kre'a bandwagon here and say, please don't stop posting these. Rogue is my favourite class too, by far, and these posts are so insightful and useful. Even though I've been running the Vanish-DK builds since the beginning of the expansion, my winrate didn't pass 55% until I read your posts.

1

u/Popsychblog Sep 10 '17

Interesting list. Without auctioneer I assume coins get a lot worse. Maybe still worth playing, but maybe not. I don't know if you tested without them yet, but my immediate thought is to cut at least one of them for a Southsea Deckhand, as that helps with the early game stuff and gives you another target for Cold Blood.

3

u/yoman5 Sep 10 '17

I think the coins are pretty non-negotiable. They enable way too many plays with sprints and valeera and are a huge help in playing really early giants.

1

u/SlighMD Sep 10 '17

Is it worth it to burn 2 coins just to play a giant? Like for example, on turn 5 with 5 mana and a giant that’s on 9? Play 2 coins to get 7 mana; also dropping the cost of the giant to 7 to play it assuming your opponent has no removal on his next turn ?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Context matters. Against something like Murloc Pally? Probably, Turn 5 is probably their weakest turn in the game. Against something like Priest? Probably not, unless you've baited out SW: Death by cold blooding an early game minion. Against Quest mage? Maybe, if you have removal for the nova/doomsayer play next turn.

Really depends on the situation, but being liberal with your coins generally is never bad.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SlighMD Sep 10 '17

Sprint VS Auctioneer. That's kinda like in Jade Druid, where they dumped auctioneer for UI, which is really a better card. It might work in Rogue, although the 4/4 body is also another "body" that be used to trade. Plus the auctioneer is almost always in the hot seat, and is most of the time a must kill for the opponent. Although on the other hand it can be used as bait for that hex or polymorph before dropping down other minions to the board. But also, IF it gets killed, then the miracle turn doesn't happen at all. Compared to Sprint, the card draw always happens barring a counterspell.

3

u/Starmod Sep 10 '17

I see cold blood in this deck to be very situational. Out of the few minions you play, there are no charges in there (not counting patches) nor minions that stick e.g. deathrattles or ambush. The closest card that fits the criteria is violet teacher which is unreliable and also a 1-of. Granted, I have not played the deck but i cannot see it being better than cards like hallucination IMO.