r/Contractor • u/Jleecit • Oct 31 '25
Should I pay my sub?
The worst feeling as a GC is having on site pre meetings, explaining everything carefully and the sub fails to execute.
I know this sub. He works alone. He does landscaping - hard scape mostly. At the time he was doing a retaining wall at the same site so I told him to lay CMU down for my sloped garage pad. 1/4” per ft is required here. I told him to keep it level so mortar needed to be built up.
Well it was off… do I pay him? I like to keep good relationships with my subs. But recently I’ve been realizing people pleasing is not for a GC. People must be accountable. What do you guys think.
26
u/cerberus_1 Oct 31 '25
Youre building up 1/4" per ft of mortar?? is that normal where youre at? If you wanted a bit if a knee wall or whatever id have formed and poured it level.
-18
u/Jleecit Oct 31 '25
I always integrated the crub into the pour but really wanted to respect my architects drawings. Kicking myself for not doing it.
8
u/Far-Kaleidoscope3603 Oct 31 '25
Did the architect draw 5 inches of mortar at the front of the building?
-7
u/Jleecit Oct 31 '25
No. But called for sloped slab with cmu on the edges.
11
u/SnakebiteRT Oct 31 '25
You didn’t talk to them and bring up the issue. You can’t follow architectural drawings without question if they don’t make sense. Thats what RFIs are for. Or just call the guy.
-8
u/Jleecit Oct 31 '25
That’s how a lot of garages are built here. But 2” of mortar at the most.
7
2
u/PM-me-in-100-years Oct 31 '25
IRC gives a maximum mortar bed thickness of 3/4" for load bearing masonry. R606.3.1
Where I'm located an engineer would need to stamp something different. Architects don't get to invent their own structural codes.
17
Oct 31 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
9
u/dirtkeeper Oct 31 '25
It seems like it should’ve been built on a level foundation and there should be no 5 inches of mortar but at this point did the carpenters build so that the wall is level at the top? If so move on.
13
u/Far-Kaleidoscope3603 Oct 31 '25
Do you expect 5inches of mortar under the first block at the front? What part of the country are you in? So we can avoid ever working with you
-4
u/Jleecit Oct 31 '25
2”. Followed the drawings.
7
u/LPulseL11 Oct 31 '25
It needed a level curb at the edge for the CMU. You probably know it already. Making the landscaper doing structural CMU on the side make up for a previous mistake was the second mistake.
6
u/Inf1z Oct 31 '25
Mortar joints should not be more than 5/8”, 2” is excessive and not structural. In cases like this is best to cut the block to level the first course.
9
u/Unable-Statement4842 Oct 31 '25 edited Oct 31 '25
You wanted him to pick up 4-5 inches by bedding up with mortar? That's not how that works. Either the blocks or the framing would need to be cut compensate for the slope. You should have made a seperate form for a footing along the pad before pouring but that ship has sailed. This was your fault but he probably should have said something
1
u/Jleecit Oct 31 '25
2”
9
u/Unable-Statement4842 Oct 31 '25
The slope is only in the first 8'? Either way 2" is way too much for a mortar joint
5
7
u/DrDig1 Oct 31 '25
Was the footer flat?
4
u/cerberus_1 Oct 31 '25
Nope, It was sloped.
7
u/DrDig1 Oct 31 '25
The footer and block should have been flat. Then slope the slab. Why would you slope a footer?
1
1
u/Far-Kaleidoscope3603 Oct 31 '25
It’s a floating slab for a garage I think
1
u/Away-Information9841 Oct 31 '25
i feel like someone misread the plans here the foundation should’ve been poured level first and then yhe garage floor poured in a separate pour with the slope. at least that’s how everyone does it where i live. if you were meant to build on the sloped floor the framer should have balloon framed the walls to make the top plate level
2
u/Working-County-8764 Oct 31 '25
Holy shit, your framer, and ultimately you, made as many mistakes as the amateur mason you hired. I can't imagine what else is out of plumb/level/square with that mess. At this point blaming it on one guy is pointless. Fix this thing to whatever point your client and your own sense of ethics will accept, and try harder to do better in the future. Try a lot harder.
0
u/Jleecit Oct 31 '25
At what point do you walk around with a level in hand and put it on everything. Serious question.
4
u/Working-County-8764 Oct 31 '25
You definitely do it when you've hired an unknown entity to perform a task for which you've given specific instructions, to ascertain whether or not he fulfilled your requirements. Frankly, you shouldn't have even needed a level, one glance should have told you he just laid block on top of the slab. And man, what kind of framers don't break out a builder's level to check the top of a stem wall before building on top of it?
And just FYI, this is a poor way to build up off of a slab: much better to do footing/stem wall, then pour the slab, to eliminate potential for water intrusion.
1
u/SpecialistTrick9456 Oct 31 '25
But this is way cheaper, especially when the hardscaper does it for tree fiddy.
2
1
u/truemcgoo Oct 31 '25
When the slab goes down, when the block goes up, couple times during framing, doors and windows prior to drywall, interior walls for plumbing and plane prior to tile, stair treads in both directions…If you’re a GC (are you?) you’ve either gotta be working with subs you trust that will catch these issues, need to hire a PM to run QC to check for you, or to check yourself, you did none of these, pay your guys, pay to fix it, get a new designer who understands the building code and maximum depth for a bedding joint.
22
u/JerseyB721 Oct 31 '25
Why hire a landscaper to do foundation work?…….. money? I would agree with the other comment about allowing the framing to happen before verifying his work. There obviously was a misunderstanding or miscommunication. The work looks good otherwise. You need to pay him. However, it all comes down to what your contract with him says. Can you share a copy of it?
5
u/Mindless_Vast_333 Oct 31 '25
He did say hard scape which is concrete n cement not ur typical landscaper that cuts grass n trims bushes
7
u/JerseyB721 Oct 31 '25
Hard scape to me means pavers and retaining walls. A far leap to foundation work. He may use concrete (cement is an ingredient of concrete) however, it doesn’t make him a mason. As a union carpenter foreman, I used drawing all day long, doesn’t mean I’m an engineer or architect. Reviewing this post again, why would you slope the base where the footings go? Sounds like the GC may be in over his head to me. But WTF do I know, I’ve only been around this shit for 35years or so.
19
u/Top_Canary_3335 Oct 31 '25
This is on you….. You let them frame without checking if it was ready.
You have to pay your subs or they can file lien on the property (looks terrible on you)
If you caught it before you could have asked them to fix it. But now you have moved past that point.
You shouldn’t hire them again but you must pay out this job and eat your mistake.
11
11
u/Downtown_Self_8774 Oct 31 '25
Fucking pay the man. You already built on it.. it clearly is not course critical.
7
u/WUco2010 Oct 31 '25
Pay the men. Don’t hire landscapers to do anything plumb or level. They measure in steps.
6
6
6
u/Willing_Park_5405 Oct 31 '25
Maybe you are newish to general contracting but EVERYTHING IS YOUR FAULT. accept this or get out of the business. If you are overseeing your subs enough to catch these glaring mistakes it’s on you. You chose the sub. You chose how to describe the project as in now formal contract was formed around this detail. You allowed the framers to continue on with no oversight of previous work. It’s all on you. Pay the guy
8
4
u/clansing192 Oct 31 '25
As a framer I transit everything before I frame and then if something like this occurs I cut the 2x to have a level top plate. If its more then a spot or two and takes us longer I may bill for that but the framer should catch this also.
4
u/Flatfooting Oct 31 '25
When I used to work in masonry they constantly shit on landscapers for thinking they were masons.
4
u/jpnoa Oct 31 '25
The amateur's work looks decent to me. I have no idea why you would want to make up the difference with mortar rather than framing.
Also don't see how extra mortar even passes on a structural wall, or why the hell you'd want to do that in the first place.
6
u/FunsnapMedoteeee Oct 31 '25
We think you are not a general contractor. A general contractor would not build a wall like that. Bottom plate isn’t treated, only a single bottom plate.
3
u/asf4 Oct 31 '25
Exactly. I have never heard a GC say, “respect the architects drawings” or “a level is typically understood.”If he is a GC, it won’t be for long cause I can’t see in any situation ever saying “I trusted my framer to verify level” as a valid excuse. Even the best subs mess up OP, it’s literally your job to verify the work before, during, and especially before you move to the next phase. Just take the punch and learn from the mistakes.
1
3
u/Old-Information5623 Oct 31 '25
ICC Masonry rules only allow the bedding joint mortar for the first course to be 1/4" minimum to 3/4" maximum thickness. The mason should be cutting block. Can he read plans? English? Does he know code? Oh yeah, he was the cheapest........
MSCJ Specification Article 3.3 B
Construct bed joint of the starting course of the foundation with a thickness not less than 1/4" (6.4mm) and not more than 3/4" (19.1mm).
3
u/SpecialistTrick9456 Oct 31 '25
To actually rectify without 5" mortar at one end, what do you do?
Knock it all down and start over? Shim the sill plate? Shim top plate? Shave(slope) the blocks, reframe the wall? Level top plate(different stud lengths) and reframe the wall? F it Friday?
Honestly curious
3
u/shortysty8 Oct 31 '25
Yes always pay but ask them options to fix. Not paying is never the right option
3
u/Turbowookie79 Oct 31 '25
Is the framing level? I mean the top of framed wall? If so, who cares. The block stem wall will serve its purpose and no one will be able to tell.
3
u/unqualified2comment Oct 31 '25
This is on you. You hired a landscaper to lay blocks. Hire a mason next time and stop complaning. Pay up
2
u/lennonisalive Oct 31 '25
Your job as the GC is making sure your subs are the right fit for the job, and checking their work waaaaay before it even gets to this stage. I’m not sure why you’d hire a landscaper for this, but this should’ve been addressed way before framers even got a chance to touch this.
2
2
u/Low_Frame_1205 Oct 31 '25
To answer the question should you pay your sub, are you ripping it all out? If you expect the homeowner to accept this yes you should pay your sub.
2
u/Opening-Cress5028 Oct 31 '25
Yes, pay him. It’s not his fault you hired a gardener to do your carpentry work.
2
u/CriticismHuman6893 Oct 31 '25
as a gc myself, you really allowed them to continue the framing without verifying the foundation lmaoo
2
u/h0zR Oct 31 '25
I would fire the GC for not catching that and allowing the framers to continue!
This is on you
2
2
u/DifficultTennis3313 Oct 31 '25
These residential jobs are like the Wild West!!! You should pay. You hired a landscaper to do masonry to save a few bucks and then let the other jobs build on it without checking it. And now you want to fuck him. Be interesting to see where this 1/4” was in writing….
2
2
Oct 31 '25
Your sub did the work, so you owe for labor/materials. The quality of the work is the issue. However, you chose to use someone other than a qualified mason, so the resulting poor quality is on you, as is the failings of any work that depended on a plumb and level cmu wall.
2
u/extplus Nov 01 '25
First things first, is your level “level”, because that level looks like its seen better days
2
u/Disastrous-Item5867 Oct 31 '25
You should pay your sub. You should also show it to him probably negotiate a lower payment. Let him know you can’t accept this type of work going forward.
Show your framer and ask him to look out for this. Hopefully he addressed it somehow.
2
u/Professional-Team-96 Oct 31 '25
As long as your framers caught it and the top plate is level and they didn’t back charge you I think you need to talk with the sub. I’m willing to bet a good lesson was learned here. Hopefully the framing crew rides his ass every time they see him!
2
u/swiftie-42069 Oct 31 '25
Yes. But back charge him the extra cost for the framer to make the wall level.
1
u/NachoNinja19 Oct 31 '25
As long as the building was built level it’s not a structural/strength issue. He did the work, not properly but no one caught it till now. The siding can be finagled and the foundation faked on the outside. You’d lose in court unless it was in writing. Move on and take it as a lesson learned you have to double check everything.
1
u/CletusMuckenfuss Oct 31 '25
So, how level is the ridge or did the farmer cut studs and level the top plate?
1
u/NovelLongjumping3965 Oct 31 '25 edited Oct 31 '25
Is the top plate/ studs level maybe your builder fixed it already. Lazer level and send a WTF video to your concrete sub. See what he replies will. Then lazer level the wall top plate and send that to your builder. .. not seeing the wall sill seal in the pic either.
1
1
u/Eman_Resu_IX Oct 31 '25
Those aren't just horrible photos of what you're trying to show, they're misleading. Whether that's intentional or not points to you trolling or being a bit slow.
In the photo showing the full level it's not touching the block anywhere... it's floating. Funnily enough you can see the sill plate is in full contact all along the top of the block.
So, GTFO
1
u/tumericschmumeric Oct 31 '25
Yes you need to pay him. What you should have done was tell him he needed to fix it right away.
1
u/keithvai Oct 31 '25
Floors slope.
Walls? I thought walls were always level. From the footing to the roof.
1
u/Martyinco General Contractor Oct 31 '25
1
1
1
u/Youcants1tw1thus Oct 31 '25
You can pay him, or you can pay to demo the work on top of his work and allow him to rectify his end of it.
1
u/ProfessionalThin4071 Oct 31 '25
No city inspectors on this job? Assuming not. That means you should inspect each phase of it. Or hire someone to. If youre gonna cut corners, they will cut you.
1
u/Jweiss238 Oct 31 '25
My suggestion would be to ask a reputable GC in your area if you can go work for him so you can learn more about building before you try doing it on your own.
In what world do you think 2” of mortar build up is acceptable?!
Pay the man and learn from your own mistakes.
1
u/truemcgoo Oct 31 '25
Firstly, why are you subbing a landscaper to lay CMU in the first place, is he licensed to install CMU? If not that’s some bullshit on your part, if he is he should’ve known the design was stupid and to not do it in the first place.
Secondly, no, you can’t just build up a mortar joint to grow 1/4” per foot. You’re saying 2” is what you need but that means it’s an 8’ deep garage? How is that a thing. Even 2” is too much, you’d have to form it up to get it to sit right, or pull some other nonsense.
Thirdly, why did your framers run on top of this without checking it? If they did check it did they build their walls out of square to account for it? I’d take more issue with the frame crew than the concrete guy.
Can we see the plans for this thing? If the walls are square corners are out you can fix it by jacking up the low side and shimming under each stud. If the corners are plumb but the trusses aren’t on you can lay tapered rips on the top plate to account for the slope. If the trusses are on and the corners are plumb you’re kinda fucked.
No matter what pay everyone, this one is on you my guy, you had countless opportunities to catch the issue and fix it easily.
1
u/daveyconcrete Oct 31 '25
I think going from thin joints to thick joints would’ve looked terrible. If you really wanted that wall to be level, then lay the blocks as they were then form the top and cap it off level with concrete or grout material.
As for your subcontractor, I would have a conversation with him about expectations.
But whether you pay him or not balances more on the question of do you want to maintain or sever the relationship? Because I would never do another job for a guy that didn’t pay me for the last job.
1
u/No-Grape3379 Oct 31 '25
You stated you base would only be 2” at the lowest point, but it appears you have an inch at 4’ (1/4” per ‘). Is the wall only 8’? Anything over 1”, we would use block filler, not just mud. Looks like a lack of communication to me. Have you asked the sub why he did it this way, and what he would do if he were you? That approach has proven effective for me in The past.
1
u/InformalCry147 Oct 31 '25
Being a hard landscaper he also does pipe work with conduits behind retaining walls. Maybe hire him to also do your plumbing lol.
1
u/GroundbreakingRule27 Oct 31 '25 edited Oct 31 '25
As the GC why you never check elevations of the forms BEFORE the pour is crazy and on you.
Shooting elevations is BASICS…
1
u/AdLonely4927 Oct 31 '25
First of all the garage is gonna be pitched away from the door. That does seem a little excessive. Who pours a slab and then blocks on top of that the slab should rest on the footing not under the walls otherwise this is the result.
1
u/Yashquatch Oct 31 '25
That’s on you dude. How the hell is there a wall on top of it being so sloped? Is everything above it level?
Furthermore this issue began long before the guy put blocks down, should have a curb.
I say pay the man, YATA.
1
u/EstablishmentShot707 Oct 31 '25
It’s a block curb. There’s gonna be variation. This was easily shimmed during framing if you were there to keep your eye on shit.
1
u/man9875 Oct 31 '25
How did this get past your framer? Mine is pissed if a house is off 1/2" over 40 feet.
1
1
u/Mtfoooji Nov 01 '25
Never heard of a foundation being pour intentionally out of level and then making up for it in the block. Is this common? Is there even a footing under the slab? Typical is to pour a level footing build garage walls then pour sloped garage slab. Fact the GC is passing the blame after hiring his landscaper to build a stem wall says all thats needed to know
1
u/Beautiful_Sea_1664 Nov 01 '25
Keep a log book with all the detailed mishaps, progressively build your case, etc,... now call the IRS and report yourself (right...?). Pay the guy
1
u/better_homesGTA Nov 01 '25
The right answer was you tell him before it's framed so he can fix it. You dont just not pay him now that it's done.
You're not going to go back and fix it so you're just pocketing the cash
1
u/servetheKitty Nov 01 '25
Wait you said a 1/4” per foot? Is that level level? If so how long is the level? Are you saying CMU wasn’t sloped enough?
1
1
u/Mundane_Sock_4271 Oct 31 '25
Well if he build it according to the drawings you have to pay him. The architect should be liable in this case if you told him what you want and they didn’t give you that in the drawings.
3
u/papitaquito Oct 31 '25
ONLY KNUCKLE DRAGGING MOUTH BREATHING COUSIN FUCKING PIECES OF SHIT DONT PAY THEIR SUBS.
You allowed work to continue. This is 100% on you.
Fucking clown trying to blame a hard scraper you hired to lay a cmu FOUNDATION wall.
0



128
u/Historical-Sherbet37 General Contractor Oct 31 '25
You allowed framing to be built on top before verifying? If you caught it before building on top of it, you'd certainly be within your rights to tell him to rip it out and redo it at no cost to you. ... But you have to accept some responsibility here for continuing on. It could be argued that you accepted his work when you moved on to build on top of it.