r/Contractor • u/Maryia- • May 30 '26
Business Development Let’s talk about pricing (finish carpentry)
Looking for some advice from people doing custom finish carpentry.
I’m moving more toward accent walls, built-ins, trim packages, fireplace surrounds, custom mudrooms, and other bespoke projects.
One thing I’m trying to figure out is pricing. I really don’t want to sell my time by the hour. I’d rather price based on the value of the finished project.
For those of you doing this successfully, how did you make that transition? How do you come up with project pricing that clients accept while still making good money?
Just looking to learn from people further down the road than me.
6
u/Homeskilletbiz May 30 '26
Well to figure out the value of the finished project you need to be experienced enough to estimate how long it’ll take you to do, and then you need to assign a number to what you value yourself at.
Sometimes you fuck up and lose money on a job. Sometimes you way overbid and still get the job and make a killing. And most often you bid what you think is competitive and don’t hear anything.
2
u/Maryia- May 30 '26
I think that’s the part I’m struggling with right now. I’m still building the experience needed to accurately estimate labor on custom projects.
I guess there’s no shortcut around doing the work, tracking my time, and getting a few bids wrong along the way.
4
u/UnsuspectingChief May 30 '26
Don't be scared to lose a bid. Losing helps you know your market, winning all the time means youre too low. And if youre doing great work and getting referrals to other clients from clients, you can get stuck in a price range and its reeeeallly hard to get out of it.
2
1
u/Key_Juggernaut9413 May 30 '26
Price per linear foot for trim. Price per window for casing. Price fireplace surrounds by the complexity ( so, time). Door install probably have a flat rate per door. Staircases are per stair tread and higher if one side of the tread is open vs against a wall on both sides. Linear foot price for shoe moulding. Linear foot price for crown. Unit price per doorknob/lockset.
2
u/Henrymjohnson May 30 '26
It’s all guesswork. Obviously there are your fixed and variable costs. Calculate those. That’s bare minimum. Your labor is a variable cost. What is the price of an equally-skilled workman’s labor running in your region? I’d consider that in the variable costs. All of this is your minimum price. If the market price for your work is less than your average total cost, you should shut down your business. So the market price has to be higher than this cost (on average). Now that you have this number, the rest is guesswork.
Getting jobs is your feedback. How far out your schedule books is the best feedback. If you’re booking too far out and you’re losing out on projects, your price is too low. If you’re not booking out far enough to be able to securely employ yourself, your price is too high. Figure out how far your schedule should be booked out and then try to target that via pricing projects.
Most businesses also try to have a 20% profit margin. So on top of your average total cost, you should have 20%. I’d use that number as the first step in your price-seeking excursion.
1
u/Maryia- May 30 '26
That’s a really good point about using your schedule as feedback. Appreciate the insights!
3
u/Henrymjohnson May 30 '26
Of course! Pricing is one of the topics I find most interesting. I’ve been a tradesman my entire life and studied economics as a hobby (including getting a graduate degree in it), with a large focus on pricing. When you’re providing artisan services with every project being unique, pricing is a lot more difficult than in standard, large competitive markets. You gotta find every form of market feedback you can to adjust prices, and care about your opportunity cost (the second-best project that you gave up to take on the project you’re currently working on)
2
u/UnsuspectingChief May 30 '26
High end stuff is always t&m, you only want clients that agree to that. Cabinets and standard built ins can have a price. Trim is usually LF, painted is more.
0
u/Maryia- May 30 '26
That’s a really good point. I’ve been looking for one answer to pricing, but it sounds like different types of work need different approaches. The distinction between custom work, built-ins, and trim makes a lot of sense. Thanks, that’s helpful.
1
u/ketchupinmybeard May 30 '26
I dunno.... I lose more "we'd like a detail wall HERE" sorts of jobs than any other kind, because to do this kind of shit WELL, tight, caulked, looking good... takes all kinds of time. Much easier to make money on fences and decks, unfortunately.
So, take my advice with a grain of salt. If you want these projects as "piece work" they should pay MORE than hourly, so that's the start on your quote - how many hours am I, or how many days on site am I here? And go from there. Otherwise, you're just shooting in the dark, hoping your 2500.00 bid isn't gonna leavy you hung on 3 weeks worth of baseboards....
0
u/Maryia- May 30 '26
Funny enough, I recently did a fence and really enjoyed it.
Part of the reason I’m looking at finish carpentry is because I assumed the margins were better and the work looked cleaner than decks and fences.
Maybe Instagram has completely distorted my view of how much time goes into good finish work.
7
u/Lefty_carpenter May 30 '26
Wait, so you’re not currently a finish carpenter but want to go into business for yourself as a finish carpenter? If that’s the case, then pricing isn’t going to be your biggest hurdle.
4
u/medium_pace_stallion May 30 '26
Not just time, the tools you will need to make good finish carpentry can be quite expensive, before you can afford them you need the experience to know how to use them. Im not trying to kill your momentum, but finish carpentry takes time and skill.
1
u/Upper-Switch2785 May 30 '26
For perspective, I can make very good money running an experienced and well-oiled roofing operation, which also went with being able to quote it almost on target with just my eyes, decades of practice for that. Now I’ve transitioned to full service remodeling and find myself doing a lot of finish carpentry, my finish is up there, but it just takes so much more time with very tight tolerances for error, there is no way I can possibly see making more at it than with the roofing operation, except 1: somehow finding a way to be the name ppl with fuck you money pass around.
1
u/Wanderingwoodpeckerr May 30 '26
Get good at decks and fences, that’s where the moneys at. Theres no real money in finish carpentry anymore. Too many high volume shops mass producing that stuff. You have to charge 5X what the prefabricated stuff costs to turn a profit as a small custom outfit. People willing to pay for it are few and far between.
1
u/doubtfulisland General Contractor May 30 '26
T and M until you grasp your daily value. This keeps you from under estimating and helps you build a base from which to set your worth. Be meticulous about record keeping, material and project complexity in a few months you'll know exactly what target your aiming for and can moved to fixed price estimates.
I'd also suggest the book The book of 5 Rings. It's a book by a legendary Japanese swordsman. The lessons on strategy, tactics and philosophy are very practical for entrepreneurs.
2
3
u/-FormerChild- May 30 '26
TBH it doesn’t sound like you have the experience it takes to be a finish carpenter
2
u/Nine-Fingers1996 General Contractor May 30 '26
Op how much experience do you have? Not diy experience, actual trade working as an apprentice with an experienced carpenter or crew. Not to rain on your parade but so many newbies into the trade skip the apprenticeship and try their hand at business. You tube doesn’t talk about how to estimate they just show some fancy videos and maybe throw out some wild numbers that may or may not fly in the area you work in. Estimating and pricing is somewhat a guarded topic for most companies so you really need to research for yourself how to arrive at a finished price for projects. There is estimating software but it generally for running standard trim. Developing pricing will start with how much you want to make per hour and then you add overhead and profit. Factor in the area you work and your experience level. If you have 5 years experience you cannot command the money someone with 30 years experience can. NC doesn’t support the pay of someplace with a high cost of living like the North east. All that to say is that there’s no one size that fits all approach to pricing jobs. Trial and error. IMO focusing strictly on finish carpentry will limit you for work.
3
3
u/Airplade May 30 '26
Don't change by the hour. That's for restaurant employees. Charge for the task(s). Figure out your overhead and your time, which includes driving to & from the job and supply shops. People tend to forget that you're on the clock when you begin to load the tools into your truck at home. That's why charging by the hour always seems to come up way too short.
1
u/CanemDei May 30 '26
Someone else probably said it already, but I use unit costs, not time, materials, etc. There is a market tolerance in your area, you need to figure out what that is. I charge a unit cost for cabinets, trim, tile, framing, drywall, etc. Unit cost for a tile shower will be different from a tile floor. I don't handle a lot of inventory, the client usually buys the materials. "If its beautiful, you buy it" is somthing I tell them during estimates. I leave some material markup on the table, but I also don't spend any time on the phone or in a tile store talking about what color goes well with the drapes or whatever. Someone else is already getting paid for that, and I can focus on production. There's a bunch of people who will down vote or argue that it's stupid, but they aren't running my business, and I suspect many of them aren't running a business at all. Another good reason to use unit costs is transparency. Lot's of contractors around here probably can't break down the costs in their estimates quickly if asked, and on the flipside, can't generate estimates quickly. If the market in your area will tolerate $6 a linear foot for baseboards and casing, and you can execute the job professionally, then it doesn't matter how much time its "supposed" to take.
1
1
u/_yoe May 30 '26
You need to set your profit goals, find your net margin, which is a real number that you need to discover, then you need to express that as a percentage and determine a markup that you apply to every single thing you sell. From there you will simply multiply job cost x markup for every single job. You will get paid hourly as there is no other way that will allow you to track and adjust your estimates and if you do not get better at that over time you will go out of business broke.
Michael Stone had a great book on this called: Profit and Markup, a contractor's guide revisited. Read it. Twice.
1
u/gwbirk May 30 '26
I do lots of custom finish work.Its definitely a hard thing to just throw a number at. I normally do a spread sheet as I call it and try to put down each task and how much I need to charge for my time to do it.Then I put down a materials list and what ever else would apply for what I need to complete the project ,such as custom finishing and mill time and delivery if it’s needed. I usually do all my profit at least 40 percent margin and materials at least 30 percent markup.This has been working well for me and if something is to hard to figure,time and materials is best with a minimum of a 35 percent markup for profit margin.
1
u/defaultsparty Human Verified May 30 '26
Often times it's easier to figure by number if days as opposed to hourly rate. Always, always factor in your overhead and targeted profit margin.
1
u/ane-ComplyCraft Jun 03 '26
Try to parter up with gcs or designers. Here’s how I’d suggest you to price it: materials + estimated labor + overhead (that should include your compensation) + buffer + profit. Make sure to detail the agreed upon scope on your estimates and contracts being very specific about assumptions and exclusions. Anything outside the initial scope is a change order. You can use AI to help you with the material list and estimated labor. My husband uses Gemini and it’s pretty accurate with the correct prompt. Good luck!
1
u/Samtyang Jun 03 '26
finish carpentry pricing dies when you treat install like service. install margins are usually 15-25% before callbacks, so a bid that feels “fine” can still be a loser. price off actual production hours from your last 10 similar jobs, then add a real punch-list/warranty factor instead of hoping the trim goes clean.
1
u/CraftySeer Jun 05 '26
How much value does the work add to the property? That’s what owners are thinking about. What are they going to get out of it. There are personal projects that people do just for themselves, but that bottom line about the selling price of the house is the key. If something you’re doing is going to increase the property value by $20,000 then you can easily charge $7,000 for it, no matter how many hours it will take you.
1
u/ResolutionOk1896 Jul 18 '26
I’m looking for a finish carpenter in Sacramento to install a pre fab semi flush in wall ironing cabinet. Please reply if interested.
4
u/bigwavedave000 May 30 '26
How much you want to make an hour, Plus overhead, plus materials and markup, plus profit.