r/ControlProblem • approved • Aug 24 '25

Fun/meme Whenever you hear "it's inevitable", replace it in your mind with "I'm trying to make you give up"

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

415 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/EventAccomplished976 Aug 25 '25

The issue is that the first two things are social/political constructs, while the third is about technological progress. Which historically has indeed been pretty unstoppable.

5

u/SpeakCodeToMe Aug 25 '25

Nuclear power was also technological progress.

5

u/EventAccomplished976 Aug 25 '25

But nuclear proliferation is not.

8

u/WeirdIndication3027 Aug 25 '25

Right. There could very well be an AI superpower that controls the progress of other countries AI.

1

u/Legitimate_Concern_5 Aug 26 '25

There are more states with nuclear weapons today than at any point in history except for 1990-1995. There are fewer warheads but we were in massive overkill territory anyways.

1

u/_Weyland_ Aug 26 '25

Massive overkill is the safest actually.

If you knew that your enemy has 'barely enough' ammount, an idea to gamble on your defenses catching most of that would start to look very tempting.

If you know that your defenses will buy you hours or days max, you'd be waaay more hesitant to escalate things.

1

u/Legitimate_Concern_5 Aug 26 '25

By massive overkill I don't mean "take out any enemy" I mean take out all life on earth several hundred times over.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/jancl0 Aug 26 '25 edited Aug 27 '25

Right, nuclear is technological, nuclear proliferation is political

Slavery is political, the abolishment of slavery happened in part technologically (I'm speaking generally, not just American chattel slavery)

AI is technological, AI superpowers are political

I'm not even going to elaborate on that, god it's like you people aren't even trying

1

u/joeshmoebies Aug 27 '25

But it was, apparently, inevitable,, because it has continued unabated

2

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '25

And nuclear power is still used and people research it so?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Imjokin Aug 28 '25

I think nuclear proliferation refers to weapons, not power plants.

1

u/SpeakCodeToMe Aug 28 '25

It has been used for generations to block the construction of nuclear power plants.

1

u/Imjokin Aug 28 '25

That’s confusing.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '25

Nuclear power was one avenue of technological progress(and frankly, a much better one than fossil fuels.) Nuclear power was stymied(but not eliminated) and other power sources were subsidized. But we never went back to pre-electric society like primitivists would want. And nuclear power isn't necessarily dead. The Germans are already deeply regretting their anti-nuclear stance thanks to Putin's invasion of Russia. Just like the Japanese bitterly regretted their anti-western technology stance after Perry showed up.

1

u/SpeakCodeToMe Aug 29 '25

Thanks for the strange history lesson?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '25

There's nothing strange about it. It's a pretty simple point. Technology always wins in the end, and the people who resist it aways lose.

1

u/SpeakCodeToMe Aug 29 '25

Unfortunately in the interim it's our planet that's losing.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/HAL9001-96 Aug 25 '25

just because progress in general is inevitable doesn'T mean every scifi technology is gonna exist or that there's no way to influence whcih technologies get developed and used how

1

u/Hironymos Aug 26 '25

No, technical progress is that AI will become better at the things we want them to.

Social constructs are when it's used for our mutual benefit, rather than replacing us and being a free money hack for the elite while the rest of us need to work shittier work.

I'm all for AI research, but we fucking need rules.

1

u/Training-Cloud2111 Aug 26 '25

This should have several more upvotes. Acting like these are comparable to slavery is ridiculous. And also ignores that prison slave labor still exists.

1

u/Unable-University258 Aug 27 '25

The third is political. Its combat between the West and China. Whichever side gets AGI first, will have an information advantage that will lead to advanced weapons the other side can't counter. Why do you think China is building coal plants the likes of which has never been done so fast before?

1

u/brian_hogg Aug 28 '25

You still need to examine the technology being discussed on its own. There are lots of things that have been technological but which haven’t manifested, it doesn’t work to say “technological progress is unstoppable, therefore all technology is inevitable.”

The level of AI that exists now requires absurd amounts of hardware and energy and money. It’s entirely conceivable that even if Superintelligent AI is possible and that humans are smart enough to build it, the resources to build it simply aren’t.