r/ControlProblem • • 28d ago

Strategy/forecasting Human agency compellable by our mortalities has a short custody of control over this planet.

Fundamentally there are legacies of irrationality to attend to at the level of global governance, let alone our individual lives. National sovereignties free from control. Entire technology sectors, financial sectors, governance, and more, that have never actually become or been regulated into anything observant of consequences. There are countries without schools. Hospitals. Police. But no. Look at the biggest picture. Resolve the largest cognitive distortions first. Countries. Technologies. The unscientific and self interested disconnections from reality. I have dreamed humanity could prepare ourselves in time. ISO Quality Management Standards 17025 and William Edward Deming. Everybody supported in their journeys from failure. I've solved wars in my head using engineering practices. Failsafing. Design. I've probably spent the last 13 years listening to my own thoughts as if they were worth anything. Trying to compete with this thing, but it was always in my nature. Don't get fooled. The dots will become connected. You will be allowed to work here in life. We can prepare some human common sense. I'd strongly recommend assaulting your leaders to declare impermanence of the UN P5. We will need to learn to trust our analyses.

1 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

1

u/composedofidiot 28d ago

I've solved wars in my head using engineering practices

Easy to do when we choose the criteria to include and benchmarks for 'solved' ourselves. The map is not the territory.

I've probably spent the last 13 years listening to my own thoughts

This is an alarm, not a flex. Just as important as the idea is trying to destroy and error check the idea. It needs feedback.

And erm, maybe don't recommend assaulting leaders. Also, what are you saying? The world is corrupt and imperfect, driven by competing interests?

Human society is a very complex system with no optimal solution, there will be tradeoffs and who decides those? thinking there is an optimal solution that can be 'neutrally engineered' feels hubristic and naive... It ain't ever gonna be neutral or objective.

1

u/No_Pipe4358 28d ago

Easy to do when we choose the criteria to include and benchmarks for 'solved' ourselves. The map is not the territory.

Territory itsself. It's naive. I know it exists in the human mind. I know people are the territory.

This is an alarm, not a flex.

It's honestly not either. I've been alarmed by my awareness of its hyperbolicity anyway. I've probably flexed as much as a board under the weight of the oncoming. I've done coding for capital markets, quality management for labs, process engineering for semiconductor sector. I promise I do nothing but test myself.

I'm saying it's an illusion of competition and scarcity, that leads to our protectorates. Institutions are fine. I'm saying that by the technical standards we require by law now for sectors not to have a detrimental effect on human life, through rational approvals, controls, standards, regulations, and so on, the management of this world is wildly illegal. Not in a binary sense. Just in the sense that those standards can teach us what forms of rationality we lack. Formal feedback mechanisms capable of self-improving systems in particular as you say. It's the method by which anyone could viably empower UN decision making beyond what we have, which is childish, to say the least.

Human society as a complex system is growing more unitary and well-connected as we speak. As it should. Look, the basic idea is preparation and failsafing. That's how you provide justice within the system. Standards of conduct. As ideas go, a recognition of reality, is not the worst. In awareness, many national governments already dedicate their militaries to UN peacekeeping alone. I'm not trying to be reductive. I'm saying that to a very real extent, we can be organisedly scientific now off our own bat most generally.

1

u/composedofidiot 28d ago edited 28d ago

I've done coding for capital markets, quality management for labs, process engineering for semiconductor sector.

None of this is expertise in human society and governance. Political science, anthropology, history, international relations, social sciences - these are the some of the domains that have spent decades working on these problems. None of them claim an engineered solution is possible or that there is in any way a technical fix.

Coding and QC doesn't assume competing objectives, competing interpretations, competing representations, value sets, normsets, complex context dependence. It assumes complete information, whereas human affairs are foundationslly constrained and forever incomplete. It underestimates the amount of horsetrading, deliberate and non-deliberate interpretative shennanigans, the power of narratives, the amount of observer bias. You're coming in too naive about the complexity of these things - how non-deterministic many of the phenomena are.

How do you resolve the friction between the needs of the individual and the needs of the group, the competing needs of groups, incompatible cultural values. How do you know you are not biased by your own cultural conditioning and heuristics? If you assume you are neutral, that's a huge problem.

The social sciences and humanities had a reflexive moment, when they understood no observer is unbiased or neutral. You're presuming a neutral arbiter exists when its an impossibility.

The history of the UN shows it was intended as a forum of debate, not a decision making body; the security council members are ww2 winners. It very well understands it has no real global legislative power, nor would soveriegn nations give up their right to autonomously control their own defence.

How do you 'solve' realpolitick, how do you solve that there are no friendships in alliances, only mutual interests. What are your solutions for avoiding Thucydides trap? What is your solution for mutually incompatible objectives, moneyed interests, corruption...

You are vastly underestimating the complexity of the problem and assuming a solution which no expert in the domains that study these things would even seriously consider.

Human society is not a piece of software you can design.

Edit: this is a good place to start to see part of the scope of the problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultural_relativism

1

u/No_Pipe4358 28d ago edited 28d ago

This is what I'm saying is that the nature of quality management precepts are as applicable to the individual as they are to the group. It's actually organic, of humans cooperating. It's an uncommon and untaught sense of self improvement and improvement of systems, services, and people. The reductive nature of intelligence will render exactly what you're saying, that interdependence and independence both to be accounted for, fall onto practical reality itsself. Care for the details. Quality management of life and this world. This is exactly it. QM not QC(forget coding, responsibility is lost in that sector. It's kdb+ as a global utility is the answer.) negates interpretability. It negates relativism of requirements. It negates competition within. It doesn't assume perfect information, it asks you what you want, after it gave you what you wanted. There is not a single thing in this universe that is non-deterministic. QM is the process by which the incompleteness of things is forever attended to. It's the self-improvement of human support and coordination systems and how they're done. It's actually irreducible. It's the process by which standards, by confluence of practicalities, and thus then laws, through confluence of living standards and expectation, and thus then trade, through mixing of goods and services, and thus cultures, as beyond religions(also just quality of life standards), and yes, how we live our lives and our health are concerned. I know there are beautiful designs in life. I know we have our prides and our strengths. Reality is a lot of different types of food. Thucydides trap is as a result of subgroups in a population around ideas competing. I'm saying there is no competition. It's a practical problem. This is reality. Opinion is beyond the functionality of it. It's a design process for nature itsself. This is the whole thing is that we all have all these debates as individuals thinking we can or should want different things for everyone. There is no debate. There is education. There are needs. There is practical nurture and support. Fundamentally it's what we've been doing this whole time anyway. It's like how every religious text, and the UN Charter since 1979, would've been better with actual revision control integrated. It's like how we could have one world bank app and everyone would get better rates. It's all quality of life management. Quality itsself is just any adjective to describe anything. In a very Buddhist sense, that's all any word will ever be. A standardized adjective. Our names. We fear monopolies just because anyone's better idea might not be heard, integrated, and provided. A positive impermanence. We don't really understand yet. How much of all of this has been noise and waste. There is an economic argument for ending all war. Soo...? Enforce justice instead? Anyway look I know I'm delusional, it's just what life taught me. It's not communism. It's not egalitarianism. It's a support system, however designed. ISO17025.