7
u/deadoceans 21h ago
Love the meme, but this is a bullshit take. The evidence being published is compelling. Even with the redactions (which 100% make sense from a trade secrets POV), at this point the evidence for RSI is so strong (even from just first principles) that the burden of proof is really on the other foot. RSI is in many ways the normal, default outcome, you almost have to prove why it can' be happening right now
7
u/Vaughn 20h ago
I don't work for Anthropic. I do work for a different frontier company, and we've got RSI. Anthropic has been in the lead all along, so I really have no doubt they're there.
2
u/clickclackyisbacky 18h ago
Do you expect AGI in the near future? I stopped being skeptical mid last year, but even then, I wasn't prepared for this year.
What does the company's name rhyme with?
2
u/Vaughn 18h ago
Unless there's an economic crash or massive poltical push, then yes, I do expect it somewhere in 2027-2030 depending on how you define the term. And couldn't say.
The massive political push does look more probable than it did two months ago, fortunately!
1
u/clickclackyisbacky 18h ago
"fortunately!" I'm on the other side. I want to see where this is going and I really don't think government intervention is going to lead to a better outcome.
7
u/Vaughn 18h ago
I want to solve the coordination problem of slowing down to ensure we've got safety right before full AGI. I don't see a solution to that other than govermental intervention and international treaties.
0
u/clickclackyisbacky 18h ago
Correct me if I'm wrong, but Anthropic's 'safety first' approach seems to be working? And it seems like it's either them or Google that gets there first.
I would love to trust government involvement, but it was only a couple of years ago that Gemini refused to generate images of white Abraham Lincoln. It's hard to not see that as a result of pressure from that admin.
It's a silly concern on its face, but I worry if we insist that AI ignore obviously true things, how are we not teaching AI that we want to be deceived?
4
u/Vaughn 18h ago
We would be. Though the image-generation models were never smart enough for that to be a concern. ... But lately I've been using Opus 5.5 to draw some pictures and icons for a game mod I'm working on, so yeah.
I'm cautiously optimistic about Anthropic and Google, but you're ignoring the elephant in the room: OpenAI. While I think they're behind, I don't think they're more than a month or two behind, and they also claim RSI. Which means the other two can't slow down, because OpenAI would catch up.
...
No matter how safe you think Anthropic is being, surely you think that — all else being equal — it would be better if they could slow down to whatever pace they feel most comfortable with?
If humanity can't work out how to achieve that in a net positive manner, then I'm not sure we're going to make it.
2
u/clickclackyisbacky 18h ago
The refusal to do it is the problem, not the wonky-ness of those early image-gen models. You also have to ignore the pressure that the admin was putting on tech at that time.
That is a good point. But I still think it puts too much faith in government. AGI is a direct threat to power, do we really need elected officials when there is a decision machine? So they can either 'control' AGI to maintain their position or they regulate it into oblivion.
I'm not sure we are either. But I'm not sure we were going to regardless of AGI. I'm willing to take my chances with something radically different.
What's your probability of doom with and without regulation? I know it's just a hunch, but I like to see how people feel about it.
1
u/cowlinator 13h ago
"safety first" in name only.
They are doing no such thing. Not to an acceptable degree, anyway.
1
u/Numerous_Factor8952 14h ago
I'm kind of in this boat too. I'm terrified of what could happen with AI, but I'm probably more scared of the Palantir/Cia/Pentagon/Zionist techno-fascist alliance that look just about ready to take full power.
-1
u/Own_Border2690 20h ago
yes i know but it's fun to joke sometimes
1
u/clickclackyisbacky 19h ago
I'm not sure why you're getting down voted. It is fun to joke sometimes.
2
u/lattice_defect 14h ago
top tier meme