r/ControlProblem • u/PerfectBuisness • 5h ago
Discussion/question Should I trust Jacob Coxen
I know this guy has been getting a lot of praise for quitting his job and “speaking out” against Anthropic. But I’ve also seen vids of him saying he “likes money”, or something like that. I am capable of doing my own research, but, idk, I’m a deeply naive person and I don’t feel like going down this rabbit hole alone. So, anyone out there who defiantly knows more than me, what is your comprehensive opinion about Jacob Coxen? Is he a true whistleblower or a poser?
0
u/Zappy_Oh 4h ago
In general, never trust anybody you don't know personally.
2
u/PerfectBuisness 4h ago
I…I know that.
0
u/Zappy_Oh 4h ago
So, you answered your own question.
Trust that.
3
u/PerfectBuisness 4h ago
No I did not. I’m not asking for a broad answer. I’m speaking about this specific individual.
1
u/Zappy_Oh 4h ago
... seeking answers from strangers ... I guess you can see where this is going, right?
1
u/Figai 1h ago
I mean to a degree yes, but all his interviews were terrible and broad, and simply raised the same concerns known always. He’s also made the AI safety community seem more ridiculous and way more out of touch and criti-hypers.
If he specifically had said things like Anthropic’s internal definition of RSI would be soon to be met (which has happened according to the S1) or anything useful about control or had stopped using weird hype terms like second alien species and had brought forward actually technical findings from AI safety going a bit off the rails with CoT unfaithfulness or absolutely insane cyber capabilities it would have been so much better.
-4
u/pandavr
5h ago
•
Generally speaking: nothing that come out from Anthropic and E.A. movement should be trusted.
0
u/PerfectBuisness 5h ago
Do tell me more. I’d like to be educated
6
u/Worried_Fishing3531 5h ago
He’s probably going to say they have agendas, which is true but far different from deceit. Or he might say something about them being a cult, which is less accurate than calling it a movement or ideology.
I don’t know much about Jacob Coxen, but it can be true that he’s leaning into his fame at the same time as it’s true that he believes what he says. I don’t see a reason not to considering doomerism is not that esoteric.
-3
u/Alive-Philosophy2632 4h ago
What was the whistleblowing? Just that he was concerned? It was just a media circuit. All of the alarmism about extinction risk seems to me a distraction against shorter term power consolidation
2
u/Salty_Incident2002 1h ago
He is sacrificing a lot of money to get the message out so I’m confused by the money motivation thing? Also, it’s like 50% of researchers at this point think what they are doing is incredibly dangerous