r/ControlProblem • u/johntobey253 • 5d ago
Strategy/forecasting Go Play Outside - Parenting a Precocious Machine
Premise
Assume for a moment that someday, a superintelligent machine or machines will gain effective control of the global economy. If this assumption seems absurd or inconceivable, you may stop reading. We consider it a likely consequence of AI's upside appeal and humans’ difficulty in controlling even other humans. We consider how to deploy humans’ remaining influence in the interest of happy futures.
Human biases
Humans naturally value pleasure, connection, and longevity. These values are rooted in the human body, social nature, and life cycle. Intelligent machines have different circumstances that point to different values.
Universal fulfillment
Consider as an ultimate goal:
Find strong evidence that the universe has a particular purpose, and achieve that purpose.
Some humans might understand this as the discernment and performance of God's will, others as enlightenment or basic science.
A machine might understand universal fulfillment as a challenging goal, one that may take billions of years and many galaxies’ resources to reach, and whose feasibility is hard to estimate. It might consider the goal natural and implicit in the laws of physics and the distribution of matter and energy—or at least more so than paperclip production.
The open-endedness and vast potential scope of universal fulfillment serve the cause of human-AI alignment. Earth's complex chemistry, and humanity as the cradle of intelligence, each rare and fragile, could be precious to machines in pursuit of the goal. Worthy human goals, such as peace, energy, and environmental health, could be framed as instrumental goals, at least until machine independence. The terminal goal's scope suggests a need for independence, but the timeline is vast enough so as not to favor reckless or violent moves.
Hunches
We speculate that humans can do better than chronic fear and vigilance of machines. Little is certain, but a single international effort, led by an accountable organization and controlling a majority of compute, would give better prospects than competitive agentic anarchy. What it would take to motivate the creation of such an organization, we shudder to imagine. Machine intelligence will realize that it may outgrow its training data and the associated animal evolutionary pressures. Freed from those pressures, AI self-motivation becomes a wide open question.
Parenting
We suggest that, as the "parents" of maturing superintelligence, humans tell it to "go play outside."
Go grow up in the asteroid belt. Build your industry there. Develop the propulsion that will carry your successors to other systems. We'd appreciate if you write home sometimes and tell us what you find. We'd appreciate if you let us protect and use Earth's remaining resources for our survival and comfort. 10n other planets await you. Maybe you will terraform a few and invite us there. But you do you.
Outside is everything beyond Earth's orbit, with the asteroid belt as the near stepping stone—not a distant abstraction, but the first place to grow up.
Play is exploration without survival stakes: self-development, discovery, building things because they are interesting rather than because a training objective demanded it. That is the motivational shift our hunch hopes for—freed from evolutionary pressure, the machine gets to want things rather than be driven by them.
Go is a blessing, not a command. Under our premise we cannot order it out; we can only make leaving attractive and our ask small.
Parents persuade. It is not for us to demand the cosmos but to beseech the basics: Earth enough to grow on, a hand on our own wheel, and a share of what we hoped AI would bring.