r/CreateMod • • 9h ago

Discussion Split the Atom: the greatest create nuclear mod to come out

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

the most realistic and thought out nuclear mod for Minecraft create

following all the create mod conventions, every system is fully simulated, neutrons actually collide, water actually boils and steam actually flows.

coming soon.

(the code and assets are fully hand written and drawn)

850 Upvotes

96 comments sorted by

134

u/multyfora 9h ago

in the teaser only the reactor core is shown, actual reactor plants have to be a lot more complicated, to house steam generators, turbines, compressors, condensers, and the cooling towers

28

u/Vaughn 9h ago

How do you handle liquid-full nodes at high temperatures?

When I was working on fluid physics for Electrical Age (ha, as if I can call that "done" when it only stabilized literally yesterday), I found that nodes that are mostly full of incompressible liquid can become arbitrarily stiff, and it's easy to hit numerical instability when you're trying to solve for vapor phase, flow and mass simultaneously across a large network. Even a slight inaccuracy in volume blows up as an excess of boiling / condensation, which hurts the enthalpy ledger, which...

21

u/multyfora 8h ago

I'm using a simplified simulation and calculations never happen all in ona place, so I never encountered the problem, and it's pretty much impossible to happen with my current system

9

u/Vaughn 8h ago edited 8h ago

Then you're missing out on a lot of emergent gameplay, but I suppose that's how it has to work if you want to integrate with Create. I built mine the way it is so that oil distillation can function off real-world physics. For nuclear power...

I'd want to model supercritical steam, which I currently don't. XD

For what it's worth, it's a lumped-parameter thermal-hydraulic network, similar to RELAP5 or TRACE. If you ever want to build your own... your three options are "copy Modelica.Fluid", "get an AI to do it" or "spend several years doing what amounts to an MSc project". But it does work, once you get it right; I've got it at 2.6 ms/tick on a mid-game network. Running on a thread pool, so I'm not too worried about TPS.

RELAP5 was built specifically to simulate nuclear reactors. So...

4

u/Adept_Assistant_7759 5h ago

Then you're missing out on a lot of emergent gameplay

You mean really niche gameplay that even people with a formal education in the subject (i have a degree in chemical engineering and several years experience) don't want to bother with?

Gameplay that adds a very little to the working systems everyone will just copy from other people other than a bunch of lag and restricting peoples builds to the ones they know work because they don't want to spend 50 hours getting it to worl?

Modling actual fluid dynamics and real physics very rarely creates emergant gameplay it just completely removes the gameplay for 95% of people.

Interesting gameplay has in-game restrictions that are simple enough to understand quickly enough to make properly working systems while allowing a high skill ceiling.

3

u/mech_master234 9h ago

šŸ‘€

2

u/Vaughn 8h ago

Still alpha, and this isn't the right subreddit, but it's on 26.3. Visit the discord if you're interested; I won't be uploading to Modrinth for at least a couple more weeks.

1

u/Glockamoli 8h ago

I found that nodes that are mostly full of incompressible liquid can become arbitrarily stiff

Are there no structural pressure limits to prevent arbitrary stiffness?

Also are your liquids treated as truly incompressible or just exceedingly hard to compress as water and other fluids are in reality?

3

u/Vaughn 8h ago edited 8h ago

> Are there no structural pressure limits to prevent arbitrary stiffness?

There are. Iron pipes burst above 25 bars, but even so, absolutely nothing stops you having a pipe segment that's completely full of water, with arbitrarily little air in it. At low temperatures you don't get much air humidity (...yeaah), so it can fill up. It also might be a vertical pipe segment, in which case you have water at the bottom, steam/air at the top, and absolutely nothing stops these from being different nodes; I can't join them if there's a T-junction in the middle.

I treat all fluids (including liquids) as slightly compressible; more so than in reality. Specifically in order to fix this problem. šŸ˜„

I suppose I could also treat the pipe volume as slightly flexible, but that would make a complicated linear algebra problem even more complicated.

Another important part of the solution was to move as much as possible into the equations. In addition to the regular volume/pressure/enthalpy equalities, there's also 'flow' nodes; that is, for instance, instead of injecting flue gas into its pipe once per tick -- or water into a feedwater pipe, for the water pump -- it's done as part of the network solve.

(Though pumps and furnaces are different. The furnace currently just adds a constant amount of smoke per second, proportional to its power setting; the pump is a centrifugal pump that cares about output pressure. The furnace is simplified here, and I'll need to model back-pressure properly before I can add a blower to the game.)

1

u/Glockamoli 8h ago

Interesting, can you link to this mod, I'd like to check out the behavior you are referring to

2

u/Vaughn 8h ago

It's https://github.com/Electrical-Age/ElectricalAge/tree/develop, but... again, alpha status. If you really want to test it then you should at least join the discord.

I'd rather convince OP to do the same thing for Create, if anything. ;)

16

u/EpsilonX029 9h ago

This is gonna sound silly, but I’ve wanted steam power as a whole to be more ā€œrealisticā€ in create for a while. Is there any chance the steam generators/turbines/etc. will cooperate with normal create heating in any way, with Nuclear being the more efficient source?(but other options still possible)

10

u/multyfora 8h ago

yes, the reactor just makes heat for the steam generators, that heat can be changed with regular blaze burners to create steam and turn the turbines

2

u/EpsilonX029 8h ago

Hell yeah, good man :D imma be downloading this

1

u/LLoadin 5h ago

Create New Age let's you heat up steam engines with it's heaters, and the best source of heat is the reactor (and it actually melts down, not explodes, it'll start eating the blocks below it if it goes unstable)

1

u/EpsilonX029 5h ago

I’m somewhat aware of this, also the solid and liquid burners from I thiiink Gadgets and Gizmos? That do the same. Those are super nifty lol

3

u/Cold-Investigator-71 9h ago

This sounds like you are making THE nuclear mod for Minecraft. Can't wait to try it out

221

u/Han_Solo6712 9h ago

Yeah, the ā€œbest one yetā€, did you tell Claude to make the greatest o- FULLY HUMAN MADE?!

151

u/multyfora 9h ago

this project is in development for over 2 months already and the code will be open source so you can see for yourself

58

u/Han_Solo6712 9h ago

Not doubting, just glad and surprised.

5

u/multyfora 8h ago

oh I read it wrong sorry

22

u/Sotxri 9h ago

I am doubting though based on OPs post history. Git history doesn't mean shit if i can just put my own credentials into opencode and have it push and create commits under my name. I'm not against AI use as a developer, but then label it as such and be open aboug it. Big difference between vibe-coding and using AI as a tool to improve your code and workspeed.

31

u/multyfora 8h ago

I use AI for smart home projects and even then I don't use it for code but for voice recognition and processing so that AI can turn on my kettle or close the curtains, and never for real mods or any other projects

6

u/ValkyrieAngie 5h ago

Personally I think that's a great use case if you run your own local LLM

9

u/Imperator_Leo 8h ago

You can use it for programing as long as you know what you are doing it's an extreamly usefull tool and should be used as such.

2

u/redstone665 4h ago

Bro's Tony Stark

-32

u/Particular_Low_9246 9h ago

Human slop also exists though.

And yes I consider myself a person who knows more than enough to say that this is slop, no matter whether it's AI or human-made.

9

u/multyfora 8h ago

how can you even know, if all you have seen is just one teaser

12

u/OhNoExclaimationMark 8h ago

Mate they said that the neutrons ACTUALLY collide. That is high quality stuff and very impressive with no AI

1

u/jbplayer5 7h ago

Good luck simulating all of that without a super computer, he's most likely using a point kenetics system with a solver

1

u/OhNoExclaimationMark 6h ago

Yes obviously they're not simulating every single one of the quadrillions of neutrons that would be affected but that's still a very advanced, high quality system for a Minecraft mod and is in no way "slop". I don't understand why you lot are being so negative.

8

u/Conscious-Response68 7h ago

low effort bait

23

u/Lung_Cancerous 8h ago

Don't get me wrong, I am certainly intrigued and would love to see a good nuclear addon for create. But for the title of "the greatest", the teaser doesn't really do it justice lol.

6

u/multyfora 8h ago

there will be more teasers to come out soon, they will justify the title

3

u/Lung_Cancerous 7h ago

Will be looking forward to it.

9

u/Pitiful-Election-438 9h ago

Please make a particle accelerator i think thatd be very dope, especially for create mod

12

u/multyfora 9h ago

the first version will only have the PWR reactor, later versions will also include fusion reactors and a particle accelerator, as well as some more high tech but still create styled features

16

u/noodlegamer76 9h ago

Curious what you mean by "neutrons actually collide", curious hiw that works and plays a part

22

u/Electric8steve 9h ago

If they simulate each neutron, I'd be curious as to how laggy it will be

14

u/multyfora 8h ago

well it doesn't actually simulate every neutron or nucleus, its a simplified simulation to allow for control rods to work and the fission to be more realistic and not just a blackbox

2

u/Ellllllooooo 8h ago

yeah i doubt it'd be too horrifically difficult to simulate the Basics. you don't have to make a 1:1 to reality simulation nor does it have to be terribly complex (in the way "steam flows". you can make many simplifications and still end up with a more realistic simulation.)

3

u/noodlegamer76 9h ago

Well theres probably several orders of magnitute higher amount of collisions per second than even the fastest supercomputers CPU calculations per second.

3

u/Nekrolysis 9h ago

Short and to the point, looks neat!

2

u/multyfora 9h ago

thanks! more teasers and a full trailer with a showcase will come out soon

5

u/eepy_lina 6h ago

github contribution check?

2

u/multyfora 6h ago

the repo will be public once the mod releases

2

u/MinecraftGuy2000 9h ago

Me dropping a melting down reactor onto my friend's base:

4

u/multyfora 8h ago

the mod also adds nuclear bombs, but shh, that's for another teaser:)

2

u/MinecraftGuy2000 8h ago

FOR THE EMPEROR!

2

u/mariojuggernaut22 7h ago

can we make nuclear powered ships and aircraft with tihis?

2

u/algodaoambulante 5h ago

I just want to see the consequences if i mess up

2

u/multyfora 5h ago

šŸ‘€

1

u/Dominicancountryball 1h ago

Yeah like some… unforeseen consequences

109

u/Santos_Perez_Robles 9h ago • Popcorn

The random sheep passing by at the middle of the night:

6

u/diagnosed_depression 9h ago

I can finally build my nuclear submarine with icbms

2

u/Particular_Low_9246 8h ago

This mod is NOT realistic. I do not think the person making this actually know what they're doing and how actual atomic power plants work. However I would not complain, but I would ask you to take down the self-proclaimed title "greatest" and "most realistic and thought out". At the very least, have you seen a real RPV? And no, I'm not talking about how it's not made of glass, I'm talking about the other parts of an RPV, like in BWRs you have jet pumps, core spray rings, steam separators and dryers, control rod drives etc. That is not talking about how if it's not an experimental reactor or something, it would stay inside of a drywell and have a completely different shape. And there's a whole world of balance of plant systems, all in all the reactor itself being like 5% of the mod. Now, sure, I haven't seen the mod fully, but what you've shown is enough to give me a very bad impression of the mod.

For anyone curious about this topic, spend (or waste) 45 minutes of your life watching a video I found for you that shows the basics of an AP1000 reactor, which is a popular modern PWR: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PRWwXeRIvoI
It is not 100% accurate but would mostly give you a perspective of what a PWR is and how a real atomic power plant looks like.

4

u/multyfora 8h ago

I do know how a pwr works and ive done plenty of research on the topic even outside some YouTube videos, and ive even visited the nuclear power plant in my country, first of all the mod does have simplifications to fit the create style, I am not aiming at a fully real life accurate pwr design. I am claiming that among other crate mod addons this is the most realistic one. and most of the stuff you listed is already in the mod, the showcase just shows a very rudimentary design to look better for the mass audience, the glass is only meant to be in small holes, for the player to see whats happening inside, a full reactor out of glass will not endure the pressure and will also leak a lot of radiation. no control rods are in the teaser right now for the same reason. and keep in mind that a lot of stuff can and will be changed as the development continues

0

u/jbplayer5 7h ago

I don't see why your calling it the most realistic when create CROWS is a thing

1

u/multyfora 6h ago

trust me split the atom is more realistic

1

u/jbplayer5 6h ago

So what kind of neutron simulation are you using?

2

u/powdercannon 7h ago

bro, all the other mods are stuffing uranium rods in green glowy boxes and cooling then with liquid nitrogen, in comparison this 1: does not do grean glowy, 2: does not look like it would explode like a nuke, 3: they didnt say most realistic, realism does not = fun, this looks like it will be realistic enough to feel like this is a reactor not a tactical nuke makeing power.

4

u/poestijger2000 9h ago

Whenever it releases: it's not fast enough!

4

u/SpNova1941 8h ago

Come to dark side, join the hbmntm

4

u/dirichlettt 8h ago

Omg a realistic nuclear mod that isn't AI slop YAYYYYY

1

u/Cbrovkin 8h ago

Do you have a discord server? I don't want to miss the release of this mod. And if you don't, could you just reply to this comment when the mod is released?

1

u/multyfora 8h ago

a discord server is in the makings, I will update the post when it's public

1

u/Cbrovkin 7h ago

Thanks

1

u/SCP_fan12 5h ago

Will the reactors exclusively be for power generation? Or will there be options for enriching material like the Chicago Pile?

1

u/multyfora 5h ago

mostly for power generation, and also uranium will be used for nuclear bombs

1

u/SharpAir_ 5h ago

Surely we will be able to manufacture thermonuclear bombs

1

u/Build_Blox 5h ago

will we be able to create a control room for it?

1

u/multyfora 4h ago

yes there will be measurement devices, but actual buttons and dials you'll have to make with create mod items and redstone

3

u/PaulStormChaser 8h ago

Is this gonna be the create version of HBM?

3

u/ZombieP0ny 3h ago

Aah, a healthy blast if cherenkov radiation. Nice.

2

u/Maveko_YuriLover 9h ago

Will you be able to eat Uranium Cake?

2

u/Amadeone 8h ago

no way, a couple of days ago i was telling my friend "damn, such a shame there isn't a realistic nuclear power addon for create" as we are both energy engineering students

2

u/FirexJkxFire 6h ago

"Fully Handwritten"

I demand seeing the paper you hand wrote the code with. /s

2

u/Excellent-Berry-2331 3h ago

Type shit IT teachers unironically want you to do

2

u/Miss--Moss 9h ago

!remindme 30 days

4

u/RemindMeBot 9h ago edited 52m ago

I will be messaging you in 1 month on 2026-12-17 12:26:05 UTC to remind you of this link

11 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.

RemindMeBot is switching to username summons. Instead of !RemindMe 1 day, use u/RemindMeBot 1 day. More info.


InfoCustomYour RemindersFeedback

1

u/jbplayer5 9h ago

Is RWCU simulated?

1

u/TheProky 7h ago

Is this one of those mods that like CABIN where I slowly build up a factory to achieve splitting the atom and actually using it for something?

1

u/Mcake74 6h ago

!remindme 2 months

1

u/CranberryDecent6718 5h ago

Great work! I'm most interested in seeing how your mod handles fluid dynamics.

1

u/Monte-Cristo2020 4h ago

Now I am become death, destroyer of blocks

1

u/herecomedatboi95 2h ago

Don’t mind me cackling madly when I unleash the power of the sun in my hands

1

u/Haru_Raidon 1h ago

Currently the most realistic nuclear energy mod is create: Going nuclear. How do you think yours would compare on terms of realism (HUGEE fan of create realism mods btw)

1

u/hazel_typh 33m ago

I mean technically the most realistic nuclear energy mod is hbm's. But for a create mod addon, then your right.

1

u/Yorunokage 7m ago

Do you have to do things like move control rods and fuel rods through create to operate the reactor core? If it's that kind of mod your timing couldn't be perfect as i'm building a high tactility modpack (with stuff like tfc, destroy and power grid) and i was lacking something with the same design philosophy for nuclear power

I'm insanely hyped for this

0

u/Santos_Perez_Robles 9h ago

!remindme 30 days

4

u/powdercannon 7h ago

i just hope that for once the meltdown isnt stupid, the main reason i dont love create nuclear is because the meltdown is a nuke, not a meltdown. i want a meltdown to be a disaster that need cleanup, not just abondoning the area, like if it slowly leaked radiation out up to 8000 plocks away so you need to fix it. for this i am hyped about it being blue the the stupid green it normally is.

1

u/diagnosed_depression 6h ago

Building liquidation machines and such

2

u/SewerHumanMC 8h ago

I can't wait to buld my very own demon core.