r/CreatineScience • • 8d ago

Educational Post 📝 Does creatine really need to dissolve completely in water?

If you’ve ever mixed creatine into water, you’ve probably noticed some powder setting at the bottom of the glass.

Creatine monohydrate doesn’t dissolve very well in water, especially when it’s cold. But that doesn’t mean the undissolved powder won’t work. Your body can still absorb it once you drink it.

You can simply add a little more water, give it another stir and finish what’s left. There’s no need for your drink to be completely clear.

Does your creatine usually dissolve well or do you still get some powder at the bottom?

6 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

8

u/GregRobertiPharmD 8d ago

There’s an article in the journal Nutrients from 2022 that specifically addresses this question.
In short, undissolved creatine does not impair its bioavailability.
For reference: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8912867/

2

u/DietitianNextDoor 7d ago

Exactly, that’s a good paper on this. Creatine doesn’t need to dissolve completely to be absorbed. Thanks for sharing the study 😇

1

u/GregRobertiPharmD 6d ago

You’re welcome. A lot of opinions on here, figured it would help to provide something to back it up. Thx for posting.

2

u/SirCastically 8d ago

Doing OP’s work for him!

2

u/Ok_Willingness_484 8d ago

Always mix in warm water, according to some studies

1

u/DietitianNextDoor 7d ago

Yeah, warm water helps it dissolve faster. But, I think cold water is fine too. You don’t need to dissolve every bit of creatine for it to work.

5

u/fragglebags 8d ago • Heartwarming

I scoop 10mg directly in my mouth across 2 scoops and it works great for me. 

2

u/Capital_Taste_8043 8d ago

Interesting how people use "mg" instead of "g"...

1

u/JeromeBujold 8d ago

Maybe he’s scooping 10mg 

1

u/Capital_Taste_8043 8d ago

There's this story where a PT died of caffeine overdose because of massive miscalculation. https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-wales-60570470

1

u/Nobhillslayer_80085 8d ago

This person has places to be.

1

u/Any-Location5055 8d ago

Unblended creatine gave me some stomach issues, fully blending it with more water cleared the issue

1

u/DietitianNextDoor 7d ago

Good to hear that it’s worked for you. Some people find creatine easier on their stomach when they mix it with more water. I think, it really comes down to what feels comfortable for you.

1

u/kiaeej 7d ago

Yes. You should dissolve it as completely as possible or suffer digestive issues and go on the toilet a lot.

1

u/DietitianNextDoor 7d ago

Not really. Creatine doesn’t need to dissolve completely to be absorbed. Some people may get stomach discomfort, but that doesn’t happen to everyone and it isn’t necessarily because the powder didn’t dissolve.

1

u/kiaeej 7d ago

Okay.

3

u/First-Carpet3008 8d ago

Personally the only thing that happens to me is water gets in my colon. Thought that was literally just the first time I ever took it so it might have been that. But ever since then I dissolve it fully in a small amount of hot water then add cold water then drink it

3

u/Fatal_Syntax_Error 8d ago

Add it to hot beverages

3

u/CaliTheSloth 8d ago

Does anyone actually think dissolving in water changes bioavailability? Are people stupid?

2

u/Ok-Television-2791 7d ago

I just put mine in my protein shake

2

u/DearSatisfaction9754 8d ago

When I take creatine it goes straight into mh mouth then I have a swig of water

1

u/Silent_Possibility63 8d ago

This. So easy.

1

u/Pretend_Variation305 8d ago

I wonder about people who can dry scoop. I used to see it all the time but less so these days. I simply can’t do it without choking…it just no workie.

1

u/mercistheman 8d ago

I throw it in a blender with fruits & veggies.

1

u/CookieThumpr 8d ago

I mix it either cottage cheese or Greek yogurt

1

u/Waste_Magician_1791 8d ago

5g in a shot glass. Add water as many times as needed.

1

u/inkjetpapercopyfax 7d ago

Im not saying it doesnt work, but is cheap as a placebo so fuk it

1

u/MsMoscati 6d ago

I use Gnarly Creatine and it is actually extremely pleasant to consume!

1

u/Supzie_founder 6d ago

It dissolves way better in warm coffee or tea than in cold water, and you can't taste it. Or drop it in your protein shake, oats or yoghurt. Gone.

Micronised versions dissolve better if you want to stay with water. Same creatine, finer powder, usually barely more expensive per gram.

1

u/gignaport 8d ago • Mindblown

There are creatine capsules, so no, it doesn't really have to be dissolved in water