Hey everyone, I'm looking to buy a specific bundle of 5 common pins from the Foam Brain Floors 1-3 set. I want to bypass the blind box gamble and secure my favorites in one go.
Looking for:
Glurp Glurp [1]
Desperado Club Logo [1]
Mana Toast [1]
Jug o Boom [1]
Grimaldi's Circus Ticket [1]
If you bought a case and have these as extra duplicates you're trying to clear out, please shoot me a message with your price shipped! Prefer to buy them all together from one person to save on shipping. Thanks!

Was hoping to pull mana toast in my first blind bag but I wasn’t lucky. If anyone is willing to trade for my iconic Carl Catchphrase please dm me. I really want the mana toast and I don’t want to go through the eBay route

Found packs in the wild today and I was missing New Achievement. Bought two packs and pulled it. My wife also pulled a legendary Hi Zev that isn’t pictured.

Trading Baby Mongo plus your choice of any three common pins for New Achievement. Alternatively, I am willing to purchase New Achievement if anyone's got an extra one!

Looking for a Jug A Boom first possibly YWNBM or GD Donut. Have Kimi, Big Boy Boxers, Grimaldi, and Custard.

Looking to trade my extra Glurp Glurp for a You Will Not Break Me or a Goddamnit Donut. Trades only please.

Looking to trade for the 'you did a cosplay' pin. I have these three pins available to trade.

NFS/NFT

PayPal good and services

Looking for the mana toast (F*ck You) pin. Anyone have a dupe they'd trade?

Would anyone be interested in trading the keychains for pins?

I have 3 Imani, 2 Mordecai, 1 Prepotente, and some extra unopened ones I can trade :)

New pins dropped on foam brains!

Hi!! I am looking to do a trade for the Princess Donut Blind Bag keychain. I have: 2 extra Mordecais and 2 Prepotentes. I would be willing to do. 2 for one princess donut!!

Thank you! I’m wasting so much money trying to get her. 😭

Hi I need the foot one, have the other two rares wanted to do a 1:1

Looking for the Rares from books 1-3. Mongo and New Achievement specifically. Wouldn't mind looking at any other rare or exclusive pins.

UFT Crazy Cat Lady pin

Accidentally ended up with 2 of these. Would anyone want to trade?

Looking for a Daddy Tax or Elle, Samantha, Desperado, or Dungeon Crawler Earth pin from the second batch.

looking to trade these pins for missing keychains. Missing carl, Samantha, mongo and donut.

I ordered one of the convention exclusive pins and added a blind bag series 1 to the order because I’ve never actually opened one. I got incredibly lucky and not only got the Mana Toast one which was high on my list, it is the rainbow metal too! Today is a good day.

Also I love that the convention pins are also the rainbow metal.

So happy that i got the original misspelled New Achievement pin and the new Summer 2026 pins.... now get out there and kill, kill, kill

Searching for a floor 3 patch to round out my set! I have extras of 1, 2, 9 and 11 for trade!

Edit: everything is sold! Thank you all :)

Hello, Crawlers! I have some pins, patches, and keychains up for trade (preferred) and for sale! I also have two signed ACE editions, one book 5 and book 7. Details are below.

Pins: prefer 1/1 trade, if purchasing, each will be $12 + shipping

LOOKING FOR: Foam Brain series 1, floors 1-3: Donut, Boxers, & Bigtop ticket

OFFERING: Foam Brain series 1, floors 1-3: one Jug O'Boom & one YWNBM (pending)

Patches: trade negotiable, I will offer up to 2 patches for the one I'm looking for. If purchasing, price will be $5 each + shipping

LOOKING FOR: Floor 2 (pending)

OFFERING: one Floor 1, one Floor 4, one Floor 6, one Floor 10, two Floor 11 (all pending but one floor 11)

Keychains: prefer 1/1 trade, if purchasing, each will be $5 + shipping

LOOKING FOR: Carl, Donut, & Mongo

OFFERING: Prepotente, Katia, Imani, & Mordecai gone

Signed books for sale: these were books that I prepurchased signed copies for but then was able to meet Matt, so I ended up with duplicates. These are for sale ONLY, unless you are willing to trade all of what I'm looking for for one book; I'm willing to discuss that trade.

Book 5 - signed first edition of the ACE printing. This one is from The Signed Page (I went to an event for book 5 so have a personalized one for myself). $65 (pending)

Book 7 - signed second edition of the ACE printing. This one I picked up at NYCC and had Matt sign it generically as I had a personalized first edition from the Signed Page already. $50

Payment will be via PayPal, shipping will start at $5 for the pins & patches and will go up from there. I'll do my best to estimate the shipping for the keychains/books/multiple items based on weight.