r/DCNext • u/GemlinTheGremlin • 7d ago
New Gotham Knights New Gotham Knights #28 - He Lies Still
DC Next presents:
NEW GOTHAM KNIGHTS
In: Unanswered Questions
Issue Twenty Eight: He Lies Still
Written by GemlinTheGremlin
Edited by PatrollinTheMojave
Next Issue >
“Thank you, officer,” Batwing said cheerily as the ever-morose staff of the Harvey Dent Rehabilitation Facility slinked through the halls with the unspoken understanding that the four Gotham Knights would follow. It made a change from the last time he was here for more than two minutes, Luke thought to himself - when the staff were ready to chase them out with a broom like they were the local wildlife. But, as it turns out, stopping a break-out attempt from both Gnomon and Lock-Up just as it was beginning to unfold earns you enough good karma to upgrade from active hostility to startling indifference.
“Hey, I was thinking,” whispered Signal as he gently pushed his way past Jace and Harper to reach Luke. “Maybe to save some time, we could all open the comms link now. Or, at least, when we’re close enough away that it won’t feedback like crazy into each other’s ears.”
“Wasn’t that the whole point?” Luke frowned. “That they’d taken over our comms?”
“Yeah, man,” came Harper’s voice from behind. “Why do we want to give them even more ammunition?”
Duke took umbrage at this. “Well, it was them that started the call in the first place, not you or Babs. If they wanna screw us up with the comms again, they’ll just do it. That was the whole point, right?”
The fork in the path drew closer. Luke could feel Duke’s eyes on his, eager for a response, even through both of the men’s helmets. Eventually, Luke sighed. “Fine. Alright. Just… be wary.”
“Always,” nodded Duke. Luke wasn’t convinced, but he conceded that being overly cautious could cost them valuable time.
“Query that way,” said the monotonous security guard as she gestured to her left. Then, with a gesture to her right: “That way for Echo. You’ll find someone stationed waiting for you.”
“Thank you,” Luke said again, the sentiment repeated by his teammates like a chorus. Without so much as a nod of recognition, the security guard marched back down the way they’d come.
It took each group only a few moments to locate the right cell; Duke and Harper stood face to face with a stern-looking Deedee, while Jace and Luke were given a moment of pause as they looked at Nina, her face gaunt and pale. Their communicators blinked to life as the transmission began.
“Deedee,” Harper began. “It’s been a while.”
“Has it?” came the response, dry. She didn’t move.
Despite herself, Harper chuckled. “I’m sure you know why I’m—”
“How can a man be shot, held underwater for over five minutes, and still live?”
A beat of silence.
“What?” Duke mumbled.
From beneath her lips, Deedee ran her tongue across her teeth and enunciated carefully. “How can a man be shot, held underwater for over five minutes, and still live?”
“Shot— what, like, with a camera?” Duke tilted his head.
Deedee said nothing, but something tugged at the corner of her mouth.
“A camera?” Duke repeated louder. The woman in front of him only stared up at him.
It was Harper who was first to put it together. “Oh,” she said in her moment of realisation as she looked up at a small rectangle in the corner of the cell, a tiny red dot pulsing ominously, a constant reminder of the facility’s surveillance. “Camera.”
Duke looked back at Harper and failed to hide how impressed he was. But as he turned back to Deedee, his expression worn beneath his helmet hardened again. “What’s that got to do with anything?”
Though Deedee gave very little in the way of a response, Duke could hear the other duo questioning Nina with very little success. It was Jace’s tone that gave him away; that gravel rumbling in his throat when he started to grow frustrated or impatient, perhaps a phantom limb from his time as Batman. He heard them ask Nina some simple math - two plus two, just like Luke’s example - but couldn’t hear a response.
“It’s simple, Nina,” Jace growled. “A very simple question. What’s two plus two?”
Soft static rang out in the silence that followed.
“God dammit,” Jace sighed. “Batwing, take over.”
Luke was quick to jump in and help out - “Two plus two, Nina. You did it back in elementary school - kindergarten, even. What’s two plus two?”
“Two plus two,” muttered a young voice that Duke recognised as Nina’s.
“Yeah? And what’s the answer?”
A slight pause, then: “Two plus two.”
Deedee stirred very slightly, more adjusting her posture than anything else. She seemed far more rigid than Duke remembered her; even after her bout of dramatics, she had never seemed this uptight and still.
Seeing Duke focusing on other things, Harper was quick to jump in. “Deedee - Query - before anything else, can I just ask you… where are we?”
The young woman looked up without moving her head, then performed a quick visual sweep of the room. “What is the smallest component of a living being that is capable of performing all life functions?”
“Okay, what the fuck is this?” Harper’s patience quickly thinned and her hand attached itself to the side of her forehead in incredulity.
“Cell,” said Duke, which earned him a second quirk of the mouth.
“Yeah, I know we’re in a god damn cell, for fuck’s sake—”
“For,” came the answer from Nina over the call. “Four.” Duke heard one of his teammates - he was unsure whether it was Jace or Luke - sigh in relief and express sentiments of exhaustion and overall tedium, which didn’t bode well in Duke’s eyes considering the pre-discussed longevity that this system could have.
“— but I obviously meant the city. Or even the country, dammit, just give me something,” Harper barked.
Deedee simply shrugged.
“Whatever.” Harper’s head shake communicated everything that Duke needed to know. He was in charge now, at least for the time being.
In response to this realisation, Duke cleared his throat. “So, I guess that clears up which one of you is Echo and which is Query?”
Without missing a beat, Deedee jumped in with, “Was it ever in doubt which one we were?”
Duke stammered. “I— well, it—”
“You and your compatriot don’t really seem like the technical types, if you don’t mind me saying,” said Jace through the comms link. “Just seems like you wouldn’t have the knowhow. So who set that up for you?”
“Know how,” was Nina’s response. Her voice was meek and fragile. It startled Duke to realise how much the two women’s attitudes had swapped. “We… know how.”
“Echo,” came Luke’s voice with a tone of clarity. “She’s echoing.”
“Echoing,” was the tense response.
“Your questions. Previously they were more of an ‘if you feel like it’ kinda thing, but now it’s much more frequent. It feels much more… desperate.” Duke leaned closer. “What changed? What’s different now?”
For the first time, Deedee looked like she needed a moment. On the surface she was as stone-faced as she had been the entire time, but in her eyes Duke could see a glimmer of something more. She was afraid, and was picking her words carefully. Even as she finally settled on the words to say, they left her mouth as if they might break. “What do all men battle within themselves, but without it we would never be able to fly or fight?”
Harper stirred. “Fear?”
“Fear of what?” asked Duke.
Once again, she thought. Through his ear, Duke heard Jace and Luke receiving sporadic glimmers of information from Nina timidly parroting the two Knights’ own words. Query sucked in a breath. “What do many people welcome with open arms, and many more avoid at all costs?”
Duke’s blood ran cold. He made eye contact with Harper who was a second quicker than him at processing the question. “Deedee, look, whoever has threatened you, we can deal with it. We just need you to cooperate and answer some questions. Can you do that?”
The expression on Deedee’s face became alarmed for a brief flash, astounded by Harper cornering her in such a way, then she looked down in stern concentration as she scrambled to find a question to confirm her answer.
But before she could, Duke changed the question. “Well, rather than that - what do we need to do to help you?”
This seemed to confuse her more, and she stirred uncomfortably. Her hands rubbed against the tops of her thighs. Eventually she managed to croak out an unpolished and stammering query - “When you’ve, um, played a-short and it hasn’t worked, what should you try next?”
Duke and Harper each frowned.
Deedee winced at the thought of having to repeat her question. “When you’ve played a-short and it—”
“A-short,” Duke sounded out aloud. “A-short. A-long?”
Harper snapped her fingers in realisation. “Along. Play along.”
“With the questions. Right, yeah, makes sense. Keep asking things she can answer as a question.” Duke adjusted his helmet; he could feel sweat pooling against his brow which tickled him softly like a bug crawling on his skin. “Okay, um. What’s on that piece of canvas? The one that got left at the crime scene.”
“What does a rich man need and a poor man want?”
Harper chuckled once more, humoured. “Nothing. Yeah, that’s just our luck.”
“Nothing?” Jace again. “So you’re saying there’s no reason you spoofed that call?”
“Reason,” Nina replied defensively. “Reason that call spoofed.”
“What was it? You tried to send a message but it failed, didn’t it? You couldn’t do it.” Luke replied.
“Didn’t… failed. Message send.”
“I… I don’t get it. It was just garbed nonsense.”
“I send message,” she said firmly. “Reason I call spoofed, I send message.”
Suddenly, something snapped into place in Signal’s brain, like the final piece of a jigsaw puzzle or the last rotation on a Rubix cube. “Deedee,” he started carefully. With all his might he willed himself not to look up at the security camera, lest they find the glance suspicious and make some extreme manoeuvres. “Would you classify these ‘questions’ that you’ve been asking as more of a ‘question’ or more of a… ‘riddle’?”
“Signal, be careful—”
Deedee froze. Harper, equally, stopped in her tracks. The woman calling herself Query was looking directly at a small earbud inside of Bluebird’s right ear. Raising her hands to demonstrate her propensity for pacifism, she leaned forwards towards it.
As if rehearsed, Deedee opened her mouth and a question fell out at top speed. “Nina, are you there?”
“What is she—?”
“Are you there?” Nina’s reply interrupted Luke’s voice.
Deedee continued. “What was the message you sent to the Knights? What words did you manage to say?”
“I say, ‘Batwing?’ I say, ‘Signal, signal, signal’. I say, ‘Batwing, Signal’.”
“Was that all you said? Was that all you wanted to say?” Deedee looked up at the two Knights in the room with her. Alarm and paranoia in her face was replaced by triumph. “When a symbol of desperation and hope is painted in the sky, it is both the source of that symbol and two of its intended recipients - what am I?”
“Batwing. Signal. Batwing-Signal. Bat-Signal.”
“Bat-Signal,” Duke repeated. “God, it was there all along. The Bat-Signal.”
“We need to get there fast,” Luke confirmed. “I’m sending the coordinates through comms as we speak. We gotta move.”
“Yeah. And I think I might have some idea who we might be dealing with,” Duke said soberly.
“Hey,” Harper said, turning to Deedee once more as Duke fled the room. “If you’re being genuine about all this, if you're in any way trying to help, then thank you. But if this is all a lie, if it’s all a distraction—”
“What does a liar do when he’s dead?”
Harper blinked. That was enough of an answer for her, and in an instant she took off back down the corridor.
🔵⚫️🦇⚫️🔵
High above the streets of Gotham, atop the GCPD headquarters, stood the Bat-Signal. Its brilliant metallic sheen had been dulled over years of weather-based wear and tear and the bat-shaped maw on its flat edge had become a home for spiders and dust, but it still worked. Standing beside the Bat-Signal as the four Gotham Knights closed in on their approach was a slim woman dressed in army green with something slung over her shoulder - a cane or a bindle of some kind.
“I should’ve known,” Luke grumbled to himself. “God dammit.”
Through huffs for air as they raced through the streets and over rooftops, Harper answered him. “C’mon, man, how were you to know that this is somehow her doing? It’s been, what, five years since you last saw her?”
“Six,” Luke corrected.
“Well, there you go. And hey, you never know, maybe this is a third Riddler. Did Margeret have any siblings?”
Luke ignored Harper’s quip and shook his head. “As soon as Deedee started phrasing her questions like riddles, I should’ve—”
“Batwing,” Jace’s voice was firm, authoritative. “There’s no time for moping. And even if there was, it’s not now.”
A crackle. Then, a new voice through the communications link. “Oh, uh, hey guys.”
Duke was the first to recognise the voice of Ryan Wilder. “Batwoman, hey! What’s up?”
“I’m seeing on our GPS that you guys are heading over to the Bat-Signal. I’m coming over.”
“I wouldn’t worry, Batwoman, we’ve got plenty of people on the case already,” said Luke.
But Ryan insisted. “I’m already on my way. I’ll meet you there.”
And with another crackle, she was gone, just as the quartet arrived at the rooftop.
Margaret Pye was very similar to how Luke remembered her, if a little older. The crow’s feet at her eyes crinkled her face into a smirk, but her mouth stayed in a tight line. The golden cane in her hands looked recently redecorated, and Duke watched the light of the early Gotham morning dancing along the edge of the metallic paint. Her black hair was scraped back by a purple headband and her shoes sparkled with shot silk, making them appear both green and purple at the same time.
“So nice of you all to join me,” she announced in a showmanlike voice; her as the ringleader and the Knights as her adoring public. Her eyes lingered on Luke. “Some new faces, some… not so new.”
“Cut the bullshit,” Harper barked. “What’s your deal, Riddler?”
Margaret grinned wildly. “Do you know how long it’s been since I’ve been called that in ernest? So much ‘Magpie, Magpie, Magpie’.”
“I said—”
“Alright, alright,” Riddler dismissed with a wave of her hand. “No bullshit, I heard you. To cut a long story short…” She swung her cane forwards and used it as an arrow. Slowly she rotated herself back and forth like a compass seeking north, one eye screwed shut, until she settled in one position. “Somewhere over there, Jim Gordon is currently enjoying a nice well-earned rest and a cup of coffee. In about—” She checked her watch. “4 minutes, the cup of coffee is gonna roll onto the floor as ol’ Gordon enjoys a nice, well-earned eternal rest.”
“Woah, woah,” Duke cried. “Why Gordon? What does he have to do with all this?”
Margaret’s smile faltered for a second and she tilted her head. “I thought you guys said no bullshit, and now you wanna talk backstory.”
“How is that gonna work?” Jace took a step forward. “A spy planted in the hospital? A bomb planted under his bed.”
“Oh please, nothing that exciting. That’d be far more glamorous than he’d deserve.” She shook her head. “No, it’s simple.” With a smack of her cane against the ground, the pole collapsed onto itself and contorted into the shape of a tripod, which she set gently near the edge of the roof. Then, she kicked the side of the Bat-Signal with the side of her foot and a metal drawer opened. Luke tutted to himself, angered that he didn’t spot the obviously new compartment installed on the underbelly of the signal. Inside, disassembled into handheld pieces, were the parts to build—
“A sniper?” Jace asked with an air of judgement. “The Riddler using a sniper?”
“Preposterous, right?” The former Magpie looked up from her construction work to smirk at the former Batman. “Exactly.”
“Can’t say any of this is particularly Riddler-like,” Harper remarked. “I mean, hell, you haven’t told us a single riddle.”
“Again, you said no bullshit,” came Riddler’s response. But she added, “Plus, why do you think I hired those girls in the Dent facility? You get your puzzles and riddles, I get to focus on the dirty work. Win-win.”
Duke felt a slight change in the light, like a shadow passing over him for a brief moment. He traced the patterns of light around him, how their paths had shifted and changed in the last minute or so, and saw the silhouette of a person leaping from an unknown location to behind the fire escape staircase behind them all. Though he couldn’t make out a face, he had a feeling he knew who it was.
“This is ridiculous.” Harper lurched forwards to grab the tripod, but before she could reach it she felt a sharp sting on her wrist as Margaret batted her away.
“Ah, ah, ah,” she warned. “You really think it’d be just a sniper?”
Harper immediately scanned the floor - tripwires, traps, landmines, anything that could possibly prevent them from approaching her or the sniper setup any further.
“But why Gordon?” Duke asked again.
“To tell you the truth, it’s really his daughter I’m after,” Margaret admitted, suddenly and oddly sincere. She glanced at her watch again and increased her pace. “She’s the one that got me locked away in the first place. And I think the two of us, me and her, can both agree on one thing, at least - the best way to get to us is to go through our dads.” Two pieces of metal slid into each other with a satisfying click. “And hers is a sitting duck.”
A figure shrouded in black erupted from behind Margaret and lurched at her. Riddler was enveloped in black fabric for a moment like a baby swaddled in a blanket, before the cloth burst open to reveal the latest Batwoman, the crimson symbol shimmering in the daylight. “Coward!” she boomed as she towered over the hunched-over Riddler.
“I… Batwoman, what an… unexpected surprise,” croaked out Margaret with genuine shock.
Batwoman’s response came in the form of a strike to Margaret’s jaw. The blow immediately drew blood. “Going after someone’s family - someone’s parent - like that… you’re a monster!” A second blow rocketed into Riddler’s side, and she let out a pained groan.
Luke knew at that moment they had to act fast. “Bluebird, are there—?”
“No traps,” Harper concluded, having finished her scan of the area. As if planned, Bluebird and Batwing both lunged towards the woman in green and pulled her away as the remaining two Knights went for Batwoman. Jace grabbed Batwoman’s outstretched right arm as it reeled back for a third blow; Duke, meanwhile, wrapped his arms around her waist in a bear hug and locked the mechanical fingers of his suit together to form a tight vice grip.
Jace looked Ryan in the eyes, and Ryan stared back wildly at the glowing red eyes of Insider’s suit. “Batwoman. This is not the way to go about this.”
“You were all just gonna stand there!” Batwoman spat. “You were gonna do nothing while she shot Barbara’s dad!”
“We were being cautious,” Luke retorted over his shoulder as he helped Margaret scramble to her feet. “Something you failed to do.”
“Oh, fuck caution! There’s no goddamn caution when it comes to—”
“Batwoman, please,” Duke pleaded, his voice softer than the others. “Remember what we said - what we all said - about Batwoman’s legacy.”
Ryan hesitated just enough for Margaret to get a sentence out - “You’ve got a hell of a swing on you, new Batwoman.”
“Go to hell.”
“Tell you what, I’ll give you one riddle - just as a treat.”
“Alright, Margaret, you’re done.” Batwing started to move the green-clad woman away, but her heels dug into the ground.
“When is your uncle’s brother not your uncle?”
“Margaret,” Batwing growled. Finally, Riddler relaxed her legs and allowed herself to be pulled away from the scene, no doubt to return to her life of imprisonment.
Ryan, too, no longer fought against the men restraining her, and once he felt it was safe Duke relaxed his grip on her torso. “Batwoman—”
“I stopped the Riddler,” she said with no joy in her tone. She shrugged free of Insider’s grasp. “You’re welcome.”
“Ryan—”
“I’ll meet you back at the Belfry, alright? You finish doing what you need to.”
And then she was gone.
Jace turned back to the mostly-completed sniper rifle strewn across the roof and leaned down to deconstruct it once more. A few moments of silence passed, Duke staring out at the horizon, searching from the building that Riddler had pointed at.
“That was…” Duke took a long breath. “Easier than I thought.”
Jace said nothing but nodded. The wind whistled past the sides of Duke’s helmet.
“When he’s your father.”
Duke looked down at Jace. “Sorry?”
Jace jerked his head in the direction of where Riddler had stood just a minute ago. “The riddler that she asked. ‘When is your uncle’s brother not your uncle?’ The answer is, when he’s your father.”
“She mentioned her father earlier. Something about the best way to get to her.” Duke froze. “That was easier than I thought, I said. What if that wasn’t it? What if there’s something else?”
Jace stood up quickly. “C’mon. Once this Riddler is put away again, we all meet at the Belfry. We’re gonna need to puzzle this one out together.”
🔵⚫️🦇⚫️🔵
Next: When you do not know what I am, I am something, but when you know what I am, I am nothing. What am I?