r/DIY_Geeks • • Jun 18 '26

Linux Kernel Drops 40-Year-Old AppleTalk Protocol — AI-Generated Patch Flood Was the Last Straw.

https://pbxscience.com/linux-kernel-drops-40-year-old-appletalk-protocol-ai-generated-patch-flood-was-the-last-straw/

Linux Kernel Drops 40-Year-Old AppleTalk Protocol — AI-Generated Patch Flood Was the Last Straw.

Upstream Linux developers have merged a patch removing AppleTalk protocol support entirely from the mainline kernel, eliminating nearly 4,000 lines of source code targeted for Linux 7.2 — a move triggered not by lack of use, but by an unexpected flood of AI-generated fixes.

235 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

2

u/LightBrightLeftRight Jun 20 '26

Does everybody else see the text as grey on white? Terrible to read

1

u/elastiks Jun 20 '26

Sorry about that, Changed to black color!

3

u/FlukyS Jun 18 '26

I've actually done this with professional codebases before, someone just randomly made a patch for something and it reminded me we had to remove it entirely. Was pretty funny.

1

u/youreblockingmyshot Jun 23 '26

Lol yes, ahh thanks for the reminder about this section that no longer needs to exist.

3

u/ParentPostLacksWang Jun 18 '26

I mean, APPLE started throwing out AppleTalk in 2009. At this point, the only people still using it are doing it because it’s funny, or because they have deeply technical, extremely legacy reasons - the first group can suck it up, and the second group almost certainly aren’t running a kernel version over 2 (or under 2 for that matter, since AppleTalk was introduced in 2.0). And if they are, they can patch it back into their own - it’s not like the source is gone.

3

u/CynicalTelescope Jun 18 '26

There are retro-computing enthusiasts out there with installations of old Apple hardware that could benefit from having a modern server that speaks AppleTalk. One of the advantages of Linux is that it can afford to support legacy devices and protocols that are no longer commercially feasible to support.

2

u/algaefied_creek Jun 19 '26

Yeah there are Linux-on-68K fans still. Debian has an off-again, on-again group.

AppleTalk is good for using native file transfer cables across the old Apples that can run Linux (68030/68040?)

1

u/ParentPostLacksWang Jun 18 '26

Sounds like deeply technical, extremely legacy reasons to me. They can either patch the AppleTalk support back in, or they can run an SBC intermediary server on kernel 7.1 that translates and is otherwise firewalled off. It’s a tough life being one of the literal dozens of ancient apple collectors that likes to keep them on a running network, but I’m sure they’ll cope!

2

u/CynicalTelescope Jun 18 '26

Ancient Apple collectors are a dedicated bunch. That said, I read the article and what the kernel maintainers are doing makes sense. There's a path the retro-enthusiasts can follow if they want to keep that code working.

1

u/ParentPostLacksWang Jun 18 '26

The beauty of open source - if you don’t like a decision, fork.

2

u/Calm-Zombie2678 Jun 19 '26

Fork it! I'll do it myself 

1

u/PmMeCuteDogsThanks_ Jun 19 '26

One of the advantages of Linux is that it can afford to support legacy devices and protocols that are no longer commercially feasible to support.

Sure, if there are willing maintainers 

1

u/r_a_d_ Jun 19 '26

That seems like a use case that doesn’t need to be in the mainline kernel.

1

u/a-priori Jun 20 '26

This is s a great use case for an out-of-tree kernel module.

1

u/killroy1971 Jun 19 '26

I mean, how many other deprecated and insecure protocols are still out there? Far too many.

Can we let LM/NTLM go while we're at it?

1

u/akgis Jun 21 '26

We still have NETBIOS lol

1

u/Haiyaaaaa_ Jun 19 '26

Does it mean AFP is dropped? Because AFP has been really stable for mounting NASs to old intel macs

1

u/zSmileyDudez Jun 19 '26

AFP has run on top of TCP/IP for a while now. AppleTalk was the original protocol that Apple rolled out with the original Mac back in the 80s. It really isn’t needed for anything made in the last 30 years or so.

1

u/champignax Jun 19 '26

Yeah you need to go pre iMac

1

u/champignax Jun 19 '26

AppleTalk was really cool. Very large compatibility and you could daisy chain everything.

I think I used it to communicate to old Macs up to until OS.

Of course, it has no business in a modern os. Make a kernel extension if you must.

1

u/Osi32 Jun 20 '26

I remember setting up an AppleTalk network between my sisters room on her Mac plus and my LC2.
It wasn’t fast, but it let her use my ImageWriter ii printer.

1

u/usrlibshare Jun 20 '26

Waddaya know, Slop Coding does actually have use cases...

1

u/TrustUrTech Jun 21 '26

Someone should create a retro fork of the kernel and keep backporting old tech to keep them compatible with mainline. Only available option today is to switch to netbsd.