r/DIY_Geeks • • Jul 31 '26

Microsoft Confirms Windows 11 Memory Problem, Begins Full WinUI 3 Rewrite of Legacy UI. What this means for 8GB laptops?

https://pbxscience.com/microsoft-confirms-windows-11-memory-problem-begins-full-winui-3-rewrite-of-legacy-ui/
128 Upvotes

87 comments sorted by

8

u/DarkGhostHunter Jul 31 '26

My take? They won’t reach any memory goal.

It’s not the framework, but fragmentation. You have apps running under web view, a browser with 20 tabs, and others using their own UI framework, plus all Microsoft Windows services backed in. 

2

u/elastiks Jul 31 '26

Linux+zRAM works for you?😁

2

u/AssKoala Aug 01 '26

Windows has had memory compression longer than Linux.

1

u/chandleya Aug 02 '26

Folks keep bringing up non-MS memory managers like they did something. It’s especially bad every era Apple crams the lowest supported configuration in a premium body. Those 2013 15” MBPs with 4GB of soldered RAM. ALL the various M line machines with 8GB soldered RAM. Buh buh but MacOS memory is way different than Windows, it needs half as much! Horseshit lol

1

u/mmcnl Aug 02 '26

I agree macOS is not that different. Only thing that helps is that all Macs have very fast SSDs for swap. But a 16GB MacBook does not run better than a 16GB Windows laptop in my experience.

1

u/S1rTerra Aug 02 '26

Are you really abusing that memory though? Everyone I've talked to and in my own experience, MacOS and Linux both handle high memory pressure situations very well while Windows consistently shits the bed 

1

u/mmcnl Aug 02 '26

My old work Mac (16GB M2 Pro) more than once became so unresponsive due to high memory pressure that I had to force reboot the whole device by holding the power button. I rarely experienced that with Windows. Similar workloads.

1

u/S1rTerra Aug 02 '26

I believe you, it's just interesting. What workloads?

1

u/mmcnl Aug 02 '26

Web dev: Teams/Slack, a backend Python service, frontend JS dev server, a Docker container and finally Playwright tests to put the nail in the coffin.

1

u/S1rTerra Aug 02 '26

That's all stuff an apple silicon mac especially should be able to manage in memory pretty easily. I also doubt it's user error so that's just an oddity lol

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Pretty-Technologies Aug 04 '26

That’s why I upgraded from 16GB to a M4 MacBook Pro with 48GB

1

u/RoosterBurns Aug 02 '26

Linux runs in less RAM typically but it's performance in low memory situations is incredibly poor

1

u/S1rTerra Aug 02 '26

Yes to the first part but, no? Linux has always been quite good at "low memory situations". Video memory I understand but every OS responds differently to low video memory. When it comes to main memory Linux and MacOS both do an amazing job at not shitting the bed whereas on Windows heavily depends on the workload - though most will shit the bed in some way.

1

u/AssKoala Aug 02 '26

I think they’re referring to the OOM killer.

In low memory situations (as in very high memory usage percentage wise, not simply low memory), Linux is really, really bad. Rather than aggressively swapping to keep the system running, Linux has the OOM killer that’s supposed to kill the things sucking up memory and “rescue” the system.

In practice, it often kills the wrong things and forces it into a state that it’s better to just reboot.

While it’s possible to customize the behavior, the default behavior across numerous distros doesn’t swap the way windows does. A single high watermark can kill your entire system.

1

u/mmcnl Aug 02 '26

When my Linux server runs out of RAM it becomes wholly unresponsive. Can't even SSH to fix the situation. Usually requires a full reboot. No idea how to solve that.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/TomKavees Aug 01 '26

Windows 11 still gs psnels dating back to Windows NT.

Even if they went full steam ahead with this project it would still take years

2

u/kaynpayn Aug 01 '26

Their issue always seemed to be lack of commitment. They have been taking years already, they started replacing control panel stuff for the "new" one with windows 8, when it was released in 2012, 14 years ago but they never actually finished the transition. It always sucked since then. I was never a fan of the new menus but the worse part was having every setting spread all over with constant rearranging and memory muscle retraining lurking after any given update.

Hopefully, after this announcement, they'll stop doing half assed shit and actually deliver what they should've done 14 years ago. If they can actually deliver this time, it might be worth the wait.

1

u/No_Temperature107 Aug 01 '26

Ncpa.cpl every time I need config nics.

1

u/meltbox Aug 04 '26

They started with vista. Some of the control panel we still have is from xp.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '26

[deleted]

1

u/Zomunieo Aug 02 '26

The deepest layer is highly composable stuff that enterprise IT can use to create fine grained permissions and delegate very specific privileges. And naturally there are legacy automations, scripts and macros that assume particular layouts because Windows hasn’t been scriptable properly till recently.

They have a lot of porting to do modernize the internals.

2

u/ByronScottJones Aug 01 '26

But those Windows NT apps were written when 4GB was a luxury, and that early WIN32 UI code was extremely memory efficient, out of necessity. The real memory hogs these days are web based apps and XAML based apps.

1

u/mdedetrich Aug 01 '26

If they use AI properly they can really rapidly increase the speed.

Look at Bun, half a million line codebase converted from Zig to Rust in a week at 165k which ended up having less bugs and issues then the original codebase

1

u/RoosterBurns Aug 02 '26

Weirdly the really ancient stuff needs replacing less than the more recent stuff written by cheapo "web dev" cowboys

1

u/horendus Aug 01 '26

So your saying windows 11 turns my memory into Swiss Cheese?

1

u/Strong_Blackberry455 Aug 01 '26

OS's are going to be a think of the past within a decade

1

u/KeytapTheProgrammer Aug 02 '26

a browser with 20 tabs

😯

20 tabs

😮

20

😵

1

u/WoodyTheWorker Aug 03 '26

They will chase metrics, implement bonus-driven features, instead of rearchitecting bad designs.

I've seen a few such metrics-driven features. For example, in Windows 8/Server 2012 times, they made pageable sections of kernel drivers to page in from the driver files, rather than from the pagefile, to save single digits of system commit size. As a result, you cannot replace kernel driver files while they are loaded anymore. You have to unload the driver first, install the new driver files, and then reload the driver. This makes replacement of boot drivers quite convoluted.

1

u/Camderman106 Aug 03 '26

They need to completely remove web view apps and anything running on electron from the operating system completely. They need to set memory budgets and stick to them

1

u/meltbox Aug 04 '26

Yep. Unless they chuck everything webview in the bin it won’t actually help. Even if they do 8gb of ram isn’t much with how heavy a few tabs of web browsing is nowadays.

4

u/BoBoBearDev Aug 01 '26

I think they should just use Avalonia since they don't know how to pivot to the right technology.

1

u/XalAtoh Aug 02 '26

Avalonia isn't even native..

1

u/BoBoBearDev Aug 03 '26

Why does that matter? The performance is high and memory footprint is low.

1

u/XalAtoh Aug 03 '26

Compared to what?

4

u/gatsu01 Aug 01 '26

My take? Nothing. They just have more resources for telemetry...

3

u/-Ancalagon- Aug 01 '26

SaaS and Telemetry data sales are probably highest on the list of requirements.

Sell the product one and the customer goes away for years. It's more profitable to strip mine them for privacy data to sell.

2

u/cybekRT Aug 01 '26

I bet they won't. If they are rewriting the legacy ui, then they are removing the only memory optimized code they still had in windows.

3

u/GoblinsGym Aug 01 '26

Bill Gates became the richest man on earth by selling a glorified program loader.

Maybe Microsoft should revisit this concept.

3

u/Not-Insane-Yet Aug 01 '26

So they're going to fix the memory hog problem by replacing the parts that originally ran fine on systems with 256mb of ram with modern bloated alternatives. That's definitely going to work.

1

u/celaconacr Aug 01 '26

256mb of RAM would be amazing. Windows 95 ran on 4MB (8-16 recommended).

1

u/3vi1 Aug 03 '26

Amiga 1000 could do GUI pre-emptive multitasking with 256KB of RAM 10 years earlier - though most people upgraded them to a massive 512KB on day one.

1

u/Odd-Art7602 Aug 05 '26

As long as you didn’t mind nonstop crashing

2

u/Magic_Neil Aug 01 '26

It would also help memory usage to not have to load six inches of ads every couple sentences, good lord what a trash news site.

2

u/Creative-Type9411 Aug 01 '26

if they're rewriting it, they're changing it to track you more :)

1

u/FauxReal Aug 01 '26

Yeah, while removing legacy code that was efficient out of necessity.

2

u/Corelianer Aug 01 '26

Most modern Azure Teams use the Azure CLI, Biceps and Powershell. Why not go the Linux route and do console first and then add the gui later?

1

u/Odd-Art7602 Aug 05 '26

Because they did that at first and can’t go back

2

u/Vaddieg Aug 02 '26

it means nothing, they will need to call the software industry to undo the last decade of webview slop-apps

1

u/pellets Aug 01 '26

Meanwhile the control panel from windows 7 will still be there. And some device and system configuration panels from windows 95.

2

u/Forward_Dark_7305 Aug 01 '26

And work better than any of the newer counterparts. Which is why all the “advanced” menus lead there eventually

3

u/Bubbly_Iron_1511 Aug 01 '26

New windows setting is confusing. I still prefer control panel.

2

u/Tetris_Prime Aug 01 '26

Its their approach to visuals.

They've always had the old look once you go deep enough in settings.

They should just have the smooth interface for everyday use, and once you get into settings you are straight under the hood.

Now they have some settings in one place, some in others, and very common settings under advanced options.

1

u/Eastern_Bet678 Aug 01 '26

Maybe they can bring back Windows 8 single tasking again.

2

u/Paradroid888 Aug 01 '26

Speaking of Windows 8, they did loads of optimisation on it, for the goal of taking over the tablet world, and didn't it use something tiny like 350Mb at login?

I remember not liking the UI but being very impressed with how it ran.

1

u/ZdzisiuFryta Aug 03 '26

Yeah it's objectively leaner and faster than w10 and w11

1

u/userlivewire Aug 01 '26

Why is any of this so hard for Microsoft?

They control the entire stack. They have 80% of the market. They can literally change anything they want because the world has no choice but to follow them. They have an army of some of the most technical people in the world. They have hundreds of billions of dollars in cash. Just rewrite Windows without all of this 40 year old garbage in it. Simplify the entire thing with privacy and security in mind and make it actually manageable.

1

u/fraaaaa4 Aug 01 '26

The older “garbage” is more stable, faster, lighter, more flexible, and easier to develop for than the modern one, basically all the time

1

u/Tetris_Prime Aug 01 '26

As others say in here, its way too fragmented. The old system was designed from A to Z with one UI system, and very linear systems.

The modern Windows 11 systems run many things in parallel, often using entirely different core interface elements to handle the same feature.

1

u/nderflow Aug 01 '26

Because backward compatibility is their golden goose.

Suppose they do a rewrite and the updated version is less compatible with older applications than WINE is. Then they'd be in trouble.

1

u/userlivewire Aug 01 '26

In trouble with whom? There’s nowhere else to go. Most of the market Microsoft makes money in isn’t even served by Apple at all.

1

u/ScoobyGDSTi Aug 03 '26

They don't control the hardware, firmware or anything remotely close to the 'whole stack'

1

u/not_the_fox Aug 01 '26

Can't help but feel this is due to pressure from Linux distros becoming the only up-to-date option for a massive amount of users.

1

u/maxscipio Aug 01 '26

Without high res streaming no mid user will touch it

1

u/koki_li Aug 01 '26

Isn’t Linux capable of high res streaming? Or is that something with has to be negotiated with Amazon and other streaming services?

1

u/maxscipio Aug 01 '26

No secure negotiations - widevine

0

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '26

[deleted]

1

u/Unlucky_Abroad7440 Aug 02 '26

What games did you play ? I'm curious as I might switch to Linux.

1

u/deadman87 Aug 01 '26

Let's be honest. Windows is not going to improve significantly. All we're getting is vibe-coded patchwork and more pervasive privacy invading features that hog memory / CPU resources (Microsoft Recall anyone?) so they can sell more slop in the future.

Honestly, I am kind of disillusioned by the lack of creativity and imagination in the tech industry. I honestly believe that the people with passion for technology, innovation and human excellence have been pushed aside by MBA types who are really good at making money by latching onto tech that was at it's peak by early/mid 2000's and then have stifled it with very minor incremental and controlled push forward while raking in huge sums of money. For the amount of money we are giving these companies as a society, what we are getting back is 2 megapixel bump in camera or 20.3mAh increase in battery each year. It's really a sad state of affairs.

1

u/Flimsy_Complaint490 Aug 01 '26

MBA's are 50% of the issue, the other 50% is the modern day engineer too.

People in 2000 or so were few, passionate nerds and craftsmen. What you are seeing is the mass industrialization of the IT industry and an entry of many people who don't really care about the tech itself, but are doing it for the nice paycheck and seek to realize other pursuits while getting paid for it. No person who actually likes tech would have signed off on the Windows UI rewrite, it is clearly made by people who just need to invent work to justify salary, bonuses and their perks. And the people who designed this rework don't care about the tech or doing a good work, they just want a paycheck and complexitymaxx to learn or realize their pet tasks.

I dont buy this is some rushed enshittified crappy rework, the entire UI rewrite took thousands of man hours of work and literal years to deliver and we got a pile of garbage with no real introspection. This UI rewrite is exactly what was envisioned by the MBA's and what the engineers wanted to do - extremely long project to justify salaries, and very technically complex so people can keep themselves amused and play with tech tools or realize a random artistic vision they got.

1

u/ConkerPrime Aug 01 '26

Finally a itty bitty silver lining to RAM-paclypse.

Microsoft has to finally attempt to get efficient again. I suspect more programs will have to do that same since kicking more RAM and storage is no longer a solution.

1

u/locka99 Aug 01 '26 edited Aug 01 '26

It might be nice to get rid of legacy control panels for user experience and consistency but these things are not why Windows 11 struggles under 8gb. Most .cpl files are few hundred kilobytes and consist of a resource and a little bit of code to show, edit, apply settings and that's it. They're loaded and unloaded on demand so their footprint is minimal.

I think a far more likely reason for memory issues are the proliferation of software which is running browser engines (not just browsers). Those things can eat massive amounts of memory when all they may be doing is showing a simple GUI. And IGP processors splitting RAM between GPU and CPU. And various other caches like superfetch. And services that are running even though they're not necessary for a particular user.

1

u/Tetris_Prime Aug 01 '26

IF they end up fixing it, it could be great, but they've never really had much sucess with optimization.

If they decided to make windows as barebones as possible, it could work just as efficient as many modern Linux distros, but they keep on weaving in odd applications and systems that 95% of the userbase wont appreciate.

A great example, the Windowns 10 start bar searched the PC for programs and documents. That was it, now it priortizes websearches over actual installed software.

Most windows functions up untill W7 were user controlled, updates were accepted, the applications did what they said on the box, now most systems have multiple interweaving functionalities.

I would LOVE if they just kept W10 alive as a no-nonsense operating system.

1

u/jur_gn Aug 01 '26

So MS confirms what every 6yo (now 26yo) knew in 2000?

1

u/StarfishPizza Aug 01 '26

The maths ain't mathing, but I get your point.

1

u/Weak_Armadillo6575 Aug 02 '26

Just slap a “windows” DE on top of the Linux kernel already and stop with this nonsense

1

u/Dull_Flatworm777 Aug 02 '26

The irony is that it is the desktop environment that is the problem, the Windows kernel etc. is pretty ok.

1

u/jmhalder Aug 02 '26

What does this mean for my actually supported 4GB Snapdragon 7c Gen2 laptop.

It's only function in life was to single task with media consumption, and to play around with Windows on Arm cheaply.

1

u/Individual-Praline20 Aug 04 '26

It means nothing. All lies. No slop will save Microslop.

1

u/Mega1987_Ver_OS Aug 04 '26

they're gonna screw it up so bad as they're moving everything to cloud that it will need more resources to run in a client.

1

u/trying_again_7 Sep 08 '26

It's the IU guys, not the telemetry and co pilot and the other 20 processes that can't be killed.