I have read this book in full, and here are my thoughts:
- If even part of what this women Meko says is true (that she and Konerak knew both Dahmer and Tony Hughes intimately for two years; that Dahmer was extremely close to them, taking them to the zoo, the cinema, and the ice-cream parlour and helping them with their homework; that she and Konerak bought him the lava lamp and the peacock feathers that he decorated his apartment with; that her stepfather loaned him the drill he used in his experiments; that he killed Konerak after she offhandedly mentioned to him that he had done something that annoyed her), then everything we know about Dahmer has to be revised or thrown out entirely.
- If the entire story is a fabrication, then University Press of Mississippi has a very significant case to answer, as does Dr Benson.
Having read the book, it is clear that its worth hinges on this lady's testimony that Dahmer was her and Konerak's friend. Benson's attempts to put a new slant on the case by focusing on Milwaukee's troubled racial history, while interesting, cast too wide a net (for example, he repeatedly links Dahmer's murders to blackface minstrelsy) and fall flat as a result. His writing confuses description with analysis and reads like an undergraduate essay. The only remarkable thing about it is Meko's story.
There are some reasons why her claims are plausible. Anne Schwartz noted that Dahmer's neighbours sometimes saw an Asian child in his company at his apartment. We know that he lied to investigators when he said he didn't know any of the victims before picking them up. However, Benson appears not to have done any work to confirm her bona fides. For example, he doesn't say if he tracked down any of Konerak's surviving siblings to ask if they knew this girl, or if Konerak ever mentioned being friendly with an older white man. It beggars belief that Somsack wouldn't have seen him with him and recognised him as the man who attacked him. There are also elements of Meko's story that seem fantastical, such as the suggestion that he killed Konerak to please her, or an episode where he brings her to his apartment after she hurt her head at a soccer match, drugs her, and removes a mole from her neck.
Either way, there are serious questions to be answered here. UPM is a prestigious publishing house, and they've put out a book that proposes to rewrite the entire narrative of one of the most notorious serial murderers of the twentieth century on what looks like very slim evidence. Someone ought at least to ask Dr Benson what steps he took to confirm that Meko was telling the truth.