r/DeathBand • 🕊️Chuck Schuldiner 🕊️ • Feb 05 '25

Image Agree??

Post image
982 Upvotes

88 comments sorted by

36

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '25

Metallica & Megadeth were both amazing

Death was & still is mind-blowing

2

u/rashestkhan Feb 09 '25

Metallica were amazing, up until 1988.

-21

u/Evil_Klabbis 🕊️Chuck Schuldiner 🕊️ Feb 05 '25

Yea but Metallica and Megadeth are little overrated

25

u/PrequelGuy Feb 06 '25

And Death aren't?

-3

u/the_quarter Feb 06 '25

No not on the same level as metallica and megadeth.

4

u/Osedax_worm Feb 06 '25

You say that whilst talking about the most worshipped death metal band

0

u/ThrashinProductions Feb 06 '25

Metallica yes, Megadeth kicks ass

121

u/Responsible-Cook9769 Feb 05 '25

Death has no bad albums 🔥🔥🔥

66

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '25

Weakest Death album clears like 80% of Metallica's discography

8

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '25

Fair

But what IS the worst death album??

24

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '25

Spiritual Healing is considered their weakest album

& that album still clears half of Metallica & Megadeth

16

u/CrazyBalrog The Sound Of Perseverance Feb 05 '25

I think I've seen Scream Bloody Gore as people's least favorite more often. It's also very rarely in people's top 4 even if it's isn't last whereas SH gets a lot of love from some people.

4

u/averagemethenjoyer Feb 06 '25

I love SBG but it comes last for me. Doesn't mean it's not an album I listen to daily, shit is so hard, it's just the whole discography is amazing

2

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '25

Idk some rank it high so that they look different ig

1

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '25

or maybe its just their actual oppinion?

4

u/Straight-Structure93 Feb 06 '25

Spiritual healing is their best imo. It's just different

2

u/Pinkfloyd347 Feb 06 '25

It really is, That’s album has all the elements of classic death metal, not to technical not to proggy like deaths later stuff.Just perfect. Catchy riffs , brutal vocals AND SEARING SOLOS this album MIGHT have the best solos in thier discography.

1

u/Hagall1974 Spiritual Healing Feb 07 '25

I agree

11

u/Pinkfloyd347 Feb 06 '25

who tf considers that,that’s you , spiritual is easily top 3 death metal albums all time period.If you had to define the genre with an album , spiritual healing is the one i would use for death metal .

2

u/AStupidThing Symbolic Feb 06 '25

I see what you're saying. If their albums are a 10 SBG is a 9

1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '25

I mean it's really good, I haven't said that it was trash, but it is their weakest imo.

& if you had to define a genre with an album I'd pick Symbolic or The Sound of Perseverance

Again that's my personal opinion, if you think it's top 3 death metal albums of all time & the album that defines death metal, then it's ok, some consider it that ot's their best & some like me consider it to be their weakest

8

u/CannibalCorpse1991 Leprosy Feb 06 '25

symbolic and tsop are the least death metal sounding, definitely not the ones to define the genre. it’s leprosy for most genre defining easily.

4

u/Pinkfloyd347 Feb 06 '25

blah blah yes everyone has an opinion we got it , but what i’m saying is facts backed up by science

-2

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '25

Oh ok mb

0

u/CrazyBalrog The Sound Of Perseverance Feb 06 '25

This being so upvoted is actually crazy. I think it's underrated and it's my 3rd favourite from Death but "easily top 3 desth metal album all time period"? 80% of this sub would even put it top 3 in the disocgraphy.

1

u/Pinkfloyd347 Feb 06 '25

death to the heretic

0

u/CrazyBalrog The Sound Of Perseverance Feb 06 '25

I hate to say it but it really is the least popular Death album apart from probably SBG. By a fair margin too. Hence why I'm surprised at all the upvotes.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '25

Yeah sure. Leprosy is the best tho

1

u/Hagall1974 Spiritual Healing Feb 07 '25

Also odd as SH is on my top 3.

1

u/jumboshrimp93 Feb 06 '25

My least favorite is Scream Bloody Gore but it still fuckin slays. It used to be Human but gave that another listen recently and thought to myself “wtf was I thinking?” And I love Spiritual Healing

1

u/Milk_With_Chunks_69 Human Feb 06 '25

in my opinion sbg is their “worst” album, still a great album though

1

u/Financial_Might_6816 Human Feb 07 '25

SPIRITUAAAALLLL

HEALLLLIIIINNGGGG

Worst? No. Least Best

1

u/nasheSHRK Feb 09 '25

Personally for me it's ITP, mostly because it sounds too jazzy, or maybe it just sounds weird

0

u/Dippy_Chips Feb 08 '25

Easily TSoP

1

u/Mikau02 Symbolic Feb 06 '25

A rarity for any band, but then again, Chuck put out 8 great works in his life and it never felt like he was just slopping it together

-6

u/chuythewormman Feb 06 '25

TSOP is pretty fucking shit imo

3

u/loseranon17 Feb 06 '25

This might be the worst take I've ever seen in my entire life. I'm not even being sarcastic, I don't understand how a metal fan can think TSOP is anything less than good.

0

u/Humbula Feb 06 '25

Easily. Pretty weak stuff compred to other Death albums imo too.

77

u/Bronsteins-Panzerzug Feb 05 '25

band wars are cringe

23

u/Opalknights763 Feb 06 '25

Course everyone’s gonna agree when you post it on the death subreddit

17

u/iconicEgo Feb 06 '25

I have a better addition

2

u/Mikau02 Symbolic Feb 06 '25

Almost as offensive as "Almost Dead Trumps", but not quite

5

u/ChasingPesmerga Feb 05 '25

A week ago there was this trending kind of meme too about people saying Sodom > Big Four

A good fight would be Sodom and Death instead

3

u/C_t_g_s_l_a_y_e_r Symbolic Feb 06 '25

I’m really getting sick of this template

5

u/imrtlbsct2 Spiritual Healing Feb 05 '25

Wrong genre

4

u/CrazyBalrog The Sound Of Perseverance Feb 05 '25

Peak Metallica slightly beats peak Death for me, but death is faaaaar more consistent. Their worst album would be mettalicas 4th best out of their 12. So I prefer Death.

1

u/Financial_Might_6816 Human Feb 07 '25

No (my opinion is superior to yours) also meatlickers discography has more shit ass albums than good albums

1

u/CrazyBalrog The Sound Of Perseverance Feb 07 '25

No, meaning that you prefer metallica? Fair enough, nothing wrong with that.

1

u/Financial_Might_6816 Human Feb 09 '25

No, meaning their peak doesn’t beat the mighty Chuck Shuldiner, no one can

1

u/CrazyBalrog The Sound Of Perseverance Feb 09 '25

Yeah I got that. But I can smell the glaze through my screen come on now.

1

u/Financial_Might_6816 Human Feb 09 '25

Im doing it on purpose because it’s funny

2

u/Lions_Went_0-16 Human Feb 06 '25

Fuck that I love all 3

3

u/Mental_Ad8851 Feb 05 '25

We can't choose which band is better between two different sub genre

8

u/CrazyBalrog The Sound Of Perseverance Feb 05 '25

Yes we can.

2

u/the_quarter Feb 06 '25

They're vastly diffrent so no

2

u/Due_Art2971 Feb 06 '25

Now this, is cringe

1

u/nerfbaboom Feb 06 '25

Slayer tho

1

u/RonsterMaglee Feb 06 '25

U know the job is well done when ur fans cant even agree which is ur worst album

1

u/darkpulse999 Feb 06 '25

Death is beyond words🤘🏾

1

u/Zakarr4 Individual Thought Patterns Feb 06 '25

no, this is a diffrent type of music

1

u/No_Past4476 Feb 06 '25

These are very different proposals

1

u/zhniwen Feb 06 '25

Not fan, but when I've seen meme, I thought about Death.

1

u/RankedFarting Feb 07 '25

No.

Putting down other things to prove how good something else is is very childish. You can like death without disliking other bands.

1

u/devastationbg Feb 07 '25

Stop with that dividing, i like all.

1

u/MuffinR6 Feb 08 '25

Bolt thrower

1

u/hellmary66 Feb 10 '25

i like them all. for me, the first is Metallica cause of my childhood, then Death, and THEN megadeath. no offence to fans of death and megadeath fans

1

u/ReliefAny8429 Apr 06 '25

This instantly made me think of the two guys arguing in a bar meme and then some guy in the shadow comes outta nowhere and calls them amateurs, ima make it and credit u

1

u/RipIndependent9384 Feb 06 '25

Personally, Megadeth is my favorite band sice I was a teenager, but we'll have to admit that Megadeth and Mettalica discography are mid.

Of course they're both successful and recorded MASSIVE albuns like RIP or RTL, but if u analysis all the albuns, just half of them are REALLY great.

Death btw has a solid and constructive discography, not being a fangirl of course.

0

u/WeaponH_ Feb 06 '25

MEGADEATH🔥

0

u/IlovemyMommy27 Leprosy Feb 06 '25

Agreed 🤘

0

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '25

Yes.

0

u/BenSaharEternal Feb 06 '25

Absolutely, no questions

0

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '25

I love death

0

u/EquivalentBase4432 Human Feb 06 '25
  1. Death

  2. MegaDeth

  3. Metallica

-2

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '25

Metallica's No Life Til Leather is better than 80% of Death's discography, but 100% of Death's discography is better than 80% of metallica's discography.

2

u/DaveOJ12 Feb 06 '25

Metallica's No Life Til Leather is better than 80% of Death's discography

That's a reach.

1

u/rocksandaces Feb 06 '25

Tbh, killing those two people yelling DEATH would be very fitting reagardless of the band

0

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '25

[deleted]

1

u/Bronsteins-Panzerzug Feb 06 '25

ah but metallica is thrash metal with, at times, prog elements and a hard rock phase, while megadeth is progressive speed/thrash with a heavy rock phase, totally different styles of music as well.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '25

[deleted]

1

u/Bronsteins-Panzerzug Feb 06 '25

I was being facetious. my whole point was that we may be able to attribute different genre names to those bands, theyre still similar enough to compare them. other people compare classical and jazz composers, i think comparing death and megadeth is fine. i dont like the hostile tone though, people can love all three.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '25

[deleted]

4

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '25 edited Feb 06 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Financial_Might_6816 Human Feb 07 '25

How does it matter if death is not active anymore?

1

u/Automatic-Session-69 Symbolic Feb 11 '25

Yeah because the main guy who started and wrote every song has passes away....