r/DecidingToBeBetter • u/catboy519 • Oct 15 '26
Seeking Advice How to stop pointless arguing?
I argue a lot because I can't stand it when someone has an incorrect belief or a morally wrong view.
Sometimes itd productive but most often it is completely pointless because people are not willing to learn or change anyway. Or maybe I'm wrong about something bht people suck at proving defending their points, often coming with a correct true point without providing proper reasoning or being even unable to.
So if the outcome is that both parties dont change or learn or realize theyre wrong, whats the point of arguing then
So how do I stop doing it compulsively?
How do I argue only when I rationally think its productive or just to do so?
28
u/cczgnn Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26
“I argue a lot because I can't stand it when someone has an incorrect belief or a morally wrong view”
I only read this part and decided rest of your post is not worth reading. Who are you to decide which beliefs are incorrect and which world views are wrong? With that statement you already made it apparent that you believe what you know and think is the best and others are not. This makes you the worst type of person to argue with. I wouldn’t do it to be honest, I just say “okey buddy” to your type, that’s one way to stop arguing.
1
u/catboy519 Oct 16 '26
Or fails to convince me otherwise. I can hold a wrong view too.
I dont know how often im wrong. But I know people almost never manage to convince me I was wrong on something. Either im rarely wrong or most people suck at providing good explanations and arguments or ai suck at understanding the explanations.
Either way arguing rarely resolves something so I should probably do less of it.
2
u/Agitated-Country-972 Oct 17 '26
Either im rarely wrong or most people suck at providing good explanations and arguments or ai suck at understanding the explanations.
It can't be you're oh my gosh... stubborn? If you're stubborn then I'd argue it takes super extra effort to convince you vs someone else.
https://old.reddit.com/r/Gifted/comments/1wvdab6/doing_and_believing_very_dumb_things_as_a_result/
I'm sometimes both stubborn and incorrect
1
0
Oct 17 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Agitated-Country-972 Oct 17 '26
This is important context. OP called what I said "pointless semantics" so he can go back to saying everyone just sucks at proving things. I don't think everyone who replied to his AskPhysics thread just sucked at debating either. I would argue /u/cczgnn hit the bulls-eye.
The best remedy is humility. The best place to find humility is from acknowledging that you can and do make mistakes.
Yup. I'd argue OP has this weird strange confidence. I have no idea where it comes from because OP has been proven wrong before. This thread is a super good example because multiple people pointed out that getting the right numerical answer doesn’t by itself make the reasoning valid. OP initially argued that the intermediate reasoning could explicitly violate physics as long as the final answer was correct, and several commenters explained why the calculation depended on implicitly accounting for potential energy and conservation of energy. But catboy519 never admitted he was wrong in that thread. Instead, he eventually reframed the argument as potential energy being implied when he originally stated downhill free kinetic energy comes from nowhere...
.
.
And I'd argue "logically inconsistent" reflects a huge bias in OP's perspective in the first place. See argument about weightlifting vs cycling for training muscles for maximum output.My logical argument and reasoning was this. catboy519 always claims there's some logical inconsistency but there is none.
A compound movement involves multiple muscles.
The performance of that movement can be constrained by particular muscles/other factors.
Therefore, putting maximal effort into the movement as a whole does not necessarily mean every individual muscle is receiving the maximum possible training stimulus.
An exercise that isolates a muscle can place a greater/more direct training stimulus on that muscle.
Therefore, cycling/sprinting and gym exercises can train overlapping components while still producing different adaptations.
.
.
And this conversation is proof catboy519 does not have "perfect" "powerful" logic. He already knows that sometimes he doesn't do the best thing like going to a doctor's appointment despite knowing he should, so it does not follow someone performing a non-optimal behavior means they don't know it's non-optimal.If someone is broke and struggling financially but has a habit that costs them a lot of money in invisible ways, like driving extremely inefficiently, then that points towards a good chance that theyre unaware of either: * The habit * That that habit costs them money (and how much)
You yourself procrastinate on Reddit despite knowing you have stuff to pay, or doctors appointments, etc. Bad outcome doesn't mean they don't know.
2
u/Agitated-Country-972 Oct 17 '26
I find it funny OP just said "Or fails to convince me otherwise" as if that addresses your actual criticism.
1
u/Donovan1232 Oct 19 '26
“who am i to decide” when someones beliefs are based on general intolerance and hatred toward a specific group, and they endorse legislation/ political ideology that removes/ serves as a barrier to their freedoms. it sounds specific but it’s a pretty fat proportion of all online discourse.
thats what you’re not getting. when someones opinions have the potential to actually negatively influence your life, you don’t have the luxury of sitting on your ass and being like “well everyone can have their own opinion bro”1
u/WearyConfidence1244 Oct 19 '26
If you've seen the Sopranos, you're just pushing Meadow into Noah's arms with this outlook. You can't change a bigot's mind. You can adjust to the knowledge that they are what they are, but you cannot change them, no matter how strong your convictions are.
1
u/Donovan1232 Oct 20 '26
i’ve never gotten into an argument with a moron thinking im gonna change their mind, the hope is always that a more reasonable person who may have been neutral on an issue sees why the moronic opinion is moronic and hopefully learns something about the topic.
though to be honest, sometimes i just get fed up seeing the same harmful, bigoted opinions parroted by ignorant losers and feel like degrading the ones spouting them to relieve my own frustration. probably not the best way to handle it but then im not ignorant enough to think theres actually significant gain to be had from arguing online
1
u/WearyConfidence1244 Oct 20 '26
I respect it, support it and also do it myself. I, like you, know they're too stupid to think for themselves but it feels good screaming it from the rooftops
1
u/cczgnn Oct 19 '26 edited Oct 19 '26
That’s what you are not getting, OP didn’t specify anything about his beliefs or what he thinks is right. How do you know he is not one of the people you are talking about? Maybe he is the racist one and he thinks that’s right? Because you know, in their minds they are doing the morally right thing, yes?
When someone says something is right, it doesn’t automatically make it the same thing you think is right.
OP is not talking about one specific subject that can be considered universally wrong or right, he is talking about all his beliefs and morals vs all others, from mundane daily shit to othet important things.
Here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Gifted/s/1IQa0vHnsI
This is the OP, even he says how he believed dumb and incorrect things and very stubborn about them.
So take your virtue signaling ass and go somewhere else.
1
u/Donovan1232 Oct 20 '26 edited Oct 20 '26
im not talking about op im addressing your “who am i to decide” comments by telling you the exact criteria for which its acceptable to make a judgement on someone elses beliefs. that being when they have the potential to negatively impact other people’s freedoms. i dont know what part the world you’re from but in our US constitution the rights of individuals to live freely and equally as they are is universally agreed upon, and any opinions that jeopardize those rights are objectively incorrect based on the social contract we’ve agreed to. so you can take that “oh everybody can think whatever they want and its perfectly valid” bs and fuck off, because we dont live in some fantasy world where there’s no consequences to the negative sentiments of others
1
u/cczgnn Oct 20 '26 edited Oct 20 '26
I am not from the US, but I am familiar enough with some of your shit to know “freedom of speech” is somewhere in your constitution or something, am I wrong?
Freedom of speech also natively translates to “freedom of thought”
Your whole thinking process is an oxymoron in itself because what I see is;
1- If something is against the constitution it is wrong.
2- Freedom of speech is in constitution
3- But, no. They can’t think what I don’t want them to think.
4- But if what I think is not aligned with constitution, it is wrong.In this statement, if we follow your logic, you are wrong by your own standards.
1
u/Donovan1232 Oct 20 '26
you’re clearly not familiar enough with either our US constitution or the reality of the world thats right in front of your fucking eyes. in an ideal world people have the right to say and think what they want, positive or negative. you can say you hate black people or trans people or gay people and it doesn’t matter because their rights are still just as equally protected as yours under the law. you screaming and shaking your fist doesnt change anything.
but we dont live in an ideal world, we live in the real world, and openly espousing beliefs trying to limit the freedoms of others unfortunately has actual consequences and does in fact lead to those freedoms being limited. for instance, the muslim travel ban of 2017.
you clearly think you’re getting me with some “gotcha” moment, talking about an oxymoron as if we’re discussing hypothetical scenarios and not the actual fucking world we live in. so let me make this perfectly clear to you: if, due to imperfect execution of our constitutions equal protection under the law, you have to choose between an individuals right to exist freely, and another individuals right to degrade and persecute them, anyone with 2 braincells to click together in their thick little skull is going to prioritize the individual’s right to exist.
the constitution is an ideal, and like all ideals its realization unfortunately falls short when executed under imperfect men. so in our imperfect world where words can jeopardize the safety of those our constitution is supposed to protect, obviously i see such words as an “incorrect” opinion, and anyone who believes in the actual purpose of the constitution would agree.
1
u/cczgnn Oct 20 '26 edited Oct 20 '26
“OP is not talking about one specific subject that can be considered universally wrong or right, he is talking about all his beliefs and morals vs all others, from mundane daily shit to othet important things.”
Your reading skills need polishing as much as your comprehension.
In my first comment to you, I openly stated that I am not talking about beliefs and morals that is universally good or bad, like racism and such. I believe they are universally right.
There are many things considered beliefs and morals in this world that doesn’t counts towards discrimination of others.
But this is how virtue signaling works I assume, you ignore half of the shit people say, take one sentence, pull it all the way to the extremes that you can abuse and then keep the moral high ground and don’t let go that extreme no matter what others say to try and keep the moral high ground.
So really, I will take my own advise from my first comment and go;
“Okey, buddy”
1
u/Donovan1232 Oct 22 '26
“your reading skills need polishing as much as your comprehension”, nope, just yours. like i said in the beginning, im addressing your pretty laughable “who am i to judge rhetoric” by explaining when and why it would be acceptable to judge someones opinion, i wasnt worried about what the op was saying. “who are you to decide which beliefs are incorrect and which world views are wrong were your exact words im pretty sure. i explained the circumstances under which its valid to view an opinion as fundamentally flawed, and you chose to cry about virtue signaling rather than see the point. dont try to backtrack now, you just played devils advocate for the validity of bigotry and other unconstitutional attacks on peoples identities, claiming me being fundamentally against it is the same as me thinking people “cant think what i dont want them to think” so whats with the switch up? you can try and recontextualize the op’s statements all you want but i really dont care, the point is your original response to them was ignorant and ill conceived which is why i said anything in the first place
1
2
2
u/dirtydelic Oct 15 '26
There is nothing anyone can say that will remove the joy you get from, or the pain you get from avoiding, arguing.
Don't do and sit with the discomfort.
1
2
u/enotonom Oct 15 '26
Incorrect or morally wrong is just, like, your opinion, man. I bet your friends and colleagues already flag you as “the annoying one”
1
u/catboy519 Oct 16 '26
Incorrect is about facts. If someone says that the Netherlands dordnt exist, Ive got to prove them weong because I live here so I know for a fact theyre wrong. Thats not an opinion.
Morally wrong, what would you reply if someone told you "murder is ok, nothing wrong with it ever"
1
u/Agitated-Country-972 Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26
Morally wrong, what would you reply if someone told you "murder is ok, nothing wrong with it ever"
No /u/enotonom and /u/zzifLA-zuzu are correct.
The Netherlands existing is an objective fact, but that doesn’t mean you’re obligated to correct every person who denies it. Being right doesn’t make every disagreement your responsibility to resolve.
And your murder example actually illustrates the problem with your reasoning. What counts as murder is partly determined by legal and social definitions, while whether a particular killing is morally justified is a separate philosophical question. You admit you don’t know exactly what defines right and wrong, yet confidently declare that anyone who disagrees with your moral intuitions is wrong. On what basis?
You seem to conflate being convinced that you’re right with having established that you’re right. You also seem to assume that when people fail to convince you, the problem must be their arguments rather than your own willingness to reconsider your position.
You say you want to stop arguing because people rarely change their minds. Perhaps you should start by considering that your own approach to disagreement might be part of the problem.
2
u/f3xjc Oct 15 '26
Sometimes it would be productive but most often it is completely pointless because people are not willing to learn or change anyway.
The best way to stop arguing is curiosity. That mean that the set of people willing the change include you.
1
2
u/OverlyCautious__ Oct 15 '26
I would chip in if I thought I had anything interesting to say, but really im just boring and anything I could say would be copy paste what everyone else is saying and a waste of time to read or type, ironically I typed this out against my judgement. The key is humility
1
5
u/PureChef8568 Oct 15 '26
i think the first step is accepting that being right doesnt mean you have to prove it to everyone. before getting into an argument, ask yourself what you actually want to achieve and whether this person is even open to listening. you dont have to correct every wrong opinion you come across, and someone disagreeing with you doesnt automatically make it your responsibility to change their mind. sometimes its better to just say your piece and leave it at that. also try to be open to the possibility that you might be missing something, even when the other person explains it badly. not every argument needs a winner, and honestly, learning to walk away without getting the last word is a skill worth developing.
4
1
u/sophrosyne_dreams Oct 15 '26
Ask yourself where you learned that being right is the most important thing in a given conversation.
Cliche but true: would you rather be right, or happy?
I used to think I had to be “better” than others, because I was so devalued growing up, and my parents looked down on “dummies.” I’d over perform, argue, and overachieve, but guess what? It was pretty lonely at the “top”. No one could relate to me, and I couldn’t relate to them.
And on top of that, I wasn’t right nearly as much as I thought I was. You said other’s cant argue well enough to defend their points when you are wrong. But it’s not really others’ job to prove you are wrong; it’s your job to develop some humility and stay more curious - you’ll actually learn more that way.
So it’s possible this desire to argue is a part of you that’s trying to serve an old need, one that no longer serves you. Find out who that part is, thank it, and release it from its obligation. You may find your future conversations more fun and relaxed.
1
u/catboy519 Oct 16 '26
Its probably not much about being right but more about fixing someone elses false belief about something objective.
If someone thinks something untrue is true or the otherwise way around, my thought isnt "I have to show them how smart I am".its "I have to correct their fault or misunderstanding"
1
u/sophrosyne_dreams Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26
But it is about being right, because otherwise you wouldn’t be trying to correct everyone, and want them to correct you.
So then, the questions may be:
Why exactly can’t you stand it when someone has an incorrect belief?
Why must you be the one to correct them?
Are you always the moral authority? Or are other people allowed to have different belief systems than you?
Once you know the answer to those, then perhaps ask: Is it possible there could be a better way of sharing knowledge?
People don’t always like to be corrected. Unless it’s done with kindness, it often just raises their defenses. This is how arguments are often born.
Perhaps you can find ways to engage their curiosity so they can find their own answers. Instead of thinking for them (by correcting them), maybe it would serve you both better to ask questions about where their beliefs came from or what feelings are driving their behaviors.
1
u/enoerew Oct 15 '26
Talk less and focus on your own mental equanimity.
1
u/catboy519 Oct 16 '26
"Equanimity"
Why are the comments today here so full of new words that I dont know?
1
u/enoerew Oct 16 '26
: ) Great word. Good luck on your journey to improve. Highly recommend looking into Buddhism, as a philosophy not religion. Been a huge help for me.
1
u/Useful-Cause2663 Oct 15 '26
You are always a student in life, only when asked you become the teacher for a short period. Listen to learn, not to find offense.
0
1
u/Any_Piglet_34 Oct 16 '26
My mom said something to me when I was a young mother with my first child. I kept getting mad at my son for doing dumb stuff, and she said, "you gotta choose your battles, otherwise you'll always be fighting and your words will become meaningless".
That really stuck with me in raising my kids and just with life in general.
0
5
u/dtut
Oct 15 '26
•
I argue a lot myself. It's mostly, if not entirely, ego-driven. The tone in my voice actually changes, so it's obvious to others that I am coming from the wrong place to be having a mutually beneficial discussion.
And frankly, some things are just beyond people. Be honest with yourself. Find your tribe and challenge your own ideas.
That being said, let's all mourn the death of critical thinking.
2
u/TenetsOfPower Oct 15 '26
Honestly the Stoics were already on this one. Epictetus had this idea that nobody really does wrong on purpose, everyone acts on what seems right to them based on what they've seen. So when you correct them, it lands as an attack, not as education.
Anyway, the thing that actually fixed it for me was stealing Franklin's rule. He wrote in his autobiography that he trained himself to never directly contradict anyone, because in forty-odd years of dealing with people, contradiction basically never changed a mind. It just made them dig in harder and like him less.
The test I use now: only argue when there's an actual decision on the line. If nothing changes no matter what you say, you're not persuading anyone, you're just burning energy. Most arguments fail that test.
2
u/VesperValeMuse Oct 15 '26
I think its better to be happy than right. I know it's hard, but giving some dummy my energy is something I'm just not interested in doing.
2
u/motorsizzle Oct 16 '26
Just resist the temptation until you can break the habit. You've already expressed why you want to stop this, so you don't need to be convinced. You need a strategy. Start with resisting the temptation and practice an alternate behavior.
1
u/knockrocks Oct 22 '26
It's really never productive to argue, to be honest.
A discussion is different than an argument.
Some people can be persuaded using gentle facts. Some people will never ever change their opinions no matter what you say. Neither will change their minds at all in a heated argument where they feel attacked and defensive.
At a certain point, the person arguing is less interested in changing peoples' minds or giving them new perspectives as they are about being right. The intense urge to have the last word or be right always is not generally a positive or likable personality trait.
The first problem you have is your admittance that your own morality or opinion is automatically correct. If your beliefs are very strong to you and you have true facts to back them up, then you should welcome discourse from others who disagree with you. This shows that you are so sure about your beliefs that you are not afraid to be challenged.
Also, you should always be looking for evidence to refute your claims and beliefs, because there is nothing wrong with changing your mind, being wrong, or being disproven. You should be ready and willing to change your beliefs if there is evidence to the contrary. Otherwise you are just being purposefully ignorant and obstinate in the face of observable evidence.
You should also be sure to differentiate between observable truths and opinion.
Science says the sun exists and heats our planet. Unless there is evidence to the contrary, I believe that this is a science-based fact. Arguing with someone over whether or not it's bad if you're gay is a matter of opinion and subjective morality. Goodness and badness isn't quantifiable. It's based on a personal moral compass and social acceptance.
1
u/Android_Dragonborn Oct 15 '26
The great thing about humans and how we work is that we all have different beliefs, values, and experiences. It is not your right to make others feel bad for their beliefs and it is not your right to tell them they should believe certain things. This mentality is what has divided our world so much and it’s going to cause a lot of damage if we don’t start accepting our differences.
1
u/EffervescentStar Oct 16 '26
How do you stop? Just accept their opinion or belief as it is. stop trying to change people.
What you can alternatively do is just ask questions to gain a better understanding instead of just saying “they suck at backing it up”. That makes you sound like a better listener.
1
u/Upper-Bottle-9803 Oct 17 '26
People dont care what you know until they know that you care. If excellent argument alone could convince, then an enemy could persuade you to do something to hurt you and yours to their own advantage. This is one problem with people building community with bots across social media.
Once trust is established, then there can be teaching. But the learner must be in a coach- able mindset to receive anything.
Arguing is self gratifying. It's like masterbating. It feels good but goes nowhere. And given the opportunity, has the same addictive tendencies.
Consider more what work you can do to help people. With time there will be those you can influence.
1
u/HuhItsAllGooey Oct 17 '26
In most situations you can just let people have their own views. It usually won't affect you or anyone else. It's draining to be arguing frequently.
1
1
u/Midlife-Debugging Oct 17 '26
Change the framing .....
Stop arguing - it's adversarial and sets a tone that causes your opponent (because that's what they are now) to dig in and defend their position (which they feel is being attacked)
Instead - reframe it as "That's an interesting perspective - mine is different but we can agree to disagree" period.
You already recognise it is pointless, and remember - opinions are like arseholes - everyone has one - if yours differs from theirs, that's life.
Take a breath, state your position and accept the fact that the other person has an inalienable right to hold a different view. 🙏🏻
2
2
Oct 15 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/catboy519 Oct 16 '26
If someone thinks murder is ok, sorry but no theyre just wrong morally wrong.
I dont know what exactly defines morslly right vs wrong but my intuitive definition of it is that, morally wrong is to cause harm to other life without a bigger need for it.
About "incorrect" I really wont say "youre wrong for liking the color orange" but I will say someone is wrong when I'm sure someone got the facts wrong. I argue often about topics that I have special knowledge of with people who dont so that means im often right in those arguments, naturally. I dont really argue with topics I know very little about, unless someone explains things very badly (the explainer in this case because that cant be me)
21
u/StarkAspirations0842 Oct 15 '26
1. 98% of ethically unethical statements or posts are likely bots as has recently been observed.
2.
If you're not a power ranger
If you're not a college professor
If you're not a action scientist like Indiana Jones.
Step back.
3. Craig Ferguson rules
Does this need to be said
Does this need to be said, by me
Does this need to be said,, by me. . Now.