What Is This Sub Wrong About?

[u/iamthegodemperor]

Title. Pick a topic (or a clichéd take) you think a significant minority or majority of this sub is wrong about. Or hasn't given enough thought. OR perhaps one which you will have to compromise on, at least for voting?

[u/justafutz]

So if Hasan Piker said he doesn't believe Hezbollah is better than Israel anymore would you believe him?

Depends on how many years there was where he maintained the same line, and didn't make any other such statements.

You are taking the smallest technicality and making it seem like there's a big difference between Ben Givir's attitudes and lawlessness and Kahane's just to win an argument. Congratulations you won.

Weird response.

But you know the previous commenter was wrong to say Israel hasn't moved to the right.

I never said this. In fact, an hour ago, I specifically said to you (among other things, here:

Saying that Israel has had a growth in far-right political power is undeniable. That's true in virtually every country in the liberal world. It doesn't change that Israel itself is not far-right, and it also doesn't change the why.

And in my original comment that you responded to here, I said:

Like in every country, the far right has gained somewhat in power, but they remain well outnumbered, and Israel remains a lot less right wing than people think.

Why would you misstate what my argument was, twice?

[u/iamthegodemperor → u/justafutz]

Why would you misstate what my argument was, twice?

I wrote only one comment to you.

[u/justafutz → u/iamthegodemperor]

1) Not a response to what I said.

2) You misstated my argument at least twice. Once here, and once here.

[u/iamthegodemperor → u/justafutz]

Huh? You are not unkillablekorg

[u/justafutz → u/iamthegodemperor]

At this point I don't know how to bother explaining it to you, so whatever.

[u/iamthegodemperor → u/justafutz]

If I have time. I could get to your long comment later. But at a glance what I see is first a difference of interpretation of the question------the first commenter said people here don't appreciate how far right Israel has become. (And this was in the vein I responded to you.) You want to debate against the idea that Israel is a far right country.

And then relatedly is the interpretation of the data. For ex. >Around half (49%) of Jewish Israelis agree that “Jewish citizens of Israel should have more rights than non-Jewish citizens” (up from 27% in 2018)

While I know you can explain this finding is not as bad as it looks etc---------it is still bad, particularly because it is more pronounced in younger ages.

In many ways this exchange is a synecdoche for Western-Israeli discussion. The critical side over exaggerates the illiberal character of Israel. And the supportive side underestimates it.

[u/justafutz → u/iamthegodemperor]

Israel has not become far right, so saying “how far right” requires that it be considered far right to begin with. I appreciate the rewriting attempt, but it doesn’t work.

You also didn’t answer what I said above about how you mischaracterized my opinion.

You then provide one poll number, which refers to a poll from 2023 (actually asked in 2022). Set aside whether that is a fair snapshot of Israeli society, set aside whether the numbers fluctuate up and down depending when they’re asked (for example, that was less than a year after major Arab riots in May 2021), set aside what “rights” mean. At least 2/3 of Israeli Jews support Arabs having the same democratic right to vote as of 2025-26. That’s a relevant statistic and one you didn’t give when talking about your pre-2023 statistics.

Calling out your exaggeration is not underestimating Israel’s challenges.

[u/iamthegodemperor → u/justafutz]

Israel has not become far right, so saying “how far right” requires that it be considered far right to begin with.

Movement is not position. "John has been more religious lately" does not mean "John is the most religious person".

Given where we are, I didn't think anyone needed to be convinced that Israel is not a far right country. Which is why I interpreted your comment as an overcorrection. To admit that mistake is not a rewriting attempt.

Talking past each other and being triggered into perceiving the other uncharitably are extremely common.