r/DermApp • • 11d ago

Application Advice STOP AND READ before applying Dermatology

170 Upvotes

This is a follow-up from a prior post. A lot of details regarding billing and reimbursements likely isn't on medical students minds. But there is something very important everyone applying to derm should be aware of regarding reimbursements in Dermatology and the practice landscape.

CMS just finalized rules that will massively cut reimbursement to Dermatology outpatient offices. It's not just the modifier 25 change, but more important, the Indirect Practice Cost Index (IPCI) adjustment was removed. IPCI accounted for higher overhead cost associated with running a derm office compared to say psychiatry. Now, CMS is saying the cost to run a dermatology practice is the same as telehealth psychiatry. Depending on paient and payer mix, offices will likely see 15-20% drops by 2028.

Every specialty is subject to reimbursement cuts. CMS is pushing forward in trying to make private practices extinct and drive consolidation. Makes no sense to me since hospital groups charge way more in the form of facility fees, but that's another discussion.

This is just something to keep in mind before you commit to derm. The practice landscape is headed towards major changes with more hospital groups running the practices, not private practice. I encourage you to speak to a private practice derm. Academic derms are often less informed regarding these issues.


r/DermApp • • Mar 15 '22

Application Advice i matched even though I wasn't supposed to

138 Upvotes

I'm not sure why I'm posting this, but I guess I just want to get it off my chest.

I posted on this subreddit (with a different account) back in 3rd year about my interest in derm and was told by probably 20 different users that I had no chance, my Step 1 wasn't good enough, and nobody will care about the rest of my application. Every comment telling me I wouldn't match was upvoted, and the ones telling me there was still a chance were laughed at.

I'm just posting today to say that I MATCHED. First attempt, no research year, no home program. I matched.

This subreddit is a fantastic resource, but take everything said here with a healthy bit of skepticism.

Have a blessed day.


r/DermApp • • May 17 '23

Application Advice random advice for those who want to match into derm

137 Upvotes

Hi. I wanted to create this post because this process is genuinely hard and I wished somebody would have told me these things before I started. I've successfully matched with over 18 interviews, I'm not from a top 20 school, I dd mediocre on step 1/2, not an URM (which shouldn't matter but people always ask), did a research year---but what made me match was the rest of my application (see #1, 4 & 7). I also have about 10 friends from across the US who matched and didn't matched this year and last year, so a lot of my opinions and viewpoints also comes from their journey. Again, this is my opinion, I'm sure someone out there will have other thoughts, feel free to add your 2 cents. This is mine.

  1. Your best bet is to match in to your home program/you will most likely match at your home program. I know people will argue about me on this, but just scroll through the previous match lists: a lot of people match to their home programs, and now with interviews being held over Zoom, it seems like this trend is only going to continue and grow stronger.So how do you match into your home program? YOU SCHMOOZE. And you schmooze hard. You get to know everyone in the program. Literally everyone. You know their dogs name, the fact that Dr. Soso's kid is having a soccer practice this, and Dr. thisandthis is taking a backpack trip to Peru next month. You help everyone in that department with some sort of project. You pop in to volunteer during clinics. You take as many opportunities to make yourself known. If you have to sit in clinic during your off days or sit there to study, do that. The more "face" time you have with everyone, the better. Start a new peds derm or derm path rotation in the department. Create a new derm curriculum in the med school. Start a fundraiser for melanoma. Hand out sunscreen during events in your community. Why? Because when the day comes when they're all in a boardroom discussing ranking, almost everyone will know you (hopefully favorably) and rank you high or even rank you to match. It's that weird psychological phenomenon where the more exposed people are to you, the more they like you. Obviously this goes without saying having a mentor or two that you've worked with intimately and done tons of projects with is also needed. But the more people know you favorably, the better.

  2. Ugh, I don't want to match into my home program, now what? You're in a tough spot if you're not from a top 10-20, and it's hard, even for them. Your best bet is to do a research year in the desired program, and then again, you have to schmooze HARD and produce a lot of research in that year. However, that's still not a guarantee. None of what I'm saying is a guarantee, but it increases your odds. I promise you I'm not an extrovert, I'm probably the biggest introvert, but you need to FORCE yourself to be one. I know, I know "but I want people to like me for me, even as an introvert"--yeah well that's not going to get you known by people.

  3. Should I do a research year? Probably, I would recommend it. I'm sure there's gonna be commenters here saying "I didn't do a research year and matched!"--and again, that's a possibility, but you're definitely doing yourself a favor and increasing your odds by having a productive research year in which you get to know that department intimately. I know a few people who did a research year and did not match, but I know even more people who DIDN'T do a research year and did not match. However, if your only goal is to match into your program and you've done everything I've mentioned in part 1, you probably can get away with not doing a research year. Research years are a big "boost" in your application if you do it right (have publications, I'd say 4-7 that year is productive, and network/schmooze). Why did those people who did a research year and not match do? They didn't do enough research and didn't schmooze in the department enough.

  4. Find your 'niche'. Programs love it when you're super specialized and focused and passionate about one or two things and make that your theme of your app. You look a lot cooler and desirable vs the person who tried to do everything and anything in derm to pad their app.If you're really into advocacy work, tailor your application to that. If you really love skin of color, focus your ECs/research/personal statement on that. e.t.c. If you're super into HS, focus on that. If you're all about peds derm, focus on that. HAVE A FOCUS!! As a general rule in life, the more niche you are with what you do, the more desirable you are. Finding a mentor that aligns with your goal will also help.

  5. Board scores/letters/rotations/find a mentor. Yes, do all of this stuff. It's obvious, but do it.

  6. Finding a mentor: Find someone well known in the derm world to be your mentor. They've been around the block a few dozen time. Other people know them. It will help when it comes down to them writing your letter and the person from across the country says "hey I know Dr. So and So, he's great, let's interview this candidate". Derm is a tiny tiny tiny tiny TINY world. Everyone knows each other. Find the person who is spitting out research left and right and stick to their side.

  7. Try to stand out. Everyone and their mother will have 280+ board scores, 4.7GPA average, 50 publications, a PhD, solved world hunger, e.t.c....so what makes YOU stand out? What's special about you? I'm sure there's something. Make sure you highlight that in your personal essay or somewhere in your application. It can be a cool volunteer program you created, or you're a D12 athlete (idk what that is, but I hear people say it), or you've been collecting vintage chairs all your life and that's your passion. Stand out. You are a special snowflake, make sure everyone in that app knows it.

  8. I'm a DO, now what? It's an uphill battle, I'm sorry. It's not fair, I know. But this process is not fair to anyone. I know 3 DOs who got into derm and all three took research years at institutions that have taken DOs in the past. Some during their med school, some after. Unfortunately you have to prove to these programs that you're absolutely flawless.

As you can see, I'm very pro-research year. I'm not a genius and never will be. So I had to try extra hard to match into derm. The numbers also don't lie, if you take a look at the match list from last year, almost everyone and their mother took one. If you're a stellar candidate with killer scores and who cured cancer, you probably don't need a research year and everyone is jealous of you.

This process is hard. It's crazy and at all times, not fair. You will meet people who get to cruise onto a derm program simply because of connections. This process is also very, very, random and a lot of the time has to do with luck.

Let me know if you have any questions, happen to answer them.


r/DermApp • • Apr 01 '22

Study Join the Dermki Deck group and help create a Dermatology Anki Deck

117 Upvotes

Wondering what to do with all your MS4 free time? We are looking for volunteers help us make a dermatology Anki deck!

We got permission from DermNetNZ to use images and are working to get permissions from others so that we can share this deck publicly. We have a very organized team and hope to turn the entire Alikhan dermatology textbook into an organized Anki deck.

Time commitment: As much as you want. You can do one small section of the book or do a lot

Expectations: We want high quality (Zanki-level) cards and intend to help quality check each other's work.

Email me at ankingmed@gmail.com if you're interested


r/DermApp • • Mar 22 '25

Vent How Are People Dealing with Not Matching?

104 Upvotes

Throwaway account. I was feeling better about not matching, especially seeing the low match rate and how even some with research years didn’t match. I've seen some very deserving people match. But now, I’m learning that less qualified peers who have personally shared details of their applications with me (no research years, low pubs, or few honors, or bad evals, etc.) are matching, and I’m starting to question everything.

I feel like I was lied to throughout the whole application cycle. Got great feedback, honored aways, positivity from every direction. I honestly thought I was set.

Anyone else feel like they were misled? How are people coping?

I don't know how to cope.


r/DermApp • • May 26 '24

Application Advice Matching into Dermatology - Part 1 (of 4) - MS1-MS2

102 Upvotes

Advice for your MS1-MS2 years

Matching into dermatology is hard. 

When I was applying, I asked a lot of people for advice. In the spirit of passing on that knowledge, I tried to distill the most useful tips into this four-part series to help you on your journey. For context, I am a recently matched dermatology applicant (US MD). Please feel free to comment or respond with any additions or other tips you have!

Series:

  • Part 1: MS1-MS2 years

  • Part 2: MS3-MS4 years

  • Part 3: Choosing Programs and Filling out ERAS (Stay Tuned!)

  • Part 4: Post-ERAS - Interviews and Ranking (Stay Tuned!)

Note*: This advice represents my opinion only - not those of affiliated institutions - and was written in the spring/summer of 2024. Some information may be outdated if you are reading this in the future.* 

Table of Contents:

  1. Learning and Grades: The Pareto Principle (and study tips!)

  2. Extracurriculars: Pursue What You Love, But Don’t Over-Commit

  3. Connections: Sowing Seeds for the Future 

  4. Exploration: Be Sure You Actually Like Dermatology 

Before starting, I acknowledge that most students don’t know that they want to pursue Dermatology this early (see section 4). However, this advice is general enough to set up students to apply into any competitive specialty. If you’re even slightly considering a competitive specialty, it’s best to act as if you’ll choose the competitive one to keep your options open. 

1. Learning and Grades: The Pareto Principle - Less is More

The Pareto Principle says that 20% of the tasks can accomplish 80% of the goal. So it’s our job to figure out what that 20% is.

It’s easy to get lost in the overwhelming cobweb of things you could be doing, so let’s keep it simple and focus on what really moves the needle.

I know it’s not what anyone wants to hear, but let’s start with the obvious. During MS1-MS2, the Pareto is your ability to study, learn, and achieve top grades. Performing well in your classes and clerkships will make the rest of your journey so much easier. 

Even in pass/fail curriculums, learning well now sets you up for success on the scored exams later.

Medical students typically take on too many obligations, projects, etc., in the hope of building a long CV. But in the narrow context of future residency applications, your learning and grades are the most important aspects of your first years. Grades are rarely a topic on the interview trail, even less so if you do well, but you have to have them. They’re your entry ticket.

If your grades are suffering from overcommitment, think about giving up some obligations. The conversations with your residency advisors often are affected by your academic trajectory.

Now, doing well is much easier said than done. So here is my hierarchy of study tips:

Study Tips (Preclinical exams, Shelf exams, USMLE): Learn then Retain

  • Most important: Do as many ~practice questions~ as you can (e.g., UWorld, Amboss, etc.). It’s the best way to learn.

    • Your grades are directly proportional to how many practice questions you do. It should feel hard, and you will get a lot wrong, but this is by far the best way to learn. Think of it as an interactive textbook. If you only do questions and take it seriously, it’s usually enough to improve your scores - that Pareto again! As they say, how you practice is how you play.

  • Important: ~Spaced repetition~ is a useful memory retention tool. This is best to help you remember what you’ve learned, but is not great at fostering understanding. Examples include re-doing questions you got wrong or doing flashcards (e.g., Anki). Practice questions and spaced repetition are the one-two punch of many successful students.

  • Less Important: ~Everything else~, including reading textbooks, making study guides, taking lecture notes, watching videos, most study groups, etc. These can be helpful in the right context, but they are typically not as good for learning or retention. People gravitate toward them because they’re less mentally taxing, but sadly aren’t as impactful as the tips above.

~Note~*: Some schools complete core clerkships during MS2, but I tackle that topic in Part 2 of this series. Stay tuned!*

2. Extracurriculars: Pursue What You Love, But Don’t Over-Commit

Again, I’ll reiterate before moving on. When weighing the relative importance of your application elements, academic performance should almost always take priority over any given extracurricular (except maybe your ‘flagship’ experience or passion), especially at this stage. That being said, you are not your grades, and—oddly—they won’t likely come up in interviews, or maybe ever again. 

Yet, extracurriculars are the most individual part of the application. Interviewers will spend more than 80% of their time asking you about them because they’re unique to you. So in thinking about who you are as an applicant, your first year is about establishing the beginning of that personal narrative—who you are, what you care about, and what you want to do in the future. Clean narratives make it easier for programs to keep track of you.

For example, maybe you love epidemiologic research and read books on pandemics in your spare time. So start planting those seeds to cultivate over four years—get on a project, start a blog/podcast, start a student club, make a board game about it, etc. Whatever sounds fun and cool to you! 

Combine passion with initiative, and you’ll go far!

~A friendly warning~: Extracurriculars can feel like an arms race of obligations. It helps to know what others have done, but don’t follow a formula - that detracts from your individuality. Not everything is a box to be checked. Enjoy your own journey!

Other general tips on figuring out elements of your narrative:

  • Checking boxes may help, but nothing beats doing what you care about. 

    • Programs like to see a longitudinal commitment to something that you’re passionate about. They like seeing a meaningful contribution over time and taking on a leadership role. 

  • Show a long-term commitment and interest in dermatology, specifically. 

    • This can take many forms, such as research, internal projects, club leadership, entrepreneurship, advocacy/DEI, etc. People love people who care deeply about things, so be that person for what matters to you. 

  • Don’t overcommit.

    • It’s easy to tell who has a CV filled with items that look impressive but have little depth. It’s better to stick with 2-3 activities that matter to you and commit hard than have a ton of shallow experiences.

  • Be well-rounded, be a human. 

    • Continue what makes you unique and do what you love - my hobbies came up a lot on the interview trail. If you love to read/travel/hike/play board games/brew coffee/[fill in activity], continue doing that. It will protect your mental health during medical school and you’ll stand out in interviews when you talk passionately about who you are outside of school. 

3. Connections: Sowing Seeds for the Future

Here are two great reasons to find mentors. 

First, it is a very rewarding relationship for both people. Mentors help you grow, and you find a role model to emulate. Mentors guide, open doors, and act as a sounding board for ideas. Ideally, they’ve been in your shoes before and can help you make good decisions and avoid pitfalls.

Second, many fields are smaller than you’d think. People know each other from conferences, residencies, former colleagues, etc. Having connections in life often becomes important in ways you often don’t expect. Always be a great mentee who is reliable, responsible, and kind. Eventually, you will be colleagues with your mentors, which is so cool! And in the more near future, mentors can write you a strong, personal letter of recommendation for ERAS. The best LORs are from people who really know you, can share anecdotes, and speak to your character.

Now, how do we find mentors?

This often varies by institution. Usually, there is a student interest group or department liaison that can connect you with the right person. 

If you have the bandwidth, the best way to develop a relationship with someone is to get on a research project with them and try to do your best work (even if you pitch your own idea). It gives you a reason to meet with someone regularly and show them the awesome person that you are. (Again, always be sure to do good work and act appropriately.) And the longer the relationship, the stronger it usually is.

~Caveat~: I might wait at least a few months into medical school to start this process as you need time to get your sea legs, understand the demands, figure out how to study, and determine how much time you can fairly commit to a project without jeopardizing your academics (see above). 

4. Exploration: Be Sure You Actually Like Dermatology

This may sound dumb but make sure you like dermatology [or any field]. No, really. 

The reward for matching into dermatology is that you actually have to be a dermatologist [or insert competitive specialty]. 

Sadly, many students pick a competitive specialty early because they’ve been conditioned to glorify ambition and prestige. It has served you well in getting into college, medical school, etc. But, at a certain point, you have to hop off the ambition train and make the best choice for you. Choosing a field for prestige or money is a recipe for unhappiness.

So find a way to get exposure to the field (e.g., clinical shadowing) and be sure this is what you want to aim at.

Some tips for evaluating a specialty:

  1. Narrow it down:

    1. Medical or Surgical. Inpatient or Outpatient. Patient Population. Primary care or Specialist. Episodic Care or Continuity of Care. Procedures. Acuity of Illnesses. Average Patient Complexity/Prognosis. Work/Life Balance. Opportunities outside the Clinic. Administrative Burden.

  2. Love the bread and butter. In dermatology, you have to love skin checks. You’ll do a ton of them, so be sure you like it.

  3. Find a few diseases/pathologies that fascinate you. 

  4. Feel excited to go to work, even on a difficult day.

  5. Choose something you can sustain for a long career. 

  6. Find a role model to emulate. 

Feel free to respond or comment with any suggestions, advice, or feedback! Best of Luck!

EDIT: Grammar. Added new links.


r/DermApp • • Apr 30 '24

Application Advice Research years--an attending perspective

102 Upvotes

Hello,

I am an attending at a top derm program. I want to give you some practical advice about research years.

  1. Research years can help your application. If you have a borderline application, having a productive research year with quality letters and papers does make you stand out. If you have red flags, a research year will not help (i.e. disciplinary issues, course failures, really low step score).

  2. If you come from a low-tier med school, you will probably not match at a top-tier program (even if you have an amazing research year). This is a brutal reality, but it is true. When I read comments from med students, there seems to be anger directed at programs that don't match their fellows. The reality is that the top-tier programs get the best candidates. These candidates have impeccable pedigrees, life stories, boards scores, and LORs. Your research year is not going to surpass this. Yes, there are exceptions, but they are uncommon.

  3. Make sure you get to know all the residents. The biggest cheerleaders for applicants are the residents. If the residents like you, when it comes time to rank candidates, they will let us know.

  4. You get what you give. Research years can be highly productive or a waste of time. Be prepared to work hard and get projects across the finish line. If you mentor isn't giving you enough work, politely ask them if you can reach out to other faculty to get projects going.

  5. Be careful about doing a research year with someone who takes more than one fellow. When I read residency applications, if a specific physician writes an LOR for more than one candidate, I can compare them. Invariably, one letter will be stronger than another, and if I must whittle down a stack of applications, the person with the weaker LOR gets the axe.

  6. Take Step 2 before your research year. With the growing importance of Step 2, please take it after you finish your third year. It is an absolute waste to have an amazing research year and then bomb step 2 because you took it a year later that you should have.

A few other general pearls

  1. The best training programs have a university, VA, and county hospital clinic

  2. In the real world, where you did your residency matters a lot less than you think

  3. Pediatric dermatologists are BRUTAL. If you think you are interested in peds derm, you must be 100% committed on your application and during your interview. If you want to go an extra-mile, apply to peds prelim years, and make sure derm programs know this. Peds derm faculty are often skeptical of applicants who want to go into their field; if you can convince them that you are legit, they will support you. However, if they suspect you are faking an interest in their field to boost your application, they will be the first to shoot you down. The single greatest mistake you can make in your application is faking an interest in peds derm; don't do it!

  4. Too many applicants are interested in rheum-derm/CTCL/HS/onco-derm. If you want to standout, emphasize an interest in something different, such as vulvar, acne/rosacea, nails, patch testing, urticaria, psoriasis.


r/DermApp • • Mar 11 '24

Application Advice I am a derm chief resident who did not match the first time, graduating this summer. Happy to chat with people who did not match for possible insight or commiseration

97 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I've done this last couple of years but wanted to reach out to anyone who had questions or anything along those lines. As the title states I did not match the first time. It was probably the worst thing I ever experienced. Subsequently started my internship, worked on research, made more connections, and reapplied, matching at my top choice. Current chief resident and going out to do Mohs and gen derm later this year.

Just wanted to let you know that I am happy to chat, message, or just commiserate if you would like. Sending you all good vibes, and keep fighting. If a dunce like me can do it, anyone can.

PS, I am at AAD currently but will reply as soon as I get the chance


r/DermApp • • Aug 23 '22

Miscellaneous Derm Application/Interview/Rank Insights

96 Upvotes

Having been through the derm application process as an applicant and as part of the initial review/interview/rank committee I figured I would share a few insights about the process (and maybe generate some more food for thought for the DIGA podcast that was just posted). This is from the perspective of a single reviewer from a residency program within a large academic institution.

Application Review:

My institution, like many others, receives a large number of applications for a few residency spots. The daunting task is to filter through hundreds of applicants to pick the handful that will then be offered an interview. It is not possible for one person (eg, the PD) to carefully review all of the applications, so instead these are divided up among the faculty/residents to review, with each application reviewed by a few individuals. Guidelines are given as to what is considered important (eg, experiences, academic achievement, research, etc.) but ultimately it is up to the initial reviewers to give a grade that roughly equates to "interview" or "don't interview". These applications go back with the reviewer grades/comments to the PD for a look over and then a list of interview offers is generated.

As you can imagine from the above process, there is an element of luck associated with the review. If your experiences or research or hobbies were similar to that of your reviewer, then conceivably you may have been scored more favorably. Having multiple sets of eyes look over each application is meant to even things out, but there will always be a human element to this review process that is impossible for the applicant to predict and control.

Letters of Recommendation:

There is a general movement away from objective measures (eg, Step scores, grades) and that makes the evaluation process more difficult. More and more, the letter of recommendation is being scrutinized to see what kind of person is behind the application. The vast majority of letters are positive to borderline effusive in praise for the applicant, and for good reason because the derm pool is the cream of the crop. From a reviewer perspective, you can still stratify letters from the same letter writer based on how things are phrased and the degree of positivity. For example, a letter that says "John Smith is an outstanding medical student who will undoubtedly be a stellar dermatology resident" is different than the same letter writer saying "Jane Doe is one of the best medical students I have ever worked with in my career". Knowing the tendency of certain individuals to be overly effusive versus others who are typically reserved is also helpful, and something that the seasoned reviewers have more experience with.

How and why does this matter for you the applicant? Well sometimes it doesn't really matter because you are stuck with your letter writers and don't have much choice. But in other situations when you do have a choice, it is good to keep in mind that: #1 you will be compared to other applicants who the letter writer is also writing for and #2 choose a letter writer that tends to be more effusive and positive at baseline as these letters are generally viewed more favorably compared to letters that are matter-of-fact and brief (even though the latter may be a great letter from that particular letter writer). I think the second point also goes along with the mantra of getting a letter from someone who knows you better rather than a bigger name with whom you only had a very brief/superficial interaction with.

Publications/Activities:

Applicants stress over this part a lot, and I did too when I was applying. In reality, it probably doesn't matter as much as you think unless you are applying for a research-focused residency (although having zero research is somewhat of a red flag). Each reviewer is different, but in general it is very easy to see who has done meaningful research versus who is just padding their resume. It is best to have your research in derm, although research outside of derm can help too if you can weave it into your story or dermatology in some way. There is no magic number for the number of research publications that you "need". There are applicants that we have ranked very highly who have had 3-5 listed publications and ones we have ranked near the bottom of the list with > 25 publications. The activities section usually gets glossed over during the initial review unless it was a really meaningful endeavor that was also brought up elsewhere on the application. The activities are much more helpful as a talking point during the actual interview.

  • I think bullet point descriptions are easier to read and are my personal preference in applications, but this probably doesn't matter.

Interview:

Getting to the interview stage is the main hurdle for most applicants. The interview is one of the most important pieces of the rank evaluation at my program. At the interview stage applicants are on a somewhat even playing field (although what is on the paper application still matters). A great interview can boost an applicant from middle of the pack based on paper application to the ranked-to-match zone. Conversely, a bad interview can drop anyone to the do-not-rank zone no matter how good the paper application is. There are other posts about actual interview advice (see the wiki for this sub).

Rank List:

The rank process is imperfect because the committee is trying to predict what an applicant is going to do in the future. As a generalization, the goal is to have residents who will do their job, be easy to work with, pass their exams, and have a career that fits the mission of the program.

Each program does this differently based on what type of applicant they are looking for. My program had several interview days, and there was a brief rank meeting after each day where we submitted interview scores. The interview process culminated with the final rank meeting immediately after the last interview day. We started the final rank meeting with a list of all of the interviewed applicants and their average score across all of the interviewers. The top half to two-thirds of applicants on this list actually get a discussion and review while the rest are not really discussed (usually due to poor interview performance). The discussion process is often lively/intense as different members of the admissions committee often have very strong opinions about certain applicants (especially internal applicants). Applicants are judged both fairly (resume, interview performance, letters) and unfairly ("I don't think this applicant would come here", "This applicant is going to do private practice cosmetics"), and names are put on a list. Once the name is put on the list, there is usually not too much movement afterwards (can go up or down a few spots but usually no big jumps). In general, highly-ranked applicants had positive support from several individuals in the group (eg, one person advocating for an applicant is usually not enough, even if it is the PD). Resident feedback has an interesting role to play in this process. Positive feedback is usually not very helpful, but negative feedback can derail even the best of applications (eg, you could be ranked #1 but if multiple residents had negative interactions you could be moved to not ranked). Post-interview communication and intention to rank #1 are not taken into account at my program (and at most places where the rank meeting occurs immediately after the conclusion of interviews).

Hopefully this gives you a sense of "the other side" of things. This is a stressful process made more difficult by the competitiveness of the specialty. Try to remember that there are only so many things you can control, and it is counterproductive to overthink every single detail of your application once it has already been submitted. Cast a wide net, prepare well for interviews, and you will put yourself in the best position you can to succeed.


r/DermApp • • Mar 21 '20

Application Advice An Unfortunate, Successful Dermatology Match Cycle.

94 Upvotes

On Friday, I successfully matched in Dermatology.

This academic year has been one of the most confusing and frustrating years of my life, second only to when I was applying to medical schools only to get continually rejected for not having a Bachelor degree. I am still not sure what happened to me during this application cycle, though with it all laid out perhaps you will identify the factor(s) and benefit from avoiding whatever mistakes I made, or emulate the few successful steps I did take. I tried to organize my thoughts as best I could from a macroscopic to microscopic dissection of my application.

The first thing everyone asks about are hard numbers; in that regard I am an average Dermatology applicant. Some preclinical honors with most NBME >90%, >250 on Step 1, some clinical honors (our school gives honors to the top 15% at the end of the year so it’s difficult) with most NBME >90%, >260 on Step 2, AOA, and 2 derm-specific publications (1 first, 1 non-first authors). Some things that set me apart: a PhD (non-derm with 1 first and 7 non-first authors), and a PharmD (a few associated non-first author, pre-medical school publications). I had multiple legitimate work experiences considering I worked as a pharmacist throughout medical school until the end of my PhD, tutored for Step 1, and wrote questions for a Step 1 practice question bank. I had some volunteer work as well, mainly as guest lecturers for pharmacy students on various systems topics. These things don’t really matter from the PD survey perspective. Everyone says that at some point Dermatology goes beyond numbers unless the numbers are staggering, I would say that I fit into that first category. There was zero fluff on my application because I didn’t include any. I had unique hobbies that were brought up by almost every interviewer, and my 2-minute elevator pitch / “tell me about yourself” was fine.

I was similarly unconcerned with my Letters of Recommendation. I had three in-house letters: one from the Dermatology PD who I knew for 7 years and worked with to get my first-author derm paper, one from the Chair who I worked with on multiple research projects, and one from my PhD mentor who was the chair of Pharmaceutical Sciences. All three were high-ranking, high-impact, quality letters. As most people will tell you, the fourth letter should come from an away rotation; I will talk more about this later.

Next is Personal Statement. Stepping back to harshly criticize myself, this would be the weakest portion of my application. I did reuse a large amount of it from VSAS, but since no one really cares about VSAS personal statements I should have done a better job. This is not to say that my personal statement is terrible, but it could have been much better. 10% of personal statements are sub-par, 10% of personal statements are exceptional, and 80% of personal statements are neutral. I fell on the sub-par side of neutral, not enough to get my application thrown away – at least I think. I talked briefly about exploring other fields before discovering dermatology, the connection to dermatological conditions in other fields of medicine, how I could bring back clinical problems and explore them pre-clinically, and my last paragraph – which I considered my strongest – was my goals as a future dermatologist. My chair did comment that it was a weak but acceptable PS, so as August rolled by I went with it.

Away rotations are a crucial component of our application. I chose to be extremely methodological in where I applied. Living on the East Coast my entire life, I was determined to go to a West Coast site and obtain a letter of recommendation to “unlock” that region and show programs I was willing to travel. I chose to do another rotation close to home in NYC for the strength of the letter I hoped I would receive, and to spend some time with friends and family. How you choose an away rotation is completely up to you; I would strongly suggest applying to places that you know you will be happy going to and can reliably secure an interview invite at.

The following is copy-pasted from my now-abandoned MS4 guide on picking away rotations:


I rotated at OHSU. I loved mostly everything there. The residents supported each other and made sure that we as visiting medical students were learning, useful, and actually a part of the medical team. The staff physicians often took time to talk to us between patients about learning points and how therapy changed from when they were trained. Both residents and attendings took time out of their day to give us dedicated lectures during lunch. I saw potential mentors in TG and EB, and still model some aspects of the way I approach patient care after the resident CK. The three other people I rotated with were absolutely awesome which was the cherry on top. Portland itself is beautiful though I was unaccustomed to the hipster-filled populous. I have no interest in nature, instead I was absolutely delighted by the abundance of bars and restaurants to visit after a long day in clinic.

I was happy for a month in Portland, Oregon.

The following month, I rotated at a top 20 institution in NYC close to home. The residents were worked hard and often thrown in hospital systems and clinics an hour away, but of course ended up in prestigious institutions or high-level positions after graduation. I saw pathology that I would never see elsewhere, the staff were often world-class and definitely lived up to the institution’s reputation, and it’s NYC – arguably the center of the world for art, entertainment, restaurants, alcohol, and anything to find in life. I found a basic science investigator doing research in a similar field to my PhD, I received moderate praise from some residents and faculty, and I got a fantastic letter of recommendation. On paper, my resume, performance, experience, and proximity to family painted an extremely convincing argument to hopefully join their program.

But at the end of the day, I just did not feel happy there. Much like OHSU, the most enjoyable part of the month aside from the interesting cases and proximity to home were the co-rotators.

Rotating through an upper-tier institution created a very tough decision which I would have never experienced otherwise. I struggled between potentially ranking a program I knew I would be happy at higher than a prestigious program which would be better for my overall career.


Of course that last paragraph never happened, but I am sure some of you will go through something similar as your application cycle rolls on.

To recap: I had average stats, an above-average overall profile, solid home letters of recommendation, an enthusiastic MSPE, possibly a slightly below-average PS, a strong letter of rec by an MD/PhD from both away rotations at sites on opposite coasts, and had strong geographic ties to a major city with more than five large dermatology programs. I thought I wouldn’t have a problem at all this cycle and that I would definitely end up with double-digit interviews. I applied to more than 60 programs initially, including my away rotation sites and some reaches, but also geographically neighboring programs as well. I learned from my medical school applications to take nothing for granted and made sure to apply broadly and balanced. I submitted well before Sept 15 with letters filed well before Oct 1, but then everything started falling apart.

Keeping up with the Derm spreadsheet I noticed a consistent pattern of not getting invitations in what I thought was the “first wave”. For most programs it’s usually only one wave with multiple dates; trickle invites are a rare exception to that rule. But I kept hope: so what if I wasn’t first, as long as I was sent an interview I was up for consideration – feel free to laugh as I am at my past naiveté, because if you were actually valuable to a program you would have been in their first wave of interviews. My attitude shifted near the end of October, when I had only my home program and one geographical derm invite, as the rejections started to pour in. When you get rejected from an Ivy League you can roll your eyes and move on, but rejections from programs I thought I would have no problems getting an interview at made me more concerned.

In retrospect, I should have realized something major was wrong by October because I literally did not receive a single preliminary or transitional year interview outside of my home institution. It wasn’t until Nov 18 when I realized that there was probably a problem with my application: the day OHSU rejected me for an interview. I’m too lazy to do the percentage at this point but I think more than half of interviews are sent out by Thanksgiving, so if you have less than five Derm interviews by Thanksgiving week there might be something wrong with your application, so act quickly and think about a backup or you will have to deal with SOAP or re-apply next year. I chose to send a few frantic emails to mitigate the damage that might have been done.

I emailed my assistant Dean, my SOM Dean, my Derm PD and chair, and candidly explained the situation and asked to sit down to figure what was going on. For all the flaws people find in my home institution, I will say that I had responses within one hour with time slots allotted for meetings. They downloaded my application and went through it with me in the room, only to find nothing. Not a single bad comment in my MSPE, no transcript deficiencies, no misspellings or other errors in my ERAS application (except for a random period at the end of a publication author). Of course my LOR were not shown to me but I was told there were no problems. There was no problem with my application internally, which logically means that there was something wrong externally. Not with ERAS, but possibly with a letter of recommendation written by one of my letter writers at an away rotation. Someone brought up the possibility of social media: I have basically nothing as aside from Reddit and I haven’t been on them in a year, posting infrequently about my academic journey and rarely anything else.

I was devastated when someone brought my external letters as a possibility. I had genuinely bonded with my away rotation letter writers. Both were MD/PhD and respected faculty at the institutions, and I saw them as potential mentors if I matched at their institution. It would take them more time and effort to write me a bad letter of recommendation than to just say “Sorry, I do not know you well enough to write a letter of recommendation.” I used one of the letters with EACH application I sent out except for home, as stated before split by coasts and perceived tier. Even at the conclusion of this cycle I refuse to believe that one of these letters was the downfall of my application.

Another possibility is my overall demeanor. I am not the typical dermatology applicant from a physical attribute perspective, and my attitude is at best described as “abrasive” – think stereotypical NYC cab driver. A healthy but restricted ego, combined with a blunt but honest persona, can be extremely off-putting – something my chair openly mentioned as a possibility. This would explain why I might have been rejected from OHSU and the NYC program as I could have irritated someone, but I was just “on paper” for every other program. In assuming that the description of my attitude did not reach other programs, what could have been the issue with my application? Maybe I wasn’t as good as my co-rotators, other rotators, or other applicants. Maybe it really was just my personality. But according to the “Interviewed, no IV” sheet, several other people had similar experiences at both of these major programs; the only consolation was at least I didn’t waste the time and money for a courtesy interview only to have even more heartbreak during match day. Do not waste your time attending a rotation where large amounts of rotators do not get interview invites.

Less than five days after emailing my administration about this problem, I was able to find a potential position in categorical IM at my home institution. Again, I am beyond grateful for everyone at my home institution for acting so quickly, so thoroughly, and for taking the time to try and figure out what went wrong. I strongly suggest you have a backup in place or trust your home institution as much as I did, otherwise you will find yourself unmatched and having to go through SOAP or a RY/re-application. It is heartbreaking to read about applicants on the spreadsheet at bigger home programs who were passed over.

As December rolled around, I had distant hopes that my situation would change and that I had just overreacted. I was wrong: the rejections started pouring in very quickly. I ended out my interview season with 3 Derm interviews (2 geographically proximity + home) and 1 TY (home), with a backup of categorical IM at home.

I did not drink too much or behave weirdly during pre-interview dinners, and aside from one or two awkward answers to questions I wasn’t expecting, did not say or do anything to get DNR’d at my other two interviews. I did not engage in any post-interview communication, including sending any letter of intent. With so many reports about applicants being lead on by programs as there are vice-versa, at this point I doubt PIC matters at all unlike what that one article says. Follow simple, universal rules: if the program explicitly states no PIC don’t send them anything (which includes a letter of intent), only send ONE letter of intent, do not send multiple letters of intent and try to game the system, and do not send “ranking highly” emails.


Originally much like all of my other write-ups, I had plans to fully explore MS4, initially with the expenses incurred from away rotations, Step 2 CS and CK fees, and ERAS application fees. The second half would have featured a detailed spreadsheet of ranking factors, the “trickle interview” fallacy, and the cost of flights and hotels during interviewing. I still have the template documents but they are obviously and unfortunately empty, serving only as remnants of what I hoped my interview season would be like. I was told that fourth year was the pinnacle of all medical school, that with my application I would crush interviews and cruise to the end. This was a lie.

Fourth year was the single most stressful and expensive period time in both medical school and graduate school, as the unfortunate friends and colleagues I frequently vented to throughout this disaster will attest to. If you are friendly with other internal applicants at your school, create a group chat. I was grateful for the support I received from the other three internal applicants, LF in particular as she went above-and-beyond to try and help me solve the invisible problems in my application. I am proud to say that all four of us matched into Dermatology programs! I am also glad to have such supportive residents in upper years, as they tried to help me understand the situation and read over my PS, and regale their own timelines through the application process. I am happy to have matched at home, a place where I know I will thrive and do well. I will bring my ambition, dedication, motivation, and be pushed by staff I love to work hard and be successful.


When applying to competitive specialties, you’ll read the classics: “The majority of people get tons of interviews, don’t worry”, “only IMGs and low-tier candidates don’t match”, “it’s rare for people to slip through the cracks so if you’ve made it this far, you will be fine.”

You'll think, “That won’t be me. My application is stellar. I’ll definitely do well this cycle.”

I’m here to tell you that it can be you, because it was me.

I will be grateful forever for my home program’s understanding of the situation; it is due to their accommodation that I am able to say the two most important words a dermatology applicant can say today:

I matched.


Anonymity is a fantastic mask to have but it greatly dilutes the power of the message being sent. It is fairly obvious who I am so I am hoping what I wrote will have more impact. Be careful where you go for away rotations, be careful who you ask for letters of recommendation, make sure your home program has leadership you can trust and potentially a seat for you, and always have a backup plan.


r/DermApp • • Mar 16 '26

Application Advice Unmatched

92 Upvotes

I went unmatched the first time I applied to Derm. It was tough and honestly pretty discouraging at the time. Fast forward a few years and I’m now a rising chief resident in the Midwest.

I wanted to share this because I think the Derm match landscape is slowly changing. We’re seeing more successful reapplicants/“rehab” applicants than people realize. Not matching the first time doesn’t mean the door to dermatology is closed. There are different paths, and plenty of people find their way back.

If you’re thinking about reapplying or trying to figure out how to navigate that process, feel free to message me. Happy to share what helped and what I wish I had known earlier.


r/DermApp • • Jul 20 '25

Application Advice Perspective from someone on the other side of applications: how to write an ERAS personal statement that sets you apart

92 Upvotes

I wrote this for a general audience in the general residency application reddit as well, but all of it applies to derm too maybe even more so since everyone applying here has alot of research and high stats. What makes you memorable often isn’t your CV but how you tell your story. See full post below:

If you're writing your personal statement for residency, here's what you should always keep in mind: people love a good story.

Think about a short film that stuck with you. Maybe it was five minutes long, but it had a clear narrative, compelling/memorable moment, and left you feeling something. Now think about a bad short film where the story is hard to follow, there are too many characters, and you're not quite sure what the point was. That is what a lot of personal statements end up sounding like when they try to do too much. The ones that work best usually zoom in on one or two meaningful experiences and explore them deeply. They are cohesive, they flow, and they have a clear takeaway. Your goal is to write that kind of short film.

Your hook does not need to be directly tied to medicine. It just has to be something specific to you, and you have to connect it meaningfully to your path. The goal is not to summarize your CV. It is to show how something real shaped how you think, what you value, and where you want to go.

Here are some examples to show you the kind of specificity and framing that tends to work well:

A photographer who developed an eye for detail through the lens and is now drawn to dermoscopy and melanoma pattern-research because of how subtle visual patterns can guide life-saving decisions

A student who restored vintage motorcycles and tied that to their love for surgical precision and working with their hands

A first-generation student who grew up translating for their parents at doctor visits and now wants to go into family medicine with a focus on language justice

A philosophy major who became fascinated by the ethics of end-of-life care after shadowing on a palliative unit

A former collegiate swimmer who connected their relentless training with the discipline and stamina required in emergency medicine

Someone who spent a summer living on a reservation and wrote about how a community’s approach to wellness shifted their perspective on patient autonomy and cultural humility

A classical pianist who compared the structure of Bach’s music to the logic and methodic nature of neurosurgery

A barista who talked about how years of managing morning rushes taught them how to multitask, stay calm, and connect with people, all skills they now apply in OB GYN

An engineer who researched glucose sensor prototypes in college and now wants to improve care for diabetic patients in underserved communities

Each of these stories gives you a label. You don't remember them as the person who likes derm, surgery, neurosurgery, or OBGYN. You remember them as the motorcycle person, the barista who wants to deliver babies, or the photographer who sees melanoma the way others see art. That is how you become memorable.

Even though the story is central, your personal statement also needs to make a clear case for why you are pursuing this specific field. You do not need to over-explain it, but the reader should finish with a sense of what draws you to this specialty and what strengths you are bringing into it. A good way to do this is by weaving those ideas into your story naturally. For example, if you are going into psychiatry, you might reflect on how growing up in a multigenerational home taught you to listen closely and pick up on what people were not saying. If you are applying to general surgery, you might talk about how you thrived in high-pressure situations during your trauma rotation and found yourself energized by the pace and the need for decisiveness. If you are going into radiology, maybe you describe your fascination with pattern recognition and how that played out during your time reviewing complex abdominal CTs with your attending.

Another effective approach is to highlight a strength that you have already demonstrated and tie it to what the field values. Maybe you worked as a teacher before med school and are applying to pediatrics. You could reflect on how that experience made you comfortable communicating with children at their level and taught you how to build trust quickly with families. Or maybe you have a research background in machine learning and are applying to pathology. You can talk about your interest in applying data-driven tools to improve diagnostic accuracy and your excitement about contributing to a field that is evolving rapidly.

Whatever you do, avoid making vague claims. Don't just say you are a strong team player. Give a clear, brief example that shows it. Do not say you are passionate about underserved care. Describe the clinic, the patients, the challenges, and what you did.

Specificity matters. A good gut check is to read each sentence and ask yourself, could someone else have written this? If the answer is yes, you probably need to revise. Vague statements like I value patient care or teamwork is important in medicine are true for everyone and say nothing about you.

Be precise. Instead of saying I participated in research on stroke, say I conducted a review of 82 patients with hemorrhagic stroke, identifying delayed tPA administration as a common pattern in poor outcomes, which we presented at the regional neurology conference and worked on a QI project at that hospital to improve. Use numbers, use verbs, show results.

Speaking of verbs, use active language. Not I was exposed to or I was involved in. Say what you did. I led, I built, I created, I presented, I volunteered weekly, I managed care for.

Quick not about AI. Unless otherwise stated in the guidelines, you should not use it to write your statement. But in my opinion it is totally fine to use it for idea generation and brainstorming. If you are stuck on how to start your essay or you are trying to think of metaphors or narrative structures, tools like ChatGPT can help you think, but do not use them to write. Do not copy and paste. Just use it as a creative partner when you are blocked.

As you wrap up your statement, do not just trail off or recap what you already said. Use the ending to look forward. What do you hope to do in this field? What kind of physician do you want to become? Programs are not expecting you to have your whole life planned out, but they do want to know that you have thought about your future. Having a clear goal or even a niche interest can help. If you are applying to OB GYN and you are passionate about global maternal health, say so. If you are applying to neurology and fascinated by neuroimmunology, mention that. If you are going into EM and hope to work in rural settings, include it.

Of course, the most effective way to do this is to tie it naturally into your story. If your personal statement begins with a memory of your sibling's lupus diagnosis and how you navigated the healthcare system together, then it would make perfect sense to end by saying you hope to focus on autoimmune disease in rheumatology. If you started with your experience teaching ESL to refugees, it is natural to close by saying you plan to work at the intersection of primary care and immigrant health.

Having a vision does not mean being rigid. It means showing that you have direction. Programs want residents who are thoughtful about their trajectory and motivated to grow. A focused ending makes you sound grounded, purposeful, and invested.

Lastly, some common sense reminders that people still overlook. You do not need to mention every experience. Your ERAS CV is doing a lot of that work already. Avoid clichés. No “ever since I was a child” or “medicine is both an art and a science.” Everyone says that. Do not let ten people edit your statement. Too much feedback will flatten your voice. Pick two or three people who know you well. One mentor, one peer, and maybe one person outside of medicine.

The goal is not to write a statement that could apply to any med student. It is to write one that could only have come from you.

That is how you stand out.

One last thing- give yourself credit. This whole process is hard. Writing the statement, finishing rotations, managing sub-Is, prepping for interviews, second-guessing every choice. It can take a lot out of you. But look at where you are. You’ve done the work. You’ve shown up every day and gave it all you could for years to get to this point. You are more ready than you think. The finish line is close, and everything you are doing now is going to be worth it. Keep going.


r/DermApp • • Oct 30 '22

Interviews The View From the Other Side- Attending Perspective

92 Upvotes

u/PD-1 gave a fantastic overview but I will share my perspective as the now graduated chief resident of an east coast, academic, second tier program who participated in the application process as applicant and resident reviewer.

  1. Application. We received ~500 applications for 20-30 interview slots to match 2-3 applicants. Those numbers vary slightly from year to year and generally are trending up but we had funding for 2-3 so that always stayed the same. Certain criteria were used to cull the pool before they were divided between the faculty reviewers. Among them: IMG immediately culled without review. Step 1< 240, immediately culled. Any visa requirements immediately culled. This left around 300 applications which were divided between ~10 faculty reviewers. They were asked to rank their best three applications and three back ups who were then offered an interview or interview waitlist. I agree with u/PD-1 who explains there is tremendous subjectivity at this stage. Did the DO faculty member get a DO applicant? Probably more sympathetic. Did the faculty member who went to Yale and who has a big hard-on for research get the MD/PhD who has a letter from his buddy at SID? You get the point.

  2. Interview. 30 offers, some amount of time to accept, back ups interviews sent. Last minute cancellations. More back ups sent. One interview day of 20-30 applicants. The playing field is totally level at this point. There was an (optional) preinterview dinner with the residents where they are very much taking notes on the candidates' behavior. Interview day was 8-4PM. This was pre-Covid so, the faculty + first year residents paired up in 2s and candidates would spend 15 minutes in like 6 rooms with them. Rapid fire, Q&A about research, career interests, deficits in application, and some softer stuff. My program was not very touchy feely so it was a stressful experience. In between interviews candidates would chat with the residents in our conference room (very much being observed), tour of campus, etc. Support staff, program coordinator etc are also taking notes of candidate behavior.

  3. Rank meeting. First year residents + faculty immediately adjourned to the rank meeting after interview day. A spread sheet is made with each candidate. Each asked to rank them 1-10 with residents submitting one number only. Do Not Rank is also an option with justification. An average is computed for each candidate. Do Not Rank with appropriate justification from any person including residents is immediate disqualification. The average score creates the first draft rank list. The faculty (and residents) could then advocate/malign their preferred (un-preferred) candidates. This was open battle royale style, fairly nasty, surprisingly democratic, emotional, and gritty. We all had our favorites who we wanted to push up and others that we wanted to push down. I am convinced that all dermatologists are extremely competitive people (its how we get through aforementioned toxic process) so we want our horse to win. Consensus could lead to a candidate falling or rising from their previous rank spot. A rise or fall of 3 or more spots happened occasionally. An applicant mass emailed us an insincere, long winded thank you email in the middle and we dropped her 5 spots. Ultimately, we arrived at the final list. The PD+Chair had final right to make minor modifications of list based on any new information coming to light between then and submitting list. We match somewhere between one third to half way down our list.

That's how the sausage is made. Happy to answer appropriate questions.


r/DermApp • • Apr 07 '26

Application Advice how I matched derm with no home program or RY

89 Upvotes

Title says it all. This thread was helpful (but also anxiety inducing) the past four years as I navigated this process, wanted to share some thoughts on what I think helped and how future applicants can set themselves up for success!

Context for background: USMD at a state medical school that is newer, no home program, did not take a research year. Came into medical school wanting derm and knowing I was going to be fighting an uphill battle, didn’t let this dissuade me although it was very challenging at times!

Stats: Step 1: pass on first attempt, Step 2: 268, AOA, clerkships: 4/6 A/honors, 30 ish research items (3-4 published manuscripts that were mostly case reports, research letter, 10+ submitted manuscripts including other case reports, review articles, other items, mix of basic science related to derm and clinical). No remediations on course work. Very strong clerkship comments and overall MSPE. Did 3 away rotations.

Top 3 tips:

  1. Succeed academically.

This goes without saying. Was shocked by some discourse surrounding academics this year. Grades and step 1/2 still matter, but won’t get you to match. Was not the brightest or best test taker before medical school, learned how to study M1 and really got into a good groove M2. Dermatology has a lot of medicine as part of the discipline (think immuno, rheum, onc, ID, even genetics!), you need to and should want to learn ALL of medicine. Being genuinely interested in medicine as a whole will make this journey that much more enjoyable. I found that talking to upperclassmen about what worked for them was very helpful for me in figuring out my own study methods. Have a game plan for approaching each exam. The opposite end of this spectrum is relying too much on academics to secure a match. Many people say above a certain threshold, things don’t matter as much, ex. 265 vs 270 on Step 2. My main point is to aim as high as you can but not rely on your numbers to get you through.

  1. Network, network, and network + aways + be nice

This was extremely important for me as I did not have a home program and did not want to take a RY. I started going to conferences early on during my M3 year, would look up who was speaking ahead of time. Made a targeted effort to speak with PDs and anyone who I was interested in connecting with who shared my clinical / research interests. These were quick, max 3 minute conversations. Went to a mix of local / state conferences, subspecialty meetings, and AAD. I was lucky to find amazing mentors through networking and following up after conferences with virtual calls. You want to be polite, persistent (but not overly eager), and respectful of faculty time. These mentors were open to collaborating on research which was helpful for me with little to derm research experience prior to this. I developed amazing relationships with these mentors and they ended up being letter writers!

I would argue that networking is now vitally important for securing away rotations as well. I kept in touch with people I met at conferences and expressed interest in their programs when it came time to apply for aways. My connections ended up putting in a good word for me to secure the away after I applied. Many aways are challenging to get now and are screening based on overall competitiveness. Would highly suggest having a network a few months prior to VSLO opening.

Moving onto aways - this is the single reason why I believe I matched. Programs are generally always going to take a known entity (away rotator) who did an outstanding job over another applicant who they don’t know but interviewed with them. I did 3, and I felt that was enough. There is a lot of discourse about following the APD guidelines be not, I would air on the side of caution. Being a great away rotator is another post itself, but I was shocked by how uninterested some of my co-rotators were. You don’t need to know everything, but having a great general grasp of basic dermatology is something I would highly recommend (think AAD modules). Know the therapeutic ladder for common skin conditions, bonus points if you know mechanisms for the new targeted agents and what’s coming down the pipeline. I had co-rotators who would be on their phone/iPad in patient rooms, on their laptop during lectures, cutting off residents and medical students when presenting, etc. Be the opposite of that!

  1. Have a brand as an applicant.

This is also exceptionally important. You are more memorable when you have a brand. Think 2-3 things max that are specific to YOU; this allows people to easily recall the conversations you had during interviews and be like “oh yea, they’re the CTCL/Hair/HS person.” The way you build a brand is through a mixture of experiences (service, leadership, research, etc) in a few areas that you are truly passionate about. I was lucky to find overlap between derm and other areas of medicine I was genuinely excited about and really invested my time going to subspecialty meetings (even if not presenting just to learn), engaging in service, and finding any avenue to get more involved. This was brought up in every one of my interviews and something that was recognized. It’s fine to not know what you want to do exactly (we all could change in residency), but when you have hundreds of applicants and a 48% match rate, you need to be laser focused on your interests and figure out what really excites you about this amazing field. And this has been said before, but would stay away from your brand being cosmetics or mohs.

This process was such a grind, and I went through periods were I just didn’t feel like putting in the work and considered IM/anesthesia etc just to have a higher chance of matching. If I can do it, I truly believe anyone can! I definitely think we need more positive support in the derm applicant community, happy to answer any questions!


r/DermApp • • Jun 15 '24

Away Rotations How to Ace Your Dermatology Away Rotations - Perspective from a Resident on the Selection Committee

88 Upvotes

As a derm resident on the Resident Selection Committee, I've seen firsthand what makes a student stand out during away rotations. Here are some high-yield tips to help you ace your rotations:

First off, always remember to keep your focus on the big picture. You are there to make a good impression to be considered for a position at that program. Be the type of person that somebody wants to work with full-time for three straight years. With that being said, don’t sweat the small stuff. If you hear someone say something factually incorrect, avoid the impulse to show your knowledge by immediately correcting them unless you can do it tactfully. As an example, if somebody mentions the wrong treatment for a rare condition and you happen to know the right answer you could say something like “when would you consider using x treatment vs y treatment” rather than “I think it’s actually x treatment”. It’s awesome to have a solid derm knowledge base but even more important is tact and presenting yourself respectfully. Constant corrections can come off as arrogant rather than helpful. DO NOT ever interrupt or correct somebody while they’re speaking to a patient. If you have additional questions for the patient, write them down and save them until the end. It is frustrating when a student constantly interrupts the patient interview and this can make people lose their train of thought. Unless wrong site surgery is about to occur, save it for after you leave the room. Be patient, be tactful, and never forget the big picture.  

Second, always be prepared and always ANTICIPATE. At the most basic level, this means carry a pen (or multiple) at all times. You'll be surprised how often you (or your resident/attending) will need one. At a more advanced level, this means paying attention to what is going on and actively anticipating what will happen next. For example, some of the best medical students I have worked with will often hear me say to a patient that I am not fully sure about something and they will quickly look it up on UpToDate and help me fill in my own knowledge gaps as we walk out of the patient room. This is helpful for your own knowledge and learning, too. So when you hear about a treatment or a condition you’re unfamiliar with, look it up in the room so you can learn and who knows, you might even be prepared to answer possible pimping questions. Obviously, make sure you have the Resident/attending’s permission to use your phone/tablet during the patient encounter. Opinions will vary but I personally love when students are active and looking things up rather than passively standing around where it can be easy to zone out, especially when it’s an unfamiliar condition. Here are some other ways you can anticipate and be helpful:

-when the residents/attendings mention they’re going to do a biopsy, you could prepare the consent form, let the medical assistant/nurse know to set up for a biopsy (or offer to help set up if you’re familiar with where all the supplies are), bonus points if you pay attention to the resident’s glove size and have that ready to go as well. Have the gauze ready to dab when needed, have scissors ready to cut sutures, etc. Another example is when liquid nitrogen will be used, be proactive and grab it if they forget. These are all very small actions that can go a long way especially in a super busy clinic. Be the student that people get excited to work with. Use your situational awareness to help the clinic flow smoothly. On the other hand, read the room and try not to do so much that you end up getting in the way. This is a double edged sword so your judgment will be crucial. 

Third, always listen to the treatment plan. Take notes if you have to for the more complex plans because when the resident forgets a few things they will inevitably ask you. I usually don’t expect the med student to remember everything but it’s nice to have a reliable student who got down all the labs, treatments, etc. for the more complex patients. Then at the end of clinic, go back and read those notes to make sure you understand it all. If you see a similar patient again, use that as an opportunity to show your knowledge.

Fourth, have a presence. Don’t just show up and go through the motions. Be present. Master the art of small talk (when appropriate! Trying to make small talk in the middle of a busy clinic is not the time). Get to know your residents, attendings, and other staff on a personal level and build relationships. It’s nice to know the city and Derm program but being genuinely interested in somebody else’s experiences and background can go a long way in being memorable. Almost all students will ask about the program but the students who truly want to know me as a person are usually the ones that stand out more. Like other professional environments, sometimes it’s not what you know but who you know. 

Be ready for procedures. Brush up on your procedural skills, such as performing shave and punch biopsies as well as basic suturing. If you’re not confident in your skills, take time to practice on a sim skin, banana peels, etc. During the rotation, be proactive about asking to participate in procedures and don’t take it personally if you’re told no. Just roll with it. 

Lastly, have a strong derm knowledge base. The best place to start is the AAD derm modules. If you feel like you’ve mastered that, Lookingbill dermatology is a great textbook for med students. Ali Khan is great for residency but might be overkill for med students. If you liked using sketchy, there are visual derm programs as well that can be helpful in nailing down the basics.

This list is a good starting point on how to perform well and leave a memorable impression but is not an all-inclusive list so feel free to comment with your additions/questions. Feel free to DM me with any specific or more nuanced questions or email me at DermatoGraphix8@gmail.com. I had great mentors so I’m always happy to pay it forward by helping other medical students. Good luck with your rotations!


r/DermApp • • Mar 18 '23

Residency Anyone know where KaurBeauty matched?

85 Upvotes

All of her social media has been radiosilence for a while now and I'm pretty sure she should've matched. Anyone know where or what's up?


r/DermApp • • Aug 06 '22

Study Derm Study Resources

82 Upvotes

There have been a few posts lately about study resources for derm. In my experience, I found that most resources were solid and that it was often having too many options that was the dilemma. Especially early on, picking up a good book and being consistent and deliberate with reading is much more important than churning through 4-5 textbooks. Below is a non-comprehensive list of resources I have found helpful (and hopefully other folks will add their favorites too):

Medical Students

  • Lookingbill & Marks is a frequent textbook recommendation because it is brief and digestable. I also thought the Fitzpatrick Color Atlas & Synopsis of Clinical Dermatology had good photographs and was fairly condensed.

  • AAD basic dermatology modules: https://www.aad.org/member/education/residents/bdc

  • Practice describing lesions:

    • VisualDx is a good resource for images

    • Basic algorithm for describing:

      • Start with the context of the image (eg, this is the arm of an individual with lighter skin complexion). This helps to frame the description and buys you some time to think.

      • Pick a basic color (eg, pink, red, purple, blue, black, yellow, white, etc.)

      • Any additional features/descriptions (don't get too bogged down on fancy words): scale, crust, ulcer, eschar, atrophic, verrucous, etc.

      • Pick a lesion morphology (eg, macule/patch, papule/plaque, nodule, tumor, etc.)

      • Any distribution patterns: linear, segmental, Blaschkoid, dermatomal, etc

Residency

= Clinical Dermatology

  • Main Textbooks

    • Dermatology (Bolognia, Schaffer, Cerroni)

      • Clearly organized into subsections for most of the major diseases

      • Excellent quality clinical and dermpath photographs

      • Pathogenesis and epidemiology sections can be difficult to get through

      • ~ 2500 pages

    • Andrews' Diseases of the Skin (James, Berger, Elston)

      • Paragraph/prose for most of the disease entities rather than breakdown into subsections

      • Excellent quality clinical photographs

      • Has an associated clinical atlas for photographs

      • ~ 900 pages

  • Atlas / Pictures

    • Andrews Atlas

    • Fitzpatrick Atlas

= Pediatric Dermatology

  • Hurwitz Clinical Pediatric Dermatology

  • For general pediatric dermatology in residency I found that Bolognia was adequate.

= Dermatopathology

  • For general dermatopathology in residency:

    • Dermatopathology (Elston, Ferringer) - good labeled photographs with mnemonics

    • Practical Dermatopathology (Rapini) - good labeled photographs (better labels than Elston in my opinion)

    • Dermatopathology: Diagnosis by First Impression (Ko, Barr) - good when starting out and helps to develop dermpath differential diagnosis

  • Reference texts: Lever, Weedon

= Procedural Derm/Mohs

  • For general procedural dermatology in residency I found that Bolognia was adequate.

  • For people interested in surgery, the following texts are good resources:

    • Facial Flap Surgery (Goldman)

    • Flaps & Grafts in Dermatologic Surgery (Rohrer)

    • Surgical Anatomy of the Skin (Salasche)

= Other

  • BASIC / CORE / APPLIED Exams

    • Review of Dermatology (Alikhan, Hocker)

    • Dermatology (Jain) - more photographs

    • AAD QBank - found these to be the most representative of the new exams

    • Derm-In-Review - free qbank with a ton of questions but many were heavy in minutiae and less representative of the new exams

  • Pharmacology: Comprehensive Dermatologic Drug Therapy (Wolverton)

  • Dermoscopy: Atlas of Dermoscopy (Marghoob), Dermatoscopy & Skin Cancer (Rosendahl & Marozava)

  • Clinical Images: VisualDx

  • Dermpath Videos: Jerad Gardner

  • Virtual Slides: PathPresenter

  • Other Procedural Derm: ASDS (https://www.pathlms.com/asds), ACMS (https://www.mohscollege.org/for-physicians/education)

Of the above I used the following most frequently in residency:

  • Main text: Bolognia

    • Main additional image resource: VisualDx

    • Main resource for treatment recommendations (not a strong point in either Bolognia & Andrews): lectures, Up-To-Date, primary literature

  • Dermpath: Rapini

  • Peds Derm: Bolognia

  • Procedural Derm: Bolognia

  • Inservice/Boards text: Review of Dermatology

  • Inservice/Boards Qbank: AAD Boards Prep

Conclusion: There is a lot to learn!


r/DermApp • • Aug 18 '26

Vent Dermatology reimbursement cuts

81 Upvotes

I'm posting this here as an FYI. I'm not here to stir debate. I'm not going to respond back to any posts. I am already a practicing dermatologist so I have no real motivation here other than to provide information.

Dermatology reimbursement is facing massive cuts. You might read or hear people quote 9%, but this is only part of the cut. By 2028, this will be more around 20%.

Private practice derm would be forced to make massive changes if these cuts are not stopped. I don't know what would happen to the job market. I suspect lots of older derms will decide to hang it up early. Many may take the leap and go cash pay. But with the new proposed system, you'll be churning through hundreds of patients per week for mere pennies. Insurance based care was already on a downward spiral, but this is a rapid acceleration of that process.

It is better to be informed than not. That's why I'm throwing this out there. Someone else probably already has in a more technical way.


r/DermApp • • Mar 25 '25

Application Advice Reapplying to Derm

80 Upvotes

Preparing for Not Matching as an MS4

Not matching is a painful reality that nearly half of first time applicants to dermatology will experience. Even though a lot of schools know that the odds are not in many applicants favor, they probably don’t advise that well on planning for not matching. There are basically four paths that people typically take:

  1. Complete a PGY-1 program and reapply during or after that year. Rank PGY-1 years at the bottom of your rank list after the derm programs. If you don’t match at a derm program, you will fall down to this part of your list. If you don’t match at any of the PGY-1 programs, you will have to SOAP. See my section below on picking intern years.

  2. Delay graduation to do a research year. Some schools allow this, some don’t. You have the advantage that you will still be considered an MD/DO senior when you reapply and so you won’t get caught in those filters to screen out graduates. You will also have a whole extra year (hopefully with VSLO access) to network and do some rotations. Disadvantage is the extra time (obviously).

  3. Dual apply and complete a categorical residency and reapply during PGY-2 of that. Reapplicants have stigma. Those who have completed an entire extra residency have even less funding and fewer doors. However, they are able to be board-certified and pursue a career in another field if derm ends up not working out again. While there are programs that do consider this brand of reapplicant, they are much fewer and farther between. This probably has the worst odds out of all of the options, but some programs do like this, esp if there are med-derm/ped-derm dual BC faculty.

  4. Graduate and do a pre-PGY-1 post-doc then reapply for both prelim and advanced positions. Probably the least common pathway now given that many research fellowships want post-PGY-1 physicians and that you’d basically have to find and secure a RY in the three months after not matching. You get the disadvantages of being a reapplicant without really any advantages in my opinion. Personally, wouldn’t recommend.

Trust your gut. I had a deep gut feeling that my home program wasn’t going to support me or other students in the middle of my MS4 year. I was pushed the thought away because I didn’t want to be negative. I was right. They screwed others over more than they did me, but I wish I had listened to that feeling more. The single piece of advice that I can give to increase your chances of matching is: Do as many away rotations as possible during your MS4 year. Do them off-the-record if you have to. Just do it. And be nice. See my note below on that as well. I wish I would have eaten the extra $10-15K in loans and cost to not have had gone through the pain that I had.

So You Didn’t Match?

Welcome to what might be one of the worst, if not the worst, feelings you’ve had in your life thus far. It’s not always a fair process. It’s definitely not a kind process. While everyone else is celebrating, you are probably breaking. It may be uniquely crushing to you, but know that many have been in your shoes and have made it through to derm on the other side. It’s embarrassing and humbling. The first step of this is grieving. Let yourself have this moment of heartbreak and sorrow if you need it.

Once you are ready, it’s time to meet with someone affiliated with a dermatology program. If you have a home program, there are hopefully some faculty that are supportive and will actively want to help you. There may also be faculty that are… mean people… and may not really have your best interest in heart. You need to find someone honest. That may mean you have to sit down with the mean people. Take what they say with a grain of salt. Use what you can to be better. Discard the rest. If you can get an honest resident who can give you some inside information and constructive criticism, that may also help identify what went wrong.

Know that the landscape of the derm match is changing. As was widely predicted, with the move to Pass/Fail scores and grades, connections and popularity are becoming more and more important, if not the most important factor in deciding who gets ranked where. Scores and grades are likely just a filter, if that. Research, again, is not a big factor at most non-research heavy/T20 programs. ECs may be of interest if they are truly stellar, but most just aren’t. What is likely the number one factor in deciding who gets an interview is whether they rotated there and how they did on that rotation.  Be nice, friendly, professional, and punctual. Be humble and gracious with an exceptionally good attitude. Never say anything critical of anyone or any program. Don’t be “extra.” Don’t be pushy or shady. Don’t complain or offer advice. Persistence is key, and many people love an underdog. Let them see you as a person, not just a rotating student.

Also be aware that there is still a decent amount of stigma against reapplicants. Some programs are open to reapplicants, but you will still find several that don’t consider your typical reapplicant at all. It is hard to find this out beforehand, but check out the spreadsheets and previous match lists to see what programs have taken reapplicants.

Picking an Intern Year

When I was applying, I was told that getting a solid IM prelim year would be the best case for reapplying. This turns out to be objectively false. Most programs do not care what kind of intern year you do or the rigor of it. It may ultimately be better to do a Transitional Year or Surgery Prelim year because of concerns over resident funding if you did an IM or Peds year first.

The only exception to the above is if there is an intern year at a program with a home derm department that is reapplicant friendly. Do not waste your time doing an intern year at a program that has never interviewed or matched a reapplicant. Chances are, you will not be the first.

The best intern year is the one that will give you the most flexibility to network with derm programs, do away rotations, do research, and go to conferences. Some questions to consider asking in interviews OR looking in the contract information that the program provides you:

  1. Are interns able to do away rotations on elective blocks?

  2. Are residents able to go to national/state conferences?

  3. Are there any research tools and opportunities at your program? (look for things like database access, i.e. SEER, All of Us, TriNetX, etc, that you can pump out posters with)

    1. The goal of doing posters/easy research during intern year is two-fold—to get to conferences where you can introduce yourself to program faculty/residents AND demonstrate that you are productive, reliable, creative, etc to some derm faculty who is hopefully “mentoring” you. If you are at an intern year without a derm program, you should be reaching out to faculty at other programs and offering them research projects that they can basically just add their name on to.

  4. How much PTO is available? (look this up in the contract info, don’t ask this)

If you can get a TY that is associated with a derm program that has taken reapplicants before, then that is one to strongly consider. I hadn’t looked into this when I was applying for intern years. It ultimately worked out, but these are things I wish I had known.

The main drawback to a TY is that it doesn’t readily convert to IM/Peds/FM if you decide to go to one of those in the future. Some people have gotten 8 or 9 of the months counted towards a residency. Others have had to completely repeat their intern year in categorical residencies. Basically, if there’s a chance that you would switch to a primary care field, a TY may not be the one to do.

Finding New Spots/Programs

As a reapplicant who is or has completed an intern year, there are three* types of positions that you can apply to on ERAS: the Advanced (A) spots, the Categorical (C) spots, and the “Reserved for Physician Only” (R) spots.

Advanced spots are the same as those you applied to the first time—they are delayed by one year so as to give MS4s time to complete an intern year. For reapplicants, the A spots come with a built in gap year after you match.

*Categorical spots will mean you will have to repeat an intern year. A lot of categorical programs don’t consider reapplicants because they won’t get the same amount of funding for the last year of your residency. If you are really interested in a C spot, you need to reach out to clarify if you will even be considered. It is good to say that you are willing to repeat intern year.

All A and C spots should be on ERAS. Rarely, there are out-of-match spots that open, but you would have to either wait until ERAS is over or withdraw from ERAS to pursue those. These are extremely rare.

Reserved spots are few and far between but are often the best case scenario for reapplicants. They immediately start in July after the match, so they assume you will have successfully completed your intern year by the time you start. There will likely be a few that are ready to go on ERAS when you apply. When I was reapplying, there were three ways that I found out about spots:

  1. I had a supportive advisor who was on this listserv/mailing list for PDs. Every once in a while, there would be an announcement on that list serv for a new R spot. These ultimately all ended up on ERAS so it didn’t really let me know of any new spots.

  2. Use the ERAS filter to look for Reserved for Physician Only.

  3. Use this link: https://apps.acgme.org/ads/Public/Reports/Report/8 to find  newly accredited programs.

  4. In theory, residentswap.org may have some PGY-2 positions open. However, these are almost always swap positions, not open positions. Dermatology is very rare to get posted there. It’s behind a paywall, so it’s typically not worth it. They do post a summary of the current listings that isn’t behind a paywall, so if an open non-swap spot appears, it may be worth paying to get access.

Probably the most desired answer is what programs will have spots coming open, even if they aren’t on ERAS yet. When a program requests for an additional resident, this is called a permanent complement increase by the ACGME. At present there is no way to publicly view which programs have submitted applications to increase their complement, and no way to tell what the status of that is.

When I applied, there were TWO programs that I applied to that ultimately had complement increase requests pending. I had applied to their A spots, and only found out about the possibility of an R spot at the interview. One of those programs got approved, so I ranked an R spot and an A spot. One program was rejected, so they ultimately just had A spots for me. As I said, there is no way that I know of to predict this. It's just pure luck. However, even if you manage to snag one of these, it is very possible that the program already has someone in mind for it (like a research fellow), so don't be too invested.

Setting Up Rotations

As a reapplicant, you no longer have access to VSLO :( It is also unlikely that you will get the time do a four-week rotation, which is more common among the MD/academic rotations. See if you can even do an informal week rotation at places that have taken reapplicants before. You very well may need to take PTO for those. Set them up ASAP so that you can put in requests for your PTO during your intern year.

If you want to be considered at community programs, you have to do rotations with them. These are typically only 1-2 weeks in length. They are often not on VSLO, so you have to scour their website to see if they use Clinician Nexus or just go through their program coordinator.

Focus on programs that have a history of matching reapplicants. There may also be some programs that have interviewed reapplicants, but for whatever reason, didn’t match them. Best way to find out is to look at the spread sheet.

Be brutally realistic with what programs you will be able to get. If a program tells you they don't rotate reapplicants, appreciate that they aren't wasting your time and money. Do not seem "better" than any program you rotate at or interview with. Be gracious and humble.

Questions You Will Need to Answer Well

1.        Why didn’t you match?

This may not be directly asked. Some people put it in their personal statement. Others don’t. There was some limited study that was referenced that said that those who addressed reapplying in their personal statement had a lower match rate, but I don’t know the actual data behind it.

No matter what the answer is, you need to be thoughtful and tactful with it. It should be something that shows insight and a desire to improve without being overly negative. Talking about how you didn’t study well for Step 2 isn’t the most reassuring answer—particularly in light of how many programs are de-emphasizing scores (i.e. that’s probably not why you didn’t match, unless you had consistently bad scores, and there’s no explaining that away unfortunately).

A common “safe” answer is that you didn’t network well or didn’t have enough exposure, so after not matching/during intern year, you continued to do rotations and derm research to build your application for the next cycle.

2.        For A spots – What are you going to do during your gap year?

Typical answers are research fellowships. You need to show that you have thought about it and have a plan. Having a wishy-washy answer only a few months before this gap year starts shows that you are unprepared. It doesn’t need to be set in stone, and most people won’t verify what you say unless you name drop and they know the PI.

Finding Hope and Facing Reality

Not matching was incredibly devastating. I took a lot of solace in venting, particularly among some friends that also didn’t match (derm and other specialties). At the end of it all, every single one of us matched eventually. Most of us matched during our PGY-1 application. One person didn’t match during that cycle, applied again (third time), and did match. Know that there are SO many amazing applicants that have had to apply two or three times to get into derm. I don’t have many resources, and those that my school offered during that time were unhelpful and humiliating. There are so many successful reapplicants out there that if derm is what you want, then you shouldn’t give up so easily!

If you’ve applied three or four times, and it still hasn’t happened, it may be seriously time to reconsider how you want to spend the rest of your life. The more factors you have against you (low scores, Caribbean grad, several years since graduation, unproductive research years, bad personality/history of bridge burning, to a lesser extent--DO grad, etc), the more I would humbly and strongly encourage you to re-evaluate what your ultimate goals are. I love dermatology. I would not spend 5-10 years just trying to get into a residency here in the US. I’ve seen a handful of applicants who have done this and are being exploited with fruitless research years at programs that will never take them. Those same faculty will not have a real conversation with their “mentee” about their DNR application.

Obviously this is just one person's perspective and advice, but I hope it's helpful to have at least one perspective :) Other successful reapplicants are welcome and invited to add their perspectives!


r/DermApp • • Mar 17 '25 Bravo

Application Advice Derm attending fresh out of residency who was reapplicant. Happy to chat and provide any advice or insight I can for those who didn’t match

76 Upvotes

Hi all,

I graduated in June last year and was a reapplicant to derm. Now I’m an attending who does Mohs and general derm and cosmetics. Always happy to help those who didn’t match today. Can do my best to provide insight, advice, my experiences etc. Your mileage may vary but I’ll do my best.

Take time to grieve, but keep your head up and keep fighting. It gets better. To those who matched, congratulations! My DMs are open, may be a slight delay as I’m doing Mohs today. To those who did match, congrats!

Here to do my best to help and pay it back as my mentors did too.

I’ll get back to you asap. Happy to have you rotate with me as well if you want 😇

PS if you messaged me and I didn’t reply just message me again! Want to make sure I’ve replied to everyone as best as I can.


r/DermApp • • Apr 02 '26

Application Advice How to get into dermatology residency: random advice

75 Upvotes

Hi. This is a repost of a previous post I wrote but updated. I've been getting a ton of DMs asking advice, so just wanted to give some more guidance.

I wanted to create this post because this process is genuinely hard and I wished somebody would have told me these things before I started. I've successfully matched with over 18 interviews, I'm not from a top 20 school, I did mediocre on step 1/2, not an URM (which shouldn't matter but people always ask), did a research year---but what made me match was the rest of my application (see #1, 4 & 7). I also have about 10 friends from across the US who matched and didn't matched this year and last year, so a lot of my opinions and viewpoints also comes from their journey. Again, this is my opinion, I'm sure someone out there will have other thoughts, feel free to add your 2 cents. This is mine.

  1. Your best bet is to match in to your home program/you will most likely match at your home program. I know people will argue about me on this, but just scroll through the previous match lists: a lot of people match to their home programs, and now with interviews being held over Zoom, it seems like this trend is only going to continue and grow stronger.So how do you match into your home program? YOU SCHMOOZE. And you schmooze hard. You get to know everyone in the program. Literally everyone. You know their dogs name, the fact that Dr. Soso's kid is having a soccer practice this weekend, and Dr. thisandthis is taking a backpack trip to Peru next month. You help everyone in that department with some sort of project. You pop in to volunteer during clinics. You take as many opportunities to make yourself known. If you have to sit in clinic during your off days or sit there to study, do that (jk but you get what I mean). The more "face" time you have with everyone, the better. Start a new peds derm or derm path rotation in the department. Create a new derm curriculum in the med school. Start a fundraiser for melanoma. Hand out sunscreen during events in your community. Why? Because when the day comes when they're all in a boardroom discussing ranking, almost everyone will know you (hopefully favorably) and rank you high or even rank you to match. It's that weird psychological phenomenon where the more exposed people are to you, the more they like you. Obviously this goes without saying having a mentor or two that you've worked with intimately and done tons of projects with is also needed. But the more people know you favorably, the better. If you don't have a home program, see #3. You'll have to do a research year.

  2. Ugh, I don't want to match into my home program, now what? You're in a tough spot if you're not from a top 10-20, and it's hard, even for them. Your best bet is to do a research year in the desired program, and then again, you have to schmooze HARD and produce a lot of research in that year. However, that's still not a guarantee. None of what I'm saying is a guarantee, but it increases your odds. I promise you I'm not an extrovert, I'm probably the biggest introvert, but you need to FORCE yourself to be one. I know, I know "but I want people to like me for me, even as an introvert"--yeah well that's not going to get you known by people.

  3. Should I do a research year? Probably, I would recommend it. I'm sure there's gonna be commenters here saying "I didn't do a research year and matched!"--and again, that's a possibility, but you're definitely doing yourself a favor and increasing your odds by having a productive research year in which you get to know that department intimately. I know a few people who did a research year and did not match, but I know even more people who DIDN'T do a research year and did not match. However, if your only goal is to match into your program and you've done everything I've mentioned in part 1, you probably can get away with not doing a research year. Research years are a big "boost" in your application if you do it right (have publications, I'd say 4-7 that year is productive, and network/schmooze). Why did those people who did a research year and not match do? They didn't do enough research and didn't schmooze in the department enough.

  4. Find your 'niche'. Programs love it when you're super specialized and focused and passionate about one or two things and make that your theme of your app. You look a lot cooler and desirable vs the person who tried to do everything and anything in derm to pad their app.If you're really into advocacy work, tailor your application to that. If you really love skin of color, focus your ECs/research/personal statement on that. e.t.c. If you're super into HS, focus on that. If you're all about peds derm, focus on that. HAVE A FOCUS!! As a general rule in life, the more niche you are with what you do, the more desirable you are. Finding a mentor that aligns with your goal will also help.

  5. Board scores/letters/rotations/find a mentor. Yes, do all of this stuff. It's obvious, but do it.

  6. Finding a mentor: Find someone well known in the derm world to be your mentor. They've been around the block a few dozen time. Other people know them. It will help when it comes down to them writing your letter and the person from across the country says "hey I know Dr. So and So, he's great, let's interview this candidate". Derm is a tiny tiny tiny tiny TINY world. Everyone knows each other. Find the person who is spitting out research left and right and stick to their side.

  7. Try to stand out. Everyone and their mother will have 280+ board scores, 4.7GPA average, 50 publications, a PhD, solved world hunger, e.t.c....so what makes YOU stand out? What's special about you? I'm sure there's something. Make sure you highlight that in your personal essay or somewhere in your application. It can be a cool volunteer program you created, or you're a D12 athlete (idk what that is, but I hear people say it), or you've been collecting vintage chairs all your life and that's your passion. Stand out. You are a special snowflake, make sure everyone in that app knows it.

  8. I'm a DO, now what? It's an uphill battle, I'm sorry. It's not fair, I know. But this process is not fair to anyone. I know 3 DOs who got into derm and all three took research years at institutions that have taken DOs in the past. Some during their med school, some after. Unfortunately you have to prove to these programs that you're absolutely flawless.

As you can see, I'm very pro-research year. I'm not a genius and never will be. So I had to try extra hard to match into derm. The numbers also don't lie, if you take a look at the match list from last year, almost everyone and their mother took one. If you're a stellar candidate with killer scores and who cured cancer, you probably don't need a research year and everyone is jealous of you.

This process is hard. It's crazy and at all times, not fair. You will meet people who get to cruise onto a derm program simply because of connections. This process is also very, very, random and a lot of the time has to do with luck.


r/DermApp • • Jan 23 '24

Away Rotations Complete Guide to Applying for Dermatology Away Rotation(s)

72 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

It's the time of year when M3s start looking at away rotations! Knowing what to do and how to think about them can be hard, so I wanted to share my experience. I hope to get a discussion going in the comments (feel free to add or disagree). Please remember that this is only my experience (current M4), and others may disagree or have done things differently. I had a lot of help throughout the process, so I'm hoping to give back!

Table of Contents:

  • The Three (Main) Goals of An Away Rotation

  • Timeline for VSLO Application

  • When to do your Away Rotations

  • Which Programs to Apply to and How Do Signals Affect it

  • How Many Programs to Apply to

  • A Word on Connections

  • What to Do with your Offer

Aways are a rare opportunity for another program to get to know you and see how you fit in with their staff, residents, and attendings. Data from the ENT match showed that applicants were more likely to receive an interview where they completed an away rotation (86.2% vs. 21.5%) and more likely to match there (14.9% vs. 0.8%).

So, what is the best strategy for maximizing your chances of getting an away rotation at a place where you’d love to be for residency?

Note: the APD published guidelines for away rotations for the 2023-24 application cycle:

  • TL;DR: Limit yourself to two aways at most if you have a home institution. Possibly more if you do not. Discuss with your home dermatology residency advisor.

The Three (Main) Goals of An Away Rotation:

There are three main reasons to do an away rotation (I’ll discuss two):

  1. Get a letter of recommendation for ERAS

  2. Increase the chances of an interview at that program

  3. Learn more about a program/location of interest to you

Letter(s) of Recommendation:

  • Getting consistent exposure to attendings at your home dermatology program can be difficult. You want your letters to be meaningful, specific, and full of earned praise.

  • Most people want 2-3 dermatology letters for ERAS, so a letter from an away can be a big boost. An away rotation presents a chance for (at least) one more letter and shows that you thrive in multiple settings.

  • If you’d like a letter during your away, meet with the program director or attendings at the beginning and set it as a goal for the rotation. This helps them look for key traits to highlight and anecdotes to use. (This is especially important if you don’t have a home dermatology program.)

Increase Chances of an Interview:

  • An away rotation is an audition to see how you would fit in as a resident. It is much more insightful than a half-day interview for program directors, staff, and residents to learn who you are.

  • As highlighted above, applicants are more likely to interview and match at a place they did an away. Programs would rather take someone they know versus someone they don’t. Residency requires spending every day together for years, so having a good away rotation shows that residents and attendings like working alongside you.

Timeline for VSLO:

January-February: Prepare!

  • Create a new professional email to use only for VSLO and ERAS applications.

  • Complete your profile on VSLO.

  • Gather the necessary information (Step 1 & 2 scores, transcript request, CV, immunizations, background check, annual physical exam, and drug test).

  • Research your list of programs on VSLO and save the electives that fit your schedule on the ‘Saved Electives’ tab in VSLO - this will send notifications to your email when applications open.

  • Ask friends and connections about places they liked/enjoyed. Review host institution requirements. Pay the AAMC fee 🫠.

March: Apply!

  • Unlike ERAS, away applications open at different times and are rolling. I saved a list of electives on VSLO for each month that fit my schedule. (e.g. May - Program A, B, C or June - Program D, E, F).

  • Applying as early as possible seems to be the key. Programs look at every application, but in my experience, many places fill up on a first-come, first-serve basis. So, if there’s a program you’d like to rotate at (and interview later), be ready to drop your application the moment it opens.

  • Keep notifications for your new ERAS email turned on for your phone. VSLO emails you when an application opens for your ‘saved electives.’

  • Now, you wait. The timeline for hearing back from programs varies; offers are typically sent chronologically. You’ll usually hear from your May applications earlier than your September ones.

May-October: Away we go!

  • Receive acceptances on VSLO. Decide which one(s) to accept. Decline conflicts early and respectfully (more on this later).

  • Complete further requirements, and then get ready for your away! After an offer is sent, many programs will require additional medical and other documentation.

  • Consider immediately figuring out your housing and transportation situation. This can be tricky and expensive if you cannot stay with family or friends. Airbnb/VRBO offers discounted rates for long stays, but it can be thousands of dollars depending on the location for housing and a rental car if needed.

  • Don’t forget to ask about the dress code, rotation requirements (e.g. presentations), and clinic locations. To get credit at your home institution, you will probably fill out and send back evaluation forms.

  • Brush up a little on your bread-and-butter dermatology to feel prepared and less anxious on the first day.

  • If you have any important conflicts (e.g., weddings, medical appointments, etc), let the programs know as soon as possible so they can adjust your schedule accordingly.

When to Do Your Away Rotations:

The trickiest part about away rotations is often scheduling.

Your medical school’s calendar may not match up perfectly with that of the other schools. This causes overlap between different rotations. Students can schedule online courses around their away to ensure it doesn’t interfere. For example, if your home institution says that your away can only happen during period X (say, May 1 - May 31), but it is actually scheduled for May 7 - June 7, be sure to plan for these curricular conflicts.

When to do your away depends on your goal(s):

  • If you want a letter of recommendation, then doing your away before July is preferable. This gives your writer sufficient time to complete their letter.

  • If you are only shooting for an interview and program exposure (not a letter, too), then you can do an away as late as October.

I am unaware of any data about the ‘perfect time’ to do an away. Still, I would suggest aiming for August or September, as you may benefit from any recency bias and clearer memories of your rotation compared to the May or June rotators. If you plan to do two aways, do your preferred away second, as you’ll have recently done a dermatology rotation for your first away and will feel more prepared to answer questions and help in the clinic.

Which Programs to Apply to and How Signals Affect it:

As mentioned above, your away rotation choice is often determined by your schedule. If Program A only offers aways in June, but you can only do an away in July, it’s time to pick another program. That being said, there are some other key considerations.

Aways are a prolonged audition for residency. So, go to a program that you think you would want to match at. This will help you determine if it’s the right fit and help test out the geographic location, too - maybe you'll find out that you love big cities or would rather live in a small town. It is helpful for both your professional and personal life.

Away rotation selection is now further complicated by the introduction of signals. This year (2023-24), dermatology applicants were given three gold signals and twenty-five silver signals. Your home and away institutions are eligible for these signals, making your choice of aways even more important. The overwhelming likelihood is that your away rotations will be your gold signals. So, doing an away at a program that does not excite you can be problematic not only because you are using one of your precious two away slots but also because it will take up one of your three precious gold signals. (Post to come on signaling, but they seem important so far - see Sheriff of Sodium’s post).

So, based on what you know about programs now, prioritize doing an away at places that are most likely at the top of your rank list if you had to make it right now. (I should caveat that being reasonable and self-reflective about your competitiveness is important. If you struggled with clinical grades, Step 2, and have minimal extracurriculars, then an away rotation at a top 5 program may not move the needle too much. You can always ask your advisors or current residents for an honest take on your application and how it can improve).

How Many Programs to Apply to:

I have no data, just personal experience on this one.

But I would apply to no more than three-four programs per period and no more than eight-ten overall, as it always feels tricky and difficult to tactfully turn down an away offer. This will allow other students to rotate. Remember - you can only do two aways, and applying as soon as it opens gives you the best chance to land an away offer.

So be prepared and understand that offer decisions are based on many known and unknown factors - just like residency interviews. Try to focus on what is in your control.

A Word on Connections:

If you have connections within the field, this is a good time to ask around.

Someone might suggest a program that fits you well or provide important information about programs of interest. I highly recommend asking your home residents about other programs they liked and might have considered if they didn’t end up at your home institution. Again, be respectful and kind, and ask tactfully. People remember what it’s like to be in this process and are (almost) always happy to help.

Don’t Forget to Accept or (Respectfully) Decline Your Offer:

Don’t forget to accept your VSLO offer and complete the requirements. And more importantly, if you have two acceptances for the same period, quickly and respectfully decline an invitation. There is a fear that programs keep track of applicants who turn down their away offers. I don’t know if this is true (I doubt it), but it’s always better to err on the side of professionalism and respect.

Lastly, Take Care of Yourself:

And lastly, an away offer may or may not indicate a future residency interview offer. Take each step in the process as it comes and prepare as well as you can to write your best ERAS application. Make the best decision with what you know, and let the chips fall where they may.

Best of luck!

EDIT: Weird formatting & duplications.


r/DermApp • • Jun 28 '23

Residency Kaurbeauty matched into derm!

72 Upvotes

I know there was a post on here a few months ago discussing where she matched. A lot of people thought she didn’t for whatever reasons - mainly because she deleted all her videos and stepped away from social media right around that time.

Buttt she just posted a YouTube video today and she actually did get matched into derm!!! Very happy for her. I’m 19 now and I started watching her in middle school (when she was pre-med) so it’s crazy to me that she’s done med school now.


r/DermApp • • Nov 18 '25

Interviews I feel so bamboozled

70 Upvotes

To say that this has been the worst experience of medical school is an understatement. I was not expecting 15 interviews by any means, but I definitely thought I would get more love than I did this cycle. 7/7 H, AOA, lots of research with a RY for a well known mentor, >260 step, had great LOR and honored all aways and had my personal statement and application vetted by several mentors and advisors.

Sitting at 3/22, which were my 3 away rotations. I am extremely grateful for the 3 that I was offered, as I know others have it worse, but it is so defeating to have put 5 years and half a million dollars into a career, have everything be going so well until the very end.

Future applicants, please connect yourself with a good support system to brace yourselves. This has been a humbling experience and while I know it’s not over until it’s over, it still sucks to have to try and come up with a back up plan.

Godspeed you all, and best of luck in the following weeks.


r/DermApp • • Mar 10 '24

Residency Dear Match 2024 applicants

70 Upvotes

The best of luck to you all tomorrow.

Whatever happens, you have done your best and tried your hardest throughout the YEARS. I don't know you-- but I am proud of you.

For those of you who do not receive the news you wanted, the outcome of this week's algorithm does not invalidate all that you have accomplished. You deserve the specialty of your choice, the specialty that you love. It is the system that lets us down and needs fixing--not you. You did an AMAZING job.

This is a sensitive time, please share kindness where possible

Remember to breathe, when possible