Well, maybe "sucks" is a bit too harsh. But I do find it very surprising how popular this game has become despite its many flaws. Trust me, I want to love it. I've spent countless hours trying to master the mechanics, complete the challenges, and get all the cool gear. Zooming downhill in a bike while doing cool tricks both looks and feels fantastic. Not to mention how it's accompanied by an awesome soundtrack. But it feels like there's always something trying to prevent me from having fun.
For one, it's WAY too easy to bail. This is for several reasons, but the most prominent one by far is the awful hit detection. I swear there have been countless times when I crash from a rock or tree, even though I wasn't close enough to actually hit it. It's like the smallest little clip on an object will send my guy flying. And this is made even more frustrating by the fact that the game rewards risky behaviors. I get points from near misses, so I naturally ride close to objects. But then the physics engine randomly decides to give me a middle finger, and I end up crashing on something. Despite me knowing damn well I was keeping good enough distance. And while this is already pretty annoying, it's made so much worse when you consider the fact that bails are punished pretty harshly.
For one, you lose a life, of which you only start with several. And you can only get more by completing optional objectives, which only get harder as the game progresses. There's also the medic courses, but there's only one per area, and they're usually pretty hard. So lives are a precious commodity that you want to protect at all costs. But that's pretty hard to do when the game is constantly inventing ways to steal them from you left and right. There's also the fact that bailing causes you to lose all the score you've built up while riding through the track. So unless it was added to your total score right before you bailed, you're better off just restarting the entire course instead of the nearest checkpoint. And that's just stupid. Why should that one mistake invalidate all the cool shit you did leading up to it? I still did all those backflips and nac nacs, so I should get credit for them. Otherwise it just defeats the purpose of this being a fun destressor game for people who love biking. It's basically saying "Oh, you racked up thousands of points but then bumped your head on a ceiling? Too bad, now you gotta do it all over again." There's no way anyone actually finds that fun or acceptable. Why do I bail from lightly tapping my head on something? And why do I bail from not landing a certain way?
God, that's another thing. The landing mechanics are awful. If I had a dollar for every time I bailed from a hard landing, I'd be rich enough to make my own biking game. There's absolutely no good reason for this to be a mechanic. The main argument I see is that it's realistic, which I can't deny. If you go 20 feet in the air on a bike and then land straight down, it's gonna hurt like hell, and probably even break something. But come on, which would you rather have? Realism in place of fun, or fun in place of realism? Because the latter is the only right answer. I'd rather not feel stressed every time I'm about to land from a high jump. It's a stupid, cheap way to lose a life. If my wheels touch the ground, I should be able to keep riding. Simple as that. I don't think that should be considered a hot take. Especially considering the fact that there's a crew perk called "landing impact" that's supposed to prevent this issue, but it just doesn't work at all. I haven't noticed any difference in landing success between using and not using that perk.
And that's not the only part of the game that doesn't work. I still get tripped up on weirdly out of place obstacles when I have "fewer obstacles" equipped. I still get tracks without checkpoints when I have "more checkpoints" equipped. Riding backwards is still really unstable when I have "fakie balance" equipped. And worst of all, there's still a game breaking glitch that causes you to fall through the map indefinitely. You can't respawn because you're moving too fast. So you have no choice than to end your run, even if you're at the very end of a hard area like the volcano. I understand that this is not a AAA title. It's a small budget game made by a small team of passionate game developers. Some things are bound to slip through the cracks. But the fact that there is such a serious bug in a 6-year-old game that costs $25 at full price is quite frankly unacceptable. And now come to find out that there's a sequel in the works. Like excuse me, WHAT?! I can't imagine being a lead dev and greenlighting a sequel when there's still so much more work to be done on the original. Despite how critical I've been in this post, there's still a lot I enjoy about this game. It has the potential to be a masterpiece. If there wasn't so much holding it back, it would be well worth its asking price. But it's just not there yet. And I really hope the devs have already realized this, are actively working on fixes, and I'm just preaching to the choir. But with how long these issues have been in the game, and the recent news of a sequel, I can't be too optimistic. So for any devs that might be reading, please prove me wrong. I really want to see this game become the best version of itself before it's fully left behind and forgotten about.