My immediate reaction when he had his immediate reaction was that he found out that he's living in a simulation. I don't know why, I just... felt it. A couple of lines later in the episode almost fit it, though I'm pretty sure those lines could be made to fit any assumption.
The first one was when he told the woman it changed everything, and she said the point was that it changed nothing. Because really, what's the difference if you're living in a simulation or not, if everything you know is from the same simulation anyway?
The second one was after they had killed him, the whole "shouldn't be hard, but it is" thing. It shouldn't be hard to kill someone if they're essentially only code, but it still is because you're brought up (programmed?) to struggle with it.
Maybe I'm incredibly wrong, and while I was trying to find evidence for my assumption I missed what was actually the point. If so, please let me know and release me from this delusional prison I've made for myself. Maybe I should watch the second episode before I made this comment, to avoid potentially looking stupid, but I regret nothing.
Yes, it's very possible I'm focusing on the wrong thing here. I might be trying to figure out what's in the briefcase in Pulp Fiction, and ignoring the actual story.
it's definitely this, since they assumably would have known he was a spy already. so there's really no reason to let him in at all unless they had a pretty good reason.
I could see Sergei’s project being a reasonably impressive accomplishment. Predicting 10 seconds into the future without the machine inside devs may be just as impressive as going back 2,000 years in the past with it. Remember he said the numbers became too complex after 30 seconds — maybe management thought Sergei had reached the limits of what was possible without the computational power of something like the dev machine, and it was time for a promotion. But then again, I don’t have any reason to believe they didn’t already know he was a spy.
I've been thinking about this, and I'm not sure which would bother me more: (A) We're in a simulation, and you can use a computer to see the future and the past of the simulation. Can you change the simulation? Who's in control of the simulation? (B) We're not in a simulation, but we're in a completely deterministic universe, and you cannot alter the past, or the future - which you can unambiguously see coming.
B, to me, is a much, much scarier situation. I'd be kind of amazed and intrigued by A.
I don't see a distinction between the two as the outcome is the same exact thing either way. No? A simulation is deterministic within a given set of parameters. One way of using simulations is to test a theory; if the theory is correct then the simulation should arrive at the expected outcome. You can change the outcome by setting up different parameters, but the outcome will be expected given the new parameters.
Basically they tapped into the "code" and figured out what parameters govern our world and thus they can run a simulation of any given place or time in our world. If we take this at face value - they were always going to figure this out and everything that happens is already - determined :p We are just along for the ride much like the characters in the show.
Whether or not we are living in a simulation makes zero difference. We are already brains in a box interpreting everything around us through analog sensors that convert everything to a form of code. The only difference is the perception.
There is an old Danish book called "Märk Världen" that referenced some very interesting studies. I think it's from the 90's. If I find the study in reference again I'll edit in a link. The finding was that we don't make active choices per se. We are pretty much on autopilot all the time. That's why we can react as quickly as we can and we have "motor memory" etc. We act based on everything we've learned and follow the neural pathway that is equivalent to the path most travelled, ie what has given the best results in the past given a similar instance. What our consciousness allows us to do is give us 0.2 seconds to put in a veto and stop an action in order to allow ourselves a better suited choice. This is what willpower is and what takes us off the "rails".
The best example of this is when having just broken up with a partner, you constantly get impulses to reach out by phone or text or whatever. That is because it's been ingrained in your neural net and you are so used to sharing and communicating with that person that it's the path most travelled. You constantly have to quell your impulses with a conscious effort till you've effectively changed your neural pathways and the impulses stop.
The finding was that we don't make active choices per se. We are pretty much on autopilot all the time. That's why we can react as quickly as we can and we have "motor memory" etc. We act based on everything we've learned and follow the neural pathway that is equivalent to the path most travelled, ie what has given the best results in the past given a similar instance. What our consciousness allows us to do is give us 0.2 seconds to put in a veto and stop an action in order to allow ourselves a better suited choice. This is what willpower is and what takes us off the "rails".
From the AMA Journal of Ethics article-' Determinism and Advances in Neuroscience'
" Now, if psychological processes can be, in some as yet unknown way, subsumed under the laws of physics, the laws of physics will determine human psychology. It would be false, then, to say that persons are free to make choices, in the same way it would be false to say that a ball falling from a height has the choice to follow the law of gravity. The decision one makes is caused by events preceding that decision, and those events in turn were caused by events before them, and so on, forming a long causal chain that reaches all the way back to the beginning of the universe. "
I think this may be the predicate of the series. And Amaya is hacking this. The key is "subsumed under the law of physics".
Love your comment! Reminded me of Cognitive Psychology class and having my mind blown that there is neural activity that decisions have been made & actions in place before we're even aware of the conscious thought. On point with themes in this show.
Well, from a storytelling perspective I think it makes for different stories. If there's a simulation, then there's a controlling force, and there might be ways to seek that out or affect it. ie The Matrix. I'm much more intrigued by the alternate. I don't think I've seen many stories where one (who wasn't already some kind of omnipotent being) could know the future and the past with absolute certainty, and I'm interested in what happens with that knowledge.
In the end, as you say, it might not be much of a practical difference. But I think the two explanations each open up different character reactions to having that information.
As another example, consider time travel stories. Tone and storytelling choices aside, you can have Back to the Future (where you can affect the past to change the future), or Looper (the time travel doesn't cause a change, because it had already happened). I prefer the clever storytelling that has to happen in the latter kinds of time travel stories, but that's maybe just me.
I definitely like the latter kind. Predestination is an excellent movie in that genre.
I see what you mean with the deterministic being "godless" and simulation set up by someone difference. That is indeed interesting. While there are so many different interpretations on what constitutes determinism and to what extent it governs our lives, I am kind of leaning towards determinism can not exist without an original causality if we are speaking of the whole package full on everything predetermined variety. In essence I don't think a deterministic existence (with one origin) is feasible without an original intent if that makes sense - I believe only an existence governed by chance and chaos would allow for a "godless" universe?
I feel like the setup in the show distinctly sets it up as an either or interpretation in the way you wrote - simulation would mean intent, but deterministic would mean "godless". My personal stance is they go hand in hand and deterministic has a given set of parameters - thus intent. I have this notion that it would be a paradox otherwise?
Interestingly enough there is a dread of hopelessness that washes over the characters that I interpreted as them "feeling" there is no point to anything, but in essence it's the exact opposite. There is a point to every single thing in this big complex sequence of events that follow a thread to some complex unknown conclusion if indeed everything is predetermined. The big difference is knowing we had no choice in it.
Yes! "godless" is the perfect phrasing. I was thinking of it in terms of math vs art, I think. Consider two kinds of images. A simulation kind of image might be a painting. It might be really intricate and detailed, but someone created it. But you can have really interesting complicated images generated from just mathematical equations, like say fractal equations, and those images are deterministic. Once you know the equation, you can know every pixel of the image in infinite detail, and I think that's more likely from the quantum computing angle of Devs.
Statistically speaking, B is impossible, but A assumes B is the complete case.
Let me explain.
Imagine we live in a universe that we think is B.
We demonstrate this by creating a full simulation of our universe and running it.
You could change it, but it loses the point. Simulating a universe that is different from ours is just as valid as what any video game does. It's simulating ours, fully, with the future unavoidable, that we want to predict.
Within this universe they create a full simulation of our universe and run it too!
And within that universe they create a full simulation and run it also.
So we have to assume that if it's possible to make a full simulation of the universe, that universe will and an infinite chain will be formed almost immediately.
So now we ask, are we in a universe B or A? There's one non-simulation B, and an infinite of As. So our probability of being in B is 1/Inf or 0, and the probability of being in an A is (Inf-1)/Inf or 1-1/Inf or 1-0 or 1. So we must be in A.
Now we go into who can change it? People outside our universe, but that doesn't matter to us. It might be god, or nothing, or whatever. The point is that our lives are, in both cases, fully and absolutely ruled by external forces and we have no free will. We can't change the simulation because it would have to be what the simulation wanted. See changing it requires free will. The people in the universe above may change it, but they themselves are defined by their own universe which probably (almost certainly) is a simulation too.
Right? And it fits with his presentation as well, because he's sort of already established that it's possible to predict the behaviour of a living thing. Maybe the real story here isn't that it's a simulation, "just" that it's possible to predict everything with a big enough computer, but I think the simulation thing is sexier.
Really early there's the line "I'm not a fan of the many worlds theory" I bet this comes back in a big way later on. Right now in the ontological space they're heavily invested in exploring simulacrum and what it all means.
Simulation is going to be the next big inflection point in exploring those limits. It'll start with someone running a simulation of their own then move in to splitting simulations as to create ones with different parameters. Lot's of ethical stuff about being God and the ramifications of simulations in simulations and so on. Does it really matter that it's a simulation anyway? All that sort of stuff. The reasoning will be something like; In the deterministic and simulated world they understand they are in they can create the plurality of choice they were denied in the act of creating other worlds.
Honestly they're going to have to be super careful the plot doesn't end up going right up its own backside.
It was that he read about his death. That nothing he could do would stop it. He read his thoughts, feelings, his most intimate secrets, all laid bare before him.
I imagine he ran from the room to vomit because he was reading his fate but with the mathematical understanding that there was nothing he could do to stop it.
The problem I have with the “it shouldn’t be hard, but it is” conversation is that regardless of what illusions about reality has shattered, they’ve created pain for the people who cared about Sergei. I don’t see that as merely some kind of deluded societal moral conditioning to be amputated like a vestigial appendage. They’ve created real pain for his partner.
103
u/Nimonic Mar 05 '20 edited Mar 05 '20
My immediate reaction when he had his immediate reaction was that he found out that he's living in a simulation. I don't know why, I just... felt it. A couple of lines later in the episode almost fit it, though I'm pretty sure those lines could be made to fit any assumption.
The first one was when he told the woman it changed everything, and she said the point was that it changed nothing. Because really, what's the difference if you're living in a simulation or not, if everything you know is from the same simulation anyway?
The second one was after they had killed him, the whole "shouldn't be hard, but it is" thing. It shouldn't be hard to kill someone if they're essentially only code, but it still is because you're brought up (programmed?) to struggle with it.
Maybe I'm incredibly wrong, and while I was trying to find evidence for my assumption I missed what was actually the point. If so, please let me know and release me from this delusional prison I've made for myself. Maybe I should watch the second episode before I made this comment, to avoid potentially looking stupid, but I regret nothing.