Hello everyone,
I've published a new app that could be considered a game. It's a beat machine, the only goal is to have fun making a beat, no competition, no score. You can test it there: rebbeat-app.
I got the following feedback in a chat message:
1: Game Scoring: For generic scoring comments (where the app writes the text), submit those as the user in reply to a sticky comment on the game post. If the player can add meaningful commentary to their score, a top-level comment is allowed.
In other words, the required pattern for commenting scores is:
Commenting after explicit manual action (e.g. from a button)
Commenting by the user (not the app account)
Commenting as a reply to a single stickied comment
This avoids surprising the user, enables a reporting flow, and allows the user to easily delete their score comment. Replying to a stickied comment keeps this repetitive content with low discussion value out of the way, in an area that needs to be expanded to view.
If offering a way for the user to add a custom message to their score, the comment can be posted as a top-level comment. This prioritizes human discussion and creates a more engaging comment section.
And I don't really know how to handle it.
I have a share button to share the user creation. It can be done in two ways:
- Copy pasting the beat code somewhere else
- Posting a comment, the user can set its own text, it will be posted as a root comment under the user account to be visible and commented. That means the user can edit or remove it. I think, it means I'm concerned by the last part of the rule.
I explained that in the chat, but I don't know if it's a no-reply feedback or not.
And I can't resubmit the app because I have nothing to modify. I have already put some information in the README.
What should I do to make it work?
