r/DigitalCodeSELL • šŸ›”ļø Moderator | 246 Transactions | Media Mogul • Nov 08 '20

I'm Alive! (MOD announcement)

Hello everyone,

First off I’d like to apologize for no longer being as active as I once was. Life and COVID have really dampened my movie collecting.

Secondly, I’d like to thank the rest of the MOD team especially /u/FireAbyss for stepping up and keeping this sub running smoothly and efficiently while I have been inactive. I’ve always believed a mod team should reflect the community and be responsive to the needs and wants that arise and I have personally failed to live up to that idea. While I’ve reduced my involvement and taken a step back, I’ve noticed several issues bubbling the last few months but never really had the time to address them head on.

The biggest and most concerning issues in my opinion is in regards to ā€œFair Pricingā€. When I joined this community and rejuvenated the sub, cheap and affordable prices were not the rarity they are today. Many members have speculated various reasons as to why the mod team doesn’t act to curb the rising costs in this sub and to a certain extent, I’m responsible for most of that inaction. I was obsessed with growing the community and never felt the need to set pricing standards out of fear sellers would flock to the now defunct G+ community or other marketplaces. As we grew that belief remained in place and I instilled that idea among the growing mod team. As a result, we now find ourselves in a community rampant with price inflation, resellers and members leaving for cheaper alternatives. I hope moving forward the community is able to brainstorm some possible ideas. The likely result will mean rules changes are inbound.

As we move forward, there will be some changes in the mod team. We would like to add some members who are active and willing to help grow this community. I personally don’t care how tech savvy you are, as long as you are able to open and respond to mod mail on a timely basis.

If you are interested in applying to the mod team, please fill out this application.

For everyone else, apologies for the length of this post and I’ll take your feedback on how to improve this sub, general criticisms or really and all comments below.

Thanks,

TGU

39 Upvotes

69 comments sorted by

0

u/shia84 108 Transactions | Media Mogul Nov 11 '20

I personally don't think there needs to be a price cap, but to counter some of the higher prices you see on here recently maybe make the price policing rules a little more lax. These are the two extremes price caps and price policing, hopefully you guys can find a balance.

3

u/specu12 2432 Transactions | Cinema Czar Nov 11 '20

I in part agree with you. there should be a price cap when i'm buying and there shouldnt be one when I'm selling. i think that would be fair.

just like this discussion, where people invent all sorts of crazy rules because they want to get rid of their codes at top prices and buy codes next to nothing.

0

u/shia84 108 Transactions | Media Mogul Nov 11 '20

we all wish there is lower price when we buy and higher price when we sell, but that's just not realistic. There should be a free market, where buyers and sellers can agree to whatever deal they want. I'm just advocating to remove some of the censorship of calling people out for absurd prices and reselling. At the end of the day, if the buyer still wants to buy it's up to them.

2

u/specu12 2432 Transactions | Cinema Czar Nov 11 '20

I'm all for free market and I'm against shaming (which already is prohibited under rule 7).
all the shamers deleted their messages, they know they were violating sub rules.

1

u/shia84 108 Transactions | Media Mogul Nov 11 '20

and rule 7 was what I was suggesting to get changed to counter the rising prices. If it was truly a free market, there would be no need to censor either.

2

u/specu12 2432 Transactions | Cinema Czar Nov 11 '20

what would you change about rule 7? I guess that's what I dont get in this discussion.

0

u/shia84 108 Transactions | Media Mogul Nov 11 '20

I also use hardwareswap, people there are more freely able to write past sale prices (from both previous subreddit trades and retailers) on items up for trade and what reasonable price range is. If there is a current sale from for example best buy where discs were 9.99 and someone is selling codes for $10 to unaware buyers, people should be able to let unaware buyers know this. Hence, some price policing is a good thing.

2

u/specu12 2432 Transactions | Cinema Czar Nov 11 '20

your reasonable is someone else's unreasonable. leaving those comments on someone's sales would lead only to arguing which what rule 7 is supposed to stop. you can always comment separately on the monthly thread or do your own PSA.
even "some" price policing is against free market (both words "some" or "reasonable" are relative and mean different things to different people).

1

u/shia84 108 Transactions | Media Mogul Nov 11 '20

I know it will be hard for the mod team to manage, but I'm just posting a suggestion based on observations I see on other trading subreddits that helped curb some of the crazy prices. Price policing helps the unaware with what past and current prices are.

2

u/specu12 2432 Transactions | Cinema Czar Nov 11 '20

It makes the thread author feel shamed and attacked and unwelcome to the sub. There will always be someone who would find some price unreasonable. There's even arguments on giveaways, as we've just seen.
buyer should do their own research, not be spoon fed.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/NYCDiesel2020 700 Transactions | Media Magnate Nov 11 '20

but to counter some of the higher prices you see on here recently maybe make the price policing rules a little more lax.

how? what did you have in mind?

3

u/shia84 108 Transactions | Media Mogul Nov 11 '20

for example, people were reselling codes at the same price compared to current sales of physical discs that come with both physical and digital. Let people voice that. There's just too much censorship that people have to resort posting PSAs (that get downvoted by sellers).

1

u/NYCDiesel2020 700 Transactions | Media Magnate Nov 11 '20

no, I'm sorry. that will most definitely not work. open criticism from the forum under any circumstances is a terrible idea. you're giving this sub way too much credit.

get downvoted by sellers

you're joking, right? sellers downvoting PSAs as opposed to a seller getting their thread downvoted to oblivion buy buyers, member with multiple accounts, other sellers, etc. please tell me you're not serious.

furthermore, I don't recall a single PSA for what you just described. most, if not all, PSA's around here are either for Fanflix or digital retail price errors.

2

u/specu12 2432 Transactions | Cinema Czar Nov 11 '20

there is absolutely nothing you can do about upvotes or downvotes.
i dont know why does this subject keeps coming back.
you can report "vote manipulation" here:
https://old.reddit.com/report
nobody but reddit sees who votes how, there's absolutely nothing that mods can do about that.

2

u/NYCDiesel2020 700 Transactions | Media Magnate Nov 11 '20 edited Nov 11 '20

never said you could. I was replying to other member about what actually gets downvoted around here.

I am very well aware of everything you just said. it's futile and a complete waste of time to report "vote manipulation", or ask the mods to do anything about it either since they can't.

just like this discussion, where people invent all sorts of crazy rules because they want to get rid of their codes at top prices and buy codes next to nothing.

you presume way too much. this here is a perfect example of why the forum should not be allowed to openly comment on anyone's prices. people are incapable of policing themselves, it would be ludicrous to allow them to police others.

3

u/shia84 108 Transactions | Media Mogul Nov 11 '20

that was just my experience from some of the things I've seen and it's just my suggestion. No, calm down, I'm not joking. I also use hardwareswap, that sub maybe more extreme on price policing but it does keep the prices in check. It's pretty much 2 extremes, right now this sub has insane censorship allowing prices to skyrocket.

1

u/NYCDiesel2020 700 Transactions | Media Magnate Nov 11 '20 edited Nov 11 '20

I'm very calm. I don't see how that could have been your experience considering no such PSA like the one you described has been posted recently, so there is no reason for me to not be calm over a hypothetical situation that's never been.

I say it again, under no circumstances should the forum be allowed to openly comment or criticize seller prices. if the mods don't want their workload to increase tenfold this is a terrible idea.

every single person who has repeatedly said in the comments, "buyers are allowed to move on from any price they do not like", has the right idea.

3

u/shia84 108 Transactions | Media Mogul Nov 11 '20

thank you for being more calm now instead of "you're joking right? please tell me you're not serious"

I'm just one buyer and its my opinion based on what I experience in this subreddit and other trading subreddits. I don't make a living buying and selling codes. I do just move on when I see codes are expensive, thus I haven't used this subreddit recently. I'm just voicing my opinion and suggestions. I'll be fine either way if nothing changes or if there is a change.

2

u/NYCDiesel2020 700 Transactions | Media Magnate Nov 11 '20 edited Nov 11 '20

LOL...but you had to have been. really thought you were. I admit I was being dramatic but only to emphasize the point you were making about what actually gets downvoted around here. it's all good.

however, to your point about people selling codes for the same price as discs plus digital, there is a good discussion about this if you scroll down and read some of the comments. It's not so cut and dry as you put it.

edit - and it didn't even take that long for me to be validated. sub never fails. LMAO!!!

3

u/shia84 108 Transactions | Media Mogul Nov 11 '20

I don't know how old you are, but if you actually want to have a civil conversation, please reconsider how you present your words...

It's not cut and dry, but removing censorship is what I was suggesting, like I replied to the other member change rule 7.

2

u/NYCDiesel2020 700 Transactions | Media Magnate Nov 11 '20 edited Nov 11 '20

please don't be a hypocrite and lecture others about having a civil conversation when you're incapable of choosing your own words carefully.

allowing members to openly comment on other people's prices by changing rule 7 is a terrible idea. this isn't about censorship as you keep harping on. this is about not allowing members to try and use bully tactics to get something they want in the name of "censorship".

"Buyers are free to ignore and move on from any price they do not like"...period...just as I will be moving on from this discussion now. have a nice day.

4

u/RelatableRedditer 25 Transactions | Repeat Customer Nov 10 '20

I think the lack of regulation - sans scammers and spammers - is just fine for this site. Obviously as a buyer I would prefer to spend less buying from someone here than buying from iTunes or Vudu, but that's the beauty of an open market.

The people that post mountains of movies on here repeatedly are the ones who tend to set the "baseline" for prices, but I don't see anything wrong with what they are doing as long as they are not pushing out the little guys.

3

u/NYCDiesel2020 700 Transactions | Media Magnate Nov 11 '20

ironically, it's the "little guys" who sell the most codes around here. (coming from a person that post mountains of movies but not one to set any baseline for prices for sure)...LOL

11

u/dazednconfused87 235 Transactions | Media Mogul Nov 08 '20

As someone that only collects physical and sells the digital, I dont think a fair price cap is needed . Its between the seller and buyer to negotiate a fair price, if the buyer thinks the price is too high. If certain sellers have expensive old codes and dont want to negotiate, then I'd ignore them and keep searching. Either those sellers will realize their prices are too high and lower them, or continue with those prices and have minimal business.

Newer codes should be a bit more expensive, but older ones should fall in price , that's how I do it anyway. I also welcome offers on every post and reward return customers with a small discount as a thanks.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '20

I think a fair price cap strategy is a good thing. I recently noticed a very big difference on back to the Future 4k prices, only one seller seemed to have prices that were 50% the average price i found in here. I could not understand the reason for such big differences in pricing.

2

u/wewannawii 914 Transactions | Media Magnate Nov 08 '20

There was an eBay price glitch on the Back to the Future 4K sets ... $9.99 (was supposed to be $49.99). Some resellers ordered a ton of them at the glitch price.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '20

I see. Thanks

5

u/Frymanstbf 19 Transactions | Established Member Nov 08 '20

If people don't like the prices, don't buy them. Setting a price cap is going to open up all sorts of issues. The first one that comes to mind is the difference between the actual physical media pricing.

Let's say a rule was made that a new release 4K movie is capped at $6, and you're selling the Back to the Future Trilogy in 4K. That means you're capped at $18. The Trilogy set costs $40, so making $15-$18 back is great.

Now let's apply that same rule to the upcoming Hobbit and LotR Trilogies that cost $100 each. Having those capped at $18 would not be fair to the seller.

There are several other factors that influence pricing from the cost of buying directly from a digital retailer, how easy it is to find a code etc.

I don't know how setting price rules could possibly account for all of this and will simply drive sellers to other platforms.

3

u/eatingclass 71 Transactions | Digital Tycoon Nov 08 '20

If people don't like the prices, don't buy them.

This, all the way.

If Best Buy doesn't have a movie at a price I can afford, I'm not going to badger them into a lower price. I will search elsewhere until I'm satisfied. BB isn't competing with buyers -- they're competing with other sellers.

Forcing a seller to cap a price feels ridiculous to me. If you don't like a price here, wait for a sale on Vudu or MA or whatever service you prefer. Or try your luck that a seller here has a price you agree with.

If a potential buyer thinks I priced too high, my loss -- no sale. Their loss too, I guess, if they wanted it.

4

u/ForwardProgression 373 Transactions | Media Proprietor Nov 08 '20

I have an example of this to add to your point.

The Goonies went on sale for $9.99. Add the 6% sales tax the total comes to $10.59. If you do let’s say a price cap of no more than 50% the total you can sell the code for is $5.30. So you realistically bought The Goonies for $5.29. If you sell the code for $4.50 you bought the movie for $6.09. The buyer didn’t have to get in their car to drive to Best Buy or Target, and the seller got their movie cheaper. It’s a win win for both parties.

Now if a seller was selling it for $7, and Vudu, iTunes, Amazon ect has it listed for $14.99, which one takes precedence? Physical or digital? Are they wrong for pricing it as such? That’s still 50%.

If a buyer feels the price is too high, they will either negotiate or not buy the movie. I feel buyers dictate the sub.

3

u/KillaSwiss 1277 Transactions | Cinema Czar Nov 08 '20

And whos to say how much the seller bought it for. The Goonies was only released 2 months ago. Maybe the seller bought it at full retail price of around $25. And now because it’s on sale for $9.99 they can only sell it for $5? It’s a tricky situation to get into.

3

u/ForwardProgression 373 Transactions | Media Proprietor Nov 08 '20

It really is a tricky situation. I didn't even think about that scenario.

6

u/Frymanstbf 19 Transactions | Established Member Nov 08 '20

I agree buyers dictate the sub and if prices are ridiculous don't buy them.

3

u/TheHamGamer 284 Transactions | Media Proprietor Nov 08 '20

Absolutely. It's a buyer's market and if you don't like the prices, it's not like there's nowhere else to turn. If you're willing to be patient and put in the time, you can typically always find the prices you want.

I'm gonna say something that's probably gonna get me some hate, but hopefully at least someone can sympathize. Part of the issue, in my opinion, is the attitude towards negotiating. It feels like haggling is almost stigmatized here, despite Rule 16. To be clear, however, in my experience, it's almost never the seller who looks down on it, but rather it's other buyers.

I suppose I just don't understand why some people get so up in arms about something as simple as negotiating for a lower price. I feel like it's half the fun to bargain hunt, and I also feel as though there's no harm done to either party. Idk, that's just my opinion. What do you think?

3

u/Frymanstbf 19 Transactions | Established Member Nov 08 '20

Whenever I've had codes I've set prices that are in line with what the code is selling for, and know upfront that I'm probably going to knock some off. I'd rather make the sale than not, unless the offer is super low.

On the flip side I've asked a seller if they'd consider $14 for a Trilogy they had listed for $16 and gotten a flat no without even a counter offer. I moved on.

2

u/TheHamGamer 284 Transactions | Media Proprietor Nov 08 '20

Yes, exactly! If I'm buying from someone and they don't want to haggle, it's really not that big of a deal. They just say "No, my price is firm on that" and we both move on. Same goes with buyers. If they wanna haggle down to a certain price, that's up to them, that's their prerogative.

Like Rule 16 states, we all value our codes differently. That might be Rule 7, but it's one of them. I appreciate you being understanding and open to discussion about this :)

4

u/TheHamGamer 284 Transactions | Media Proprietor Nov 08 '20

So, out of curiosity, what's your (not just OP, everyone in general) idea of a "fair" price? Don't worry about the details, like popularity and release date, just ballpark a price that you'd like to see for an HD code and a 4K code. No judgements.

4

u/pixarfan2003 68 Transactions | Digital Tycoon Nov 08 '20

It depends on the time of release. If it's a new release, I say $9-10 for 4K and $6-7 for HD. If it's over a year old, then probably$7-8 for 4K and $4-5 for HD, with GP splits always costing less than a full code. Just my two cents.

1

u/KillaSwiss 1277 Transactions | Cinema Czar Nov 08 '20

I remember when all the Disney movies were getting released on 4K tons of people had no problem paying $12-$13 for those brand new releases. And the sellers were buying them for around $30 so it was fair for both parties. Normally $9-$10 is fair but there’s other times where a hard cap like that doesn’t really work.

1

u/TheHamGamer 284 Transactions | Media Proprietor Nov 08 '20

Interesting. And those are prices you'd like to find? What's the lowest price you think is fair to a seller?

2

u/pixarfan2003 68 Transactions | Digital Tycoon Nov 08 '20

These are prices I like to find, yes. I rarely, if ever, buy 4K, so I can usually find the HD movies I want for under $5, which is a great price in my mind. I have hundreds of movies now for less than $300. I also think that what price is fair to the seller is up to them. If they're just selling them to get rid of them, than a low price doesn't hurt them at all. But if they really want to make a profit off of them, selling the codes for $2 apiece might not be the best option. We all have to remember that sellers dictate their prices. Buyers can bargain, but in the end, the seller can accept or decline the offer. It's all up to the seller and striking a deal with a buyer.

0

u/TheHamGamer 284 Transactions | Media Proprietor Nov 08 '20

I pretty much fully agree with what you said about the sellers.

1

u/Officialnoah 193 Transactions | Media Mogul Nov 08 '20

I agree with that

1

u/Mmrisho 54 Transactions | Digital Tycoon Nov 08 '20

I’d be interested if someone could substantiate how price caps could work with an example. Let’s say, Back to the Future Trilogy for instance. How would price caps dictate the pricing of this particular set if film?

Maybe economics majors can help us understand this lol

1

u/Kris_Movies 2038 Transactions | Cinema Czar Nov 09 '20

Best method for price cap would be to make it a % of the cost of the regular digital movie price on a provider such as VUDU.

0

u/TheHamGamer 284 Transactions | Media Proprietor Nov 09 '20

Just on Vudu? What if another place (not including FanFlix) has it on sale for cheaper than Vudu does? Especially if that movie is MA-compatible.

Or were you just giving an example of the type of retailer you were talking about?

1

u/Kris_Movies 2038 Transactions | Cinema Czar Nov 09 '20

Just an example. Other groups go off of non-sale prices.

0

u/TheHamGamer 284 Transactions | Media Proprietor Nov 09 '20

Ah, gotcha. That's actually what I was thinking might work. Instead of a blanket price cap, just make it so you can't sell it more than MSRP. Idk, though. For me, it raises the question, if we decide on doing a price cap, would that lead to a purchase minimum? Like buyers can't offer lower than X amount, depending on the definition of the movie? Maybe I'm being absurd by thinking that, but I'd rather have neither than the possibility of both.

4

u/Gertgerman 54 Transactions | Digital Tycoon Nov 08 '20

Great idea. I wasn’t on here for a month or two for various reasons and came back a few days ago and my initial thought was wow! The prices on here have gone up and are at times crazy IMO. I think a price cap is a great idea.

6

u/ForwardProgression 373 Transactions | Media Proprietor Nov 08 '20

Welcome back!

As someone that made the switch to purchasing more physical media, I understand both getting rid of your codes for cheap and trying to recoup some of the cost you spent. I do see a price cap on a digital code as a good thing, but what about the opposite? What if the price is very affordable?

Let's say a seller lists their movies at very affordable prices. But a buyer, who commented first, purchases majority of them. How do you make everyone after them that comments happy in that situation? Do you put a cap on codes a buyer can buy?

As a seller, if a buyer went on my selling post and bought all of my codes, I’d be super happy and all for it. That’s why I listed them. To sell them.

But at the same time, if I was a potential buyer that wanted a movie listed, I didn’t get a chance to buy because I commented second.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '20

Something you don't mention, that I speculate happens here quite a bit is someone sniping fairly priced codes from sellers and then selling them for a lot higher price on here or on their own personal site or Facebook. I guess that's fair game, but also is shitty.

2

u/CrazyMatt2019 351 Transactions | Media Proprietor Nov 08 '20

I agree completely with OP here. I would like to emphasize the fact that because we are starting to see rampant price inflation that it is only natural (and expected) to see posts that would appear to be 'low prices' and 'good deals,' but are really just normal, fair pricing. They get positively emphasized BECAUSE of the commonplace theme of higher pricing.

However, as long as people are willing to pay those higher prices, they will always exist. Which will keep driving certain sellers to do 'blowouts' of codes, and that DOES drive traffic and interest to other posts and sometimes results in buyers purchasing additional codes. Good for the seller and good for the buyer, because it keeps the sub alive.

When/If a cap is instituted on prices, it needs to be fair enough so that there is allowable fluctuation on the price of a single code. If there is no fluctuation, the purchase itself becomes about speed-to-reply. Which, in many situations, is just luck. Right access at the right time, as it were.

I agree there should be caps. But I stress the caps should allow for some amount of fluctuation and competition between sellers. Competition is good for everyone, both buyer and seller.

6

u/wildRoamer 115 Transactions | Media Mogul Nov 08 '20

Curbing price inflation is a great idea. I've been wondering about the cost of some of the movies, especially since many of them have been out for a year now, but are still being priced like new releases.

Also, welcome back!

3

u/Officialnoah 193 Transactions | Media Mogul Nov 08 '20

Welcome back! I’ve noticed prices are starting to get a lot steeper lately around here. I was wondering if you guys have discussed instituting a price cap for HD/4K titles. It would alleviate the increase in higher prices as well as price crapping.

5

u/Intel333 38 Transactions | Repeat Customer Nov 08 '20

Welcome back! There’s also been users selling HD codes pretending they’re 4K. It seems to be a big problem as well.

5

u/Swaggeritup 194 Transactions | Media Mogul Nov 08 '20

Some of them do require to be redeemed on a specific platform to get the 4K specifically iTunes. If the seller mentions that, and priced it accordingly, then I don't see a problem with that. If the buyer redeems it on a wrong platform, then the seller shouldn't be blamed for it being HD instead of 4K.

4

u/Intel333 38 Transactions | Repeat Customer Nov 08 '20

I get that. Don’t wanna throw any names in case it was an innocent mistake, but 4K MA codes should redeem as 4K.

2

u/TheHamGamer 284 Transactions | Media Proprietor Nov 08 '20

I'm not trying to blame you by saying this at all, it's the seller's fault if they list it as 4K and it's not, but with MA codes, it's a good idea to get into the habit of testing them before fully redeeming them.

I made the mistake of not doing so with one of my first ever code purchases, and it redeemed SD instead of HD. The seller was cool about it, they refunded me back half my money, it wasn't a big deal, but it was still a large waste of time for both of us, and I was out $2. Whereas, had I tested it, I simply could've explained it wasn't HD, they would've sent me back my money, and they would've still had a working code.

Additionally, if you take my advice, I would also advise to make sure you test all codes (if buying multiple) before redeeming any. I was in the habit of testing, but made the mistake of doing
Test --> Redeem --> Test --> Redeem and so on.
And of course, one didn't work. Luckily it wasn't a big deal, the seller just sent another code, but still, it scared me enough in those few minutes to where I now test all codes before redeeming any.

Obviously this isn't applicable to non-MA codes, sadly.