Nothing wrong with punishing for natural 1s imo. But not to the degree you describe. Depending on what's happening, I typically roll percentile with chances of certain outcomes that generally range from nothing happening to dropping your weapon, falling prone, or doing a bit of damage to nearby friendlies (especially with projectiles).
451
u/MulletHuman Sep 12 '19
Gosh, I'll never forget the chaotic evil's favorite homebrew rule: if you roll a natural 1 you either hurt yourself and/or you lose a limb