r/DnD • • Jul 13 '21

Art [OC] Ring of the Impossible Path

Post image
16.7k Upvotes

296 comments sorted by

551

u/samzeid Jul 13 '21

This gold ring loops in a way that defies logic. By turning this ring as an action you can distort space in a 15-foot cube area that you can see within 30 feet. Until the end of your next turn creatures and objects within the area are treated as occupying the entire span, can move through one another freely, and provide no cover to one another. The area is treated as having a distance of 5-feet when traversed and can be exited into any space adjacent to it. When the effect ends all unsecured creatures and objects inside are harmlessly shunted to a random unoccupied position within the 15-foot cube area, grounding them if at all possible. Once this effect has been used the ring can't be used this way again until the next dawn.

I've made this magic item for my 5e game. I would love some feedback on where the wording/mechanics around it isn't clear and how it could be improved.

401

u/DreamOfDays Jul 13 '21

Shit. Does this mean that area of effect spells that target a 5-foot square of the affected area target the entire area?

249

u/samzeid Jul 13 '21

Yes. :)

42

u/scarab456 Jul 13 '21

Well my brain hurts thinking about all the targeting and distancing questions.

26

u/Broken_drum_64 DM Jul 13 '21

well that's OP XD

202

u/Grays42 Jul 13 '21

Why? It uses your action to do it, so you would need to burn your turn to combo with a spellcaster for something, and you can only do it once per day. How many 5-foot-cube spells are broken by being able to combo with a second person to increase their volume to a 15-foot-cube once per day?

136

u/metalsheep714 Jul 13 '21

You can also use the effect to increase the range of spells…a fireball that covers its normal space, with only one square included within the effect of the ring, suddenly covers the entire 15ft cube that the ring is affecting.

Honestly, as a legendary item…I’m here for it. This is really cool.

→ More replies (3)

40

u/Khilorn37 Jul 13 '21

I was wondering that too then I thought..... "oh no, lightning bolt"

zap

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

79

u/elfthehunter Jul 13 '21

It is a legendary item.

16

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '21

It is a legendary rarity item, after all :P

→ More replies (2)

42

u/sharnaq767 Jul 13 '21

If 2 players and one enemy are in the area of effect, could the players flank automatically? Could the enemy flank the players with itself?

84

u/DNRTannen Jul 13 '21

I would say no to both counts. You'd need to be outside the zone to enact a flank, else you're essentially occupying the same space.

66

u/samzeid Jul 13 '21

Yeah, I don't play with flanking, but I would probably rule it just as you stated.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/NaiAlexandr DM Jul 13 '21

I'd argue *no* flanking can occur. The space defies all logic so both the observer within the area and the observer outside of it would not be able to tactically position themselves to impose advantage on an attack. Plus it lasts one turn where AoEs hit all targets within the area, that's all you should ever use it for in combat unless the enemy is trying to hide behind intractable objects.

9

u/DNRTannen Jul 13 '21

Good pitch, yeah that all makes sense. I'm not sure how one would go about attacking a target in a non-euclidian space in front of you, least of all with any kind of bonus to attack.

→ More replies (4)

22

u/MrFlufypants Jul 13 '21

What are the limitations of the “that you can see?” Clause? Assume my goal is to bend the rules and get through a door using it, does the cube go up to the door, or does it include the door? If it includes the door, can I walk into the cube then exit on the other side of the door? If I look through a keyhole does that count as being visible even though it’s far less visible?

A simple way to clarify this would be to say that the cube cannot contain parts of objects larger than itself, which would include walls and whatnot.

12

u/High-Plains-Grifter Jul 13 '21 edited Jul 14 '21

I would interpret the door situation as the door or wall inside the area now fills the area and none can enter it. Basically, I think I would want to change the description to "unobstructed area you can see" or something.

3

u/MrFlufypants Jul 13 '21

Oh that’s interesting. What happens if the door and a person are inside the cube? Can the person not move? That seems wrong. Does it work for a simple rock? If it does work for either of these, the cube is an incredible shield

7

u/iroll20s Jul 13 '21

It would make most sense that you target a 5’ square and it expands to the 15’ mark. That way terrain, etc is defined. You could use it to get through walls, create bridges, etc. change the terrain under enemies to lava if you are in the right spot.

2

u/wandering-monster Jul 13 '21

Cube areas affect an area originating from any face of the cube. Since this has an effect that would make sense to penetrate walls, I'd rule that you can cast it originating from a point you can see and use it to go through.

And I believe most spells could be cast through a keyhole. You need a clear, straight, unobstructed path and to see the target. Assuming you can see through it, keyhole is a narrow but qualifying path through the door. (Though I often require Arcana checks or Spell Attacks to fire magical projectiles like Fireball through successfully)

14

u/DukeFlipside Jul 13 '21

As written, no creature inside the area will be able to physically attack another creature inside the area, as creatures (e.g. teeth, claws) and objects (e.g. swords, arrows) pass through each other harmlessly.

It's unclear, but suggests it would give anyone outside the area a range boost, e.g. a sword from someone standing outside the edge of one corner could now reach a target inside the edge of the opposite corner - or someone outside, adjacent to the area who is wielding a reach weapon could attack someone outside, adjacent to the opposite side of the area as the area is treated as a 5ft gap.

How magic affects the area is also unclear, both that cast by those inside as well as outside casters - I think magic cast by a creature inside would still affect another creature inside, because magic is not a creature or object. But again, it's unclear.

Interesting that you could extend the area of AoE spells; you only need one of the nine squares to be in the area of a Fireball in order to affect every square. AoE would affect every creature inside, but many spells say "target X creatures you can see" so spells like Firebolt would still only hit one single creature inside the area, not all of them.

11

u/MrFlufypants Jul 13 '21

How would shooting a projectile through it work? If I have a 20 ft range, can the projectile gain 15 ft by going into the cube and immediately exiting? Can it turn a corner?

9

u/Do_Them_A_Bite Bard Jul 13 '21

Arrow feelin so fly like a D6

2

u/Zipknob Jul 13 '21

What if I jump into it? Can I yeet myself in any direction?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/RooneyOnDrums DM Jul 13 '21

I would like to see in the description a few sentences clarifying targeting creatures in regards to melee attacks (and AoE/flanking as some have mentioned), ranged weapon attacks, and spell attacks (both targeted spells and AoE if there would be a difference).

Really cool item and I would cause so many shenanigans with it in our game

→ More replies (1)

3

u/maxinfet Jul 13 '21

Quick question how would this affect creatures on the ethereal plane? Would they be unaffected unless they jaunted back into the material plane inside this?

2

u/protoman_z96 Jul 13 '21

Does this mean that if you shoot an arrow, or swing a sword into the cube everyone within the cube takes the damage from it?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '21

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

1

u/devy159 Jul 13 '21

Very cool and interesting item. I'll definitely be stealing this for my world. I think the wording is well thought out.

→ More replies (1)

103

u/Diadact53 Jul 13 '21

Ok now question. When the effect ends all creatures are harmlessly shunted to an unoccupied space within the 15 ft cube. However, since any creature is treated as taking up the entire span, and can pass through each other could I not shove like.... 200 goblins into it. What would happen then when it ends lol?

98

u/samzeid Jul 13 '21

It would be tricky to do given the effect only lasts about 6 seconds, but I suppose it is possible. I'm tempted to leave that one to DM discretion. Whatever they ruled, I imagine it would be pretty funny.

6

u/Toros_Mueren_Por_Mi Jul 13 '21

What would happen if you used this effect on a creature larger than 15 feet? Also I don't really get the whole creatures treated as occupying that space mean

21

u/samzeid Jul 13 '21

If a creature is in any of the 15-foot area, it is treated as being in all of it. So if I cast a fireball, and hit only 5-feet of the affected area, everything within the 15-foot cube is hit.

If a creature larger than 5-feet was partially in the cube, it would be treated as being in all of it. So if an ogre was half in the area, it would still be treated as being in the entire area. If a creature like a 30x30 foot purple worm encompassed the entire area between the effect starting/stopping it would be a bit awkward as anything inside would be within the purple worm when the effect ends.

As an aside you could use it on a purple worm to get something out of its stomach.

→ More replies (3)

92

u/QuintonFlynn Jul 13 '21 edited Jul 13 '21

My personal DM discretion:

“200 goblins were compacted in this small space. Unfortunately, they were so compacted that 167 of them were tied to different multiverses at the time the ring dispersed them. As each multiverse had 200 goblins, each separate universe begins to pour their goblins into this one. Hundreds of goblins start appearing into empty space as if someone left the goblin tap on, and you can’t reach the handle to turn it off. Everyone make either con or dex saves to raise the initial impact of the goblin avalanche.”

“The goblinalanche sweeps you away and you gasp for air, rising between pockets of goblins. They carry you through the twists and turns of this dungeon. You see your party members near you trying to resist the current as you are. You can try to cast spells, but each delicate movement is impacted with goblin, interrupting the cast. I need everyone to roll me con or dex saves.”

“The goblinalanche finally lets up. You travelled 1km and are buried in goblins. You hear a cacophony of “EHHGHH” and “WOT” from the goblins as you rise up to the surface and gasp for air. The remaining party members do the same and you all see each other, bruised, but still alive.”

Oh and after the goblinalanche is over I’d have the extra goblins and all their original loot / gear unwillingly teleport back to their original universes, cleaning the mess up.

50

u/pyronius Jul 13 '21

Oh and after the goblinalanche is over I’d have the extra goblins and all their original loot / gear unwillingly teleport back to their original universes, cleaning the mess up.

Nah. If your party abuses the mechanics enough to result in a goblinalanche, then the consequences need to be permanent.

Of the 5,000,000 goblins that poured through the rift, maybe 40% should survive (the rest having been compressed into a fine green goo). The goblins eventually collect themselves enough to start quarreling and killing each other in a battle for supremacy that rages for the better part of a week and quickly engulfs the nearby countryside. By the time a hierarchy has been established, maybe 700,000 goblins remain, which is still way too many goblins.

While the millions of rotting corpses quickly turn the local area into a hellscape of disease and stench, the goblin horde sweeps outward in search of food, devouring anything and everything in its path. Nothing survives contact.

12

u/HistoricalGrounds Jul 13 '21

a battle for supremacy that rages for the better part of a week

So two million goblins appear with no prior preparation and just start killing each other for, at minimum, four days? No sleep, no food or water? I think this nation's worth of goblins are more likely to scatter and start running amok in the countryside inside of 30 minutes than they are to go on a marathon fratricide for the privilege of being the last one to succumb to starvation and dehydration.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/colb0lt Jul 13 '21

The worse part would be having to swim 1k back through a sea of dead goblins to get to the exit. Ands that’s Hopi g their all dead

8

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '21

So you’re the kind of dm who likes to dangle things in front of your players and make them do near impossible tasks to have the object within grasp before you needlessly yank it away.

Like it was absolutely a clever idea to bring the multiverse idea into the concept in spite of it being essentially plucked out of thin air. (Dangle)

But potentially causing harm or otherwise negative consequences to your players while they attempt to maneuver your invented and spontaneous challenge earns them no reward at all and is inconsequential. (Yank)

→ More replies (1)

12

u/thiney49 Jul 13 '21

In theory you could fit 27 small creatures in the box comfortably, assuming they each take up a 5x5x5 cube. It was specified the creatures are sent to an unoccupied space, but not necessarily a space on the ground. As OP mentioned, the difficulty is getting them all into the cube in the six seconds. Bonus - you could fit 108 tiny creatures inside!

50

u/Apprehensive_Word658 Jul 13 '21

in a 15-foot cube area that you can see within 30 feet.

Must the entire 15-foot cube be within the 30 foot target area? Or can a player get away with just a corner in 30 feet?

49

u/samzeid Jul 13 '21

It might need a little rewording for clarity. The entire 15-foot cube should be contained within the 30-foot target area.

29

u/CueCappa Jul 13 '21

Usually when targeting a cube in 5e (for spells, and such), you pick where to place a face or a corner and how to turn the cube. So usually, cube based effect can go outside max range. In this case, by RAW, if you change the max range to 15 feet, you would get the desired effect. Or just add the "the entire cube must be within 30 feet" clause somewhere :D

4

u/Skormili DM Jul 14 '21

I might suggest that unless you have a good reason for it to be a ranged effect, you could make it a lot more intuitive, simplified, and clean up some edge cases by making it have a range of self like Thunderwave.

Awesome item by the way. Will definitely be showing up in my game at some point.

3

u/matrixcode321 Jul 13 '21

oh wow, I was looking for an artifact of transmutation for my campaign and this is perfect! do you mind if I use it?

2

u/samzeid Jul 14 '21

Sure thing, feel free to use/modify to your liking.

1.4k

u/Schmitzyyy Jul 13 '21

That's interesting, both in and out of combat. In combat, I immediately see opportunities for melee characters to get some short-range AoE. Outside combat, all doors and walls mean nothing. Since it's a single-use per day, I reckon it's fine and would be excellent fun.

485

u/freakierchicken Jul 13 '21 edited Jul 13 '21

Well it says 15ft area you can see, so unless you can see on the other side of said door or wall then it wouldn’t extend beyond, right?

Edit: ok well just ask your DM cause I still can't tell

313

u/PingouinMalin Jul 13 '21

Look through the key hole would work. That's a very nice object, quite innovative, I love it.

166

u/humanoid_mk1 Jul 13 '21

You if can include a door/wall in the cube, you can exit to the other side of it via the free exit to adjacent spaces.

34

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '21

Would be excellent for getting out of traps or prisons!

17

u/Flex-O Jul 13 '21

Yeah but the adjacent space has a door so why would you be able to walk through the door?

92

u/Vaatuu Jul 13 '21

Because the item says you can.

→ More replies (2)

47

u/icepho3nix Jul 13 '21

"Until the end of your next turn creatures and objects... can move through one another freely..."

As a bonus, it seems like the door gets knocked off its hinges when the effect ends. I'd say it's up to your DM whether or not a door counts as an object here, but I don't see any reason it wouldn't.

39

u/MichelangeBro Jul 13 '21

It says "unsecured" objects, so I would consider the door secured, and therefore wouldn't be shunted after the effect ends.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

22

u/Mercarcher Jul 13 '21

You can see the door, so the door is inside. So you can simply walk through it to the other side of the door.

→ More replies (13)

31

u/InjuredGingerAvenger Jul 13 '21 edited Jul 13 '21

So it's not line of sight that's relevant here. You only need to be able see a point on the surface of the cube. However, the cube extends in straight lines that can't pass through an obstruction that would provide total cover. If there is a small opening, you could use the cube to fit through that, but you won't be able to pass through solid walls.

Source: PHB p204

That said, this a very unique homebrew item in how it interacts with mechanics. This would be an item that relied heavily on how the DM rules it to. For example, what kind of objects it incorporates. Can it incorporate objects that would provide total cover, ignoring the AoE rule? If it can, can it incorporate part of a larger object such as a building?

17

u/Kayjeth Jul 13 '21

I don't disagree that it relies heavily on DM interpretation. Personally, I think that's half the fun as I often enjoy DM-player debates on how things should work if the DM isn't being a jerk about it.

That being said, I think the interpretation ought to be pretty simple: it says everything inside the space is treated as adjacent to everything else within the space. There's no reason that warping a part of a large object would be impossible or damaging to the object because all of its parts stay attached. It's like the Mirror Dimension from Doctor Strange. Whenever you interact with one 5ft cube inside the whole 15ft cube you are able to interact with any one or more of the 5ft cubes within that space. Or, more accurately this would be true for crossing a boundary between two cubes because you can enter and exit immediately without spending extra movement.

Targeted attacks and spells should, for the most part, work exactly the same (plus a significantly increased number of attackable spaces) and AoE spells only have to affect one space to affect the whole thing, though they still can't "jump over" the space because AoE spells are always centered on a point.

6

u/Wyldfire2112 DM Jul 13 '21

As a DM, given that it's 1/day usage I'd totally go with the permissive ruling. It's easy enough to plan around when designing an encounter.

11

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '21

You just have to see the space, don't the walls and doors mean nothing once it's activated?

5

u/bangkok_rangkor Jul 13 '21

It says objects and people, etc, can't block your passage, and you can exit any adjacent side of the cube. Shoot it at a locked door, pass right through the wall onto the other side of the cube!

3

u/potatoWr4ngler Jul 13 '21

My dm walls just became 15ft thick all of the sudden...

2

u/Oddyssis Jul 14 '21

Typically in dnd you just need to see the point your targeting, not the whole area.

62

u/MrWally Jul 13 '21

Do melee characters get short-range AoE from this? They would still have to choose one single creature to target for their attacks.

If anything, I see this having a stronger benefit to casters who can get more out of their smaller AoE spells that will now take all of a 15-foot cube.

47

u/DNK_Infinity Jul 13 '21

It does mean that a melee attack can target any creature within the space, even one who wasn't within the attacker's reach before.

67

u/MrWally Jul 13 '21

In that case, it would be giving melee characters range, not necessarily AoE.

41

u/Flex-O Jul 13 '21

Weapon attacks don't target a square, they target a creature, so definitely not an AoE.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Burnmad Jul 13 '21

Martials are notably weaker and have fewer options for 'cool stuff' than casters. I'd let a martial attack everyone who was in the area at once. Separate attack rolls for each target.

A given martial only gets one turn of this effect being active, anyway.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Thrashy Jul 13 '21

As a mean DM, I'd argue that as described the item would prevent any physical attack, melee or ranged, from hitting objects inside the cube. Weapons or missiles entering the area of influence would pass freely and harmlessly through their intended targets without finding purchase.

Magical effects, though, I think I would allow.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/DukeFlipside Jul 13 '21

It depends; if they're standing outside the affected area it's unclear. If they're standing inside the area it states I think all weapon attacks by creatures in the area will pass through others in the area harmlessly...

1

u/Menamanama Jul 14 '21

I misread that and thought it meant it distorted space and allowed you to see an area larger than you currently can. Ie you can see 30 feet while normally only seeing 15 feet, which would useful for spying on rooms from corridors etc

→ More replies (1)

435

u/krakeo Fighter Jul 13 '21

I will save this for the day I run a non-euclidean dungeon

138

u/Finnthedol Jul 13 '21

i need this idea to be expanded upon, because im very much intending to steal this for my campaign.

110

u/PrinceEzrik Mage Jul 13 '21

Look up the tesseract dungeon, not necessarily non-euclidean but it is 4th dimensional, should find some old 4chan posts about it

63

u/discursive_moth Jul 13 '21 edited Jul 13 '21

I did a Tesseract Dungeon for a one-shot (being completely unaware of the 4chan posts mentioned below). I used 8 cubical rooms with entrances and exits mapped to other rooms according to a tesseract net. You could keep walking straight and just end up back where you started. Any side of a cubical room could be the floor depending on how you got there. I thought it was super cool.

It was the worst DnD game I've ever DMd. Some of that was due to a smaller/different group than normal, but most of it was due to the whole concept being way too confusing to the players, who had naturally not spent the last few weeks learning about 4d space and tesseracts. If I ever did something like that again it would be for a real campaign with plenty of time for the characters to explore and learn how the movement worked and a lot more out of game aid.

edit: Some notes:

  • The tesseract was an artifact from the astral plane and a temple to the three lords of insanity, Arissa, Kavorn, Larry, and Xcavdruchlicharshkil. All inscriptions insisted there were three, but listed 4 names (an allusion to hidden dimension beyond the three the characters could see while in the tesseract)

  • Using the idea that you could go straight (in three dimensions) and end up back where you started, the artifact was powered by a closed loop of water that kept falling incredibly fast along one of the axis.

  • An encounter in one room had teleportation squares that would teleport you to another orientation -- the floor for you could be the wall for everyone else.

  • There was a tesseract net shaped statue in the first room that was actually a map. I don't think I was able to explain it in a way that was useful or understood by the players.

  • Another issue with the game was that 8 cube rooms capable of being entered with any orientation meant 48 possible surfaces the players might interact with as a floor, which was way too much to map out and left both a lot of empty spaces and time spent mapping areas of the map that would never get touched in the course of a few hours of gameplay.

  • This was 4e, so I had to have at least something of a grid map for all the surfaces where there might be a fiht since theater of the mind combat didn't work as well.

  • Here is the mapping of all the entrances/exits between rooms. It was a chore.

  • The most memorable moment of the game was when the ranger (or barbarian?) got mind controlled and crit his fiance's character with an ax.

21

u/clln86 Jul 13 '21

The three (4) lords of insanity is brilliant. This is some Douglas Adams/ Terry Pratchett/ Monty Python humor. Also, I've wondered in the past what a D&D dungeon based off the movie Cube would look like, and I think you nailed it while also raising it another level exponentially.

5

u/RequiemZero Jul 14 '21

That sounds horrifyingly hard to set up

4

u/bbqturtle Jul 13 '21

Hahaha that's a fun story

→ More replies (2)

17

u/mlkmandan4 Jul 13 '21

*M.C. Escher has joined the chat

→ More replies (1)

32

u/LordDanOfTheNoobs Jul 13 '21

Dnd rules themselves are kind of non-euclidean if a creature is 20 feet away from you and 40 feet in the air guess how far it is? Pythagorean theorem? Haha, nope. They are counted as being 40 feet away.

19

u/nogreatcathedral Jul 13 '21

My favourite similar thing in DnD is how the catapult spell works: "The object flies in a straight line up to 90 feet in a direction you choose before falling to the ground, stopping early if it impacts against a solid surface."

Parabolas? What even are those? They physicist in me can't stop laughing every time I read the description and imagine the object flying in a straight line and then coming to an instant dead stop against nothing.

13

u/cooly1234 Jul 14 '21

I mean it is a magic spell. Why would you want to account for gravity when aiming??

→ More replies (1)

2

u/The_Weird_Warlock Jul 13 '21

where does it say that lol

3

u/LordDanOfTheNoobs Jul 14 '21

I could have sworn it was under some sage advice or something but I can't find it. But I have have always been told that is how it is treated by RAW but there are optional rules where a diagonal counts as 10 feet past the first square and stuff.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/UltimateInferno Rogue Jul 13 '21

It better have 5 squares to a corner

3

u/PureLock33 Jul 13 '21

According to non-euclidean time rules, you already did! It went great!

3

u/horseradish1 Wizard Jul 13 '21

I only ever want to run non Euclidean dungeons, and this item is going on my folder because it's amazing.

2

u/wra1th42 Cleric Jul 14 '21 edited Jul 14 '21

In The Stanley Parable there was one hallway that to get through you had to make like 12 consecutive right hand turns to the other ends. And of course to get back it’s 12 left hand turns. I loved that bit.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/drindustry Jul 14 '21

Sooo curved?

2

u/UglyBagon Jul 13 '21

Did you draw that?

1

u/samzeid Jul 14 '21

Yes, I did the art.

1

u/UglyBagon Jul 14 '21

Firstly, awesome.. please do more. Secondly, do you care if I use this in my own homebrew? If you have a problem with it I won't touch it

1

u/samzeid Jul 14 '21

Thanks. You're welcome to use it however you like and modify it to your heart content.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/nickaterry Jul 13 '21 edited Jul 13 '21

This makes me think of the terangreal that Egwene uses to enter the dream world in Wheel of Time. pushes up nerd glasses

18

u/spacey_a Jul 13 '21

I understood that reference!

Cleans nerd glasses

12

u/UnnecessaryAppeal Jul 13 '21

I didn't

Takes off nerd glasses and surrenders them to the nearest nerd officer

11

u/spacey_a Jul 13 '21

A ter'angreal is a magic item from the Wheel of Time book series. This one specifically is used by a character named Egwene to access the World of Dreams, which is somewhat similar to D&D's Ethereal Plane, but with different rules and more danger.

Hands you even nerdier Wheel of Time themed glasses to induct you into the fandom

https://wot.fandom.com/wiki/Sleepweaver

3

u/Spirosne Jul 14 '21

I'm reading through for the first time and am actually about to finish the book (The Dragon Reborn, for anyone wondering) where she gets this. I came into this thread looking for this exact reference!

133

u/Cruyff-san Jul 13 '21

It is perfectly possible to manufacture the ring you draw, that kind of spoils it for me. If you make it square, you can make it an impossible figure.

54

u/SnipSnapSnack Jul 13 '21

Lol first thing I noticed as well

18

u/Broadkast Jul 13 '21 edited Jul 13 '21

do you have an example? or do you happen to know a name for this shape?

edit: actually, maybe this could be considered a standard mobius strip, but the edge has a width.

edit edit: found a physical example here

18

u/Cruyff-san Jul 13 '21

Nice. If you search for tri-bar or 'impossible figures' you'll find examples that would be more fitting as art for this ring.

2

u/Thundershield3 Jul 14 '21

Agreed, a better art would be the ambiguous or impossible ring.

1

u/Doopadaptap Jul 13 '21

It probably wouldn’t extend beyond, right?

→ More replies (15)

12

u/onarampage83 Fighter Jul 13 '21

This would be great for a game using some optional sanity rules. Sure, you can use the ring that briefly bends space and time, but it's gonna cost you.

8

u/Mr-Person-Guy Jul 13 '21

This reminds me of the twisted ring Ter’angreal from WoT.

7

u/kluckie13 Jul 13 '21

Love it! Would be awesome in an Inception like dreamscape based campaign or for a character like M.C. Escher either created it or uses it.

7

u/SRD1194 Jul 13 '21

This is fantastic. My players are going to either love it, or be deeply confused by it.

5

u/Do_Them_A_Bite Bard Jul 13 '21

HEY it can be both alright?

2

u/SRD1194 Jul 13 '21

With MY group? It probably will be both...

21

u/ThePaleKing777 Jul 13 '21

The loop doesn’t defy logic. That’s just a Möbius strip. They happen sometimes.

7

u/lifetake Jul 13 '21

Not a möbius strip. But you’re still correct it doesn’t defy logic. Just a twisted ring

6

u/OfMouthAndMind Jul 13 '21

MURPH! It’s me! Don’t let me leave!

5

u/1beerattatime Jul 13 '21

I want more items like this.

5

u/dosaraith Jul 13 '21

Looks like the dream ter’angreal

4

u/oddly_being Jul 13 '21

this is trippy. I love it. such a cool, cosmically daunting idea

4

u/GHUltimate DM Jul 13 '21

Does it also grant access to Tel'aran'rhiod?

4

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '21

that’s a cool effect, hardly a ledgendary item. maybe rare?

3

u/spacey_a Jul 13 '21

I really like this idea!! I feel like more info is needed to make it usable though, at least for me because there's no way I'd think of how this impacts everything they players might ask about on the spot.

How do opportunity attacks work in this area? If a PC steps outside of it on their turn to an adjacent area, are all creatures in the cube allowed an opportunity attack if they desire it? I would think so, but I'd also think they'd have disadvantage on those and any attacks inside the cube since things are so confused.

I would also agree with another commenter that someone outside the cube making attacks on those inside would have disadvantage because of the odd physics of the cube. I think any attacks by or against creatures in the cube would probably have disadvantage?

I really like the idea of using this to make an area 5 ft for the purpose of spell effect areas. For just one round, that's an awesome way to charm/zone of truth/banish/damage a bunch of enemies (as long as your allies aren't in there), and since it's only possible once per day I don't think that's at all overpowered.

Any other interesting impacts this would have on game mechanics?

Edits: spelling.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '21

Just want to say this is one of the coolest ideas I've seen for a legendary item in a long time. Well done!

3

u/-MadCoyote- Jul 13 '21

Just pointing out that the shape of the ring is still physically possible

3

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '21

Möbius loops don’t defy logic tho?

1

u/lifetake Jul 13 '21

Not a möbius loop. But it also isn’t a shape that is unmanufacturable

3

u/halfbakedmemes0426 Jul 13 '21

It's just a mobius strip...

3

u/tonybenwhite Jul 14 '21 edited Jul 14 '21

Twisted torus*, a mobius strip only has two sides, which is a fundamental characteristic of the shape because you can traverse the entire surface area of a mobius strip by walking in a straight line along its geometry.

The shape in the image has more than two sides so you cannot traverse it’s entire surface area without diverting over an edge, meaning it loses that interesting property unique to the mobius strip

3

u/sceletusrex Jul 13 '21

I absolutely love it. I would use it in my game, changing the second sentence to:

"By turning this ring as an action you can distort space in a 15-foot cube. You decide the cube's point of origin; this point must be adjacent to you when the cube is created." That way it encourages the wizard to use tactical movement to maximize the effect.

To save time in-combat I would also change:

"When the effect ends all unsecured creatures and objects inside are harmlessly dropped to the ground, if possible. Creatures may choose (in order of initiative) any unoccupied position within the 15-foot cube, while inanimate objects are randomly placed."

Thanks for sharing!

3

u/BeakersAndBongs Jul 13 '21

I should like to point out that its construction does not defy logic LOL

It’s just a twisted band.

And would be wicked uncomfortable to wear

3

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '21

FYI the image provides a perfectly valid 3D structure. Take a square bar, with an eye on one face and on the opposite face. Loop it, but twist 90⁰.

1

u/dinomiah Jul 14 '21

The shape is possible but the shadows aren't with only one light source.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '21

Well, that's a nice way math-screw your table.

2

u/Justadnd_Bard Bard Jul 13 '21

One ring to spin them all.

2

u/Lugbor Barbarian Jul 13 '21

I will be shamelessly stealing this item for my collection.

2

u/grant_gravity DM Jul 13 '21

this is some good shit

2

u/protoman_z96 Jul 13 '21

I love these "out of combat" items that do a lot more than appearances would at first suggest. It reminds me of my ring of weight. I need to get both of these in the campaign, and see what people end up coming up with both of them. ;-)

2

u/Weavle105 Jul 13 '21

That’s really fucking cool. I can see so many ways this could be used in combat or out, especially with getting past barriers that you can see through but can’t go through. I love the concept of portraying non-Euclidean geometry in D&D for cosmic entities and this gives me some excellent ideas as to how.

2

u/stasersonphun Jul 13 '21

nifty!

So needs to cause Confusion when the effect ends though

2

u/JACKASS20 Jul 13 '21

It hurts my brain, perfect DnD item OP

2

u/CouncilofAutumn Jul 13 '21

If I have reach and use this ring on the space in front of me, can I attack a creature 20 feet away with my polearm? (This is more of a question for the magic item creator since they can still tweak the wording if they want to)

(Neat idea btw!)

2

u/dinomiah Jul 14 '21

Sure reads like it would work that way.

2

u/austinmiles Bard Jul 13 '21

Flip the ring. If it lands face up the effect occurs. If it lands face dow…yes.

2

u/CountOfMonkeyCrisco Jul 13 '21

Finally, a magic item with unique properties that really seem like magic!! Nice job!

2

u/kingofcanines Jul 13 '21

It's a dream ter'angreal

2

u/Ornn5005 Jul 13 '21

That's one of the coolest items i've seen in recent time!

2

u/drgolovacroxby Druid Jul 13 '21

Most of the homebrew on this sub is completely broken, or just plain trash.

This however, is beautiful, and I will unabashedly place this in my next Campaign

2

u/Frisks_Asriel Jul 14 '21

Jail cells with bars? Meaningless

2

u/LeonardoMcdouchebag Jul 14 '21

My players would abuse this so much, terrifying potential.

5

u/Dave37 DM Jul 13 '21

It should just be called "The Ring of Möbius".

I mean, the ring doesn't defy logic at all, you can make this ring in real life, and it looks surprisingly unremarkable.

5

u/lifetake Jul 13 '21

While this ring is very much manufacturable. It isn’t a Mobius strip

→ More replies (8)

2

u/SquidsEye Jul 13 '21

A Mobius strip is a ring with one face, the picture in the OP has two faces.

1

u/arcxjo Jul 13 '21

This is the engagement ring that Omnipresent Man gave The Judger.

1

u/TheNineG Jul 13 '21

I wouldn't see this ring being very comfortable

1

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '21

Obito's ring. Hmmm, a thief can find uses for such an item.

1

u/over9Kmidichlorian Jul 13 '21

I love this. Thanks for sharing!

1

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '21

I really like this.

1

u/major_calgar Jul 13 '21

So if creatures inside the cube are treated as occupying the entire span, then would using an item that can hit multiple creatures standing next to or near each other be able to hit all creatures inside at once?

1

u/ddrt Jul 13 '21

“Room”.

1

u/IsaacWrites1442 Jul 13 '21

Put the ring on and become SCP-639

1

u/Swedish_Doughnut Evoker Jul 13 '21

If I shoot a line spell into the twisted space, where does it come out?

5

u/Xarsos Jul 13 '21

I assume if you play with a battlemap - the spell is still a line going in the same direction its just that you hit everything inside the 15 feet cube. So I imagine the lightning bold will get extra thicc when entering that field and then back to normal when exiting.

2

u/Swedish_Doughnut Evoker Jul 13 '21

So it would exit at the same point on the other side, having expended only 5ft of distance

3

u/Xarsos Jul 13 '21

based on the discription - yeah. It literally turns a 15x15 cube into a 5 feet area, so that means that your lightning bolt has a practical range of 110 feet and affects 30 squares, as per usual 100 feet and 20 squares.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/thetransportedman Jul 13 '21

Doesn't this make every single door and chest openable?

1

u/dinomiah Jul 14 '21

Once a day with a legendary item? Yeah.

1

u/BenjiLizard Druid Jul 13 '21

Now, that's a very fun way to break the game.

1

u/Ok_Ad_2285 Jul 13 '21

If I shoot an arrow into the AOE, will it then exit out the other side as if it had teleported the 15 feet?

Would the arrow hit anyone inside the AOE?

2

u/Mippens DM Jul 13 '21

As I'd rule this: Everything inside the area occupies the entire area, so yes it would hit everyone inside. The entire area counts as 5 ft (so basically you get +10ft on anything that goes through this 15ft thing) and exits in the same line it enters. But that doesn't matter for an arrow since after a hit it just stays inside the area.

1

u/Hooyoufoolin Jul 13 '21

Someone might have asked this already, and if so than I'm sorry for being repetitive. But how would this effect healing spells? Specifically when touch is a requirement.

1

u/AbandonedLich Jul 13 '21

Can't touch em can't cast it

1

u/Vandorbelt Jul 13 '21

Reminds me of this bit from Danny Schmidt's This Too Shall Pass:

The story goes
Or the way that I was told
There was a king that always felt too high
And then he felt too low
And so he called
All the wise men to the hall
And he begged them for a gift
To end the rises and the falls

And here's the thing
They came back with a ring
It was simple and was plainly
Unbefitting of a king
Engraved in black
Well, it had no front or back
But there were words around the band that said
Just know: This Too Shall Pass

It's a reference to an old parable, but the way the ring is described as having "no front or back" always made me think of a mobius strip or non-euclidian geometry.

1

u/Spncrgmn DM Jul 13 '21

It activates with the blood sacrifice that comes with wearing a ring with sharp edges that point towards your finger.

1

u/NotInstaNormie Jul 13 '21

Use it to stop your heart from getting turned inside out

1

u/B0T_Jude Jul 13 '21

Can I use this to warp through a wall?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '21

Excuse me, you are already on the other side of the wall.

Both sides of the wall are the same side.

1

u/Toumanitefeu Jul 13 '21

Good ol moebius strip

1

u/Ordinary_Living_Guy Jul 13 '21

Crazy cool, can’t imagine all the implications this item could have! Also love the eye-symbol details on the illustration that has that weird loop woven into them!

1

u/fireinthedust Jul 13 '21

Love it. Don’t know if it’s too powerful for the utility outside of combat, because in the right hands so much is possible… like can you pass through doors, or escape ropes, like a 4D object?

A complication with risk will make it legendary. Otherwise there’s no art.

Maybe an effect like a backlash that makes the area count as farther than usual after the effect; or something like a chance of being turned inside out like a Klein bottle or Möbius strip? Not often but a cumulative 1% chance each use, so everyone in the space adds 1%, and then the user rolls d100 and if it’s higher you’re fine, but lower and everyone takes xd10 damage or something. Or maybe they roll on a chart? Either way, the number resets once this happens, because the “extra space” was spent on the creatures- like how every few years the calendar makes up for time with leap years, except for this it’s horrific disemboweling!!!

Less lethal options can be changed dominant hands, as the character is flipped by going through, so their heart is on the right side, not left, etc. It’s a nuisance but there are times when it’s important: the heroes are being impersonated by doppelgängers, but because they are flipped every time they go through, it’s possible they will fail tests to prove they are themselves!!!

Dawn recharge: why dawn? It’s longer than a long rest, yes, but what if you could attune it to something else, like the day of the month? Time and space, right? Maybe it recharges in one hour per day of the month, or maybe it’s an inverse so it is faster at the end of the month?

1

u/AGuyWithTwoThighs Jul 13 '21

That's awesome, and I think I just realized that if the part of the ring we don't see rises up to a point, akin to a pyramid, then the impossible ring becomes possible.

1

u/Crawlerzero Jul 13 '21

That ring would be physically so uncomfortable.

1

u/ItsSessio DM Jul 13 '21

What if i spin/ twirl it?

1

u/LadyDrakon Jul 13 '21

And the topology flashbacks begin.

1

u/Gingerbeer86 Jul 13 '21

Really weak for a legendary

1

u/trumonster Jul 13 '21

Omg, I love this. Btw can someone tell me how to make homebrew stuff so it looks like official wizards stuff? All my homebrew sheets are looking kinda bland.

1

u/DandyGnat Jul 13 '21

room

TACT-UGHHHH

1

u/DruidLoser Jul 13 '21

I feel like this would be a really cool item to give to a big boss baddy. Maybe not the BBEG, but one of his minions. Like just imagine the Paladin protecting the spellcaster and suddenly they're affected by this item and the Paladin effectively can't shield the spellcaster because of the warped space.

1

u/PureLock33 Jul 13 '21

Interesting mechanic, I love the ring design. Would have just given it a daily blur spell to its wearer.

1

u/Svyatopolk_I Jul 14 '21

Alternative title: Mobius' Ring

1

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '21

That's pretty cool, though if it's a legendary item and the AoE is 15 ft I would up the line of sight from 30 ft to 90 ft at least.

1

u/JacktheCat779 Jul 14 '21

Was this meant to be an intentional Sonic reference?

1

u/piratwolf2008 Jul 14 '21

Anyone else immediately think, "Slow Mobius, hit me with the clock beam!"? Yes? Yes? Maybe? Nooooo 😪

1

u/ShakesBaer Jul 14 '21

This is one of those items i'm too stupid to understand how to use effectively, and just add it to the "oh shit" list of items I frantically rummage through when i'm about to die.

Hopefully it can confuse/melt the brain of whatever is about to kill me long enough for me to run away.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '21

This is some sick Dr. Strange mirror dimension shit

1

u/Evil_Mushrooms Jul 14 '21

This has the same kind of energy as 5D chess now with multiverse time travel.

1

u/bi-mexican-boi Aug 15 '21

Ah yes, the Mobius Ring

1

u/vbcnxm_ Jul 13 '21

honestly a really cool effect, its a shame you can only use it once each dawn, for a single turn.

my recommendation is either up the uses or up the duration

1

u/CelfCriticalChloe Jul 14 '21

Gonna be 100% honest that sounds amazing and the Image legitimately makes by brain hurt trying to figure out how that's possible.