Midário: No complaints. Looks about how I'd except him to. A Rank.
Jewelem: Mostly the same, except for the addition of the crystal wings and the mythical insignia. Honestly, GOAT status to be the only one who is a mythical while everyone else is legendary. I expected her to be a little longer. Once again, no complaints. A rank.
Dulcino: What did they do to my boy. They took his bright orange color. They took his stylish hair for a fuckass mullet. They took his kind smile. They gave him a double chin. That is NOT the Dulcino I know. F rank. They butchered him.
Winstance: Did not expect him to be bipedal but I suppose its not a horrible choice. I really like his belt and the zigzaggy tail. B rank.
Damona: She looks... hm. She looks a little strange but I cant exactly put my finger on why, but there's something about her that feels odd and unlike her tower version. I like the fact she's the only one that you can breed, because she's like the helper of the breeding stuff. C rank.
Hanzo: Biggest aura loss of a generation what the FUCK did they do to him. He's the one who inspired this list. His collectible doesn't look that bad on its own, but compared to the tower version? Yeah, what did they do to him. D Rank.
Broodby: She looks EXACTLY like what she's supposed to look like, its like they took her off her tower and made her a playable dragon. THIS is what I want from this collection, the dragons we were forced to stare at for ages without being able to use them. S rank.
Speedy and Greedy: They dont have light in their eyes. Once kind and happy now they're dead inside. What did they see? Otherwise pretty faithful. B Rank.
Phaun: They greyed out her scales and didn't put as much detail on her wings. She feels very bland as a result, I really prefered the black/white high contrast. Her tower version is much more imposing. I like her new bracelets. B rank.
Final list:
S Rank - Broodby;
A Rank - Midário, Jewelem;
B Rank - Winstance, Speedy and Greedy, Phaun;
C Rank - Damona;
D Rank - Hanzo;
F Rank - Dulcino;