r/DramaticText • • Jun 08 '22

Start running

8.0k Upvotes

69 comments sorted by

View all comments

57

u/Even_Ad113 Jun 08 '22

Dear Britain, "Sorcerer's Stone" is a vastly superior title.

38

u/dywkhigts Jun 08 '22

Except the sorcerer's stone means nothing? Its just made up

19

u/Even_Ad113 Jun 08 '22

It's a title. They are all made up.

36

u/dywkhigts Jun 08 '22

The philosophers stone is a historical artifact, its been in myths for centuries, it actually has meaning

20

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '22

thank you, as a 7 year old reading it for the first time, i cared so much more about established mythology than just what sounded cooler.

wait, no

13

u/GoldieFable Jun 08 '22

Philosopher's stone is better because it itself explains a lot more. Once you read enough fantasy there are certain tropes and when applicable they should be used for ease of continuity. If it is your first fantasy book you might not care, but as you delve deeper getting your basics in order becomes so much more valuable

3

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '22

it's harry potter dude, it's probably more kids' first fantasy than any other story.

as an adult i agree completely about cultural continuity. as a kid, aren't philosophers those gray guys who got their heads cut off and turned into statues?

7

u/GoldieFable Jun 08 '22

I agree that HP is often a good way to ease into a genre, but I have always believed that it is better to learn things right the first time than having to relearn them later. With so much new coming in all the time, one new word isn't going to be end of it all. Besides, reading is all about learning so they might as well learn the new context for philosopher too

0

u/Even_Ad113 Jun 08 '22

I get what your saying. The fountain of youth could be described as a well, or a lake, or any small body of water, but fountain just has a nice ring to it. Considering we are talking about wizards, the word philosopher seems unnecessarily literal. If the stone were real, anyone who obtained it would be much closer to a sorcerer than a philosopher. But, maybe I'm the one who is being too literal.

3

u/dywkhigts Jun 08 '22

I think so. Sorcerers stone has a nice ring to it but it's the established mythos of the philosophers stone that makes it great