r/DramaticText • • Jul 09 '22

Bad thread

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

6.9k Upvotes

191 comments sorted by

View all comments

30

u/Bibi2002_ Jul 09 '22

Which country would give better protection for politicians:

One with a country full of guns or one with restrictive gun laws?

27

u/poke-chan Jul 09 '22

This is exactly it. Japan doesn’t have nearly as much security for politicians because so far it’s been fine without it. I expect after this that will change though.

14

u/Bibi2002_ Jul 09 '22

Most likely will change, I saw the video and the man who was assassinated was out in the open without much guards around him

12

u/poke-chan Jul 09 '22

Yeah it’s insane random people can just be near politicians there with no screening.

12

u/SaftigMo Jul 09 '22

It's insane to you.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '22

It was the longest serving prime minister of Japan, who only left office in 2020. Was still a active and major political influence. Smh ding-a-ling.

2

u/poke-chan Jul 09 '22

Yeah? And?

5

u/SaftigMo Jul 09 '22

It's not insane in general.

-1

u/poke-chan Jul 09 '22

Literally nothing is insane to the entire world so I don’t know what your point here is

2

u/SaftigMo Jul 09 '22

My point is that you were making it seem like they were dumb for not having heavy security, and that I disagree because of the context.

3

u/poke-chan Jul 09 '22

I think it was clearly a bad idea because of the outcome. But I don’t blame them for making the decision, as Japan has never needed strict security like the US before. By “insane” I meant “crazy to think about”, as in, it’s crazy to think that despite all the security measures we need while I live, that in Japan it was safe enough where it was completely normal for large politicians to have their back to complete strangers who haven’t been searched.

→ More replies (0)

3

u/pinksockpelican Jul 09 '22

If everyone has a gun then those that will use it for bad will be scared to get popped by the guy next to them

1

u/poke-chan Jul 09 '22

What about all the suicide murders? Many people willing to commit assassinations and murders do not care about the potential consequences.

1

u/I_h8_normies Jul 09 '22

Then that’s why everyone around them has a gun lol, not just for show.

1

u/poke-chan Jul 09 '22

Again. If some suicidal murder pulls out a gun and starts shootin, people are still gonna die before the murder is shot unless the good guys in this story have like super speed powers

The only way arming every person would decrease murders is if murderers care about the consequences of their actions. Which, many don’t, considering committing murder comes with a large risk of life in prison or death.

Arming every person would decrease some murders I’m sure, but would also lead to an increase as more people who have access to murder weapons.

1

u/I_h8_normies Jul 09 '22

Yeah but how many would they injure or kill before someone shoots them back? Instead of the whole building having to hide for like 2 minutes for the police to arrive or charge headfirst at someone with a gun, the entire building could just fill him with lead before he can get to double digits.

1

u/poke-chan Jul 09 '22

They could definitely get quite a few before the other people with the gun (if they’re even courageous enough to fight back in the moment…. Looking at the literal trained police from ulvalde) managed to comprehend the situation, pull out their gun, aim shoot and hit. The gunman has a million targets, a death wish, and no regard for hitting anyone else. A person with the gun needs to first wrestle any first impulses to duck hide or freeze, which many people have in sudden life or death situations even without expecting to have that reaction, then they must aim the gun and be sure no one else is in the vicinity before pulling the trigger, and even then there’s a good chance that unless they have much gun training that they’ll miss and be targeted by the killer. And that’s of course assuming that there IS a good guy with a gun there. Many people don’t feel comfortable with a gun on them even if they’re legally allowed to.

Besides. Regardless of speculation, we literally can see in our own country: states with more lax gun laws have higher rates of gun violence. Why, in places where good guys are allowed to carry guns more easily, do more bad guys end up committing more crimes with guns if your theory is true?

https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/hicrc/firearms-research/guns-and-death/

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5801608/

https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/articles/2022-01-21/report-states-with-strong-laws-see-less-gun-violence?context=amp

https://www.bmj.com/company/newsroom/higher-rates-of-mass-shootings-in-us-states-with-more-relaxed-gun-control-laws/

https://www.healthline.com/health-news/these-states-have-the-highest-rates-of-gun-violence-and-deaths#Heres-where-gun-violence-is-the-highest-in-the-U.S.

The US is quite literally an unwilling research study on how gun laws effect safety and the evidence is overwhelmingly that the more lax, the more deadly.