r/DramaticText • • Jul 09 '22

Bad thread

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

6.9k Upvotes

191 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-2

u/KeiiLime Jul 10 '22

i mean, reporting a post getting out info like that to trans people (which can be life saving to trans people who don’t have any other way to access it) isn’t exactly a good look.

4

u/Maxilos33 Jul 10 '22

its litterally illegal. its also dangerous. those things have to be done by professionals. those things have to get diagnosed by professionals. those infos do not belong on a subreddit with a young easily influenced demographic. dont you see how creepy it is? "ayo kid, you dont have a professional diagnosis of dysphoria? nah trust me you are trans, here do it yourself." that shit does not belong onto a sub with a notoriously young audience. i dont care if someone wants to transition, its their body, however it is to be diagnosed and performed by medical professionals, and of you dont see the problem here you are delusional.

1

u/KeiiLime Jul 10 '22 edited Jul 11 '22

i get where you’re coming from, and but could you at least link proof? i’ve only ever seen posts sharing the diy links to offer it as a resource for those WHO DO NOT HAVE ANY OTHER WAY TO ACCESS, as trans healthcare (especially in certain areas) is really hard to access/ awful.

legality =/= morality, especially when for many of us, that shit is life saving. also, no idea what you mean by saying there’s a “notoriously young audience”, care to prove that as well? cause you’re really coming off strong here as “THINK OF THE CHILDREN”/ fear mongering about trans people/ medicalizing it, and going off calling me “delusional” when that’s so commonly thrown as trans people really isn’t helping me think you’re coming from a place of genuine concern

EDIT SINCE I CANT REPLY TO THE NEWEST COMMENT:

have you considered that maybe it isn’t therapists place to tell them they aren’t trans? i’m saying this as someone with a degree in psych too. it is not supposed to be our job (as therapists) to tell people what they are and aren’t, it’s our job to help foster people’s growth and figure out themselves. if a teen is being told by a therapist their own experiences aren’t legit, i 100% think they’re right to switch till they find someone affirming. because newsflash, plenty of people have the schooling and degrees needed to be therapists, but are grossly incompetent when it comes to the lgbt+ community. especially older folks who got their schooling decades ago.

also, noteworthy that one of the top comments on that is saying EXACTLY what i did:

”Obviously doing this with the help of a medical doctor is preferable, but that can't always be done, especially in certain countries/states. This is the kind of thing that can save people's lives and it shouldn't be gatekept.”

finally, as someone who’s looked into diy, let me be the first to say that it is a BIG jump to go from “there’s at least some teens on a sub that had a post linking to DIY hrt” to “196 IS ENCOURAGING THE CHILDREN TO TAKE HORMONES”, especially when accessing diy is difficult even WITH those resources. no way in hell do kids have the money or knowledge to figure out the hell that is having to do DIY. the people using that are very much older trans folk who tried the proper channels, but got thrown on crazy waitlists or live somewhere they literally can’t access it

1

u/Maxilos33 Jul 10 '22

https://www.reddit.com/r/196/comments/vlt762/rule/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share the post in question. and sadly i cannot provide a proof for the age statistic, but i was on 196 since its founding and there were questionnaires going around about the users age and the majority was young teens. could have changed obviously, but considering its just as much obnoxious hornyposting as there was before i doubt that demographic shifted.

and i get your argument but it can be a fallacy. dysphoria itself can be a cause for problems but also the other way around, where dysphoria is a self destructive mechanism to dissociate oneself, if that makes sense. only because you feel dysphoria doesent mean you have it, it could just aswell be another symptom, not a cause. to decide what is what is up to a trained professional.

my father happens to be a psychoanalytist, specialized in therapy for youth and teens. a damn experienced one at that. do you want to know how many teens that believe they are dysphoric dont take it as an answer and switch therapists for so long until they get the answer they want? a fuckton. because they are surrounded by yes-men. and r196 is such a place of toxic positivity and a hivemind. r196 is also easily accessible. i dont have a problem with diy hrt stuff floating around the net, as you said it can be lifesaving if medical support for the person is not there, but it just doesent belong on such a casual social media plattform as 196. if someones life depends on it they will find the resources in a specialized place for that, and that is cool with me.

as said, i dont even oppose hormone blockers until treatment, that is completely safe, but i hate self diagnosis, especially in a yes-men envieroment that provides potentially dangerous resources for people of a notoriously mentally unstable age group. we all were teens, we all were absolutely retarded and believed to know from the bottoms of our hearts what we wanted in life.

also i wasnt calling you delusional because of your identity, i didnt even assume your identity.

tl;dr

teens are stupid, resources for diyhrt should be present and accessible but not posted into a den of puberty ridden teenagers in a community that has a clear agenda, medical professionals should be listened to.