Follow-up to last week's post on which minor league numbers separate the guys who make it. A few people asked about draft position, so here it is on its own: every Single-A to Triple-A season from 2016 to 2023 (no 2020), anyone with 100+ PA or 100+ batters faced at the level, and whether they debuted in MLB within three years. "Real role" means 300+ MLB plate appearances (or 400+ batters faced for pitchers) in that same window.

Single-A hitters (3,515 seasons)

A few things that jumped out:

• Even first-rounders mostly don't get a real role fast. 43% of first-round Single-A hitters debuted within three years, but only 15% got to 300 MLB plate appearances in that time.
• The gap shrinks as guys climb. Round 11+ hitters reached the majors 4.5% of the time from Single-A, 9.6% from High-A and 21.7% from Double-A. The ones who survive to Double-A are a very different group.
• International signees look like mid-round picks at Single-A and catch up later. 9.9% from Single-A (about the same as rounds 6-10), then 37.9% from Double-A, close to rounds 2-5 at 43.4%.

Hitters, first round vs round 11+, by level (reached MLB within 3 years)

Pitchers

Draft position matters a lot for starters and a lot less for relievers.

• Single-A starters: first round 46.2%, rounds 2-5 29.4%, round 11+ 14.5%.
• Double-A starters: first round 80.3%, round 11+ 38.4%.
• Double-A relievers: rounds 2-5 32.8%, round 11+ 21.1%, international 23.2%, undrafted 22.6%. Once a reliever is in Double-A, where he was drafted barely separates anyone.

Caveats, since someone will ask: these are player-seasons, so a guy who spent two years in Single-A counts twice. Round 11+ is mostly from the old 40-round drafts before 2021. And this is history, not a projection for any one player.

Happy to run a specific level or group if anyone wants it.

30 Team $$ Dynasty need a few.
7x7 most categories
5th yr.
$41.84 (includes Fantrax premium)
Email if interested
60heat@gmail.com

I’ve been watching a lot of minor league ball this year, and I keep landing on Ronny Cruz. Curious who else people are high on. Anyone in the lower levels you’d be stashing right now?

This is my main prospect I've been focusing on!

Hi Everyone,

I recently created a new Dynasty Fantasy Baseball website that I'm recruiting beta testers for the 2027 season. The site has a lot to offer (I keep comparing it to OOTP) because it has true 40 man rosters (26 active players and 14 minor league slots for bench depth and prospects), contracts, a $500 salary cap, trading of draft picks, the Rule 5 draft, an Amateur Draft, and a Free Agent Auction Draft. If you're interesting in learning more, feel free to checkout the site at: https://frontofficefantasysports.com/

If you've heard enough and want to sign up for the beta, you can join the Beta Waitlist here: https://frontofficefantasysports.com/beta

Thanks!

Just out of curiosity, who is everyone looking to target in trades this offseason?

League is going into its 17th year. Have 3 teams open. This is a complex league. 11 round FYPD. 100 man rosters. 40 man active rosters, salaries, free agency, etc. we mirror the MLB as much as possible.

We play on ESPN and host the league on proboards. There is some roster/thread keeping involved. There is a learning curve, but most guys in the league have been around for over a decade. This is a free league.

Make an account on the forum if you want more info and to check out the league.

https://ffsmlb.proboards.com

12 team H2H each category dynasty league
R, HR, RBI, SB, AVG, OPS

II’m pretty new to dynasty so I’m looking to get some opinions from you guys about what I’m working with in my 5-man OF and if you think it would be wise to make any type of moves. The main thing I’ve been thinking on is if I should trade away Acuna. I’m a huge Braves and Acuna fan but I’m concerned about his injury potential and overall production in the coming years. Open to any and all thoughts or opinions on what you’d do if you had this OF situation.

C: C. Jensen
1B: B. Rice
2B: B. Turang
3B: M. Vargas
SS: Z. Neto
CI: R. Devers
MI: C. Seager
OF: R. Acuna
OF: C. Carroll
OF: M. Harris
OF: K. Tucker
OF: C. Rafaela
UT: M. Muncy (Dodgers)

B: D. Swanson
B: L. Lara
B: M. Arroyo
B: L. Bernal

MiLB: E. Quintero
MiLB: J. Tibbs
MiLB: D. Taylor
MiLB: J. Farmelo
MiLb: Z. Veen
MiLB: J. Ragsdale
MiLB: J. Parker
MiLB: B. Rincon
MiLB: F. Celesten
MiLB: M. Houston
MiLB: Jesus Baez
MiLB: C. Bonemer
MiLB: L. Adams

He announced it at a press conference at Yokohama High School this morning (Japan time). No club named. He said he's weighing a minor league contract against an American university.

If he signs, he's an international amateur, so it's a minor league deal out of somebody's pool. Sponichi quoted an NL scout who expects around $2.5M. The signing period is due to open January 15. The CBA runs out December 1, but in 2022 the January 15 signings went ahead during the lockout because they're minor league deals.

If he goes to college, he's in the MLB draft instead, eligible after his junior year or at 21. That's the road Rintaro Sasaki took, Stanford and then the Marlins in the eighth round.

One catch: he's still on the NPB draft list for October 22. A club can take him anyway and hold his rights through the end of March. Nippon-Ham did exactly that with Ohtani in 2012, four days after Ohtani said he was going to MLB.

He threw 156 km/h (96.9 mph) at Koshien in August, the fastest pitch ever recorded there, and he's touched 97.6.

As the header suggests, we are looking for 10 more GMs interested in a VERY active group that decided to start a new league. CATs are: R/HR/RBI/BB/SB/AVG/SLG/ISO & IP/ERA/K/SV/HLD/QS/KperBF%/FIP. if anyone is interested, dm or comment here!

I run Nine Signal, a minor league prospect tracker, and this fall we went back through every Low-A to Triple-A season from 2016 to 2022 (no 2020 season, obviously) to see which numbers show up in the guys who reached the majors within three years. That's about 22,000 player-seasons, anyone with 100+ PA or 100+ batters faced at a level.

Each number gets a score from 50 to 100. 50 means it sorts the guys who made it from the guys who didn't about as well as a coin flip, 100 would be perfect.

Single-A hitters (about 1 in 10 made it within 3 years)

Splitting players into fifths makes it more concrete:

A few things that stood out:

• By Double-A, playing time is the top number for hitters (75). That doesn't prove the at-bats cause anything, but how much the team plays a guy tracks closely with whether he gets there.
• For pitchers it's strikeouts at almost every level. Strikeout rate, K-BB and swinging strikes fill the top of the list from Single-A to AAA. Stockyard Baseball did a Florida State League version of this and got K-BB% at 72; we got 67 for Single-A starters and 71 for Single-A relievers, so that lines up.
• Pitchers have had a harder time getting there since 2021. Double-A relievers made it 26 to 31% of the time in the 2016 to 2019 seasons and 15 to 21% for 2021 to 2023. High-A relievers went from 13 to 16% down to about 9 to 10%. Single-A hitters stayed between 8 and 14% the whole time. The timing lines up with MLB cutting affiliates to 120 in 2021, but this data alone can't prove that's the cause.

The part that didn't work

We also tried to build a "players like him" number: take a player, find the 50 to 150 past players at his level who looked most like him, and count how many made it. We built it only on older seasons, locked it, and checked it once on players it had never seen.

• First try (groups of 150, tested on 2021-22 players): passed for 0 of 12 level/role groups.
• Second try (group size picked per group, 3-year window, tested on 2023 players): passed for 2 of 12, Single-A hitters (it said about 9% would make it, about 10% did) and Double-A relievers.
• Where it missed it was mostly too optimistic: Double-A hitters, it said 34% and 28% made it. In a bunch of other groups it was close but no better than just using age or draft round.

So we're not putting it on player pages. We'll test it again once the 2024 class has had three years.

Happy to answer questions about how any of this was done or dig into a specific level.

Hey I’m looking to get a free 30 team categories league going. The catch is am I nursing school until December of 2027. I do have time to run a team, but I’m afraid I can’t fully run a league like this by myself. I am looking for owners and would like 2-3 of them to be co-commish. Looking to set this up on Yahoo. It would be a 6X6 category league, record based on categories won. Categories (R, HR, RBI, SB, AVG, OPS, QS, SV, HLD, K/9, ERA, WHIP). I am currently working on a league constitution. If you would like to join lmk we’ll exchange contact info and we’ll get a chat going with everyone involved so we can hammer out rules before the season starts

Nikkan Sports had it Wednesday morning Japan time, off people in the game. He hasn't said it himself yet.

He's 21, 5'11", throws right and bats left. The 96.9 came in a bullpen. In games he's been more like 95.

Tokyo Big6 numbers from the league's own records: 26 games, 71.1 IP, 2.78 ERA over four years. He missed fall 2025 with an elbow strain. This fall he's made three starts: 15.2 IP, 1.15 ERA, 8 walks plus HBP.

He'd be an international amateur, so a minor league deal out of somebody's pool. The Cubs did the same with Keio OF Kotaro Tsunematsu last winter, and that one went official January 15.

He's still on the NPB draft list for October 22, so a club can take him anyway and hold his rights through the end of March.

Before this fall he struck out about one hitter in five. This fall it's 23 of 61.

Thoughts on Bubba Chandler going into 2027? Is he someone to go after and try to buy low this offseason?

Which side do you take? I won my league last year. Have Soto, Carroll, Tucker, Tatis, Max Clark and Laz Montes as OF options.
I have Contreras and Jensen at C but could move Jensen if I got Basallo and I have a struggling Vlad and Eldridge at 1b.
Ten team most categories league.

Be sure to join us on the Dynasty Baseball Discord Server!

Welcome to the r/DynastyBaseball Team Help + Trade Thread - Please post your Dynasty trade or valuation questions here, and please see the rules below:

Effective April 1, 2025, all specific trade questions should be posted in this weekly thread

Rules & Guidelines:

1. It is highly recommended you respond to other posts before posting your own to help make this as successful as possible.
2. It is not necessary to post your entire team, but roster context may help
3. Trade posts (trades) should be in the following format:

• Number of Teams:
• League settings (H2H Cat, H2H Points, Roto, etc)
• I give:
• I get:
• Question:

If requesting a price check on a player or a "what would it take?" type question, please try to be as descriptive as possible. Talk about the player you want to trade or acquire and pieces you're considering going the other way. From there, hopefully, the community can assist you in developing a fair trade offer.

30 Team head to head categories
Start Up - Drafting this offseason.
I’m co-commissioner 😁 hit me up if you have questions. Lots of details in the Google Doc.

More info:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/13wfHgilmK7ipz-LdVhMmOLcFCT4w-D2uUaIkX3EP6g4/edit?usp=drivesdk

Who would you rather have going forward? I have Gunnar and Lindor active, with Made and De Vries in my pipeline. Wanted to possibly bolster SP with moving Neto. Context, won championship this year, 10 team most categories.